NOC Charge Me Up! Mafia GAME OVER MAFIA (psy, Laurel, af) WINS!

usually in irl mafia you do just throw accusations out early as a bit of a meme
Click to expand...

pt. 3 celever generalizes about other forms of playing mafia at risk of not knowing what he's talking abt but at least he's hedging things


ANYWAY im caught up, loose TRs because i dont have scum reads yet - celever, tommy, psy all feel like invested members of town to me
 
Celever said:
mainly basing my answer off this post cos looking at the ISO joey's content has been about literally only me since this post 7 hours ago, I don't think these reads are good. every read besides NightEmerald is specifically based on how people are interacting with setup/mechanics which isn't something that most people in the game have seriously done, and he's just scumread everyone for interacting seriously with mechanics at all. NightEmerald reason is bad because NightEmerald (IIRC) talked about playing irl mafia and usually in irl mafia you do just throw accusations out early as a bit of a meme. RVS exists for a reason and it also exists in both styles of the game.

basically joey's not actually reading in the way a regular mafia player should, which on reflection does probably demonstrate the newbie status but even so there's a slight lack of depth here.

(sorry joey LOL this is lowk a bit cutting but Tommy asked)
Click to expand...

honestly, i disagree and think thats a great and inspired post for a new player and the reads definitely make sense and have a level of depth most newbies dont have LMAO

if hes mafia id be very impressed, because im impressed if hes town anyways
 
Duskfall98 said:
honestly, i disagree and think thats a great and inspired post for a new player and the reads definitely make sense and have a level of depth most newbies dont have LMAO

if hes mafia id be very impressed, because im impressed if hes town anyways
Click to expand...
I mean fair ig, for me it's more about what's not there than what is there like their reads being so focused on just one thing, painting 3 different approaches to mechanics with the same brush, and then throwing in like one non-mechanical read that's super flimsy and shallow is giving mafia newbie a little bit lol

like he's not reading anyone who hasn't seriously interacted with mechanics yet, which I don't even mind that much if not for the fact that he then landed on me who's one of the only 2 players to outright say "yeah honestly this game is lacking major readable content" that should be a mindmeld if he's town and I think I'm worried that he didn't take it that way.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top