NOC Smalltown Hotel Mafia - Game Thread (MAFIA WINS)

apricity said:
everyone remembers posts that relate to themselves much more than posts that don't

in the past 34 pages what kind of sticks out to me as a sore thumb is cel putting skipperz as a towncore

i can't help but doubt where this read comes from. i've read the ISO and i guess i just don't see it at all

if skipperz is actually town, this towncore read makes the most sense to me from someone who is scum who is hedging that i might actually gladiate and get this guy lynched (and in this hypothetical mislynched)

i wonder if it's just TMI
Click to expand...

possible, but skipperz has the newbie townie tone too that everyone takes in too easily
 
apricity said:
i had psy town earlier, i can' treally remember why, i'll come back to this thought when i do

but the early pages are a bit shouty and the emotional trajectory doesn't track

eli said that this is town. which also struck me as very TMI, because i felt like psy is probably worse this game than last game, and last game it took a while to get there
Click to expand...

psy just never commits to this on me as scum here i think, it's such a hard tunnel that the only way it happens is if he truly believes it imo

I don't think he has the balls to try thunderdome me as mafia so it's usually just wrong town
 
actually probably I'll take jker

I'm surprised you would think I'd take bpv, we are aware I'm worse town than you two so obv I'd give it to whoever I think is the best town with the likeliest chance of being town
 
Duskfall98 said:
actually probably I'll take jker

I'm surprised you would think I'd take bpv, we are aware I'm worse town than you two so obv I'd give it to whoever I think is the best town with the likeliest chance of being town
Click to expand...

I mean like if U took it off me would it be off of odds or actual reads. Don’t really care if you can’t give it to urself

It sounded like u implied u had a more confident tr which was the ?? part for me
 
JALMONT said:
ok no one's really said anything I want to respond to so I'm leaving this and going to bed.

My pool of people I'm willing to vote is: dusk/master oden/LS/realiti/apricity. That's the 5 roles I think cause major town problems later.

That said, I'm open to dusk using his role TODAY and doing whatever ASSUMING he doesn't stealth and do this 5 seconds before deadline. I no longer see the downside of him doing that because the threat of his role comes in a mylo or lylo situation. This won't affect night actions because we can assign those based on role, not person (ie JAILKEEPER do this, not M24 etc). This is probably the ideal play since we can't allow mafia!dusk to reach a mylo situation and swap to mayor.

I'm starting to feel we have to vote within the mayor/poisoner slots because there's just too many risks letting both go. My brain is fried so I can't really work through those. But essentially, fruit vendor/gladiator are so low impact, we can let them live and go after them late game when they can't just outright win the game for mafia if that's what it comes down to.
Click to expand...

the mayor and poisoner slots are some of the worst ones to vote though

like poisoner is gonna end up having to just poison someone in Poe or out, who cares if mafia has it

these roles are sure kinda strong but it's likely in town and no point killing our strongest assists in the unliekly chance it's mafia

like you want to kill all these "good" roles, but chance are you'll end up killing 3-4 town ones to get the 1 mafia got on rand
 
Nuxl said:
between you and me i think that kind of stuff feels quite hard to fake on an alignment jump

maybe it’s me underestimating how good of a player scum psy would be

Feel free to not respond etc
Click to expand...

psys first game as mafia was far townier than his town game

that being said, it was also very much not this!
 
apricity said:
Like legitimately what if the most helpful thing I can do this game is just to YOLO a gladiate into tommy

or maybe threaten to do so, so Tommy has to use his role before an ideal time
Click to expand...

go ahead if you would like to I will still Dave town with my ability and I guess you won't have to worry about getting the bpv since you'll be dead D1
 
Duskfall98 said:
psys first game as mafia was far townier than his town game

that being said, it was also very much not this!
Click to expand...
ik he has a scumgame on mu but ngl i don’t remember it atm (tho when I skimmed it last game iirc the way he carries himself here is much different than he does in games in mu anyway)
 
apricity said:
Like has Tommy ever made so many posts as town without seeming like scum

maybe it’s just psy throwing me off again

but somehow Tommy seems reasonable and bridge-building and that’s I guess just not what I associate with his town game

haha I’ve called everyone scum now I’ve become psy
Click to expand...

tbf I do play way different now, im reformed!!! I think you said something similar the last time you played with me and tried to tunnel me D1 for a bit
 
Nuxl said:
I mean like if U took it off me would it be off of odds or actual reads. Don’t really care if you can’t give it to urself

It sounded like u implied u had a more confident tr which was the ?? part for me
Click to expand...

I think you are just not towny this game moreso than I think half is overwhelmingly town, basically all your reads have been piggy backs and even then you're not really committed to them your game has been very weak overall and very cautious
 
Duskfall98 said:
I think you are just not towny this game moreso than I think half is overwhelmingly town, basically all your reads have been piggy backs and even then you're not really committed to them your game has been very weak overall and very cautious
Click to expand...
You think Hal's overwhelmingly town?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top