Night Train Lane said:My argument for a ban is what it does on and off of stall. I didn't think I needed to bring it up what it does on stall and I won't since it's already been said many times over.
Night Train Lane said:"Saying it brings all of that utility while at the same time as crushing stall," where did I say that.
Okay, so then you WERE implying it...regardless, my argument against that remains the same. I do not support the argument that Dugtrio functions equally well on and off stall, bringing the same level of utility off stall.
Night Train Lane said:"outside of hurting stallbreakers, it's a REALLY finicky team member." This argument is bad because that's all it needs to do on stall. The point of the pokemon is to trap problematic stall breakers. When it's not on stall it only needs to remove the pokemon that you need removed in order for it to be a success. Dugtrio only has 1 job. It does that job and a little extra.
You're right that it's really only got one job; it is not always easy to accomplish that because of things like hazards, misplays, etc. The frailty of Dugtrio should not ever be understated, and arguing with such an air of certainty is something I--from experience--cannot endorse with Dugtrio. The game often comes down to one read (meaning, if you mispredict, you lose) just getting him in safely.
Night Train Lane said:"Your argument rests entirely on the assumption that Dugtrio will get a KO and be unharmed." There is no assumption. If you're using stall chances are there are not going to be hazards on the field. If you're not using stall you probably want it to trap things like Chansey or Clefable. So prior damage doesn't matter when all you need is a screech and an EQ to do its job successfully.
Yes, there is an assumption. Saying stall never has hazards down against it is also an absurd assertion to make; how frequently do you USE stall? There are a number of ways to force M-Sableye away from the field and safely get hazards down. I say everything I've said
from experience--extensive experience with Dugtrio stall. I actually am one of the few people that enjoys playing with stall, so yes, I have plenty of understanding how it functions in a realistic setting.
Night Train Lane said:"Dugtrio is never a guarantee unless it's on the revenge." Which is the only time it should be used. Unless you make a prediction that has a low risk and high reward.
Sometimes, you cannot afford to sacrifice something in order to get Dugtrio in. His best use is not always as a revenge killer, sometimes you actually need to play mind games (especially with stall, where you're switching in and out like every two turns).
Night Train Lane said:"broken on paper, not so much in practice". I consider it the opposite. On paper it has very average stats and a very average movepool with a nice ability. But in practice it has everything it needs to be unhealthy for the OU metagame.
No, in practice, it entirely depends on matchup, player skill, and sometimes a degree of luck.