SpritePony said:My philosophy behind it is "Try playing with the Pokemon WITHOUT the move they're abusing." (No Shed Tail Cyclizar, no Rage Fist apes) and then see how strong they really are. PokeAimMD and Emvee talked about this in regards to utility snek and Shed Tail in their recent video and made some valid points. Cyclizar without ST is a very good utility mon, but isn't necessarily broken. I've ran into Apes online that don't run Rage Fist (instead using stuff like Shadow Claw) and it isn't a big deal to deal with.
A lot of people, including the council, want to stray as far away from complex bans as they can, in spite of things like Arena Trap and Shadow Tag being banned. When HOME releases with Basculegion, Houndstone is coming back and Last Respects is getting banned -- yet another complex ban. Baton Pass is also a complex ban in and of itself. Houndstone was never the problem with LR, it was the move itself and the teams built around it. I think the same goes for Shed Tail and Rage Fist.
But hey, what do I know? I don't bother getting reqs for a tier I don't like playing. Yet I still weigh in on stuff like this and Tera because it has direct impacts on the tier(s) that I DO play.
(
Note: For argument's and brevity's sake, I will be referring to potential Suspects as if they are Unhealthy or Unwelcome, this does not reflect my stance on calling for a Quickban or the result of a potential Suspect)
I disagree immensely with the philosophy you express in paragraph one, because it simply ignores the nature of Pokemon where these traits do not exist in a vacuum, they are part of a full kit that may in total make a Pokemon more than the sum of its parts. Nothing about Cyclizar is particularly overpowered (honestly a lot of its kit reminds me of Noivern otherwise), nor is Shed Tail oppressive when simply given to any available user as Orthworm attests to. It is that the combination of traits Cyclizar has alongside Shed Tail makes for a potentially concerning Sum-of-parts.
I have a lot more to say about the second part because I feel there is a lot more here that is just incorrect information or understanding than a difference of philosophy (unpopular or otherwise).
Banning moves or abilities is not what is considered a "Complex" ban, as in the case of Arena Trap, Shadow Tag, Moody, etc. The point complex aims to avoid is banning things in combination/tandem to keep track of that can't be summed up in a simple sentence (Gen 5 OU was a massive headache because of the weird "No Drizzle + Swift Swim" and such bans, which do fall under complex).
The Houndstone thing is not complex either, moreso a combination of simple changes: we go from "Houndstone is banned" to "Houndstone and Basculegion are not banned" with "the move Last Respects is banned". Baton Pass is almost exactly what this is getting at, because various metas jumped through all kinds of dumb hoops with Baton Pass like "only X number of users" or "cannot pass Speed + Another stat at the same time" or "Dry passing only" (which runs into complications with outside or non-guaranteed boosting) before going with the much more straightforward and comprehensible "the move Baton Pass is banned".
SpritePony said:>Comparing an obviously broken mon with near perfect coverage to a mon that's only seen as broken because of one move + its ability.
The amount of mental gymnastics here is astonishing. Bundle was broken because it hit everything the game for at least neutral between Freeze Dry and Hydro Miss. Cyclizar is seen as broken because of Shed Tail and Regenerator. If you take away one, the mon is no longer broken. It just becomes a faster, more utility-based Orthworm that suffers from similar issues Orthworm does, except it doesn't have an ability you can POTENTIALLY make use of to regen your HP for another Shed Tail.
The other problem here is that you're arbitrarily operating as if it is better to keep Cyclizar in the game without Shed Tail as one part (emphasis here) that ties its kit into an extremely oppressive force. The point of the Iron Bundle comparison is that while Iron Bundle's Individual traits are certainly more powerful than something like Cyclizar's individual traits, it is having them all in combination that makes it a negative presence in the game rather than trying to run it without one piece of its toolkit.
Why is it so preferable to have a no-Shed-Tail Cyclizar at the expense of the less-effective-but-still-notable ST Orthworm, compared to banning Cyclizar because the sum of its parts are what make it unhealthy while Orthworm stays? Greninja in Gen 6 was primarily made oppressive because of Protean, its movepool, and its statline, compared to Kecleon who remained an unviable Mon with the ability. Despite Protean being a, if not THE, major factor that pushed Greninja into unhealthy territory, we banned Greninja, not Protean, because it was decidedly apparent the ability was not the solitary trait that gave the Pokemon its results. For the sake of context and consistency, would you have approached this suspect in the same manner you are advocating for Annihilape and Cyclizar, i.e. banning a key trait of their kit that has other non-broken users rather than the mon bringing said kit together?