The thread's been finally updated! Me and the rest of the team came to the conclusion that the best way of handling the upper rankings was to make some slight changes to their structure (there are now 5 subrankings in the A rank). For reference, here a post by Hogg that addresses the issue I'm referring to:
Hogg said:I've mentioned this elsewhere, so I'll c/p some chunks of my arguments there re: Krookodile, Entei and others.
Most of the arguments I've seen for Krookodile rising focus on how easy it is to fit Krookodile on teams, how it puts in work versus most matchups. I've got no argument there. Yes, there's practically no drawback to putting Krook on a team, and it fits on a myriad of playstyles. The same is true about Sylveon, which is probably the single most splashable Pokemon in the tier right now, and almost every argument I've seen for Krook being S-rank would apply to Sylveon as well. To be honest, I think Krook, Entei, Sylveon and (sorta) Conkeldurr are all really hovering in an odd space right now - they're better than the rest of A+, but not as good as the mainstays of S (in particular Hydreigon, Celebi and Suicune - I'll get to MAero in a bit).
Regardless of how good Krook is, I don't think it's at all quite at those levels. The issue to me is not that Krook & Co. are all suddenly S-rank, but that there's a growing gap in the A+/lower S ranks. If we're keeping the ranks as they are, then we're in this sort of odd position where either Krook, Entei and Sylveon stay in the same rank as Mega-Beedrill and Gyarados (which feels wrong), or we move them up and put them in the same rank as Hydra and Celebi (also feels wrong), or we shift the rankings downward and move stuff like Mega-Bee down (which will make many people think we're saying that they got worse, when really it's that the others got better).
But anyhow, while things like Krook and Sylveon are incredibly good at getting their jobs done, and are really crazy splashable, they just plain don't do what Hydreigon/Celebi/Suicune do, which is shape the goddamned metagame around themselves. Hydreigon is just about the hardest Pokemon to switch into in the game, offensively checks a major portion of the tier and more or less singlehandedly forces teams to run a Fairy or trade with Hydreigon every time it comes in. Celebi is the single most dangerous setup sweeper in the tier, has completely changed how every team operates right now, and has the tools to beat just about every one of its "counters." Suicune is rivaled only by Sylveon in the amount of crap it shuts down, while ALSO being probably the second most threatening setup sweeper after Celebi.
As for Mega-Aero... I never thought I'd say this, but Mega-Aerodactyl is kind of suffering right now. It's funny because I still use it more than any other Mega, and it's still crazy good, so it's really hard for me to say that it's getting worse. If anything, you'd think that the rise of things like Celebi would really help it. Pursuit is still a crazy-busted move (let's be real, Pursuit is the only reason anyone should ever be considering moving Krook to S rank), it still checks a ton of shit. So what's the problem? Well, the issue is twofold. First, the kind of HO teams that Mega-Aero particularly excelled against have really started to dwindle in favor of BO teams that are way less threatened by it. Second, there are things that Mega-Aero should check, but it just doesn't. In particular I'm talking about Celebi and Conkeldurr, which take anything Aerodactyl can throw at them when healthy. The fact that they're both popular SHOULD be a selling point for Aero right now, but in practice you need to stack redundant checks to those two because if either of them are healthy, Aerodactyl doesn't actually beat them. It means that Aerodactyl is no longer the emergency button it once was, and often I find I have to sack something else to get chip damage off on Celebi/Conk before I can bring in Aero to revenge. It's still really really amazing, better than anything in A+, but I don't think it's quite at the level of Celebi/Hydra/Suicune.
Speaking of Suicune, here we have the opposite issue. By any reasonable metric, the rise of Conk and Celebi SHOULD mean Suicune drops, but in practice, I've actually found Suicune if anything better than it used to be. Part of this is because unlike Aero, Suicune was actually able to adjust to these drops so that neither one necessarily checkmates it. In particular, more offensive Suicunes have been growing more popular, especially SubCM (including variants such as Vincune, Ice Beam Cune and SubCM Roar), which don't necessarily counter Celebi/Conk but at least mean that Suicune isn't setup bait. Also, teams have been slapping on a Celebi or a Conkeldurr and assuming that they're covered against Suicune, which is something that a well-built team can really take advantage of. As I said above, I think Suicune is the second most dangerous setup sweeper in the tier, and I feel like I've won more games lately with Suicune than with any other Pokemon. It helps that Suicune never really was expected to check shit like offensive Grass types to begin with, so it doesn't actually strain teambuilding to account for Celebi when you're building with Suicune.
