• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC a nice basic game of actual mafia - game over - won by the Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
sandshrewz said:
I was joking about unwatch thread :d I said both to rid of the notif and to check for pings. And by what Whydon meant, if that were the case, I didn't even need to watch the thread in the first case and put myself at risk given how much I check smorgen.

Not sure if im making any sense ? ?_?
Click to expand...
I have to wonder why you'd even make a joke like that anyway. Literally anything will be used against you in a game like this. On top of that, you only clarified it was a joke when Whydon started pushing you. Tbh it sounds like one of those situations where you realized you messed up and decided to say it was a joke to get yourself off the hook.
 
lmao. aianyway I'll decide whether or not to lynch partly based on whether mislynching or no lynching is better or something. Whoever explains which is better in this game's context. Otherwise I'm holding back for now as undecided.
 
SomewhatOddish said:
I have to wonder why you'd even make a joke like that anyway. Literally anything will be used against you in a game like this. On top of that, you only clarified it was a joke when Whydon started pushing you. Tbh it sounds like one of those situations where you realized you messed up and decided to say it was a joke to get yourself off the hook.
Click to expand...

It was meant as sarcasm so like ??? More of something I said because I got annoyed. I seriously didn't think anyone would take it seriously LOL. Like ?_???? Sorry if I'm not a good joker / sarcasm guy, you're free to take it as you wish, I don't think I can convince you on that .

If I actually unwatched ppl wouldnt still be catching me reading the thread at all. Not that it means anything. And not that reading the thread means anything either.
 
sandshrewz said:
If I actually unwatched ppl wouldnt still be catching me reading the thread at all. Not that it means anything. And not that reading the thread means anything either.
Click to expand...

Ok last post on this I promise. In a game like this one (NOC) if you are seen reading the thread but don't post anything, people will assume you are lurking/flying under the radar. Because players can't talk outside the game, people will look for anything to get as much information as possible. Reading the thread and not posting is something you can get called out for.
 
Still catching up (bear with me, had wisdom teeth pulled Friday) but as bad as Sandshrewz play has been, I doubt its mafia play right now. The whole pack and forth with aubisio felt like fairly useless town on town arguing.

Shubka on the other hand has mantioned to post a pretty good amount and never give reads. I'm going to vote shubaka17 for now.
 
Lynch Empoof

This was going to be Aubisio, but I feel a little better by voting Empoof. His self-iso was just really random and not really helpful? When you read yourself, there's always going to be that bias there where you hint at a conclusion that the reader should make. In this case, it just always feel like a self-iso is coming from a point of view where you telling the reader "this is why I'm town!" For one, that's not helpful because it doesn't help us find mafia. You're basically just stating the obvious regardless of your alignment. The real danger is then that post becomes an easy way for ppl to form opinions on someone without actually reading their posts, which is essentially twisting the truth.

I guess I'm forced to post now although I'd be surprised if there truly is enough subs lol.
 
Just checked the timezone thingy I will probably not be online at the time deadline unless I set my alarm to wake me up and go back to ZZZland.

Also apologies for being a bad villager and wasting some people's time here :X

I think I'm better at mafia acting villager than villager acting villager lmao. sorry im bad e_e

so not voting for now so that I don't tip the scales either way.
 
Jalmont said:
Lynch Empoof

This was going to be Aubisio, but I feel a little better by voting Empoof. His self-iso was just really random and not really helpful? When you read yourself, there's always going to be that bias there where you hint at a conclusion that the reader should make. In this case, it just always feel like a self-iso is coming from a point of view where you telling the reader "this is why I'm town!" For one, that's not helpful because it doesn't help us find mafia. You're basically just stating the obvious regardless of your alignment. The real danger is then that post becomes an easy way for ppl to form opinions on someone without actually reading their posts, which is essentially twisting the truth.

I guess I'm forced to post now although I'd be surprised if there truly is enough subs lol.
Click to expand...
Could I know your reasoning for why you were going to lynch me? thx
 
Can somebody explain to king that me winning a OC mafia where the mafia teams went full clown isn't revalant to noc skill.
The self iso from empoof seems kinda desperate to get people to think he is super towny. Also him voting haruno after dle called him out is pretty scummy also.
 
