MilkyWay said:The reason I'm not that impressed with these calcs is because I could post the same thing except with Gengar instead, which isn't even ranked on the viability ranking thread.
Like literally, Gengar has 5 less sp atk, and could run Nasty Plot, Shadow Ball (over Dark Pulse), Focus Blast, and Psychic/Sludge Wave. You even get STAB on Sludge Wave.
I concede that 125 speed vs. 110 is significant, and that 70/90/90 bulk is a bit better than 60/60/75, (albeit Life Orb recoil makes the modest bulk increase less significant). I suppose you could make the case Dark Pulse is more spammable than Shadow Ball due to lack of immunities, but those moves are still pretty comparable.
Like I said before, I don't like theorymonning, but considering Gengar isn't considered viable, it seems wild to me that people think Darkrai is so laughably broken it doesn't even deserve to be tested.
Edit: fwiw Gengar even gets Knock Off like you mentioned for Darkrai too
Gengar's paper-thin defenses and much lower speed matter a lot. It's not a bit bulkier as Darkrai has close to 50% more bulk on the physical side than Gengar does and has a typing that is better against the most common priority move in OU in Sucker Punch. Darkrai if dropped into OU would be the third-fastest Pokemon, which allows to beat a lot more than Gengar since many OU threats have more options for OHKOing Gengar than they do with Darkrai and are faster, such as Cinderace (Pyro Ball and also Sucker Punch if you can fit it), Choice Specs Dragapult (Shadow Ball and Draco Meteor whereas it can only OHKO Darkai with Draco Meteor), pre-transformation Battle Bond Greninja (Dark Pulse and Hydro Pump whereas none of its moves OHKO Darkrai), Meowscarada (Knock Off and Sucker Punch while it doesn't OHKO Darkrai with anything), and speed-boosting Walking Wake outside of sun (has a chance to OHKO Gengar with Hydro Steam whereas Darkrai lives). And as you yourself pointed, out, Dark Pulse is more spammable due to it having no immunities.
One of the bigger upsides Darkrai has over Gengar is that it beats Clodsire, the main special wall of OU, while Gengar outright loses to it.
To pretend that Gengar is even remotely comparable to Darkrai in performance is disingenuous or just outright wrong.