Lcass4919 said:my question, as a pikachu user myself, is if its worth using over lucky punch chansey, which 50% of the time can do pikachus job, without fearing speed ties due to its over 4x higher bulk, and still allows chansey to copy walls to utilize their utilities as well. 50% is usually enough to KO most walls designed to stop imposter (mega ray 2hkos registeel with boomburst if getting 2 crits, which isnt as rare as you think) of course its not guarenteed, but id take the bulk+wall breaking potential vs guarenteed wallbreaking but reliance on luck. the issue isnt that pika is bad, its that its niche isnt even much of a niche, as both rely on coin flips, but chansey at least has a safe back-bone. not to mention pikachu REALLY appreciates para support to do its job better, which considering burn and sleep are so huge in BH, really forces you to build around pikachu way more then you need too. of course, im not saying pikachu is a "meme" as i said, i ran imposter pikachu+imposter chansey with para support, and it truely amazed me how much work it could put in...but im still opposing its rise. after all, its heavily reliant on team support to do its job, otherwise its just a coinflip. and saying a mon is good 50% of the time isn't enough for me to see it rise. dont forget, if pika loses that speed tie, it dies most of the time. meanwhile if you win the speed tie, its not guarenteed you will KO the opposing mon if its at full hp. its a coinflip that isnt even entirely in your favor. thats why i think D rank is perfect for it. its usable, but requires you to rely on "Something else" to get its job done, weather it be coin flips, the opposing team structure, or your team itself.
First off, IDk why you bring up Lucky Punch imposter when it's way more RNG reliant and worse at the job. There are a ton of reasons why Pikachu is better than lucky punch at this, which is mostly exemplified by this:
252 SpA Aerilate Rayquaza-Mega Boomburst vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Registeel on a critical hit: 141-167 (38.7 - 45.8%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
252 SpA Light Ball Aerilate Rayquaza-Mega Boomburst vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Registeel: 189-222 (51.9 - 60.9%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
Pikachu, unlike chansey, can actually do it's job when it gets RNG; ie, destroying any imposterproofing that doesnt use immunties. Chansey can't, so in most cases there just isnt any reason to use Lucky Punch chansey; the only relevant example is QD ogre.
Lcass4919 said:i mean, the only point disproven is that pikachu can tank a hit or two before dying vs certain mons. doesnt change the fact that chansey still does its job safer, while being able to actually switch into these threats. imposter isnt that great if you lose a mon each time just to send it in. if anything, you just saw my one point and just treated it as "one point proven slightly wrong=entire argument voided" let me ask if im wrong, why isnt pikachu S ranked like chansey...oh wait thats right, its frail as fuck. it cant switch into the shit it wants to beat. so your forced to either lose a mon, or futily switch into a wall, and BEG they switch into a mon that allows pikachu to do work. so ill ask again, how is my point wrong, when the main argument i made for it not rising was "it relys on team support to do its job, and even then its a coinflip" when both my points still hold ground. enless you and QT have magically found a way to automatically switch pikachu into sweepers, then by all means explain to me. with this in mind, both my points of "Requiring team support, and relying on 50/50's" are completely valid points, and your just nitpicking details.
how is ANY of my argument contradicted by calcs showing that pikachu can ohko mons, while others fail to ohko back, lets not forget that in order for pika to attack these mons, your opponent has to be stupid enough to leave them in in the first place when your forced into your wall. LP chansey can switch STRAIGHT into these pokemon. so ill ask again, is pikachus job worth using over LP chansey, because it can do the same job reliably, and doesn't rely on the 50/50's pikachu brings. stop nitpicking, and actually think and look at the posts contents. my point had nothing to do with those calcs. every mon his calc posted, requires you to run a wall to deal with. so that means in order for pika to actually do its damn job, you need to go into a wall anyways. which means pikachu already is at a downfall, because whats the point if your just going to have to switch into your wall to tank the hit anyways?
pardon my hostility.and i dont like pulling the "ive been here longer card" but really. ive used imposter pikachu successfully way before you guys. so i think i know a BIT about what i'm talking about when i say things.
Again, you seem to be under the impression that chansey can do the job when it get lucky. It can't. Furthermore, needing to win one speed tie vs some pokemon it wants to imposter puts way less in the hands of RNG than banking on lucky punch critting 3-4 times in a row. It doesn't really matter if you cant hard switch in Pikachu, because even if they KO an important part of the team you sacked to bring Pikachu in, you're doing a lot more back to them.
They aren't stupid to leave it in - for most offensive pokemon, Pikachu imposter has no switchins - zero, zilch, nada. The whole point of using pikachu is to win using it offensively, not wall, so I'm not really sure why you're asking what the point of having an imposter that can't switch in is.
And seriously? If we're bringing join dates of PS into this (which we really really shouldn't), I predate you by 2 months. It's just not an argument, otherwise someone like Lordmagecar is more of an authority than Highlighter.