I... I was gonna have to post in the thread eventually, right? I have no idea how I've managed not to do that yet.
Okay, hi everyone!
Alleged council member Hematite here!
Sorry I'm usually kind of useless for this mod!
I'm going to take this opportunity to guide the discussion on TMs, TRs and move tutors a bit, based on the "important" ones we've had in the past three Generations, and also to give my own thoughts on exactly what we should be trying to accomplish with respect to the TM list at this moment (as opposed to what we might be better off saving for later).
---
First thing: what do we stand to gain by establishing a list of TMs and tutors for ourselves instead of just saying all of the official ones are fair game?
Other than a handful of specific moves that I'll be listing below, I can't see a TM list having much of a bearing on the
competitively-relevant contents of our movepools so much as the flavor of them - plenty of moves are common without being TMs or, as will be shown below, relatively rare even as TMs
especially after Gen VIII gave us a million pointless ones.
As far as I'm concerned, I think having a solid list is really a matter of
presentation more than move distribution - these are based on pretty old statistics and may not be fully accurate, but I seem to recall that only something like 20% of the average Pokémon's full movepool came by level-up, so the TMs we choose to make available have a great deal of weight in influencing our full movepools both on a flavor level and a competitive one.
If we
are meant to be making properly complete movepools with realistic flavor for every line and not just giving them all a handful of relevant moves, it would help a
ton to have a list set in stone before anyone starts on that, so I appreciate that we're having this discussion now and strongly encourage waiting until it's over to ask anyone to work on full movepools -
including level-up and Egg move lists, because plenty of important moves prefer to be TMs unless none exists and I guarantee that those lists would need to be redone once we know which ones can be - beyond the handful of moves specified in submissions.
For our purposes, I think I would personally support drafting a TM list of 100 with a healthy blend of competitive and flavor - perhaps with a handful of slots set aside for potential new moves to be added and numbered?
(SM only made three new moves into TMs and SwSh only made two into TMs and TRs, so not necessarily very many! any more we add later can always be tutors as well) - and then also having a gradually-expanding tutor list of "whatever else doesn't fit that we actually care about competitively,"
preferably with any canon move inclusions being decided now and only new moves being added later.
I think this would be the simplest way to organize them up front, at least - I would really rather not make detailed, numbered lists of these things if we're just going to keep improvising and adding more as we go, so I think leaving "placeholders" for a new TMs to be decided later
way later - after we have a picture of most of the Pokémon of those types in our dex and what tools are relevant to them, not early on and otherwise just choosing new moves' distribution as we make them would be best.
(But yeah, trust me - I've been working on an organizer along these lines lately for another purpose, and it's
way harder to work with "any of the moves that have been TMs, TRs or tutors in the last three Generations" than a refined list specific to our project. It may look like reinventing the wheel, but I guarantee it will save everyone's time in the long run.)
On that note, we seriously don't need 226 of them like SwSh. Can we not have 226 of them like SwSh? Please.
---
Second thing: what impact might this decision have on our future movepools in general?
In general, certain moves, whenever they appear as TMs, TRs or tutors, have had
notably wide distribution in a way that lets us make certain assumptions about
how our learnsets would look if those moves were on our list.
Others have had
notably restricted distribution, often limited mostly to Pokémon of one type
(and not necessarily being universal even within that type!) even though they take a TM slot.
These factors, I think, are valuable for us to take into account when deciding what moves we want to include and what moves we don't.
This is definitely a big part of what I would choose to have in mind, at least!
I really enjoy the wide distribution of a move like Toxic, so that's a move I would support bringing back.
On the other hand, I feel like variety in Fighting-types is stifled by the omnipresence of Close Combat, and I've
complained endlessly occasionally suggested that the choice to make it a TR in Generation VIII is one I don't really like. In that case, the information in this list would make me vote against having Close Combat as a TM, TR or move tutor so we can be more particular about its distribution.
Another thing worth noting:
about half of all TM and tutor moves over the past three Generations are still more or less flavor. I mean, actually the average Pokémon only regularly uses like 15 to 20 moves competitively... but about half of them are flavor on almost everything that has them and only useful for in-game or in formats other than singles.
This means two things! First, I don't think filling our list with the 100 most competitively relevant moves will have a positive effect on our movepools' quality and would just result in either bloating of competitive options or unreasonably small movepools as we try to limit them.
But second, it's also worth remembering that
that means flavor options don't have to be crammed into level-up and Egg movepools! Like I said, there are many Pokémon that learn about four times as many moves from TMs, tutors and breeding
(breeding is usually like 3-8 at most, so still mainly TMs and tutors) as by level. TMs being usable for flavor is important to alleviate the space concerns of level-up movepools, which is another reason why I think it's best to have a TM list up front so people know
how many moves they can reasonably fit rather than feeling constrained to prioritizing competitive options/moves that are more "important" at the cost of supporting their Pokémon's flavor identity.
