Finland said:To be blunt, yes. You are wrong. This is material covered in intro to macroeconomics courses. Demand for one good reduces the demand for possible substitute goods, even if the substitute good does not completely fill every need of the original good. There are only so many sports fans, and if they're caring about and spending money on the NFL, they aren't caring about soccer (and require extra effort to change existing/entrenched preference). There's only so much time and money each household spends on food, and if they're spending that time at a fast food restaurant, they're not spending it at a fine dining establishment. Yes, some substitute goods are stronger than others and have stronger effects, and (the NFL) isn't a perfect substitute for (the MLS), but their demands are still inversely correlated.
As a whole, Pokemon lacks many strong/viable substitutes, which is a huge reason why it's so popular. But for specific aspects, like PVP and especially single-player difficulty, the substitutes are less weak. This partially explains why GameFreak puts less time and effort into these features than some would like, especially single-player difficulty, where it is competed against more strongly. Note that SWSH's most obvious focus of effort is where Pokemon lacks as many substitutes: the individual Pokemon themselves.
Shiny hunting is not a kid's fad, it's consistently disproportionately made up of older and more experienced fans. What I and others are looking at is kids.
Yes, Nuzlockes are an exception where a Pokemon difficulty challenge is still popular among kids. However, it wasn't made by Nintendo itself, which makes things more complicated if Nintendo would try to capture such a community with an in-game feature. This complication is another point against the viability of putting effort into the Frontier. Also, Nuzlockes and other exceptions aren't strong enough to fully compensate for the single-player accomplishment that Pokemon lost in the Internet transition (especially discovery, bragging ability to friends, and perception of difficulty, all of which are harmed by online walkthroughs).
Again, as far as single-player accomplishment specifically, Pokemon's problem isn't difficulty, but difficulty ratio that is too low. Other games tend to have higher difficulty accomplishment, less time needed to burn in gameplay to reach the same level of accomplishment, or both, giving them better time-to-accomplishment ratios. The Internet has made more kids aware of these other games with better ratios, giving Pokemon more competition in this field.
1. Maybe I'm wrong, but I'm not sold with your examples. Yes, demand for one good may reduce the demand for possible substitutes, but that would not realistically apply to a chicken vs candy example, it might apply to a chicken vs vegetable example (comparing Pokemon to not another RPG but instead another ''traditional'' video game like Tekken instead). Let's just say you'd have a very very hard time convincing anyone that candy is a realistic substitute for chicken. You're probably more accurate with the NFL vs soccer comparison, although that belies the fact that Americans as we currently speak are far more favorable towards the NFL even though both currently exist at the same time. I honestly doubt NFL would be much more popular (or soccer much less popular) if the other sport disappeared from history and the world itself.
2. I'm...not remotely convinced. Some of the most popular Pokemon games universally (and not just among adults, a lot of who played these games as kids anyway) come from generations known for notorious bosses - Gen 2 (Whitney, Red, and Clair) and Gen 4 (really just Cynthia), looking at you. Gen 5, arguably one of the hardest generations itself, is also becoming more well-loved and if kids are really such a significant part of the player base as y'all and Game Freak assume, I honestly doubt that's separate from the kids' own interests. I even wonder if kids and adults are all that divergent in their attitudes towards the game - Gen 7 ironically pisses adults off EXACTLY because they're slow and handholding, yet we're assuming the kids and even the more impatient ones among them would be fine with such a slow game either.
3. Shiny hunting isn't a fad belonging to any specific age group actually? Ever thought that the reason it looks like mostly ''adults'' do it is because...*gasp*...adults happen to have louder voices about Pokemon shit in general? My college professor's kid literally collected square and sparkle shinies in Sw/Sh and showed them to me. I just came across a YouTube video chronicling the shinies the YouTuber found as a kid. As a kid myself, I freaked out when I found two separate shinies and made sure to catch them - yes, that's not really shiny hunting, but it's not as if my kid self didn't appreciate shinies nonetheless and I see zero evidence to assume at least some kids wouldn't partake, especially when I know some did.
4. People really come off as apologists for Game Freak at best and going full on ''kids bad'' at worst, neither of which is particularly cool. Like it's pretty clear a massive and arguably the more influential portion of the player base is relatively grownup, it makes no sense to NOT cater to them ESPECIALLY when doing so doesn't even have to come at the expense of more ''casual'' players. In fact, given that the massive hysteria and even boycott threats regarding Sw/Sh came from so-called veteran players comparing them to earlier Pokemon games, BOTW, etc - who would naturally trend much older than the ''kids'' - it definitely seems as if it's the grownups and not the kids who have the loudest (and by proxy the most influential) voices. If kids dump Pokemon, you probably wouldn't even know it. If adults do, you sure will. It should be clear who has more influence.
Game Freak has an opportunity to maintain brand loyalty - possibly even draw in new fans - by allowing the possibility to maximize challenges (among other things like undoing the Pokemon removal, which I really doubt anyone liked). A difficulty setting available from the beginning literally solves that problem, quick as spit, most ''casuals'' will play casually and anyone wanting a challenge would know what to do.
Just create the option. It's not hard. Y'all did it with B2W2, don't pretend you can't do it now. And make the Exp. Share its SM equivalent.