Alright taking a break from smash while I write my takes on the topics brought forth in this thread lol.
Jhon said:Cart
I appreciate that cart play generally has a higher level, but I don't think that's the case for what's required to qualify through cart play currently. The situation at the end of the last season was that someone who got 1827, just once, would grab them selves the final cart invite. I personally don't consider 1827 to be particularly high level. Someone could have gotten in with much lower scores with repeat finishes; 1743 3-times would have been enough. An idea might be to scale the point gain after the threshold, such that 3-times 1800 < 1-time 2000 (example using the current system and bfl). This weakens repeat low finishes without removing the bfl. Not having the bfl doesn't promote continued play, which is the point of a circuit, while also not reducing the value of fantastic high finishes for people who can't commit to multiple seasons of laddering. Of course, just a more basic reworking of the bfl and point threshold is also a worthwhile consideration.
Making cart harder to qualify is definitely something that needs to be looked at but at the same time the primary reason that it is so is because there aren't that many people playing on cart. If we, say, make the threshold 1800, simply succeeding to surpass 1800 once would qualify you for the Invitational, which is lower than the 1827 requirement that we were looking at the end of the season. There just isn't really a good solution points-wise when only 5 people have posted points above 1800.
So naturally, the next option is going to be to limit the number of slots in the Invitational that is acquired through cartridge ladder performances. In this regard I'm thinking of going from 6 -> 3, with the number 1 seed getting a bye to round 2 of the Invitational.
Seperately, I've been thinking about moving the ladder tour to cart. Focusing it on one season with 4, 6, or 8 highest placements for that season (depending on how you want to play it) get to play it out in the bracket. I'm not sure what the itention of using the ps ladder was originally but if there's a better ladder that you want to promote the usage of, why not use it for the ladder tour?
Ultimately the biggest issue is simply that too few people are playing, or submitting scores when they are (me).
Using the ladder tour for cart is not feasible for the reason you described. Also, the most important aspect of the PS tournaments in the circuit is that there are no barriers to entry. Unfortunately, this is something cartridge play will have, and perhaps always will. The PS ladder has the added benefit of creating alts for the sake of the tournament and easily seeing how your competition is faring, which is great from a tournament perspective. Yes, I know cart ladder > ps ladder but it's far better than the alternative.
Tournament
Double > Single >>>>>>>>>>> Swiss. Swiss is awful for online tours with weekly rounds. It's fine for live tours, everything is done and over in a few hours, but when it drags on week after week it can be pretty hard to find the motivation to continue. Double can carry the same risk with lengthy tours, but that predominantly only affects people that fall into loser's very early and then have a long win streak, which helpfully carries good motivational momentum. Single too often feels like walking on a tightrope, the second chance with doubles is much valued to me. Especially when the possibility of being paried with greil or chem r1 and losing would otherwise cut someone the chance of getting any cp at all.
I'm actually thinking about using a similar system to what the VGC tournament used, where people will just drop after going x-2. This will create a tournament where you have the same amount of breathing room as a double elimination tournament, with the length of a single elimination bracket (+ maybe a few more weeks for a playoff bracket of some kind), without the drag of needing to continue the tournament when you're already 0-4. The only downside is that the number of players in playoffs depends on cutoffs and potentially on the results of paired down matchups, but I'm still crunching numbers to figure out what works best if we do end up going down this path.
I'm personally pro-teamlock, and I think a substantial amount of the problems people have expressed about it come from them not knowing how to play teamlock properly. Also as a dreamy idea for me, the later parts of tours where we've been switching to Bo5, we could use a variation of the n1n1 format, a Bo3 of [teamlocked] Bo3s (so you can switch your team after each sub-Bo3). That would range from 4-9 games, which in other pokemon formats I might consider too long, but BSS tour games have been consistently short with time as practically no issue. I couldn't imagine a 9 game BSS sets being longer than your average bo3 in OU, and most would be shorter than 9 games anyway that anyway.
It might still be a little too early to jump all the way to bo3 bo3s lol, especially when a lot of the community is still divided when it comes to whether to have teamlock in the first place. I do see potential in teamlock bo3s, and I do think if an officially sanctioned singles tournament would ever be considered by TPCi that would be the format that would be played (though not bo3 bo3s obviously lol), but it's definitely better to ease into it.
