• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon NOCfia DX

Haruno said:
You know what's more believable? A watcher in a game that oh so conveniently targeted the person that was NK'd the day before and then claiming they saw nothing. Not to mention waiting until near DL to post this key information.
Click to expand...
I wasn't the popular boy until now. Why the fuck would I claim before now?
 
HeaLnDeaL said:
You're saying you think I'm scum that forgot about the flavor ofthe scum team?
Click to expand...
No, I think busting out the Scum Meanies shade when there is public evidence to the contrary is desperate scumplay. You and Caff have been lynch contenders for a while and instead of sussing Team Meanies when it was first brought up, you waited until Caff claim put you in the hot seat.

You are trying to discredit something that if allowed to be trusted ends with you getting lynched, and THAT's shade with an agenda!
 
It's far more likely that scumteam can see that,

1. Tracker did not target nuxl
2. bg did not target nuxl
3. whatever other PR town might have likely didn't target nuxl and/or wouldn't have saved him

So they can safely claim watcher on a dead target and then go, "OH MY GOSH! THEY HAVE A NINJA!!!!!!!" then force town to divert their attention elsewhere. It's poor misdirection.
 
Also whoever is ekans better claim.

TBH I would find it highly unlikely that gengar is the only member of team meanies with PR, but we'll need the ekans claim to get that ball rolling. Who hasn't claimed
 
HeaLnDeaL said:
because telling town that there's a ninja in the game is somewhat important?

tbh I'm not exactly sure wut the best time to claim a result like this, though
Click to expand...
It's somewhat important, but if it's 1-Shot like Clarinet then I can out a scum if I can predict their moves next night.
Scum wasn't gonna kill me N2 while I was unclaimed.
 
I think Ninja makes a lot of sense Haruno

And like if Caffeine is a town watcher I don't think their scepticism of your claim is unwarranted given the roles fit in a somewhat similar space and town watcher is powerful.

It is a "convenient" claim in some sense but it's also not in others - like saying he targeted Nuxl is flipping risky I think
 
dopog said:
I think Ninja makes a lot of sense Haruno

And like if Caffeine is a town watcher I don't think their scepticism of your claim is unwarranted given the roles fit in a somewhat similar space and town watcher is powerful.

It is a "convenient" claim in some sense but it's also not in others - like saying he targeted Nuxl is flipping risky I think
Click to expand...
It makes no sense with the current setup.

We have

what, 1 confirmed VT
5 VT claims
1 tracker claim
1 watcher claim
1 BG claim
1 scum role cop/ blocker.

We have 2 missing claims. You seriously think that in a game where town has almost no information, that mafia would have a ninja?
 
Panic Station said:
No, I think busting out the Scum Meanies shade when there is public evidence to the contrary is desperate scumplay. You and Caff have been lynch contenders for a while and instead of sussing Team Meanies when it was first brought up, you waited until Caff claim put you in the hot seat.

You are trying to discredit something that if allowed to be trusted ends with you getting lynched, and THAT's shade with an agenda!
Click to expand...
panic

I say this with as much love as I can

BUT YOU ARE THE PERSON IN THE GAME WITH INFO ABOUT TEAM MEANIE'S TOWN OR NO TOWN STATUS. WHEN YOU MADE YOUR EARLIER POST ON THE MATTER I HAD NO IDEA YOUR ROLE MENTIONED THIS SO I THOUGH IT WAS MORE LIKE "HMM ONE PERSON SAYS TEAM MEANIES COULD BE SCUM, ONE SAYS IT COULD BE TOWN.

YES I FORGOT ABOUT CHARM AND SQUIRTLE. MY BRAIN DOES NOT SEE SQUIRTLE AND CHARM AND THINK SCUM. MY BRAIN DOES SEE TEAM MEANIES AND THINK SCUM. DON'T BE A POPTART AND THINK THAT I AS SCUM FORGET MY OWN SCUM FLAVOR FLIPPED PUBLICLY WITH CLARINET. AS AN UNINFORMED TOWN WHO HAS NO PMD EXPERIENCE, IT'S NOT EXACTLY ALIGNED IN MY NATURE TO THINK MEANIES ARE GOOD AND CHARM AND SQUIRT ARE BAD.

: (
 
Haruno said:
It makes no sense with the current setup.

We have

what, 1 confirmed VT
5 VT claims
1 tracker claim
1 watcher claim
1 BG claim
1 scum role cop/ blocker.

We have 2 missing claims. You seriously think that in a game where town has almost no information, that mafia would have a ninja?
Click to expand...
Hate to say it, but Haruno's right. Combined with the fact that Caff claimed so late in the day, it just doesn't add up.
##Vote: CaffeineBoost
 
Haruno said:
We have 2 missing claims. You seriously think that in a game where town has almost no information, that mafia would have a ninja?
Click to expand...
possibly, if they did I don't think it would be an every night ninja.
I think they very likely would have some sort of evasion if town had a tracker and a watcher
 
dopog said:
possibly, if they did I don't think it would be an every night ninja.
I think they very likely would have some sort of evasion if town had a tracker and a watcher
Click to expand...
What's more likely to you?

1. Town having a tracker + watcher and mafia having a ninja
2. Town having either or of tracker/watcher and mafia having no ninja?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top