People I don't like right now:

Aubisio - When a player has a lot of posts but then claims they don't have any "reads," that's just not a good sign for me. Of course, it would be very hard to say "x is mafia for sure," but thinking that no one is scum just seems a tad lazy? The short posts shows that obviously they are paying attention, but saying actually nothing of substance. I guess it's a little better than pretending to contribute but it's still no good for me.

King - I just feel like he's going after inactives a little too much, if that makes sense. I find it strange that when twin calls him out for finding tropius scummy that king doesn't move away from that and sticks with tropius AND twin being scummy after that. I guess it basically just boils down to him going from tropius is scummy! --> tropius is scummy because afk and so is twin after twin points out the weirdness in that.

People I like right now for various reasons that it would be a waste of time to get into -

Da Letter El. Whydon. SomewhatOddish

People that are interesting to me -

Haruno - I'm just not getting "Town Haruno" vibes. I didn't like the activity vote he made and it just seems to me that at least early he was putting in a little more effort in terms of "appearing" town. I'm not sure I felt his reaction to my vote was as scummy as everyone else felt, but just in general it doesn't feel like he's going after people as much as he would maybe usually do. The last post about being in church felt like he wasn't willing to take responsibility in terms of finding a potential lynch, although that's not limited to him.

shubaka - Feels really honest in his posts, but then has also said/done some weird things. Highlights include that one random "I should be reading the thread and didn't" post (which was like okay???) and then the "I don't know need to prove my villagerness." On the flip side, it does feel like he is trying to work through the game and is being very honest in the mistakes he's making.
Haruno - I'm just not getting "Town Haruno" vibes. I didn't like the activity vote.
King - I just feel like he's going after inactives a little too much, if that makes sense.
King - I just feel like he's going after inactives a little too much, if that makes sense.
 
aw man it looked so pretty before - just ignore the last two lines regarding king although i guess technically you could argue that my summary makes it seem like king is more "interesting" than "scummy"
 
Mithril said:
Still catching up (bear with me, had wisdom teeth pulled Friday) but as bad as Sandshrewz play has been, I doubt its mafia play right now. The whole pack and forth with aubisio felt like fairly useless town on town arguing.

Shubka on the other hand has mantioned to post a pretty good amount and never give reads. I'm going to vote shubaka17 for now.
Click to expand...

After finishing the read, I see it was Sandshrewz and Whydon, not Aubisio. Also disagreeing with myself that sand is town. His reads post in 233 was a bunch of writing with no reads. There was a singular questionable person, and a bunch of IDKS or passive / aggro, none of which do anything. His posts on Page 11 are interesting as well as he keeps going back to not needing to read the thread if he were mafia. Just generally doesn't seem to be contributing at all.

Tropius has been another weird one for me. Telling people not to look at your past games (regardless of a name change) just seems awful. It makes me think there is a distinct playstyle difference between them. He also make Sandshrewz town for a pretty bad post IMO.

I wasn't a huge fan of Empoof's self ISO, as there really wasn't much there. He seemed to just try to summarize his posts in ways that make him look good. It feels like forced filler to make people think he's good.

I'm less sure on Shubaka after the re-read, but not enough to change my vote yet.
 
Just to note, I really don't really have much of a read for anything which is why my posts all have no content but people have been asking for posts so ?___? Aubisio was really the only oene that stood out to be only simply because he had quite a few posts yet I somehow noted nothing noteworthy, like nothing. I'm not experienced with scum read or w/e but I do get the town feel from Mithril for being attentive and that's about it. I didn't quite expect the DLE/Empoof thing I thought initially they were on the same page but seems not. I *personally* can't really read anything this early and ye I probably went in loop too much for my own good lols. I have no noteworthy opinions other than Aubisio but that will probably be addressed or something.

What's self ISO btw ?_?
 
sandshrewz said:
Just to note, I really don't really have much of a read for anything which is why my posts all have no content but people have been asking for posts so ?___? Aubisio was really the only oene that stood out to be only simply because he had quite a few posts yet I somehow noted nothing noteworthy, like nothing. I'm not experienced with scum read or w/e but I do get the town feel from Mithril for being attentive and that's about it. I didn't quite expect the DLE/Empoof thing I thought initially they were on the same page but seems not. I *personally* can't really read anything this early and ye I probably went in loop too much for my own good lols. I have no noteworthy opinions other than Aubisio but that will probably be addressed or something.

What's self ISO btw ?_?
Click to expand...

An ISO is where you only look at a single player's posts. In this case its a self ISO because Empoof iso'd himself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top