Anyhow, that was a really long and convoluted way of saying that I think the rankings look something like this in my head:
BEST OF THE BEST: Celebi, Hydreigon, Suicune
ALMOST THE BEST OF THE BEST: Aerodactyl-Mega
REALLY GODDAMNED GOOD: Sylveon, Krookodile, Entei, Conkeldurr
VERY GOOD: Everything else in A+/A
Besides that, we also made some minor changes to the lower rankings (they're still organized the same way, don't worry) to reflect the current metagame better. We've removed the 3 following Pokemon from the list: Druddigon, Shedinja and Venusaur. I don't think this covers all of the changes, but here are some of them along with their respective reasoning (written by dodmen):
Heliolisk: Rose from B to the bottom of B+, I think by now we've realized the power of the Specs set and that it can legitimately be dangerous with the right support. Great for chipping stuff with Specs Volt Switch as no Ground-type besides SpDef Mega Steelix has any business switching into Hyper Voice.
Sableye: Fell from B+ to B. I just think this is a liability a lot of the time with Sylveon & Conk so good, and it just doesn't have the bulk to come in and out of the field frequently enough. It's definitely something that you can find your offense randomly weak to, similar to randomly finding out your balance is weak to Jellicent, but not consistent enough for B+. Also, Specs Hydreigon increasing in popularity means that there's one less top threat that it can check (even though it could only "kind of" check LO Hydreigon in the first place) - Draco does 96-113%, Dark Pulse does 60-70% to 252/252+ Sableye.
Tyrantrum: Fell from B to B-. A wallbreaker with very few switchin opportunities, considering that it can't switch into Fire-types whatsoever (Infernape, Entei, Chandelure), or Flying types (only thing that comes close is a Crobat that doesn't U-turn on it). On top of that, it has enough switchins to be held in check a lot of the time and make it think twice about using its best move (Doublade, Swampert, Krook, Cobalion, Bronzong).
Cloyster: Feel from B- to C+. I brought this up in here a little while ago, because usually it just isn't worth using this over other shit that can lure/force in bulky waters. First of all, setting up isn't easy with a SR weak Pokemon with 1 relevant resist (Water, which is either Scald or backed by a secondary STAB like Knock Off or EQ) and that is literally OHKOd by Florges's Moonblast and rlies on Life Orb to kill the things it needs to. Furthermore, we're seeing a rise in things that don't even care too much about a +2 Cloyster; whereas before, it was used to lure Coba/Doublade with Hydro, now we're seeing Steels like Empoleon, Mega Aggron, Bronzong, and Metagross (it takes a +2 Life Orb Hydro Pump to kill 0/0 Metagross, bulkier ones can still take the hit). Not to mention that even if it does manage to setup vs offense, there's still things like priority from Conk/Entei/Ape/legendary Banette, offensive Empoleon/Tentacruel (Tenta just trades) that can stop Cloyster.
Diancie: Fell from B to B-, it's a cool Pokemon but struggles to keep rocks up vs Tenta, Empoleon, and Forretress; Hydreigon is running a lot more Steel coverage now too. It does manage to fit on some teams though, I just didn't think that was worth keeping in B anymore.
Machamp: dropped it from B- to C+, just faces so much competition but I could see an argument for it staying because of outspeeding Fairies + Heavy Slam (and DPunch obviously). Let me know if you disagree
Hoopa: dropped it from B- to C+, haven't seen it used at all recently and it struggles to break Sylveon anyway.
Virizion: dropped it from C+ to C, it was only rly good against like Alo/Bliss/Steel/Tang or Chesnaught/Mence stall. Now it has to pick between running Stone Edge (which it has to hit shit like Crobat and Beedrill on the switch with anyway) or X-Scissor (which leaves it helpless against those and more). Easily checked by Cress, U-turn Gligar, and just a ton more so I think C is better. We can wait till Tony's project ends but from watching and trying to build w/ it with Bouff there's way too much to be desired.
Qwilfish: dropped it from C+ to C, gets Defogged/spun on by literally everything, doesn't check anything it needs to (Beedrill, Fightings, Entei).
Dropped Goodra and Seismitoad to C- too, just way more worthwhile Pokemon to use over these two, lemme know if you disagree
Unranked Shedinja cause Mence leaving means supporting it is that much harder. Drud and Venusaur are pretty self explanatory.
Since these are some pretty massive changes, feel free to ask questions if there's anything concerning you regarding the rankings. As far as new nominations go, the team considered adding
Pangoro to
C-, but I'd like to hear what the community thinks of that before going forward with it (
Tony, this is your time to shine). Happy posting!