Clas said:stealing idea from
here, but with a better premise.
i also cant lead this since i already lead revelationmons, but this was just to throw it out there rather than anything so if this is somehow given the green light someone else can take the reins. this doesnt mean i wouldnt be out of helping out with the council side, however.
1-2 Switch!
This metagame effectively combines Singles and Doubles Pokemon into one metagame by having each Pokemon switch between "active" and "inactive" every few turns. On every odd turn, all Pokemon can attack, while on every even turn either the second or first Pokemon on each side is unable move or be targeted depending on if the turn follows a 2, 6, 10 turn pattern or 4, 8, 12 turn pattern. With such a major mechanical shift, who knows what could happen!
Rules
Mechanic: Doubles-based metagame where each Pokemon switches between active and inactive every few turns.
Clauses: Standard Doubles, Sleep Clause Mod
Bans: Annihilape, Flutter Mane, Koraidon, Miraidon, Tatsugiri, Shadow Tag
Strategy
i honestly have no idea at this point lol
Incresed Viability
:espathra: Protect becomes immensely more useful here, as being able to either stall out a Singles turn or Doubles turn can turn the tides quickly.
:hariyama: Fake Out can quickly and easily stall out a turn, being able to force a mechanic shift reliably while also preventing the target from moving if they lack a Covert Cloak. Feint also gains a lot more viability due to it mitigating Protect.
:wo-chien:Leech Seed and similar effects still harm inactive Pokemon if they were set beforehand, so it is possible to stall out turns like this to slowly whittle down and recover HP targets while being untouchable yourself.
:arcanine: Intimidate is fantastic as it is still able to affect inactive Pokemon. Defiant and Clear Amulet also gets an indirect buff from this, but Clear Amulet is decently niche and all the good Defiant Pokemon are already known.
:Covert-Cloak: Covert Cloak is able to ignore Fake Out and similar effects without giving up much utility, which is amazing on a wide variety of Pokemon. I expect this to be a possible staple.
Decreased Viability
:murkrow: Tailwind is all-around nerfed badly. While some dedicated Tailwind setters like Murkrow and the rare Talonflame are only affected minimally, more often than not the offensive Pokemon are setting Tailwind themselves. This means that either their partner or themself will often be the one unable to do anything the next turn, and the few times the setter is the only one active will likely be spent using Protect or inerting less passive pressure. Tailwind effectively being active for 3 turns doesn't help much, either.
:tyranitar: Spread moves like Rock Slide and Earthquake receive a substantial nerf, as the single-target effect only comes into play when there is only one target on the field and not when there are two effectively non-existent Pokemon. This is especially the case for opponent-only spread moves, as half the time only one Pokemon can be hit while still receiving the 0.75x damage boost.
Other Viability Shifts
:heat-rock::damp-rock::smooth-rock::icy-rock: Weather being harder to abuse means that setters will have to be careful with what they choose. Torkoal is likely to be an exception to this rule, however, as it tends to fair well alone in Doubles environments, both offensively and defensively.
:light-clay::indeedee-f: It's hard to predict if Screens/TR setters will gain a buff or nerf from such a mechanical change. On one hand, its much easier to set them up from the Singles-Doubles turn shifts, while on the other it becomes a lot easier to stall out said turns (and in the case of TR the support Pokemon are unable to support for half the duration).
Watchlist
:chien-pao::chi-yu: Being able to both offensively and defensively support its ally really helps in almost every situation, as removing 25% of your opponents' defense will always be incredibly strong.
:ting-lu::wo-chien: While notably less oppressive than Chien-Pao and Chi-Yu, the major defensive boost these two provide could be considered too much, especially considering how much more viable hazards and passive chip are here than standard Doubles.
:dondozo: Singles Dondozo with more set-up opportunities. This doesn't sound scary at all.
:iron-bundle: While a lot more manageable in Doubles, Iron Bundle is no stranger to tearing apart Singles formats. Having Icy Wind and Encore are nice bonuses too, although rarely will Icy Wind be doing any notable damage.
:espathra: If abilities still work in a state of inactivity, then Espathra can become scary incredibly quickly, and no explanation is needed for why. Espathra does have to be careful in a Double-battle state, though.
:palafin-hero: This menace is free to do stuff, although it cannot fit Drain Punch, Taunt, and Protect in two slots so Bulk Up sets are a little more manageable.
Questions for the community
Should abilities, items, and similar effects still activate for inactive Pokemon? While abilities have no in-game counterpart that is testable, items like Leftovers and other effects like Toxic and Leech Seed still activate on Commander Tatsugiri. However, other items like the Toxic Orb do not follow this rule and need to activate while the holder is active too, and so has some valid contestion.
Should moves that always hit be unable to hit inactive Pokemon? This would be unlike the in-game example of Commander, where those moves specifically can hit, although this removes a decent portion of the niche of the metagame idea in my opinion.
guess whats back
1-2 Switch!
This metagame combines Singles and Doubles into one metagame by having each Pokemon switch between "active" and "inactive" every few turns, much akin to Rotation Battles. On every first and third of four turns all Pokemon can act, on every second of four turns the second Pokemon cannot act or be acted upon, and on every fourth turn the first Pokemon cannot act or be acted upon. With such a major mechanical shift, who knows what could happen!
(edit for clarification since this is for faq: having 1 mon only means that there is no inactivity)
Rules
Mechanic: Doubles-based metagame where each Pokemon switches between active and inactive every few turns.
