iLlama said:Already discussed all of these in chat, so I'll just reiterate key points. Smeargle and Linoone can both run the same items so the point on Focus Sash isn't relevant. Linoone, for one, has better bulk than Smeargle no matter how poor it is and also has a 100 base speed stat, making it more useful outside of e speed (or with e speed and a speed boost berry as you suggested) than smeargle simply being able to hit more threats without relying as much on priority. As you stated yourself, Belly Drum is a significant part of Linoone's kit, which when paired with a better speed stat and gluttony, can be more useful than running smeargle in various situations, such as when webs are on your side, when psychic terrain is up, etc. I agree that on the priority side, Smeargle is far better than Linoone as well as with type coverage, but does that mean that Linoone is not a good secondary option with its own benefits? No, which is why it's ranked as B+. It's still a very effective attack-receiving Pokémon and thus it's ranking is justified. Also, Scarf Tyranitar is not even remotely relevant in the current metagame as it doesn't outpace anything the is relatively significant as far as I know. Plus, Band Tyranitar is simply better. Anyways, it's rank is not changing.
Scarf tyranitar is totally relevant in this meta- being a good mon for the speed slot for base 90 gods, and is used to trap swellow and smeargle for those teams. Lets look at Linoone when extremespeed is taken away from it (in psychic terrain, the one advantage it has over smeargle). You will have a 100 speed mon with non-stab grass/ghost coverage, and struggles to even get the ohkos on uninvested mons even with 180 atk, such as Lele which either outspeeds adamant Linoone or survives a shadow claw. Its viability entirely hinges on its priority, without espeed this mon would not be ranked, and in situations where its espeed will be taken away from it its not going to be outspeeding and putting in work against the incredibly fast psyspam teams that psychic terrain will be utilizing. In a theorymon sense linoone has uses over Smeargle, but I think in practice it is not the case. I think the overlap is way too huge to justify such a high ranking above the likes of KyuB, Manaphy and Muk-A.
iLlama said:I'm not sure how it being difficult to wish pass to, which it isn't, justifies a drop to D tier. Lanturn is able to check Elec Terrain teams, Rain teams, Pikachu, Mega Blastoise, Tapu Fini, Suicune, Araquanid, etc. I'd say that more than gives it its place in rank B.
Personally I have never seen this mon in the tier and I watch a lot of games and play a fair bit, and thats over 2 generations. I would love to see some matches of it, because I cannot see this deserving B rank when it cant even beat a lot of these mons 1v1, meanwhile can only loosely check a few mons on this list depending on whether it inherited defense or special defense. This feels like a sentimental addition to the tier list, or perhaps something that was theorymonned. A resttalk seems like its only usable set thanks to bad offenses making it unable to hit the mons it wants to switch into hard enough to beat them, and that sounds very questionable for B rank
iLlama said:I can see Azumarill being higher on the list, although a slow priority user isn't exactly the best option in this tier, especially when it can get walled by PDon, one of the best gods currently, and can be shutdown by extremely common Pokémon such as Tangrowth, Smeargle, Unaware mons, etc. I don't think B+ is a good place for it, but B- should be fine.
Okay
iLlama said:First, Nidoqueen's bulk is barely better than Nidoking's and calcs utilizing extremely specific scenarios, such as +1 Comfey HP Fire with Stealth Rock and 1 layer of Spikes isn't going to help your case. Adamant Smeargle with Life Orb cannot OHKO Nidoking without hazards and since every Smeargle runs Fake Out, this point isn't significant in most situations. Earth Power ohkoes Toxapex so the fact that Nidoking is 2hkoed by Scald (with high rolls mind you) is not significant. Nidoking is however faster than Nidoqueen, with a base 85 speed stat in a generation and meta that has a high focus on speed. Unlike Nidoqueen, Nidoking naturally outspeeds Pokemon such as Buzzwole, Dragonite, Gyarados, Heatran, Hoopa-U, Mamoswine, and Xurkitree, all of which have at least some, if not a good presence in the meta. Although I am willing to give Nidoqueen a spot in B-, anything higher seems a little much. So Nidoqueen being outright better than Nidoking and deserving of A rank seems a little ridiculous
I gave a lot of good, relevant examples of where Nidoqueens bulk is more useful than Nidokings, can we not zone in on the comfey example which was more a case of pointing out how generically weak it is and say that all the examples are irrelevant. Heres the Nidoking calc for LO extremespeed:
252+ Atk Life Orb Smeargle Extreme Speed vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Nidoking: 298-351 (98.3 - 115.8%) -- 87.5% chance to OHKO
The Toxapex calc is relevant as it allows Nidoqueen to switch directly into the pokemon it is threatening, plus with stealth rock and the added burn chance it is an over 75% chance of a 2hko, so it wont be low rolls.
Regarding the examples of mons that naturally outspeed Nidoqueen but underspeed Nidoking, there are very few mons and also a number of them will either run speed or are irrelevant examples: Hoopa-U and Xurkitree both run speed stats, Mamoswine has priority that will ohko if running an attack stat over a speed stat, Buzzwole runs a bulkup set without speed, the only mons that I can see that have relevance are Dragonite, Gyarados, Heatran sometimes, and Kingdra. Nidoking needs to be running a Timid set to make any of this relevant though, and this will cut into its strength in its primary role of wallbreaker.
iLlama said:Golduck's role is not through swift swim, but through cloud nine, which beats PDon for rain teams. This is also an incredibly niche role and only works in certain scenarios, which is exactly why it is rank D. Zekrom can beat Giratina and Toxapex, but loses to extremely common teammates in Clefable and Mega Sableye, so although it can beat part of a decently common core, it is still very limited.
Okay