NOC The Mafia Invitational Redux Game Thread - GAME OVER

Status
Not open for further replies.
What do you want me to show? Why do you even scumread proph? Cos Hawkie is calling him scum? Lol? You want to knock out one of the stronger town players on smogon day 1? Duck off
this is like the twelfth time someone has asked my "why do u think x" when i said why i think x in the last three pages
 
Yeah okay here are my townreads in general


Yeti proph leet Texas FH KoC myself

Congrats that’s almost all the active people? Idk

Moody needs to buck up

Hawkie is just ??? For me

Just lynch from randoms thanks
 
If proph does flip town and I die, then my reads don't really matter. Yay.

But if I live, then I would probably first and foremost revisit hawkie and probably place more pressure on him. As he has been able to scapegoat proph a lot this game and while he has posted here and there on other focuses, he has avoided a lot of pressure imo and frankly I think it would just be good to reevaluate that slot either way.

Otherwise, I'd probably want to keep looking at Asek and Moody. As well as pressuring the idlers and hopefully getting subs.

As for why leet isn't in there...I want him pressured. But I don't think I necsasarily want him lynched today. He at least seems like he's trying even if it's a bit weak. But more so, to quote someone else, I think that slot will probably resolve itself if he keeps posting.
 
My issue with lynching a no-poster right now is that it's literally a coin flip, but I'm sure that I've explained this before.

D1 is the most critical day for interactions to happen, and I'd almost rather lynch town, but it be a huge fight with people committing to things all over the place, than it be an apathetic lurker lynch on scum. That's why I'm sort of okay with myself being pressured right now - people are committing to things and that's all very helpful when we reread.

It's easy to justify lynching a lurker, and easy to paint someone as scum for wanting to lynch a lurker, and hard to tell what any of the alignments are of the people in question, because it's all justified...sort of.

That said, we really can't progress from this gamestate without making sure the lurkers post, because 3/13s of the thread is just straight up Not Posting.
 
Okay, I read proph's big post (and...I was an idiot and closed that tab so now I can't reference it and I'm too lazy to dig it up again)

Honestly, is it wrong I actually liked most of it? Like I actually feel like I can understand a mentality from it and there's evidence of paying attention and doing detailed reads. There are a few of those reads that I did thing were kinda poofy or the reasoning was a bit whack and would revisit later if those people flip before proph does (or if proph flips scum, revisit those reads). But on the whole I do sort of like the tone from him on that post as well as the tone he was doing when evaluating the reasons people were on the thread with.


But posts like these and a lot of other ones, that's why I'm actually scum reading you atm. Like, in this post above it just feels so fake or manufactured compared to the usual genuine tone you have in games. And while maybe you are right and you just don't do well under pressure (because frankly, it's your actions under pressure which are why I'm SRing you) but that's something I can't really verify as, like you've said, you never really have been pressured on this site.

ie: I actually am liking a few of prophs posts here and there. But his posts under pressure displease me greatly and texas has pinged me so I must return to my beloved state
I agree that his wall post was pretty towny

I believe he's more than capable of making a towny wallpost as scum, and the rest of his game suggests scum more than town

Porph meta that i've seen is all town, all the time
 
My issue with lynching a no-poster right now is that it's literally a coin flip, but I'm sure that I've explained this before.

D1 is the most critical day for interactions to happen, and I'd almost rather lynch town, but it be a huge fight with people committing to things all over the place, than it be an apathetic lurker lynch on scum. That's why I'm sort of okay with myself being pressured right now - people are committing to things and that's all very helpful when we reread.

It's easy to justify lynching a lurker, and easy to paint someone as scum for wanting to lynch a lurker, and hard to tell what any of the alignments are of the people in question, because it's all justified...sort of.

That said, we really can't progress from this gamestate without making sure the lurkers post, because 3/13s of the thread is just straight up Not Posting.
What’s wrong with a coin flip when 3/13 chance that a random player is scum? It’s better than average odds. I’ll take a coin flip any day
 
My issue with lynching a no-poster right now is that it's literally a coin flip, but I'm sure that I've explained this before.

D1 is the most critical day for interactions to happen, and I'd almost rather lynch town, but it be a huge fight with people committing to things all over the place, than it be an apathetic lurker lynch on scum. That's why I'm sort of okay with myself being pressured right now - people are committing to things and that's all very helpful when we reread.

It's easy to justify lynching a lurker, and easy to paint someone as scum for wanting to lynch a lurker, and hard to tell what any of the alignments are of the people in question, because it's all justified...sort of.

That said, we really can't progress from this gamestate without making sure the lurkers post, because 3/13s of the thread is just straight up Not Posting.
Who would you want to lynch then? You seem to be mostly SR moody except moody hasn't really been much better than an idler this game.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top