• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC 2d3 Mafia - Game Over, Town Win! (and postgame is up)

ok if you think it's duskfall/apricity, why aren't you voting duskfall? what is the issue with voting someone who you think is mafia here

what's the issue with voting duskfall if you think he's mafia? you think apricity is the worst mafia here or something? we get a mafia today either way and we can use this as analysis for tomorrow worst case

this is a really bad interaction imo
 
Nuxl said:
ok if you think it's duskfall/apricity, why aren't you voting duskfall? what is the issue with voting someone who you think is mafia here

what's the issue with voting duskfall if you think he's mafia? you think apricity is the worst mafia here or something? we get a mafia today either way and we can use this as analysis for tomorrow worst case

this is a really bad interaction imo
Click to expand...

My vote is already on Hal I believe.
 
Nuxl said:
ok if you think it's duskfall/apricity, why aren't you voting duskfall? what is the issue with voting someone who you think is mafia here

what's the issue with voting duskfall if you think he's mafia? you think apricity is the worst mafia here or something? we get a mafia today either way and we can use this as analysis for tomorrow worst case

this is a really bad interaction imo
Click to expand...
I'm more confident with my read on Hal than my read on Duskfall. This is why I would prefer a lynch on Hal.
 
CaffeineBoost said:
Alright.
Duskfall98 Why shouldn't I move my vote to you?
Click to expand...

Because hal is very likely scum and you just ninja saved me from his hammer. Do you really want to undo that play? We should at the very least be able to draw from that me and hal are never a pair. You should vote whoever you think is most likely out of us two.

Anyways besides that don't hammer yet it's really far away from deadline and the conversation is advancing well.
 
Duskfall98 said:
Because hal is very likely scum and you just ninja saved me from his hammer. Do you really want to undo that play? We should at the very least be able to draw from that me and hal are never a pair. You should vote whoever you think is most likely out of us two.

Anyways besides that don't hammer yet it's really far away from deadline and the conversation is advancing well.
Click to expand...
I'll rephrase. Why aren't you scum?
 
Duskfall98 said:
Please don't make me try prove a negative. Give me reasons why I am scum and I will defend.
Click to expand...
CaffeineBoost said:
Page 7:
Duskfall states that he doesn't think that Heal is VT and starts to think that Heal isn't scummy enough to warrant further investigation lest he is forced to reclaim as a power role. In the context of the N1 kill, this actually implicates Dusk a decent amount as it shows what I think is a scum mindset trying to figure out the wifom behind the VT claim (the wifom being in his own head). Dusk also fails to present much of an opinion on other players who have shown a variety of playstyles. He's definitely been active enough to have just a small idea on who's what.
Texas and IFML have another interaction which seems a bit bland on Texas's behalf. He hasn't said all that much in his posts thus far and seems to not care for IFML's responses. This may just be due to Texas's tiredness though.
At the end of this, I'm actually going to suggest that Duskfall is very likely to be scum. He hasn't provided many opinions on other players despite showing obvious activity and/or lurking. He accuses me but does so in a way that makes it easy for him to deny it if I get mislynched.

Page 8:
Texas returns and provides a very solid post indicating that he is probably the town Texas I saw in Greek Myth Mafia. He states a potential slip up that IFML has made and chases it.
Some Heal vs Viper action and Viper does come off a bit worse from it. His responses are fairly weak as he continues to backtrack on what he said about his paranoia.

Page 9:
Mainly the Nuxl show tbh. My opinion on him does not change. He's attacking with solid arguments and discussing reasonably and that's good.
The wagon shifts to Hal and I can't really comment on that since I do think Hal is amongst the top 3 most likely scum candidates number 2 will shock you.

Page 10:
I've noticed that Hal tends to ask people for reasons as to why they think something yet says he has a reason himself. This is a pretty weak argument for scum Hal since I do think Hal is capable of coming up with actual reasons to falsely accuse somebody and seem genuine but it's worth noting. I could be wrong. He seems to be quizzing people about stuff he should be quizzed on.
Duskfall is on me a bit which I guess is fair. Still think he's probably scum looking for an easy mislynch this cycle given the previous context.

Page 11:

...

Distancing despite being fairly on me and Viper earlier.

This immediately follows it which may indicate a coordinated attack on me. This does make sense from my POV since both Dusk and Hal are in my scum pool.
Most of this page though is just memes and vote counts.

So my current pool for people I think are scum are:
  1. Hal
  2. Duskfall
  3. Viper
Nuxl is hard town, Texas is town lean, IFML is null but basically a town lean due to the confidence I have in my scum pool. I am convinced that they're both in there.
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top