DetroitLolcat said:The question I wish to open this discussion with is: "What do we want CAP21's Primary Ability to accomplish?" When answering this question, take into consideration that CAP21 will not be spending a lot of time in its base form and that many of CAP21's potential weaknesses can be addressed in later stages. For example, our Water weakness doesn't need to be addressed in this stage because it's possible to threaten Water-type Pokemon with proper stats and coverage moves, even if our Ability doesn't make up for our weakness. That doesn't mean we can't patch the weakness in this step, just that we don't have to. I'm starting this discussion open-ended for a reason: I'd like to see what you all can come up with in order to ensure our project's viability and adherence to the concept.
From the Threat Discussion and OP, we are trying to threaten Water, Fairy, Flying, Ice, and Bug-types while still maintaining our weakness to Ground, Steel, Psychic, and Water. As far as I can see, that does not necessitate a defensive ability exactly, but such abilities do help. There is no obligation to have different abilities on the base and Mega forms: once again, how equal the forms are in accomplishing the concept is a minute issue, as long as the Mega does accomplish it. But that only is if we are expecting the Mega to be so powerful that people automatically Mega Evolve first chance they get. That part was not set in stone, and I don't see it as a problem if the base form has uses that prevent someone from Mega Evolving immediately: the chance of someone simply using the base form alone is still pretty low, but it has no bearing on the concept.
2. Continue discussing what we want from the base form's Primary Ability. Should we patch a weakness, provide additional opportunities to switch in, or something entirely different?I'm pretty neutral about this, but I do think that the base form should focus more on survival and let the Mega form worry about defending itself.
Here are my thoughts on the abilities I think are quite viable options while still following the concept:
Sand Stream
I like this because it helps the CAP be self sufficient. It triggers the Special Defense boost, giving it a better chance at taking special Water and Psychic attacks, without actually removing its weaknesses at all. I disagree with the argument that the base form would be used more (not that it is a bad thing either), it has a lot of competition from Hippowdon and Tyranitar: there is no stipulation that the two forms can't have the same Ability either, so that isn't a good reason against Sand Stream. The argument that the boost won't prevent the CAP from falling to Water and Psychic attacks is true in a sense, but it helps take them better by far (we don't even know its stats, so we can't accurately speculate anything past this) without removing its weaknesses.
Drought
This is a pretty cool ability as well, weakening Water moves at the cost of weakening the match-up against Fire-types. Admittedly, it does threaten Manaphy and other Water-types without having to do anything but switch-in, so looking at it that way makes it fulfill the concept. However, I do think weakening one of our few good match-ups is not worth the cost, unless you Mega Evolve immediately into a method that removes that problem.
Water Veil
Burns are a huge nuisance to this CAP, even if it doesn't end up being physically oriented. While I'm sure that a physical Rock move will still threaten Talonflame, hurting the physical aspects of this CAP's type makes getting burnt a large cost. Since we are still wavering on the defensive side of things to maintain our "utility counter" role, something steadily chipping away at the CAP's HP hurts it heavily. It's no protection against Scald or other Water move, but no burns applies to Fire moves as well, which we do plan on switching in on often due to the typing. Only real problem with this Ability is that it's area of effect is limited to Burns, and has little/no effect on deterring the opponent from using moves that it is weak to.
Regenerator
Good general ability, and helps keep the CAP healthy while taking hits. As we don't know if it will get recovery, and the CAP lacks Leftovers if it Mega Evolves, the extra healing will definitely benefit its longevity. Only complaint might be that it does make the CAP focus a lot on the utility counter aspect, and less on the typing advantages. Might be me though, so I wouldn't take it too seriously.
Intimidate
As this CAP is likely not going to pivot too often, having a one-to-few-times Intimidate isn't too problematic. Noting that the Sand helps Special Defense, Intimidate provides the CAP with a more well rounded defensive option, without having to crank its defensive stats as much (leaving more room for other stats). In the end, the ability won't save you from Ground moves, and likely not against any Steel moves either (most users set up). So it doesn't really improve the match up against Pokemon that threaten us, but it benefits the whole team a lot more.
Sand Force
I actually like this ability, but I don't like the fact that it requires a teammate to set up Sand for it. As the base form, it also has weaker stats, so it can't make use of it the same way its Mega form can. Maybe save it for the next discussion?
Solid Rock/Filter
Former has better name, but w.e. It gives the base form a bit more leeway in switching in, though it won't really matter on the turn you Mega Evolve. The reduction isn't that large, but it'll weaken Water, Psychic, and Steel moves in a desperate situation (might help more in Sand as well). That said, I don't see the point, as why would you be in on a Pokemon that use those moves in the first place? Not my favorite option out of these.
Water Absorb
The only water immunity ability that has significant worth. It gives a better switch in against most Water-types, except the ones with super-effective STAB. The recovery is nice, like with Regenerator, but more restrictive and situational. No one with half a brain would be spamming Water moves if they know you have Water Absorb, but regardless it still can catch someone off guard. It's better than Storm Drain, as it's not decided that this CAP would utilize its Special Attack, and there is no benefit to having a RARE boost in Special Attack if you have no moves that can use it (or you carry a useless move on the off chance you get a boost?). The problem with Dry Skin has been stated. I am still iffy on it since it does remove a weakness, so I'm leaning towards neutral on it at best.