Notably we get no info from Laurel bc he hasn't developed any solviness or reads
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Bigvivor Mafia Game Thread Day 5
- Thread starter Tommy
- Start date
Do you have any opinions on voting Ryo instead of Laurel, because I think Ryo!scum gives a reasonable chance of Laurel!scum but I don't think the inverse is true
But obv it's weird not to vote on the tribe we know has a scum, but on the other hand I still tr most of that tribe and sl most of the other which has been a lot of my struggle today lol
ty
if i wanted to go for less information ryo would definitely be the vote to do it, but i don’t have any stronger thoughts about voting ryo since i think he’s just been kind of there and hasn’t really been discussed today
do you actively think ryo is scummy? it feels like ur asking this based on a preflip
idk like i'm not ruling out the possibility after the last couple days but man that push was so forced...
but it’s not like he was the only one pushing you though?
i think there's a decent chance he flips scum, biggest thing in my read back was how static his progression was, didn't move or evolve his reads at all and kept to the same trajectory of his targets and interactions
the only one to keep pushing the activity narrative after i showed up
i never do NKA until we see the first red flip, way too many assumptions to ever have good analysis
tbf you showed up super late and immediately started pushing me back and others/maybe you made a bunch of weird associations implicating us.
oh i didn't even do that in the end
read back = in past games?
TBH I do. There have been a couple times this game that he’s provided conclusions while not taking responsibility for them, serving more as a commentator on thread state than anything else. It’s p standoffish and a way to provide little new content writing it off as a paradigm
It’s weird af that he pushed me earlier today and Laurel now, the interim being me pushing Laurel. If Laurel’s town then that’s a clear attempt to crossfire as Laurel said
And if Laurel’s scum I think Laurel always busses in return so the interaction is kinda catch 22 for Ryo and just results in scumminess
Which uh is like the definition of WIFOM right that’s interesting LOL
i prob do laurel before dyo if its between the two just b/c dyo can confirm m2hs earlier claim to an extent
A LOT of people have references vizh’s posts and either read them as “soft scum” or pulled an eli and gone “his posts suck but in a nice way”-direct quote
I think voting Dyo is bad and saying I’m scum because I agree with Spiderz that you’re Sus is kinda whack.
Not even Vizh would claim that people aren’t scum reading him lmao.
i think the thing that confuses me about ryos progression is how much he follows people and sort of defers to others takes, hes had posts where he takes back his reads a lot (like when he stopped looking at Sam after reading his posts) on other people’s opinions. maybe that can be new scum nerves though
i don’t think that’s inherently scummy though cuz i see less agenda in it, like a celever vote probably isn’t going through
you looked me up tf
the day 1 analysis i did on thurs night
I literally did not say this and drookez has been suspicious since day 2 when his opportunistic dyo push and subsequent vanishing act happened. I didnt feel solid about his claim so this didnt "materialize from nothing". I'm more than fine dropping it though since, like I said, I didnt feel certain about it anyway