itsjustdrew said:This thread has essentially been bored users throwing stones at council and waiting for October drops. C'mon peoples let's just leave them alone. They have done a great job this generation and there is literally nothing of use they can do as of this moment. The stall suspect, like the Mega Altaria and Scizor suspect, was a valiant effort by the community but ultimately a waste of time. Something as intertwined with the tier as those three can never be banned, bar significant meta-game changes.
This is a completely fallacious argument. Just because they
are intertwined with the tier doesn’t mean they have to be or even should be. Yes, I agree council has generally done a good job over the course of the generation. However, they haven’t been perfect.
Criticism of council does not equal complete derision of the job they have performed. It simply means that people have found that they have made a mistake in their current course of action regarding the “stall suspect” and they are using their public platform to voice as such. (Sidenote: Calling the ideas
pokeisfun brought up as a stall suspect is a complete and total misrepresentation of his arguments. He wanted one of blissey or alomomola suspected, not stall as a playstyle. Calling this a stall suspect has led to many, many players being misinformed about the topic at hand, which quite frankly wastes everyone’s time when we have to explain the terminology actually means suspecting one of Blissey / Alomomola.)
itsjustdrew said:In response to Mysil's post about Mimikyu being broken I have written a research paper, enjoy. Mimikyu is literally no different than Scizor at it's core. For example. A well played Scizor is guaranteed 1-6 kills in any given game. Scizor's weight in a matchup depends largely on its set because depending on the Scizor set and its check on the opposing team, it could end up being useless. This also applies to Mimikyu. Mimikyu's weight in a matchup depends largely on its set. If you are not Wood Hammer and you face stall, it's useless. If you are LSF and you face a bulky Steel-type, it's useless. If you're Life Orb and not Ghostium Z, you miss out on killing bulky Steel-types in certain scenarios and may face Rocky Helmet damage from Amoonguss or Hippowdon. Clearly it's to a lesser extent of Scizor but the principle remains the same.
As a journalism major the importance of using evidence to back up claims has been violently bashed into my skull so we will get to the fun part now! Mimikyu has made five appearances in SSD, all of which I will analyze because I finished all my homework this week and I am chillin'
I would like to point out the fact that at no point ever did
Mysil ever mention Wood Hammer. This point is essentially moot because of the simple fact that no one uses Wood Hammer or LSF. The fact that you think there’s viability to that undermines your shaky credibility even more in my eyes. Mimikyu is simply different than other traditional sweepers in that it consistently limits counterplay into either “go into uber fat mon and hope it’s life orb” or “pray I can break disguise before I’m in a situation that gives Mimikyu a free SD” with literally no in betweens.
Comparisons to Scizor or anybody else are pointless because they do not play in the same way that MMQ does. Other sweepers don’t essentially get free SDs or revenge kills on the opposing team with only a modicum of effort. Other sweepers don’t limit counterplay ingame to this extent. I could go on for hours but you should get the point. Mimikyu has limitations. It has drawbacks and flaws, but those flaws are essentially moot in comparison to the large pros in using Mimikyu. It may not break walls, but it breaks them just enough for teammates to respond. It may not win every game, but there’s some solid builds that
just lose even if they’ve covered every other threat well, and that’s the problem with MMQ.
itsjustdrew said:1st Appearance (Christo vs. robjr
pattern emerges):
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7uu-454269
All Mimikyu does in this replay is get a free switch and kill Krookodile. It is then forced out by Florges. If you are a set up sweeper that is forced out by Florges because you're too weak to set up and kill Mega Aerodactyl with a priority move, are you really broken? Mimikyu's defensive utility and ability to set up on things pales in comparison to Scizor.
As
Christo mentioned, it
forces the death of Krookodile. Any swap as Christo SDs here means instant loss. This is a 50/50 more than anything. Additionally Christo went Scizor on the Florges because as the rest of the game shows, Scizor had the correct moves to just win the game. This has nothing to do with Mimikyu’s weakness or whatever. This is all to do with finding the quickest, most optimal way to win, which happened to be Scizor.
itsjustdrew said:2nd Appearance (Christo vs. ht
do you see the pattern?):
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7uu-455371
In this replay Christo makes an intelligent and aggressive play, switching in Mimikyu and using its ability to force out Mega Altaria. (Got lazy so) Mmq deals 29% to Rhyperior with a Life Orb Play Rough and is forced out. This exact same sequence is repeated 9 turns later. Mmq later wins the game because Infernape is forced to choice lock itself into CC to kill Maero and ht's only optimal switch in, Tenta, is asleep. So the question we must ask is, does that showcase Mmqs power and potential broken qualities? In my opinion, no. Mmq just won based on the circumstances of the game as any sweeper would have.