Important clarification:
- All of these are "by default," but they are not required. There can still be exceptions if there's either a strong flavor reason or an important mechanical reason! It's just worth noting that these are the moves that will be the most affected and the most widely distributed by gaining TM or tutor status. There are one or two exceptions to almost all of these in canon already, but we do need to have some kind of starting point; I would much rather ask the few people who don't want one of them on their Fakemon to say so than be limited to only the people who know to mention these as competitive additions.
- This also extends to moves that are noted here as being "mostly exclusive" to a certain type. There are frequently exceptions made for "honorary members" of the type (like Comfey and Sirfetch'd for Grass) and sometimes just one or two outliers if the move has strong flavor significance.
Absolutely none of these are strict requirements, and none of them should be treated as such! However, they're
very useful guidelines to follow and can help to provide a starting point for movepools, and I think it can be valuable to offer them as a starting point for our TM list.
Moves to Assume by Default
:mew: Facade, Frustration, Giga Impact, Return, Hidden Power, Hyper Beam, Round, Snore, Attract for all Pokémon that can be male or female, Confide, Double Team, Endure, Protect, Sleep Talk, Substitute, Swagger, Toxic and Rest will go to every Pokémon by default.
:blissey: Work Up, Sunny Day and Rain Dance will go to every Normal-type Pokémon by default.
:typhlosion: Flame Charge, Fire Blast, Fire Spin, Flamethrower, Heat Wave, Incinerate, Overheat, Sunny Day, Will-o-Wisp and Solar Beam will go to every Fire-type Pokémon by default, and Fire-type Pokémon often learn Scorching Sands.
:wailord: Surf, Rain Dance, Blizzard, Ice Beam, Icy Wind and Hail will go to every Water-type Pokémon by default, and Scald will go to every Water-type except part-Ice-types by default.
:manectric: Charge Beam, Electro Ball, Rising Voltage, Thunder, Thunderbolt, Thunder Wave, Flash and Rain Dance will go to every Electric-type Pokémon by default, and Electric-type Pokémon often learn Electroweb and Volt Switch.
:gogoat: Seed Bomb, Energy Ball, Giga Drain, Grass Knot, Solar Beam, Sunny Day and Flash will go to every Grass-type Pokémon by default.
:regice: Blizzard, Ice Beam, Icy Wind, Hail and Rain Dance will go to every Ice-type Pokémon by default.
:throh: Brick Break, Close Combat, Revenge, Rock Smash, Focus Blast, Bulk Up, Coaching, Strength, Rock Slide, and Stone Edge will go to every Fighting-type Pokémon by default, and Fighting-type Pokémon often learn Bulldoze, Earthquake and Rock Tomb.
:garbodor: Sludge Bomb and Venoshock will go to every Poison-type Pokémon by default, and Poison-type Pokémon often learn Rain Dance.
:hippowdon: Bulldoze, Earthquake, Earth Power, Strength, Rock Smash, Rock Slide and Rock Tomb will go to every Ground-type Pokémon by default, and Ground-type Pokémon often learn Dig, Stone Edge, Sandstorm and Stealth Rock.
:tornadus-therian: Aerial Ace will go to every Flying-type Pokémon by default, and Flying-type Pokémon often learn Dual Wingbeat, Fly usually unless they're also Bug-types?, Air Slash, Defog, Roost, Tailwind, Steel Wing, Heat Wave and Rain Dance usually unless they have an unusual matchup against Fire or Water thanks to their secondary type?.
Dual Wingbeat, Defog, Steel Wing and Heat Wave are all particularly common among winged Pokémon in general.
edit: updated Defog distribution based on feedback from Discord!
:alakazam: Expanding Force for all Psychic-type Pokémon that are affected by Psychic Terrain (not immune to Ground), Psychic, Psyshock, Calm Mind and Psych Up will go to every Psychic-type Pokémon by default, and Psychic-type Pokémon often learn Future Sight, Psyshock, Light Screen, Reflect, Trick Room, Rain Dance and Shadow Ball.
:accelgor: Struggle Bug will go to every Bug-type Pokémon by default, and Bug-type Pokémon often learn Electroweb.
:gigalith: Rock Blast, Rock Slide, Rock Tomb, Stone Edge, Rock Polish, Sandstorm, Stealth Rock, Bulldoze, Earthquake, Earth Power and Iron Defense will go to every Rock-type Pokémon by default, and Rock-type Pokémon often learn Smack Down and Meteor Beam.
