boxlb said:I mean the opportunity cost of running a specific tera type is the same as running anything, no? It's not an argument in defense, but the cost is that you can't run a different tera type. For example, if I run normal tera on slowking to make it surprise-wall ghosts, than I'm not running a different type that it could enable it to instead wall grasses. Or am I misunderstanding the concept of opportunity cost?
This is not entirely how it works. Thats like saying “by running physical infernape then I miss out on running special infernape.” Yeah, that’s technically true but otherwise inconsequential. Ideally, when choosing a Tera Type, you are building your entire set around the Pokemon’s Tera and your entire team around that set. I think it’ll help if we start reframing what Tera is, functionally. In many ways a Pokemon is completely changing what it is, entirely. I played a few games with Fire-Tera Amoonguss and what Fire-Tera Amoonguss does is almost completely different from what regular Amoonguss does; from the Pokemon it can check to its role in the battle. Tera is like giving you a seventh Pokemon that you can activate in battle whenever you want; its different from Dynamax in that sense since, where Dynamax was matrix for boosting and sweeping, Tera (can) fundamentally alter the role the Pokemon is trying to accomplish.
In many matches I simply changed my Iron Bundle to electric and now its essentially a different Pokemon. Sure it shares some similarities with regular Iron B, but for the purposes of a singular match its completely different, with different checks and counters; its no longer buffed by Snow and no longer weak to SR, it can no longer be paralyzed. These considerations are important in analyzing Tera because suddenly each Pokemon you see on your opponent’s team preview actually represents 18+ variations.
Tera is different from Dynamax and Z-move in that its not *just* upgrading stats or boosting the power of moves, its changing a fundamental aspect of a Pokemon that goes beyond a simple “I have increased my power by X.” Types and the interactions between them is something so fundamental to the game that its hard to gloss over this fact.
Again, I’m not totally against keeping Tera, though I lean more towards banning it, I can respect that it adds a different layer to the game. While I dont find that layer particularly fun (“Oh he changed his Roaring Moon to Steel-typ on my ice shard….yippee…”) I’m eager to see how it develops in a metagame without so many Pokemon that are busted before even considering the mechanic, and I do wonder to what extent the “not-brokenness” of Tera feels to some has to do with the fact that there are just a crap ton of obviously busted shit in the metagame right now. Regardless, I think its important we are all on the same ground when discussing this
Apologies if this topic has moved on, I’m at work and cant read every post
Finchinator said:HUGE MECHANICS UPDATE
When Protosynthesis / Quark Drive boost Speed, its by 50%, but for ANY other stat, its 30%!!!
This is big but not massive imo. The 50% speed boost was the craziest aspect to the item imo and that is unchanged. 30% is still a lot and its nice icing on the cake, though I wonder how many mons would just rather go LO instead.