This sequence of Play Roughs led directly into Aerodactyl being able to kill Rhyperior on the switch with EQ, which in turn leads to the CC lock later which led to MMQ winning the game. Mimikyu had everything to do with this game’s result if you would just look a little closer.
itsjustdrew said:3rd Appearance (Accelgor vs. Adaam
two humble champions duking it out):
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7uu-456282
Mmq makes its appearance in this replay when it gets a free entry on a .5 Spa Latias at 3%. Accelgor switches into Rhyperior understanding that a Swords Dance is free and that Rhyperior will take a hit, preserving Latias as a sack for endgame. He reveals Rock Blast which is a very simple tech for Mmq. Accelgor breaks disquise, sacks Latias, and switches into Sharpedo which resists Shadow Sneak and takes nothing. This replay displays multiple qualities of Mmq. Firstly it needed to come in on a weakened Latias to set up. Secondly it is not difficult to counter offensively. And lastly it did 47% to a regular Sharpedo with +2 Life Orb Shadow Sneak which is frankly nothing.
Mimikyu chipping rhyperior like that was an important part of Adaam’s win scenario, which has Swampert + Aero + RotomH applying enough pressure on Accelgor’s team to where one of those three eventually wins out once Shark megas and switches out. This obviously didn’t happen but saying MMQ did nothing in this game is completely absurd.
itsjustdrew said:4th Appearance (Christo vs. Corazan
the pattern has now smacked you in the face):
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7uu-455995
Christo brings Mmq for the third time. While Scizor, a common sweeper, plays a role throughout the entire game, Mmq only enters the battle at the very end. This is a testament to its fragility and one dimensional style. Mega Sharpedo misses Ice Fang in this match which was unfortunate but did not actually affect the end game. Mmq needed +3 to kill Mega Aerodactyl with Shadow Sneak and this was not possible as Hippowdon was Rocky Helmet. The fact that a set up sweeper needs to take two turns for set up to kill a not bulky offensive Pokemon is a clear sign that it is not broken, over centralizing, or any dangerous quality that will affect the stability of the tier.
You do notice how Aerodactyl and Hippowdon could’ve been put in range if Froslass got the Icy Wind off, right? Icy wind hitting there means it gets at least one spike, and assuming the game goes similarly, that spike puts Hippowdon into range to where MMQ wins, not discounting the fact that MMQ did not even need those things considering it had a not insignificant chance of killing Hippowdon (31.3%) right there and then cleaning Aerodactyl up with Shadow Sneak. The fact that christo got unlucky early and still had a decent shot of winning with MMQ should be a + for it, not a negative.
itsjustdrew said:5th Appearance (Lycans vs. Indigo Plateau
let's give some love to IP, what an amazing person):
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen7uu-458189
Mmq enters this game to force Maero out which is a pattern we've seen throughout this analysis. It is trapped losing its ability and rendering it useless.
My guy, Play Rough was disabled. I don’t see how bad RNG rendering MMQ useless is a point in any direction, never mind yours.
itsjustdrew said:All the Mmq's were LO which is a reflection of its lack of immediate power. No Mmq played a central role in the players victory if they were victorious. Multiple techs were presented as viable ways of dealing with Mmq. It was only used in two ways, coming in to force a Pokemon out if it had the assurance it would maintain its ability and attempting to sweep at the end of the game.
In conclusion, Mimikyu is a one dimensional Pokemon that lacks the coverage options, strength, and defensive utility to make it enough of a threat to the security of the tier that it needs to be suspected or banned. Mimikyu can usually only come in if a Pokemon has weakened attack or is locked into a move that yields little damage. Once hit, it is very easy to revenge kill so Mimikyu can only switch in well if its ability can remain intact. Its impact in a match is largely concentrated in one area limiting its power and influence. As I mentioned before, a well played Mimikyu can wreak havoc in a matchup and can be quite useful. Mimikyu is a very good Pokemon and I do not denounce its usage, I just find a suspect to be flat out stupid.
The MMQs were LO because the teams all had better, more effective users of Z-Moves within the context of the team. This doesn’t show jack shit. Being passed over for a Z slot for Latias (indisputably the best user of Z crystals in the tier), Roserade (who is pretty unviable without it), and Rocks Krook on a team that actually needed the Scizor lure is nothing against Mimikyu.
In conclusion, MMQ forces one dimensional counterplay and places a large amount of pressure on offensive and defensive teams alike. This “once hit, its easy to revenge kill line” is blatantly missing the point. MMQ players only let themselves get hit when they know they can do it and be in an advantageous position to trade hits or clean up. MMQ rarely is just “hit” as you say without some large amount of consolation to compensate. I don’t see anything in these replays to think anything short of “RNG and total dogshit matchup in Adaam’s case were the only things reslly stopping MMQ from really just breaking down walls or revenge killing things for free or freely chipping things for teammates. As someone who aspires to be a journalist, looking at how and why things happen within the context, not just what happened is an extremely important part of the picture. A part that you seem to have overlooked.
Have a wonderful day.