We had BSPL with teamlocked singles games and a lot of people had differing views from before and after the tournament. We will have a teamlocked bo3 tournament next year, and I'm contemplating what to do for the Invitational format of 2019. Of course with the Invitationals being a single elimination tournament having a teamlock would involve a lot more risk since it's close to a bo1 at that point, so if anything that's where a bo3 bo3 could be a possibility. I may end up creating some kind of voting system for the players that qualify.
I feel like I get to say this from a good position as the Classic winner, I'd rather past gen stuff was kept out circuit. We could instead have some mini-tours on the side to bring past gen play to people more often than just once a year for BSPL, and I'd be happy to host them. For the circuit itself though, I'd rather it was just played in the same format the invitational is.
I'd like you to elaborate a bit more on why you think past gen BSS formats should be left out of the circuit. I personally think if we left it out of the circuit it would just die out. Side mini-tours doesn't seem like it would do much especially considering the tournament burnout that comes up often in discussion. It would also make it a harder choice to include in BSPL, with the limited growth that we can expect to see in those formats.
Points
Already spoke with you ages ago about the 3-way final points situation. The rest I will think about some more and hopefully come back to.
Getting new players
This is something I worried about when I saw the 'Other Circuits' sub-sub-sub-forum made, it's so comparitively hidden that I can't imagine too many people happily stumbling upon it. The only potential new source of advertisement is through
cant say ,
11oyd and others' streams/youtube stuff. Y'all get a lot of viewers not from our community, mentioning the tours around the time sign ups are open might bring in some new friends.
Yeah I'm not a fan about the placement of the forum (and we're mixed in with a bunch of other tournaments), and I fought for it but senior staff wasn't having it :(. Advertisements aside there really isn't a lot of opportunities on this site to get our circuit out there. I even tried to get our format involved in this year's Exhibition tournament (a tournament with other smogon formats that aren't included in SPL) but that ended up not working out either. Maybe Smogon itself is just not an ideal place for BSS to grow, who knows.
Biber said:I just love playing the catridge ladder and watching others trying to climb it. So I like that there is some incentive for people to play and share their experience. I think the system with the 1700 points threshold was good to reward above average players. Maybe it would make sense to give CP only to the best three players in the season instead of basing it on points, since it's easier to get many points in inflationary seasons where many people are playing.
Really liked spectating BSSC tournaments, just hope that there will be more people participating in cartridge laddering next year.
I'm not much of a fan of the "top 3" rewards system. Sure rating inflation is slightly a thing but with the ratings that people are reporting it's not that big of a factor. If it's people submitting getting first place 2200 scores and first place people in later seasons getting 2150 because of deflation yeah I understand but our scores are something that can be exchanged with one more or less battles won.
Glad to see you're enjoying the tournaments though.
Moose And Goose said:Personally, while I haven't really played much cart atm, I still like the idea of having some sort of event where we ladder on cart. I really like the idea to do something like BSSLT on cart so there's a larger pool of players, and the ladder won't be as dead as the PS! BSS ladder can be.
As far as the affect on the community when it comes to removing the ladder qualification system I feel like it will make it less compelling for everyone to ladder on cart, especially if there's no place to put your rankings because there's no way for you to really show people what score you got, so why ladder.
To explicitly answer whether or not cart laddering should stay, I want it to stay. Unless there is another type of cart laddering that is better than what we currently have I don't like the idea of throwing cart out of the picture.
Another thing that I thought of reading 11oyd's post is that, despite only a few people playing the cart ladder, it's not like those accomplishments made weren't impressive. 1700+ is nothing to sneeze at, and it takes a lot of effort to get up that high, especially for the people that got 1850+.
See above for my thoughts on a ladder tour for cart.
I think that Single Elim is fine as is. I would like to see a double elim tour at some point, but I don't really want the typical BSSC tour to have it at this point in time.
Teamlock sounds pretty ok, as the level of play is probably about the same as without teamlock, and having variety without sacrificing quality is pretty cool.
