R_N said:So there's a number of Pokemon that only get one ability.
Usually it makes sense.
Levitate is dumb and already broken twice, but those are the exceptoins that prove the rule (please just break this rule entirely gamefreak c'mon man)
Legendary (& Mythic) Pokemon most frequently don't get them at all these days (shoutouts to the Tapu & Loyal 3)
Cocoon Pokemon, I guess for the aesthetic
And of course Gimmick pokemon. Makes sense why something like Mimikyu ONLY has Disguise, you know? Slaking & Archeops are always going to have their bad abilities as part of their game design. Forecast, Flower Gift, and so on.
And there's a lot of things to pick at within those for various reasons, the one Pokemon I keep coming back to......is Stunfisk-G
Why does it only have Mimicry? Mimicking its surroundings stuff is obviously part of its design, but it's not really a gimmick that it would have to have. It's not so integral to its design or gameplay that it should be limited to ONLY that ability. Contrast with something like Dancer (EVERYTHING about Oricorio is about the concept) or Comatose (by design and lore, it is always sleeping)
It feels like something they'd put in a Hidden Ability like Grass Pelt Propeller Tail, Stalwart, Cursed Body, etc.
It's not an outright gimmick but it is a signature ability, and so the decision seems to be "this is for this Pokemon, and nothing else"; it might change in a couple of generations but for now it's tied to Stunfisk. And while it's not an outright gimmick that Stunfisk-G is forced to use, it may have been something that was created with the expectation that players would want to use it and that it would basically become its thing.
There are cases where you can sort of see this happening in the past*, like Sableye getting Stall (I'm still unclear why Sableye was given that ability, and why specifically
only Sableye has it - off the top of my head there are a couple of other Pokemon like Bastiodon or Forretress who it'd suit thematically and mechanically) or the Goodra line getting Gooey, though tbh I can't bring to mind a case like this where it's a line's only ability.
On a slight tangent I also find it interesting when they seemingly change their mind and decide that it's fine for something to get a HA after all when it formerly didn't.
Like in DP a load of Pokemon got their ability slots "filled in" as a bunch of species that only had one ability formerly got a second (Super Luck Absol, Solar Power Tropius, No Guard Machamp etc) so that by the time BW came around the majority of lines had three abilities to choose from, then in XY it felt a bit like they were "filling in the gaps" since a few species which still only had one regular ability up to then got a second one (Wigglytuff, Milotic, Gothitelle) and a few species which up to that point had never had a Hidden Ability now got one (Plusle, Minun, Starly, Ferrothorn, Dusknoir)**. Ferrothorn's a funny example to me because yes barbs are an obvious part of its design but it's one of those things where I look at it and go "but does it absolutely HAVE to have Iron Barbs?" Like yeah Tyrunt has massive fangs but it doesn't only have Strong Jaw, so it always struck me as odd that Ferrothorn didn't get a HA in Gen V.
*This is distinct btw from a Pokemon having an ability that's decent but simply not much use
on that particular Pokemon, like Weavile having Pressure for instance - I've always felt that Weavile was purposely given not-great abilities since its HA is only situationally useful - or Weak Armour Cursola; for better or worse those abilities can have some limited effectiveness.
**Sun/Moon did a similar thing with giving four older lines that still only had one regular ability slot weather abilities, but I'm inclined to think that was more a balance decision than a flavour one since weather had been nerfed by Gen VII. Sw/Sh only gave one old Pokemon a new ability (Weezing) and Sc/Vi mostly just changed the abilities of Hisuian forms, which doesn't really count as a full change since they never got to use the ones L:A assigned them. IIRC only Gallade and Shiftry were given new abilities outright, while Empoleon had its HA altered.