MSC Knightmare said:I'd like to suggest that Mega Sharpedo go from A>A+. I'm amazed that this thing isn't considered a top tier threat. It can quite literally tear through entire teams with Stealth Rock and about 2 layers of Spikes, neither of which are at all hard to get, since it can easily blow through Defoggers and Rapid Spinners that aren't Forretress (which it can still go through with a mixed attacking nature and Hydro Pump).
First off, I'm pointing out that taking any significant amount of EV's out of Sharpedo's attack is gonna severely weaken its power, something it already struggles with enough to the point of needing a specific team archetype (Spikes HO) to successfully overcome.
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/uu-431867241
I literally go through this entire team with a row of spikes and Stealth Rock. Basically, Froslass took out Nidoqueen and Forretress sacrificed itself to put up rocks. From there, M Sharpedo took care of everything else, albeit with a small bit of luck.
The replay you have here is far from a high or even mid level showcase of Sharpedo's effectiveness. Your opponent has three completely unviable pokemon on his team, and the battle seems to have occurred on the lowest rungs of the ladder. /rank-ing your opponent on PS provided further evidence:
Hide
Playing against someone like this proves nothing about how good Sharpedo is. Not to mention he had 2 chances to stop Sharpedo cold that you haxed through, Sharpedo lacked the power to OHKO Heracross even through two layers of hazards, and you crit Milotic that could have used Haze/Recover stall and eventually scald burned. Your team choice is also strange to say the least, with a suicude lead (that you didn't even click spikes three times despite being given ample opportunity to), Sharpedo, and four momentum sinks that let common hazard removers like Tentacruel, Empoleon and Crobat Defog/Spin without much risk. Essentially, the quality of this replay doesn't help your argument in the slightest.
Now some calcs, all of which feature there being rocks and a layer or 2 of spikes on the other end:
252 Atk Strong Jaw Mega Sharpedo Crunch vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Cresselia: 264-312 (59.5 - 70.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock and Leftovers recovery Most Cress run Colbur Berry
252 Atk Strong Jaw Mega Sharpedo Crunch vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Suicune: 135-160 (33.4 - 39.6%) -- 5.1% chance to 2HKO after Stealth Rock, 2 layers of Spikes, and Leftovers recovery only a 5% chance to 2HKO cune after three layers of hazards
252 Atk Strong Jaw Mega Sharpedo Crunch vs. 0 HP / 4 Def Mega Beedrill: 417-492 (153.8 - 181.5%) -- guaranteed OHKO (also outspeeds after 1 Speed boost, so that bee can fuck off) lol
252 Atk Mega Sharpedo Waterfall vs. 0 HP / 4 Def Entei: 318-374 (85.7 - 100.8%) -- guaranteed OHKO after Stealth Rock again, pretty unimpressive damage, not even being a guaranteed OHKO w/o rocks
252 Atk Mega Sharpedo Waterfall vs. 0 HP / 4 Def Krookodile: 332-392 (100.3 - 118.4%) -- guaranteed OHKO every Krookodile runs Intimidate
252 Atk Strong Jaw Mega Sharpedo Crunch vs. 88 HP / 4 Def Gyarados: 250-295 (70.8 - 83.5%) -- 68.8% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock every Gyarados runs Intimidate
When Salamence hit the road, this thing lost of its biggest checks. That in itself aughta be good enough to have it bumped up here.
Left my thoughts on these calcs in bold. Salamence was never a Sharpedo check, either.
MSC Knightmare said:Banded Entei deals about 68% in 1 ESpeed, so you'll need plenty of prior damage on Mega Sharpedo. All about the M Pedo user being in the right place, right time. Sylveon does not wall M Pedo by any means, Poison Jab does a number on it, and though Sylveon will beat it, it'll need to take a pretty powerful blow before it does, and if it's got enough prior damage, M Pedo will break through it. Yeah, Hydreigon and Conkeldurr beat its ass and Cobalion walls it. If this thing had no problems and didn't need support, it would be banned.
Poison Jab is inferior to Ice Fang in almost every case. Ice Fang provides pretty similar or even better coverage (bar fairies, which you fail to OHKO Sylv/Florges, and has a decent chance to kill Hydreigon after rocks) and gets the Strong Jaw boost. To repeat what Mr. Highways said, its simply not as good as other A or A+ rank pokemon. Your point that Sharpedo needs support is obvious, but it needs it to the point where it has to be the focal point of your team that only fits well on one archetype. Compared to top mons in the meta like Celebi and Mega Aerodactyl, that can fit on literally any archetype from hyper offense to hard stall, that require minimal support for their few weaknesses, Sharpedo does seem mediocre compared to them. Sharpedo is far from unviable but certainly not deserving to share A+ or S rank with things like Hydreigon that have proven over the course of ORAS to function with much less support than Sharpedo needs.