As much as I like GBU
, I think that having minitours that feature past gens would be better. I did enjoy the classic (I don't remember if that counted for qualifying in BSSC), but it feels like its isolated from the other tours because it's not gen 7 only.
Wtf was I saying right then the classic is the best and I want mintours outside the classic to hone my GBU skills.
I..uh...am not really sure what you're trying to convey at the end there. You want past gens in the circuit or nah?
I guess if we kept cart ladder, it would be good if it counted toward the same points (If i understand it correctly tournament and cart are different types of points), and have cart worth less. I'm not sure if that would even work, but it might solve the cart ladder problem assuming we kept it the same way it is now because, while cart would still make you able to be higher on the rankings than players who don't play cart, it's possible that someone who does reasonably well in tours, but doesn't play cart could get in.
That's the way we do it right now...if I'm understand this correctly?
- What do you think we can do to welcome more new players into the circuit? (most important)
Of course the most important one is the hardest question :(
Anyways, The biggest problem I see is that typically all of the people that join the BSS circuit tours are REALLY GOOD. Most of the time I look at round one of every circuit tour and I think to myself, "Dang this is a loaded bracket". That's really good for spectating because we get big matches as early as round 1, which is insane and hardly seen in most tours that I look at (granted I don't look at many). This is a problem for new players though because typically you stop following the tour if you lose R1 in a meta you aren't invested in. And before anyone thinks that Double Elim would solve that problem, I don't feel like it would. My reasoning is that people don't know how to read and don't realize that they have another chance before being eliminated and don't ever look at that tour again. Now I have no idea how this could be changed to give someone new to BSS enough of a chance to win a round, which I know from personal experience was enough to hook me into BSS and therefor play in more tours.
Please don't throw away your games just so newcomers can feel happy LOL.
marilli said:Generally agree with jhon's posts about cart laddering, i feel like we need to hold ourselves to a higher standard of play and the cartridge ladder does that. During ladder tours i've consistently faced multiple players repeatedly and this really put me off of actually getting to ladder in a consistent fashion, so moving the ladder tour to cartridge is an idea i can get behind, too. Just the higher number of population on cartridge drives the competition higher. I think a lot of people overblow the 'ps ladder is bad' but there's no denying that the higher population naturally drives up the quality of play, and the cart requirement is a very healthy thing for the community.
However, I'm not sure jhon's suggested solution will work as well as it should in the current state of our community. While the theory is obviously sound, at the same time the main problem there's only a few players in the community that ladder on cart often enough and are in genuine contention for 2000, mostly just chem / greil / lloyd. The players who were, as long as they posted their ladder scores, ended up qualifying with high seed through cartridge requirements. The remainder of the players, no matter how we restructure the qualification format, were going to be from the 1800-1850 level. At that point qualifying through a single 1850 performance isn't the main problem - the main problem is that there's not enough good scores being posted at the first place aside from the said group of select players.
If you were personally discouraged from posting / laddering the first place because a repeated 1800 performance would be able to beat a single 2000 performance, we can definitely change that, because more entries is definitely a good thing.
Without either being able to entice more higher-level players of Battle Spot Singles to post their scores and play in our circuit, or being able to nurture more players in our own community to pursue a higher level of play and reach 1900-2000 on cartridge, this is gonna be really hard to fix. I really liked how lloyd really pushed himself to improve his level of play through playing into the 1900s and I thought it was really good to encourage that kind of development. But right now it feels like it's not going to matter how much we restructure the qualification system. This is what dragonwhale is obviously concerned about, too, which is why the most important section of this feedback thread is "What do you think we can do to welcome more new players into the circuit?"
just a rant cuz i really don't know to get a good solution to this
Well damn this is basically what I have been writing about until this post LOL. But yeah this is why the new players part is labelled as most important, as it is probably the biggest obstacle that our community faces from a competing aspect. Getting them involved in BSS is one thing, but getting them involved with the cartridge ladder is another thing entirely as well. With the game being over a year old and the release of LetsGo means the only people who are still in there are the serious competitors, and most newcomers are going to face several losses from the get-go unless they are really proficient in other formats (and even then have a hard time climbing).
Alright will get to the latter half later. Gonna go back to playing some Smash.