Godly Gift VR Nominations - The Gods
:rayquaza: Rayquaza to B
Rayquaza is an insane wallbreaker but a lack of recovery or defensive donations makes it hard to use outside of Hyper Offense where it's definitely had a slow decline with players favouring Mewtwo instead. This is because, frankly, there are a dozen Pokemon that become borderline broken when given a Speed boost with Pangoro, Dhelmise and Slowking-Galar being three examples that have become particularly notable in recent weeks. On the other hand, Zeraora is the only particularly good follower above base 130 Speed, leaving Rayquaza to fairly niche HO subgenres like Venusaur Sun and Arctozolt Hail which are both more prediction reliant and also require better positioning than the mindless clicking Mewtwo (and Pheromosa) promote. Rayquaza
can work on offense leaning balance teams, but I personally feel that this role is performed much better by Yveltal. It's about as strong offensively, has much more defensive utility and longevity through Oblivion Wing/Roost, and base 99 Speed means it and its Speed recipient can offensively pressure every other balance-centric God far harder than Rayquaza can which I find to be a huge boon to it.
:ho-oh: Ho-Oh to B
The resident Ho-Oh hater is trying to lower its VR placement again. Kyogre and Nidoking are gone so SpDef mons like Tangrowth and Gastrodon can manage just fine with the 100ish SpDef that Lunala, Dialga etc. offer while base 154 SpDef is honestly complete overkill. I've actually changed my tune on Ho-Oh itself a ton after discovering this set:
Ho-Oh
Ho-Oh @ Heavy-Duty Boots
Ability: Regenerator
EVs: 80 HP / 156 Atk / 252 Def / 20 Spe
Adamant Nature
- Brave Bird
- Sacred Fire
- Thunder Wave
- Substitute
It's absurdly hard to switch into and offers some great compression, but as a donor I still think Ho-Oh is a perfect example of "jack of all trades, master of none"; it certainly lacks the 'oomph' of mons like Lunala and Yveltal as it really suffers from having a below average Speed stat, to say nothing of its middling HP and SpAtk stats that make building with it a real chore.
:zekrom: Zekrom to D/UR
Zekrom's reputation as a nigh unstoppable wallbreaker completely falls apart in Godly Gift; reliable answers to this mon exist on nearly every balance team as a result of Zeraora and Tapu Koko's dominance, with Zekrom having a very hard time breaking past defensively amplified Electric-resists like Tangrowth, Landorus-T, Ferrothorn etc. regardless of if it's going mixed or fully committing to Dragon Dance. It offers great stats, but not better stats than Dialga or Kyurem-Black and I find both of those far harder to switch into. As an attack donor, Groudon has built in chemistry with followers like Victini and Rillaboom and has way more defensive utility with its mono Ground-typing while again offering a very similar stat distribution. Even in the D rank, Pokemon like Magearna and Stakataka, while very limited, have a clear cut niche whereas I've yet to find any offensive core that can justify Zekrom over its aforementioned stat monster rivals.
:diancie: Diancie to D (HP Only)
It's Shuckle, but instead of playing 5v6 you're using a reasonably bulky Yveltal (& Ho-Oh) answer that can click Stealth Rock more than once and sometimes force a trade with Calm Mind. I think everyone on the Council saw this game but
here's me vs TPP in OMWC where I showcased how much base 150 defense can offer to a bulky wincon like Slowking-Galar, even if your opponent is playing far better than you.
The Quickfire Round
:mewtwo: +(Atk)
:ho-oh: +(SpAtk)
:zamazenta-crowned: +(HP)
:yveltal: +(Atk, SpAtk)
:giratina: +(SpAtk)
:lunala: +(Atk)
:giratina-origin: +(Atk, SpAtk)
:necrozma-dawn-wings: +(HP) -(Def)
:zamazenta: +(HP)
Godly Gift VR Nominations - The Followers, and a proposal
There is a clear gap in viability between different 'sets' - Atk Victini is far more viable than Spe Victini, for example, and conversely Alolan Persian is far stronger in the Def slot than it is running Beat Up in the Atk slot. The current viability ranking includes all of these sets, but does not distinguish between them, which I think makes it misleading as a resource for newer players especially with the absence of something like
OU's Sets Viability Ranking. I have two possible solutions:
Proposal A: Almost Any Ability
The Viability Ranking resource for Almost Any Ability has two formatting variants; emboldened and plain. Emboldened text is used for a Pokemon's most common abilities, marking them as particularly notable, while plain text is used for niche abilities that still have a place on certain teams. I think this would be something that the Godly Gift Viability Ranking would benefit from adopting. The first few ranks would look like this (in my own, biased opinion):
S and A+
S Rank:
:landorus-therian: Landorus-T (SpD, Any)
:clefable: Clefable (Def, Spe)
A Rank:
A+
:ferrothorn: Ferrothorn (HP, Any)
:moltres-galar: Moltres-G (SpA)
:rotom-wash: Rotom-W (HP)
:tangrowth: Tangrowth (SpD)
:tapu koko: Tapu Koko (SpA, HP, Any)
:tornadus-therian: Tornadus-T (Def, HP, SpA, Any)
Proposal B: Monotype
The Viability Ranking resource for Monotype, on the other hand, boasts
eighteen different rankings, with each type getting its own fun-size sector. Godly Gift could make do with just seven; HP, Atk, Def, SpA, SpD, Spe, and Any. I'm not an entire Council so I won't run through the whole thing but here's a sample of what it might look like
HP and Spe
HP
S Rank
Nothing!
A Rank
:ferrothorn: Ferrothorn
:rotom-wash: Rotom-Wash
:skarmory: Skarmory
:tapu koko: Tapu Koko
B Rank
:aegislash: Aegislash
:rotom-heat: Rotom-H
:shuckle: Shuckle
:tapu fini: Tapu Fini
C Rank
:diancie: Diancie
:ditto: Ditto
:magnezone: Magnezone
D Rank
:comfey: Comfey
:hatterene: Hatterene
:klefki: Klefki
:scizor: Scizor
Spe
S Rank
:heatran: Heatran
:pangoro: Pangoro
A Rank
:dhelmise: Dhelmise
:slowking-galar: Slowking-Galar
B Rank
:aegislash: Aegislash
:conkeldurr: Conkeldurr
:tapu lele: Tapu Lele
:volcanion: Volcanion
C Rank
:slowking: Slowking
:tyranitar: Tyranitar
:victini: Victini
D Rank
:clefable: Clefable
:druddigon: Druddigon
:sirfetchd: Sirfetch'd
:tapu bulu: Tapu Bulu
I think adopting either of these systems would be a notable improvement for the VR. The AAA approach would be easier to skim through and probably require less upkeep, while the Monotype approach would allow for the ranking of far more niche options without massively inflating the viability ranking to a point beyond usefulness; Godly Gift is unique in that it can be very easy to build with, say, SpA Pelipper, or Atk Nihilego, without it being a completely unnecessary gambit when compared to running a D rank Pokemon from literally any other tier's Viability Ranking, and the Monotype approach reflects that admirably.
I'll do some proper Follower nominations in the future, but I wanted to float this idea around first to see what people think