Lemingue said:romhacks would be better if people realized having every fight be a bootleg showdown ranked match is not very fun for an actual game
Real talk, having 6 Pokemon eligible for in-game battle was a mistake. Either you have a team of 6 battle-ready mons and few things are more challenging than your average wild encounter (unless you give all the trainers degenerate strats that can potentially wipe you), or every trainer is a slog that costs a ton of resources or many tedious trips to the Pokemon Center to recover from.
Hugin said:I'm curious, what aspect of the original games are you wanting to see fixed by romhacks that they aren't touching?
A speedrun timer.
If you have a strategy guide and a rabbit's foot, you can beat any turn-based game. Speedrunning Pokemon can be a lot more interesting since you absolutely cannot grind or drag your team to a Pokemon Center if you want competitive times. The randomness can be a pain but a lot of speedruns use starters or early mons to mitigate a lot of it. Maybe also have an in-game reward for reaching certain times?
Volt-Ikazuchi said:obnoxiously optimized mons forcing you to EV train in-game
Talk about a "realistic" change that's boring as sin to play. I'm not opposed to some slight EV tweaks to add some spice and mitigate your own EV gain, but stopping everything to grind just to have a chance, especially before the E4 where some fangames love to spring this on you, is the worst.
And if you want to max out EVs, you ought to make getting and resetting EVs real easy so no one's shaving years off their life. Please make the Vitamins cheaper!
Celever said:A story's use in video games is to motivate the player to keep playing in order to resolve the cliffhanger, as well as to make the player care about the characters and purpose behind the work and effort they're putting into the game.
Gen I was a strong start for the series' stories: you had an immediate goal that put your pride at stake, then when you get to know the world better, you're eased into stopping the mafia from treating your animal friends badly for profit. Along the way your rival will make life worse for you so you remember to kick his butt whenever possible, culminating in a battle that will decide who your surrogate father loves and who gets shafted. It's far from a deep narrative and being forced to win against your rival diffuses the tension by a lot, but later games get so wrapped up in abstract apocalyptic stakes and annoying characters that the OG games' story is still my favorite.