Clauses: Standard Doubles, Gravity Sleep Clause
Bans: Annihilape, Arceus, Calyrex-Ice, Calyrex-Shadow, Darkrai, Dialga, Eternatus, Giratina, Groudon, Koraidon, Kyogre, Magearna, Mewtwo, Miraidon, Ogerpon-Hearthflame, Palkia, Rayquaza, Tatsugiri, Urshifu, Zacian, Zamazenta-Crowned, Moody, Sand Veil, Shadow Tag, Snow Cloak, King's Rock, Razor Fang
Strategy
Protect, Fake Out, and redirection is by far the most important tools in the metagame due to their control over the singles and doubles turns, especially the latter for redirection, despite their limiting effects on moveslot space. Abilities like Intimidate not affecting inactive Pokemon means that they cannot be weakened on the switch during a Singles turn, making it much more important to micromanage. This also extends to switched in Pokemon that are inactive, as they cannot switch. Spread moves like Earthquake, Rock Slide, and Bleakwind Storm are much more potent, as they do not target inactive Pokemon and as such have the 1x multiplier during Singles turns. Hazards and setup, similarly, are also more potent as Singles turns grant more safety into bulkier Pokemon to play around the much more chaotic Doubles turns. All of this culminates into a metagame like no other, so use your knowledge from both Singles and Doubles to great effect!
Increased Viability
:espathra: Protect becomes immensely more useful here, as being able to either stall out a Singles turn or Doubles turn can turn the tides quickly.
:Iron-Hands: Fake Out can quickly and easily stall out a turn, being able to force a mechanic shift reliably while also preventing the target from moving if they lack a Covert Cloak. Feint also gains a lot more viability due to it mitigating Protect.
:Covert-Cloak: Covert Cloak is able to ignore Fake Out and similar effects without giving up much utility, which is amazing on a wide variety of Pokemon. I expect this to be a possible staple.
:flutter-mane::gholdengo::dragapult: Much like the above case, the ability to avoid Fake Out and Feint is incredibly notable while still retaining the ability to hit hard with mostly neutral STAB coverage.
:tyranitar: Spread moves like Rock Slide and Earthquake receive a substantial nerf, as the single-target effect only comes into play when there is only one target on the field and not when there are two effectively non-existent Pokemon. This is especially the case for opponent-only spread moves, as half the time only one Pokemon can be hit while still receiving the 0.75x damage boost.
:torkoal::pelipper: Weather is much better here, as it is very easy to switch in a weather setter like Torkoal and Pelipper on a Singles turn while reaping the rewards on a Doubles turn. Screen setting is the exact same, except the setters can do it safely without the constant threat of two attackers at once.
Decreased Viability
:tornadus: Tailwind is all-around nerfed badly. While some dedicated Tailwind setters like Tornadus are only affected minimally, more often than not the offensive Pokemon are setting Tailwind themselves. This means that either their partner or themself will often be the one unable to do anything the next turn, and the few times the setter is the only one active will likely be spent using Protect or inerting less passive pressure. Tailwind effectively being active for 3 turns doesn't help much, either.
:Garganacl: Status effects and other damaging effects like Salt Cure and Fire Spin do not activate during inactive turns and so are much worse in practice. That being said, the trapping move timer does not decrease at the end of an inactive turn.
:landorus-therian: Intimidate does not affect inactive Pokemon and therefore has to be played with acknowledgement of this. This is also the case for other on-entry abilities like Hospitality and the Ruin abilities.
:Dugtrio: Imagine Arena Trap in Singles but its reliant on trapping during the first turn, loses 99% of the time to Protect, and is completely useless otherwise. That is Arena Trap here.
Other Viability Shifts
:cresselia: It's hard to predict if Trick Room will gain a buff or nerf from such a mechanical change. On one hand, its much easier to set them up from the Singles-to-Doubles turn shifts, while on the other it becomes a lot easier to stall out said turns. Support setters like Cresselia and Indeedee also do nothing but sit there for at least one turn, if not two.
Watchlist
:flutter-mane::chi-yu: Both are incredibly powerful already, but give them easier Sun setup and even fewer largely consistent answers than regular Singles and you have quite possibly the deadliest core in the metagame.
:chien-pao: Much like Chi-Yu, Chien-Pao is a crazy enabler and abuser in a much more defensively limited metagame that is already famous for many physically offensive cores like PaoPult and PaoNite, and these cores only improve in a metagame limited in effective speed control options.
:amoonguss: Gravity Sleep Clause in a half-Singles metagame is incredibly threatening, and needs testing in of itself. However, the widespread use of Safety Goggles in Doubles already paired with the relevance of Tera Grass makes this less of an issue, hopefully.
:basculegion::houndstone: Well this one doesn't need explaining. Male Basculegion is probably broken but the other two Last Respects users are likely to not be.
:cyclizar::orthworm: I hope this doesn't need an explanation either.
:ursaluna: Previously banned from DOU but stuck in UUBL, Cocaine Bear is a nightmare to deal with in Trick Room and just a slow attacker out of it. Whatever comes of it is hard to tell.
:palafin-hero: While limited in the moveslot department, its still Palafin. Safety Goggles or Choice Band, pick your poison. Probably the least broken watchlist Pokemon here.
Questions for the Community
- Are there any other Pokemon that should be watched or banned, or specific things that are inherently better/worse?
- Are there any combos that are now buffed specifically in 1-2 Switch?
- How would Dondozo + Tatsugiri work, despite their interaction being already banned?
- Should tiering be more in respect to Singles, Doubles, or in line with its own unique definition?