NOC C9++ Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
To clarify why I voted durza d1 : I was asked to do it, didn't have better (it was between Earlio and him as far as wagons that had support went) and it was largely because of the specter of matrix NOC where I gave someone a pass despite them being sketchy two times and both were scum.
 
So you chose Durza over Earlio simply because of a past game even though you thought Durza had a good chance to be town? Were Earlio's reads at the time not sketchy?

pancake: I've already talked about Zorbees and Asek and nothing has changed since. I think Zorbees is quite townie aside from a few odd posts and Asek is likely town from the timing of his claim (the forethought to hide his shot is also very good).

Shubaka subbed in for what I think was an awful slot, he started off ok but now is scumreading me for reasons, apparently everything I do is scummy and my lynch is very straight forward, even though the only other interaction he had with me is what looks like him agreeing with me. His push on me only started since Twin and Asek have been on my case and Haruno was taken care of which makes me worried he just wants to mislynch me because he knows I'm a target.

shubaka17 said:
kirsche is a scum read. if you want more, lmk and i'll run an iso
Click to expand...

I asked for reasons in my previous post, but I guess you didn't see because I didn't ping you. Do you have a reason to lynch me other than the fact that others want me dead?

Moody + Shubaka make a good scum team regardless. Would explain Earlio's incompetence.
 
Ah my b

The slot he subbed in for was meh but not as abysmal as Champ (could still see Fenrir and Moody not being able to help Earlio properly though as one was drunk and the other went afk after 24 hours, but the rest of what I said still stands. Do need to reread Fenrir though.
 
Shubaka and I are not a scum team
I think it's to be found in kirsche/asek/acid
asek flipping scum might make me rethink the townread on champ-now-pancake
if bbm is scum he can take this game
 
i buy that claim, you were on the "power roles should wait to claim" track, and it makes sense with asek's claim to give a lack of serial killer in the setup.

this means

twin is 100% clean. moody and asek are 100% clean unless someone else claims a power role or a serial killer shows up. i can only be the godfather if i'm scum, and am otherwise clean.

this leaves:

kirsche
acidphoenix
BigBangMeteor
Fenrir->Shubaka
Champ->Pancake

I really feel like BBM is town. Will try to look into isoing some of the others later
 
Earlio: BBM, acidphoenix, Jalmont, Kirsche, Twin
BBM: Haruno, Fenrir, DurzaOffTopic
DurzaOffTopic: zorbees, Moody
Thetwinmasters: Champ1604
Acidphoenix: Asek
Haruno: Earlio

Haruno (5): BBM, Durza, Kirsche, zorbees, Twin
Durza (3): Haruno, Asek, Moody

Not Voting (3): Acid, Shubaka17, Pancake
 
ok kirsche scum reads shubaka but noted that my logic was invalid from before which is the response that is good for him I think? town/scumread wise

anyway yeah since haruno was being a top tier idiot and claimed doc as vt (Haruno for the future, that's a horrible play and don't ever do it again especially w/ a role like doc) sooooo my logic about conftown shubaka is invalid now!!! yay!!!! how fun!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! love haruno. shubaka's reads as absolute dong and absolutely need to be elaborated on, but on the other hand feel kinda genuine/tstbt

i seriously don't like the way moodycloud is currently playing. let's take a look at his posts.

1. filler
2. filler, but tells fenrir something he knows
3. filler except this time he's at a party and drunk!!!
the next few: a few minor insights, mostly taking a stance townie-wise, except for asek
then we get post 425.
"I'd lynch Durza more to check whether Haruno/Asek are his teammate and because he's had a hard time working smoothly with town so far, not really because I think he's scum. His claim is sketchy either way but I'd hate to lynch a doctor like that and his omgus at Twin did seem genuine"
the first sentence is his real reason for lynching durza. this is a pretty big inconsistency IMO and should definitely be noted. also later in the post he's like wait but i'm not sure and that's really sketch.
the next few posts are ok but suddenly he decides to lynch kirsche and forgets about durza ?
next filler
next is a weird thing where he says durza is town and also defends earlio kinda but also kinda twists it in an ambiguous way??? (up to 545)
next durza is town
next durza is scum and lynches
ok I don't have time for this but he basically fillers/is super defensive when even pressured a bit for the rest
later he says he agreed with earlio lynch but he also kinda lowkey defended him and never really took a big stance on it?

this looks really bad for moody tbh there's just so much inconsistency here and then zorbees is also like moody is 100% clean because of some claim that I missed???? is it asek's????????????????????????? so I'm very confused. but unless someone explains to me zorbees' post (which has bad logic in "unless someone wants to claim pr") i think moody is most likely scum. lynch MoodyCloud
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top