Let's talk dynamax for the 500th reply. I was put in a spot where dynamax came across my mind, and that got me thinking a bit.
I've warmed up to dynamax a bit, being the only sure thing in Metronome battle. Most of the time, one won't go for it, rather choosing to roll moves and advance the battle. Dynamax has a much different role compared to its use in the pokemon games; when using Max Guard, you immediately lose all momentum for the next 3 turns. You'll usually get two Guards off, possibly three, or even none if you want to take some hits while asleep or something. It's not something to throw out at random, but could be a good save against an incoming 2-turn move. This scenario happened to me today.
(EDIT: 2 turn moves are a threat unless they're choiced, lol. Another factor to consider)
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8metronomebattle-1090038235
On turn 6, Dusclops begins to uproar, putting Skymin in a fatal state. Now on Turn 8, the big decision was to dynamax Shaymin-Sky or not in a hope to survive. Technically this decision should've been made on Turn 7, but I got lucky and Skymin lived the turn.
There are 4 ways this could've gone.
| No dynamax on Shaymin-Sky | Dynamax on Shaymin-Sky |
| Targets Shaymin | Shaymin-Sky gets an attack off and lives | Shaymin-Sky loses 3 turns and lives |
| Targets Shaymin-Sky | Shaymin-Sky gets an attack off and dies | Shaymin-Sky loses 3 turns and lives |
In the end, I went for the dynamax, Dusclops targeted landmin, and Skymin ended up dying next turn. It bought landmin a bit more time to live, and I would've won if I rolled an attacking move. That's the way it went, and there's not much to say about the actual fight. But that moment shows something I appreciate, the true heart of Gen 8. You're able to make a choice that directly impacts the battle. I like dynamax, and it's not quite useless because of its defensive utility and availability. You always have the option (unless you pick a mega) to guarantee survival for a turn, if you're willing to suffer the harsh consequences. Megas not being able to max is more a result of national dex's existence than Metronome, but I appreciate that it ends up adding a bit of balance that way.
Overall, I think Dynamax is pretty balanced and a nice addition to the game. It's more on the weaker side, but that's not so bad to keep luck in the forefront. Still, there are 'optimal' times to max out around endgame, like to not explode while in an inevitable Perish Song victory, or leaving the enemy to succumb to poison. It probably isn't needed when playing for fun, but I could see these RNG-proof strats being used on ranked. Personally, I prefer having the slim chance to make a comeback, but people might like being less susceptible to being RNG screwed on the other side of things. All assuming that you're not just mashing Metronome. It's hard enough to remember to mega evolve turn 1 as is. Speaking of megas...
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/battle-gen8metronomebattle-1090044783
Also today, I saw this guy mega evolve his Mega Alakazam.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8metronomebattle-1090046468
So I tried it for myself... yeah, you can mega evolve mega Pokemon. I swear that I remember trying this,
knowing it worked ingame, and finding that it didn't work. Maybe it changed at some point, or it was my b. The funny thing is that this is probably worse than just using a base forme, because Imposters can get your mega stats on top of a free +2 (if slower).
EDIT: You'd think with all the vanilla sets running megastones on megas that this would have come up before if it was possible. As said below, there are probably some scenarios where you want to be usable at base/not mega evolve immediately like not triggering Defiant.
-----
Here's hopes for ranked battles to return, smash that like button on the suggestion if you want to show support. The 2nd threadniversary is coming up soon. Having a ladder could both increase quality of games and expand the playerbase. The current unranked system is nice to find games and play for fun, but it's hard to evaluate strength without consistency. You get in games quickly, but they're based on completely random matchmaking. I found a random kid's gameplay
video a while ago, learned that you can go in with 0 EVs if you don't type or click anything in that section, and watched an uninvested team play against some real teams. I guess what I'm saying here is that adding rankings would make the game more competitive and grant more measurable insight on the meta. Ratings themselves are kind of just winstreaks and you can go from 1000 to 1500 and back, but it'd be nice to fight on a fair playing field more often.