So who knows how the council is going to decide to review Tera, but at this point its worth trying to refine our initial plans for it. This is really rambling.
The Funky Reason said:" [Tera] is a stupid swing factor that adds so much stochasticity to the game for very little value. Yeah it's cute that you can use some creative sets but overall it makes so many sweepers get away with murder.
Part of the issue is we're playing with subjectivity when judging Tera. How much swing factor is too much? Its not like this is the first introduction of it, items and sets are part of this, as again it stems from asymmetric information. At what level of Tera does this become too difficult? When it can Tera into 4 types reasonably? 7? (Let's be serious: No one is contesting a mon has more than 10 tera types, probably none have more than 4-5 maximum). In general, both stabs and the two most advantageous defensive type
But again, the words associated with randomness are not the right word. These are not random. These types are pre-determined and eventually will be optimized. But right now we do not have the knowledge for what will be optimal which prevents us from being able to make informed choices about real %s a Tera shows to a specific type. As we know more, both our choices for Tera and what we expect will become more focused.
The Funky Reason said:Setting up my dark or fighting weak mon as opponent switches breloom or kingambit etc just to tera fairy to now resist priority and go for game is so dumb. Even if I don't go for game eliminating any of those can open the game out for other sweepers. Tera supporters, answer me, was my opponent bad for not predicting the tera and not mach/sucker punching? What if they predict tera and I don't and now they lost there prior user. Was he bad for not running sciz too to catch sweepers tera typing to avoid sucker and mach punch, the two most common forms of priority right now?
So in this scenario, your opponent has gotten the momentum to not only properly set up but begin their sweep. They are ALREADY ADVANTAGED. Should you then from a disadvantage be able to escape without equal investment? You have the option to go "oh wow he's in his sweep, I need to commit my own tera to survive". And yes, does that suck? Well that's the punishment for getting in that situation.
Like if a mon at one boost (which is all you're getting if we're speaking generically and 'reasonably') is being contained only because of a single priority option to you, then you have some major problems to begin with. You either had a team that had a critical weakness to it, were already heavily worn down, or the mon itself is probably broken. One of these is fixed by tiered action, and in the other two are you really deserving to win in that situation? Who knows, that's a real loose question for this discussion. But hey if you're weak and they have a tera available + boost, its not really the tera saving them but the fact that they set up to sweep and you gave them the ability to do so.
The Funky Reason said:Final plea to tera supporters, do you want to see the many offensive threats that abuse it banned, or keep all of those mons and lose tera?"
I'm open to banning it if over each interation of the meta, we find that Tera is consistently raising a mon to broken status from otherwise-playable/handlable. As of current, this situation hasn't come up. This is not happening with palafin, this was not the case with Flutter Mane and Houndstone. Quite clearly, only Roaring Moon is on the radar with a substantial piece of its power specifically FROM Tera, and thus far it doesn't seem like its gonna get banned.
Should we show Tera in team previews:
I don't think so. Besides the argument between cartridge and sim (of which I have 0 care for), fundamentally this strips part of the identity of the mechanic. Is it a good identity? Its not relevant for this change. Smogon has largely been committed to keeping the full identity of any mechanic/pokemon/move and then handling whether that mechanic is legal in tier as is. If the mechanic is broken, we ban it. If its fine, we keep it. The middle ground is reserved almost exclusively for changes that are too difficult to handle in other ways and if not addressed would threaten the overall competitive integrity of the game.
The fact of the matter is there's a large part of terastralizing that IS in the asymmetric information of what type you change to. This is part of the mechanic. So it stands to reason that we would be gimping Terastralizing in what is obviously (and has been acknowledged as such) as a complex ban in a situation where we could easily avoid one.
Low ladder Warrior has a post about how much more information we used to lack, and we played with it as is. That was seen as part of the generation, and still is. Is revealing team information something smogon should mandate in early gens? The game is fundamentally different with that information revealed. Whether or not its for the better is not really
our decision. The mechanic is the way it is.
Low Ladder Warrior said:I don't mean to be rude but if you think a lack of knowledge on your opponents full capabilities is automatically uncompetitive, then I'd love to see your reaction when you find out about Late Game Luke, or any of the other several dozen scenarios that a new player might find unfair in DPP all because they weren't experienced enough to properly read the gamestate. I think it's an extremely difficult argument to make that Tera-type is somehow more hidden than quite literally obscuring my opponent's entire team. And yet in generations with no team preview, it's the same players that are winning, and they are winning a lot. Not to downplay the accomplishments of any newcomers to old gens, but it's clear that oldheads have a very solid grasp on the concept of playing with incomplete information.
