NOC Reinforcements SCUM WIN.

apricity said:
ok

i ran this through caffeineboost extensively so i know that this is within the rules of the game (that's why i asked for ruleset to be posted)

on september 8 i asked you a question about wayne brady. there's a two day gap between this conversation and both the conversation that preceded and the one that succeeded it, so hopefully it's easy to find. The question ended in two question marks.

we can't communicate privately obviously but i want you to answer this question in public again. don't tell anyone what the question is. think VERY HARD about why I'm asking you this and then choose your answer accordingly.

thanks
Click to expand...

I think I know what you are getting at, the answer would be a negative one if I am correct.
 
For the record, this is what's going to happen if we ask the cop to publicly inspect someone and report back.

1. The cop probably isn't going to inspect the person in the first place. Why would they? Unless it matches with their own read, chances are they are going to take an action they think is most beneficial. So when Day 2 rolls around then what? We are back at square one.

2. If they do inspect that person, (in this case, me) and I pop up town, then you are asking the cop to reveal themselves just to clear one town. Which is absolute stupidity. We have two cops, let's not waste them on just a single lock town which can be killed easily this early in the game.

3. Also let's be honest here. It's super wolfy to try and direct the cop since the mafia 100% would like to make sure they aren't randomly inspected.
 
Former Hope said:
For the record, this is what's going to happen if we ask the cop to publicly inspect someone and report back.

1. The cop probably isn't going to inspect the person in the first place. Why would they? Unless it matches with their own read, chances are they are going to take an action they think is most beneficial. So when Day 2 rolls around then what? We are back at square one.

2. If they do inspect that person, (in this case, me) and I pop up town, then you are asking the cop to reveal themselves just to clear one town. Which is absolute stupidity. We have two cops, let's not waste them on just a single lock town which can be killed easily this early in the game.

3. Also let's be honest here. It's super wolfy to try and direct the cop since the mafia 100% would like to make sure they aren't randomly inspected.
Click to expand...

who actually suggested this
 
So, after reading the 5 pages of the thread that happened while I was sleeping, I agree with FH. I don’t really think this current plan is our best option.

No lynch is only helpful if we actually get results, and with the combined likelihood of the cop getting blocked or FH flipping town, this likely won’t happen

Read-wise, I don’t have anything specific, but I am leaning Nuxl. He just seems much more on edge than he did during the last game, but this is a pretty weak read
 
I mean cop doesnt have to reveal, if cop doesnt claim we can assume fh is town and locktown him. If enough people agree to do this cop will surely inspect him.
 
Duskfall98 said:
I mean cop doesnt have to reveal, if cop doesnt claim we can assume fh is town and locktown him. If enough people agree to do this cop will surely inspect him.
Click to expand...
Like the other guy said, this is equally bad.

Frankly, let's stop talking about the cop. It's not going to do us any good d1 and worse case might give mafia hints as to who it is.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top