New World Order said:I tend to not like getting involved in suspect discussions for the most part, but there is one argument from the pro-ban crowd that I feel is misinformed: That is, the notion that Dugtrio does not have counter-play. Sure once mole comes in on a Pokemon it can OHKO, there's nothing you can do about it, but the potential for counter-play occurs before this. There are two ways you can go about this:
1) Set optimization: There are many ways to get around an attempted Dugtrio trap. You can add U-turn to your fast offensive threat. You can add Shed Shell to your powerful but frail attacker. It can even be as simple as slap Substitute onto your Wallbreaker Heatran to at least give yourself a fighting chance via Magma Storm if you predict properly. I see a lot of complaining about how people's Tapu Leles are gimped in their wallbreaking power due to having to run Shed Shell. Guess what? You're supposed to optimize your sets to fit the meta. And if you keep losing to stall because your Lele is holding a Twisted Spoon, that's your own fault for not taking that into consideration when teambuilding. Dugtrio absolutely puts a lot of strain on teambuilding, but so do Mega Metagross, Greninja, Pheromosa, and Lele. You already adjust your sets to make your team less prone to being ran over by the offensive powerhouses. Why is it so wrong to have to make your team less Dugtrio weak?
2) Control the pace: Put yourself in a position where the mole's impact is minimized. There are plenty of ways to get up entry hazards against Mega Sab, and if you can get rid of the Sash, Dugtrio's impact is immediately gimped. No longer can they go for hard switch-ins against slower wallbreakers. No longer can they come in and eliminate anything it can 2HKO. Also, know what mons you're willing to trade off for Dugtrio. Your wallbreakers are enablers for your sweepers, and if you're smart about what you kill, you can put yourself in a great spot to win. If the only thing stopping your Charizard-X from ripping the opposing team apart is Toxapex, then it's absolutely worth it to sac your wallbreaker to kill Tox. But if you get greedy and kill Skarm, then you've misplayed and the Dugtrio player deserves to kill your win enabler and wall you out. You can also plan out the turns following Dugtrio's entry into the battlefield. While there are some Pokes that just absolutely get decimated by Dugtrio, there are plenty of others that can take advantage of it as set-up fodder. Proper long-term planning is sometimes difficult and I myself fuck up all the time. But it's a key skill in battling, what's wrong with learning from your mistakes?
While I'm mostly talking about stall above. Similar concepts can be applied to playing with or against Dugtrio whether it be on balance, bulky offense, hyper offense, or 3rd gen Milotic/Blissey/Skarmory stall if that's what floats your boat. It doesn't matter. It's up to you to have a contingency plan against Dugtrio and just because you built a piss poor Dugtrio weak team or risked your win enabler for no reason doesn't mean Dugtrio "has no counter-play". On a tangent to the idea of counter-play, the claim that seeing Dugtrio in team preview forces sub-optimal plays is complete bogus. The whole point of team preview is to allow for long-term planning. If the opponent has a Dugtrio, then playing safely. If you get greedy and try to go for game too early, then your loss to Dugtrio is your own fault. If they see that your Mega Metagross is your only ticket to victory against Scarf Lele, and manage to double switch in Duggy as you try to get in gross, then your opponent made a ballsy play and deserves to win. Guess what, if you saw a Mega Metagross, Greninja, Pheromosa, or Tapu Lele in team preview. You'd make plays you normally wouldn't as well. It's called adaptability. You don't get to go into every game following a step by step formula on how to farm free wins. Play the player, not the team. Having to hold off on bringing in your win condition isn't you being forced to play sub-optimally. It IS the optimal play.
Moreover, Dugtrio itself is a measure of counter-play for stall. Trapping has been a thing in stall since Gen 3 often because it is necessary for certain stall cores to function. There are plenty of teams on the ladder right now that are packing 2 stallbreakers, often with another powerful wallbreaker/sweeper hybrid. This puts an incredible amount of pressure on stall teams and if there was no Dugtrio waiting in the wings, the Tapu Lele or Hoopa-Unbound can get a kill pretty much every time it comes in and can come and go as it pleases. Sure you can replace it with a Pursuit trapper (or if you're on crack, Diglett/Trapinch), but they wont be able to function as optimally, nor can they trap as many threatening breakers, and leaves your stall core more prone to getting abused.
Is counter-play against Dugtrio more difficult than that of most other Pokemon? Absolutely. Does it put a lot of strain on teambuilding? Definitely. Is it possible that Dugtrio is an unhealthy element to the metagame? Possibly. I am personally on the fence about the issue. But please don't use "there's nothing I can do playing against Dugtrio" as your reason for arguing pro-ban.
I'd like to respond to these with my ideas for why I say there is no counterplay and such:
1. This is entirely true, one can optimize sets for dugtrio in order to not be weak to it and this is an effective measure against dugtrio. However, this is effective ONLY against dugtrio.
When I'm prepping for greninja or specs mosa by adding SpDef celesteela or AV tang to my team, it not only prepares me against those special attacking monsters, but against all special attackers in the meta (except like char-y but you get the point).
When I prep for MMeta by using defensive MScizor, I'm also packing a powerful pivot with priority.
When I run shed shell on heatran to be able to switch out of duggy, I'm not running grassium-z, lefties, scarf, whatever item that has uses outside of that 1 situation, actively making this pokemon WORSE against every poke in the meta except dug (zone doesn't matter)
2. 'play better' is certainly a somewhat valid argument. It takes skill to get around/beat a dugtrio, especially to do so with one of the things it can trap. The uncompetitiveness comes from the imbalance of skill required. The dugtrio user doesn't need to be make any risky plays to revenge your char-x, but the char-x needs to be conscious of whether it has to chose not to get a KO so as not to be trapped by dug. Then you have to hard switch your CharX out, losing all momentum.
I just want to make clear that my attitude isn't 'there's nothing i can do against dugtrio,' it's that using dugtrio on stall is a no-brainer, and making use of it is not at all hard, whereas counterplay to it is very challenging and risky. The sub-optimal plays are like in my example above. People have said 'just don't get that KO with your dug-weak mon', but what that translates to in an actual game is 'just hand over momentum to your opponent 2-fold: 1 cause you're not getting the KO you could have and 2 cause you're hard switching out.' And the dugtrio user didn't even have to make a play to force this situation. They literally only had to have the mon on their team.