Hello OU,
I am here to tell you why Tera should be banned outright. Any restriction does not solve the main problem of how unpredictable tera makes the game, and I would like to make my case with some replays.
Here's one that I had on day 0, where htcl brought some stall and I had some sash HO:
Hide
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9ou-1714260194
Ultimately I won because I pulled out a novel tera type that htcl could not have possibly prepared for. It was pure MU. Now, would any of the restrictions have helped htcl not lose to tera flying gholdengo?
-If htcl knew that gholdengo could indeed tera flying, then he could try and force it with clodsire and then seismic toss with blissey, but I could just as easily stay ghost/steel and NP up some more. It's still a guessing game.
-Limiting the number of pokemon that could tera wouldn't help, because tera flying gholdengo was insanely good and it would be one of them on my team. That wouldn't have changed anything.
-Limiting tera type to stabs would have made a big difference. But as we'll see in some other replays, that doesn't necessarily make playing around tera any less difficult.
-Banning tera blast would have made no difference here.
Here's another replay from day 0, I was using the same team against 3B on the fire's pincurchin team:
Hide
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9ou-1714288396
Having gholdengo block memento and thus getting a free turn was the sort of stroke of luck you could expect so early in the metagame, but regardless, it was able to ultimately win because I could tera flying vs the iron valiant, tank the knock off, avoid being revenge killed, and continue to kill everything.
-If 3b knew I could tera flying, it certainly helps the guessing game, but it stays as one. He has to use the correct move to kill and predict my tera, and if he guesses wrong he loses. That's assuming gholdengo even dies to anything in that position.
-Again, limiting the number of pokemon that could tera wouldn't help, I'm gonna let gholdengo use tera flying.
-Here is a game where limiting tera type to stabs actually would not have helped 3b very much. If I could tera steel on knock off, I can still win. If I can tera ghost on the CC predicting 3b to predict tera steel, I can also win. The unpredictability remains either way. Revenge killing isn't safe either way.
-Banning tera blast also makes no difference here.
Here's a more recent battle on the ladder, where I'm using a sun team vs Stevy124
Hide
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9ou-1721143397-qaktbfne0kvp4t678ftoq4q4871uwkrpw
I used tera fire on my specs chi-yu to avoid dying to iron valiant. The moonblast damage meant it was specs, but in case it wasn't, Tera fire would have allowed my to live an aura sphere. Chi-yu then goes on to 2hko ting-lu while a tera blast cb ghost pult smashes my team.
-If Stevy124 knew I was tera fire, it wouldn't have much of a difference in this scenario. This is one of the times where it's more telegraphed who has what tera (chi-yu probably tera fires on a sun team, pult often tera ghost, especially when banded) The raw power of both of these teras really doesn't care about whether or not you know about it, because what in the world is tanking tera fire specs chi-yu under the sun.
-Limiting the number of pokemon that can tera wouldn't help. I only tera with 3 mons on the updated version of this team 95% of the time.
-Limiting the tera type to stabs also makes no difference here.
-Banning tera blast would certainly make cb pult worse, but I imagine tera ghost specs shadow ball can do similar things on the special side.
Here's an interesting case on the ladder where I'm using a sun team vs vkhss
Hide
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9ou-1721365332-uh0j4u83u5udbazasazhpy93mifdhv3pw
I used tera fire on specs chi-yu yet again, but this time to get a surprise kill vs palafin. I think vkhss was aiming to tank the hit and drain punch to heal the damage back because chi-yu from full will live an unboosted jet punch under sun, but the unpredictability of tera struck again as I tera fire to avoid drain punch but end up just killing from 83%.
-If vkhss knew I was tera fire, maybe he could've switched out and sacked something else, but nothing else could kill me from full under sun either. I think he would've played the exact same way.
-Limiting the number of pokemon doesn't help here.
-Limiting tera type to stabs makes no difference here.
-Banning tera blast makes no difference here.
Here's yet another ladder battle where I'm using a sun vs fewavead
Hide
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9ou-1722346772-gkngmx68bc763xfyr36aiufqjnxd55ypw
Turn 1 I tera steel my roaring moon and iron head to kill the sylveon. Yeah that's really it.
-If fewavead knew I could tera steel, they could play more defensively and try to scout, but they are also using a pretty fat team vs my specs chi-yu which can always tera fire. Any defensive play and scouting means giving room for chi-yu to come in and blow something up. Meanwhile, I have no real hyper voice switch-in. Even with the information that fewavead could have, they are still forced to make a very important guess right off the bat.
-Limiting number of pokemon doesn't help here.
-Limiting tera type to stabs makes a difference here, but not necessarily a big one. Roaring moon iron head won't kill without tera, but that's only because I'm scarf here. If I'm banded, it will kill, and fewavead and it doesn't change the decisions fewavead has to make.
-Banning tera blast makes no difference here, pult got greedy and put itself in first impression range anyway.
So what sort of trends are we seeing? What conclusions can we draw?
In my opinion, the problem of tera is twofold: 80% of the problem is that it is unpredictable, and another 20% is that it makes certain pokemon incredibly strong and hard to wall with the right combinations. Ok then, are the proposed restrictions effective?
Showing Tera type at Team Preview:
In my opinion, I think that showing tera type does not do enough to mitigate the guesswork involved in playing around tera types. For every replay, I feel that knowing the tera type would not have helped the opponent in making the correct play. Even if they knew my tera type, they would still have to guess when I do it and with whom. As the metagame develops, I think we will see certain pokemon settle into certain tera types, so perhaps the "who will tera" question will be easier to guess with time. However, the timing is the most important and most problematic factor, and knowing the tera type beforehand doesn't change the fact that you have to guess when it comes out, and guessing wrong can lose you the game.
Limiting the number of pokemon that have access to Tera:
I think that this restriction is near meaningless unless it is literally 1 or 2. Anything more really doesn't hamper the flexibility of tera. Very rarely am I using tera on any more than 3 pokemon on a team across many games, and I suspect many people feel the same way, depending on the team.
Limiting tera type to stabs:
This restriction would remove a LOT of the unpredictability of tera and take a lot of guesswork out of the game, but most crucially, it does not remove it entirely. Being able to tera into pure fire with chi-yu still forced my opponent to make the same guesses that I could force by tera steel with roaring moon. This restriction is meaningful but not complete enough. It also doesn't stop unwallable nonsense like ghost dpult or fire chi-yu.
Banning tera blast:
This is just a lesser version of limiting tera type to stabs imo. Very meaningless restriction.
Let's take a second to address all the pro-tera arguments too, while I'm here typing this thesis.
"You can't ban the generation defining mechanic!!"
Yes we can. Dynamax was completely unbalanced, and got accordingly banned. Tera does not get any special treatment. If the qualified playerbase thinks it's broken, then it goes. Simple as that.
"Give it some more time!!"
This is a discussion thread, not a suspect thread. We are doing exactly that.
"But it's fun!"
I think specs kyogre would be a lot of fun in OU. But my idea of fun has no bearing on what the OU community should do to make the OU tier as competitive and diverse a tier as possible. At it's core, tera is uncompetitive because it forces players to consider and prepare for WAY too many options and regularly forces near-50-50s. The free adaptability to strong pokemon is just the icing on the cake.
"Just get used to it!"
This one baffles me the most. We got used to broken pokemon like dracovish too, and we carried seismitoad on most of our teams. It lead to the worst stretch of gen8 ou. The meta CAN adapt to any broken nonsense, but that doesn't mean that's a good thing, nor does it mean we should be satisfied with just adapting to whatever exists naturally.
In conclusion, I think all of the restrictions are inadequate and I support a full ban of terastallization.