Playing with incomplete information certainly increases the skill level required to compete on a serious level, and that skill is difficult to master for many, but it is objectively a skill and we already decided it was a competitive one at that four generations ago. If I said to a gen 3 main "Aerodactyl, Skarmory, Flygon" they'd almost certainly respond along the lines of "Swampert, Zapdos, Ttar." If you know you know. It's perfectly reasonable that in a few years when I say to a Gen 9 player "Amoonguss, Corviknight, Quagsire" they might respond "Water/Dragon/Poison" or w/e. It's far too soon to just call Tera "random chance" just because players have to deal with something they aren't full accustomed to. Gamefreak has done basically nothing but inflate the numbers since gen 4. In light of that, it's no wonder that Tera feels so foreign to so many people, but that does not make it uncompetitive.
Should we ban Same Type Terastralizing:
]
Same argument as above. This is a slightly better option if we WERE to consider a complex ban, but also:
Porygon2Bandit said:The adaptability option to me is actually of far less concern. It makes mons that are too strong already, stronger. Outside Azumarill which is requiring a +6 belly drum tera water to get to stupid damage levels, are we actively seeing Tera Adaptability sweeps consistently come from mons that we aren't at least pointing to as eventual suspect tests? Moreover, we will probably find that the THREAT of terastralizing is as high if not higher than the actual terastralize. Once your Tera choice becomes common knowledge, if the switch to the type doesn't end the game, the value of it goes way down as you've lost a lot of informational superiority.
Really, even taking this option, I believe the primary power of terastralizing is NOT the sustained type change, but the immediate effects of the turn used. The threat of using Terastralizing is as strong (if not stronger) than the actual use of it. Beaf Cultist has echoed what I think will be the most common point of contention for Tera typing when we eventually focus in on it:
Beaf Cultist said:This is generally right, but my issue isn't with conflicting Tera types, it's with the fact that if you bring a mon that can Tera, and never Terastalize it, you lose literally nothing from its standard sets without Tera. So the opportunity cost for me is tied to Terastalizing itself, not so much what you do with that Tera.
Re: Comparing Tera to items
Guys come on. This is a bit much isn't it? It's a new mechanic, not a fucking item replacement. I get that on its face it seems like a fun point to compare to Z-Moves but in any real discussion about how broken a mechanic is, we do need to look at where it's being used, not add hypotheticals of something we're not even able to run.
Will Terastralizing be stronger than an item on average? I would hope so? Because, you only get one use of it per team. Just like Mega Stones were stronger than items, just as every mechanic from 5? 6? onward has been stronger than items but then limited to a single mon. Calcing Yache berry salamence to compare Tera'ing out of an ice weakness is just... not helpful. It's a single use mechanic that both players have equal access to.
Re: Split format
We've done stealth rock and no stealth rock formats before. The second format died in a month. There will not long term be two 'separate but equal' formats for OU. You can do it for a suspect test, but long term you HAVE to commit, and the other is basically relegated to like Other Metagames.
Its both a matter of playerbase and the fact that managing two different formats as 'ou' is just a colossal task for both making informed decisions about what needs bans as many users attempt and conflate the two formats.
Re: Defensive Terastralizing (Like actual stall defensive, not just type advantage for sweeping)
ayevon said:Stall might have the best teratype applications of all. While stall has certainly be neutered by other mechanic changes like reduced recovery pp and the huge increase of taunt users, the fact that wall on your team comes preloaded with a second typing that could be used to neuter the specific team you happen to be up against is such a huge advantage. Imagine your unaware clefable being able to change to be a fire type because you loaded into lo kartana, or your blissey being able to become a dark type because you're up against stored power reuni. Certainly these have drawbacks against specific team combonations, but the sheer volume of optionality in terms of offensive and defensive responses from all your different pokemon makes tera have a huge amount of random variance compared to z moves.
I find this to be... part true. Stall gets to turn some mons that have been absolutely shot by typing into a decent wall (Avalugg being the most obvious) and it does allow us very specific outs to otherwise bad situations (Water Tera Blissey to beat Chi Yu under sun, Ghost Tera Water Absorb Clodsire to wall Palafin). The real advantage stall has is that 'one turn of power' is backloaded into informational differences, not raw attack power. Because stall is good at extending a game, we can heavily reduce the amount of power a terastralize mon will gain from the surprise factor. Whereas Z Moves would just break us on that one turn of power being raw damage. This information warfare is way more pertinent and dangerous to offense where you have to make decisions on less information and have less time to gather what you need to be sure of the 'correct' option.
The major thing is right now Stall is kinda committing to a very obvious Tera user. If we have replacements and can gain that flexibility it will help us cover hyper specific stallbreakers teams struggle with in the same way offense does that to prevent specific checks from revenge killing.