:dusknoir: Shadow Ball and Spite will go to every Ghost-type Pokémon by default, and Ghost-type Pokémon often learn Poltergeist, Hex and Will-o-Wisp.
:haxorus: Outrage, Draco Meteor and Dragon Pulse will go to every Dragon-type Pokémon by default, and Dragon-type Pokémon often learn Flamethrower and Focus Blast.
:zoroark: Lash Out, Payback, Dark Pulse and Taunt will go to every Dark-type Pokémon by default, and Dark-type Pokémon often learn Assurance, Foul Play, Thief and Snatch (all four of these usually unless their pre-evolutions aren't Dark-type?, as well as Snarl and Rain Dance usually unless they have an unusual matchup against Water thanks to their secondary type?.
:klinklang: Steel Beam and Iron Defense will go to every Steel-type Pokémon by default.
:alcremie: Dazzling Gleam will go to every Fairy-type Pokémon by default, and Fairy-type Pokémon often learn Draining Kiss and Rain Dance usually unless they have an unusual matchup against Water thanks to their secondary type?
Moves to Avoid
:silvally: Fire Pledge, Blast Burn, Water Pledge, Hydro Cannon, Grass Pledge and Frenzy Plant are mostly exclusive to starter Pokémon.
If you do make an exception to this one, it should be for a Pokémon that can be considered similar or related to starter Pokémon, and you should account for all six of these moves (such as in the context of Pokémon that come in a trio). It is not recommended that you give them to just any Pokémon that would benefit.
:wailord: Dive, Flip Turn, Razor Shell or Waterfall are mostly exclusive to Water-type Pokémon.
:manectric: Electro Ball, Rising Voltage, Volt Switch, Eerie Impulse and Electric Terrain are mostly exclusive to Electric-type Pokémon, but Steel-type Pokémon are more likely to be exceptions than other types.
Electroweb is mostly exclusive to Electric-type Pokémon and Bug-type Pokémon, but there are multiple exceptions in cases with strong flavor justifications. It seems to be equally associated with both types.
:gogoat: Grassy Glide, Leaf Blade, Grassy Terrain, Synthesis and Worry Seed are mostly exclusive to Grass-type Pokémon, but there are multiple exceptions to each in cases with strong flavor justifications.
In canon so far, Leaf Storm is fully exclusive to Grass-type Pokémon but remember that you can still break that if you want.
:regice: Frost Breath and Icicle Spear are mostly exclusive to Ice-type Pokémon, but Water-type Pokémon are more likely to be exceptions than other types.
In canon so far, Aurora Veil is fully exclusive to Ice-type Pokémon but remember that you can still break that if you want.
In canon so far, Hail is mostly exclusive to Ice-type Pokémon and Water-type Pokémon. It seems to be equally associated with both types.
:throh: Coaching is mostly exclusive to Fighting-type Pokémon, but there are multiple exceptions in cases with strong flavor justifications.
:garbodor: In canon so far, Corrosive Gas is fully exclusive to Poison-type Pokémon but remember that you can still break that if you want.
:hippowdon: In canon so far, Scorching Sands is fully exclusive to Ground-type Pokémon and Fire-type Pokémon but remember that you can still break that if you want. It seems to be equally associated with both types.
:tornadus-therian: Brave Bird and Sky Drop are mostly exclusive to Flying-type Pokémon, but there are multiple exceptions in cases with strong flavor justifications.
:alakazam: Expanding Force and Cosmic Power are mostly exclusive to Psychic-type Pokémon.
In canon so far, Psychic Terrain is fully exclusive to Psychic-type Pokémon but remember that you can still break that if you want.
:accelgor: Bug Buzz is mostly exclusive to Bug-type Pokémon.
:dusknoir: In canon so far, Poltergeist is fully exclusive to Ghost-type Pokémon but remember that you can still break that if you want, and Phantom Force is mostly exclusive to Ghost-type Pokémon, but there are multiple exceptions in cases with strong flavor justifications.
:haxorus: In canon so far, Draco Meteor is fully exclusive to Dragon-type Pokémon other than certain external event distributions but remember that you can still break that if you want.
:klinklang: In canon so far, Steel Beam is fully exclusive to Steel-type Pokémon but remember that you can still break that if you want.
:alcremie: Misty Explosion is mostly exclusive to Fairy-type Pokémon.
(Huge thanks to the people who collaborated with me on this on the Discord!
I did end up manually going through the rest of the TMs, TRs and tutors after that like I promised, so I think it should be complete now, although there were a lot of them and I may have made some mistakes. Let me know if there are any other changes to be made!)
---
Closing thought on how the movepool process might actually work once this list is decided:
To repeat something I've said on the Discord,
I feel strongly that individual submitters should not be responsible for creating full movepools. It's a somewhat long process that can take moderate amounts of time and research to learn and probably takes more than a few minutes at a time, and I don't think it's reasonable to expect every submitter to put that time into it or to expect every submitter to be as familiar with it.
I would definitely support asking submitters to list
competitively significant moves (perhaps in the context of sets they would like the Pokémon to be able to run?) and
any and all moves they would like to put forward for flavor, but the task of expanding and organizing these into full learnsets should be a group effort on the Discord - there's simply no way that everyone who submits to the mod
(nor even everyone who wins, which I think was your intended solution, but correct me if I'm wrong) will be willing or able to do this on their own.
(I also would not be surprised if anyone was prone to misjudging what moves are competitively relevant and what moves can be distributed liberally for flavor reasons - I know I would have been if I were on here two years or so ago. I feel it would not be a good idea to give complete control of this to the submitters
after they win and the vote is concluded, which I think is what you intended to do?)
For right now - when people are submitting Fakemon and we don't have a TM list to work with yet - I personally would
strongly encourage submitters to take into account the list we have in canon and
assume for the moment that moves will have fairly consistent distributions (especially with the ones I listed above - some key moves like Stone Edge on Fighting-types or Volt Switch on Electric-types are kind of important, and it seems like a bad idea to leave them out just because we don't
know they'll be TMs, especially if you feel the need to compensate in other ways). We can figure out exactly
how they can be learned later on, but if you think a move is worth listing, go for it and trust that we'll be able to fit it later!
But don't, like, specify them as coming from level or breeding or TM. I would recommend against trying to settle on a full level-up movepool when we don't know which moves
need to come by level, you know? It would be best for that to wait until this discussion is closed (which is why, like I mentioned, I support having this conversation early - if Fakemon are supposed to have full movepools, we want to prepare for that as soon as possible and not wait until we have to deal with dozens of them all at once!).
In any case, there are many of us here and on the Discord who would be happy to help with the process, and I think it would be much more realistic - and much less pressuring on submitters - if everyone in the mod was free to pitch in as a group and the original submitter had no obligation beyond the moves they line out initially in their sub; I would definitely not put the expectation on each submitter to construct a full movepool for their own submissions, wherever we end up with our TM list.
---
TL;DR because this was way too long:
- Let's definitely try to get a solid list sooner rather than later so we can make real progress on movepools before there are too many to cover at once.
- I think we should collaborate - either in the thread or on the Discord, but absolutely in public and with involvement from anyone who's interested - on picking our top hundred most-valued TMs, with a healthy balance of flavor and competitive moves (probably close to 50/50) and a few free spaces for custom moves to be decided later.
- After that, we can also get together a list of the most important tutors that we can't afford to drop, but I would like to avoid inflating the number more than necessary, so let's stick to widely-used competitive moves for this. I also do not think we should plan to continue adding official tutor moves to this list in the future - once we have our initial tutor list, we should probably be adding only new moves we introduce and want to give wider distribution.
- If we do introduce new moves with wide distribution (not just signature ones for new lines, which I think are fine to do at the same time as the line itself), we should save those for close to the end of the project when we have a broad picture of our dex's competitive needs overall.
- Please don't give us a list as big as SwSh's I'm begging
- there are so many things I hate about TRs
- When deciding which moves should be included or excluded as TMs, the contents of the first spoiler ("Moves to Assume by Default") are the most important moves to decide right away, and I would love to see people share their thoughts on any they want to keep and any they want to drop!
- Those are also moves you should always have in mind for your own movepool submissions (and the spoiler after, "Moves to Avoid," is also always good to check if you ever aren't sure on including a move). I know it looks long, but only about three bullet points will be relevant to any given sub (the fully universal moves + moves associated with your one or two types), so I would encourage people to check it every time!
- Full movepools should absolutely be a public/group endeavor, not an individual one! I particularly disagree with expecting submitters to finish them on their own after their submissions are voted in (or really having total control over any step of competitive relevance after voting is over).
WHEW
That's all now - sorry :'D
EDIT: ah, update since Sharpen42 was able to respond!
By my own request on the Discord, I am no longer a council member - I've found that I don't really have a ton of time to contribute to this and feel bad not generally making it a priority, and there are definitely more consistently engaged members of the community who absolutely deserve the position
(congrats to the person I think is replacing me by the way!!! I was really hoping you'd be added : D) - but I will still be contributing to stuff like movepools and coding on my own time!
I might occasionally make opinionated rambles like this in the future as well, haha.