flome said::tyranitar::skarmory::swampert::blissey::gengar::moltres:
I would like to talk about three observations I have made about the sample team I have been using as a new player over the past few weeks. I have about 300 games played with
Eden's Moltres TSS team, with a rating anywhere from 1200 to 1500 on the gen3ou ladder. I've been having lots of fun and I wanted to try my hand at the skill of identifying what weaknesses this team has. Specifically, I want to know if there is something I could better understand about the purpose of the team, or if other players would corroborate these observations. Namely:
:Tyranitar::Skarmory::Gengar: 1. Taunt is not worth three moveslots
Spoiler
I would guess that a good player taking a look at this team would say that three Taunters--Tyranitar, Skarmory, and Gengar--is unusual. It would suggest that this move is strongly supporting the team's broader game plan, so I want to talk about what this team wants to do with Taunt.
Taunt Tyranitar completely walls Skarmory, which is useful off the rip for forcing out Skarmory leads. Maybe I hit the jackpot and catch an incoming Swampert with Toxic, or Metagross with Earthquake. But this trick only really works once: I can't hereafter switch my Tyranitar in to Skarmory expecting to apply the same pressure, because they now have the threat of bringing in that same Swampert or Metagross for free on the Taunt. I can't both enforce the threat of the taunt and also punish switch-ins and free attacks, so it becomes a 50-50. My own Skarmory can run the same surprise again, but I don't think this is much better than just Spiking up alongside the opponent.
Lategame there is a very satisfying scenario where a low-health Blissey switches into my Gengar's attack, hoping to heal up. I can surprise her with Taunt, allowing me to get in an extra turn before she can heal. If Blissey is too low to attempt switching out and back in again, this can allow Gengar (or maybe Swampert or Tyranitar if I have Spikes advantage, no Paralysis, and health to spend switching into Ice Beam) the time to finish off Blissey where otherwise she would have healed up. But this requires so many favourable conditions: Spikes advantge, health advantage, Taunt landing on the passive move; that it feels more like tapping in an already won game than being an integral part of the win. You certainly wouldn't say Taunt allows anybody to *1v1* Blissey--even if all the conditions are all in my favour, I'm still spending Gengar's health at 2:1 to finish her off.
I see the synergy between Taunt and the Spikes game plan, and I accept that this is a high-skill move that a better player would find better opportunities to squeeze value from. I would really like to hear some theorymon on how I can better use Taunt to enable my gameplan. Ultimately these Pokemon have other very strong, more reliable, much simpler moves competing for the slot.
:Suicune::Milotic::Starmie: 2. Status resistant Bulky Waters 1v6 me
Spoiler
Refresh and Rest give my team a lot of trouble on almost any Pokemon, and Taunt can disable those moves. So I tried to explore if this was a major explanation for Taunt on this team. The correct play with Refresh seems to be to instantly heal off any status without waiting even a single turn. I obviously can't just spam Toxic against someone using this strategy, because of its accuracy and PP disadvantage against Refresh. So I would need to be able to Toxic and then--with the same Pokemon--immediately outspeed and Taunt on the subsequent turn. I would then also need to be able to survive Surfs, even assuming the opponent doesn't just switch out of the Toxic buildup. This just isn't viable against something like Refresh Milotic, who outspeeds outdamages and outlives my two Taunt/Toxic users. The scenario where Gengar makes progress against Milotic here is similarly contrived. Rest and even Sleep Talk also end up being sound against Taunt against all but the most negligent players.
The mere presence of certain status-resistant water types feels like an auto-lose. Milotic/Swampert's Refresh, Suicune's Rest, Starmie's Natural Cure. Blissey can switch in and wall them, but they also wall her and outlast her with their high PP moves. Gengar might be able to switch in once, but is ultimately overloaded. Surf means that Moltres is not a viable switch-in, so the remaining hope is to catch them with HP Grass 3HKO trying to switch into Flamethrower. Starmie can threaten to beat me in its capacity as a sweeper, as a bulky Water, or as a utility Spinner, though countering it is easier once I know which one it is. (This has been one of the most fun things to learn over the last few weeks: how so many Pokes threaten everything before they are scouted, and the little Poker game around figuring out which flavour of Tyranitar or Salamence they have.)
:Forretress::Blissey::Moltres: 3. Forretress+Blissey takes Spikes advantage
Spoiler
Nothing on my team really makes progress by switching into Blissey. Maybe Tyranitars in general will threaten Blissey, but my set in particular can't set up on her or 2HKO. Spikes is the only way for this team to keep damage on Blissey. Nothing on my team can outdamage her heal (best I got is a shot at a 3HKO from Swampert or Tyranitar), and she keeps Toxic off with Natural Cure. But under spikes, she has to be paranoid about staying topped up, or else she won't be able to come in on Moltres' flamethrower. She'll eat 25% from the spikes, 20% from the switch-in flamethrower, then 20% on the outspeed. I feel like this was the idea behind choosing Moltres for this team. Once Spikes are up, Moltres overpowers even the Pokemon designed to switch into it. If Blissey's a bit lower, Skarmory (after Roaring her in) and even Gengar (who Blissey wants to switch in on) can also start to threaten her by taunting her Softboil. This is a little more fraught, as discussed at length above.
This gameplan vs Blissey is so dependant upon Spikes that things fall apart if they have a decent spinner. Forretress illustrates this well, as he is better equipped to sit on Skarmory than the Toxic-and-Taunt-susceptible Claydol. When he Rapid Spins on Skarmory, he unravels any progress I can make against Blissey. This should cost him something, as a passive Pokemon inviting my Moltres a free Flamethrower shot. But with Spikes now cleared, Blissey is such a solid Moltres switch-in that no progress can be made. Not even the bulky waters can boast this, as they are risking a HP Grass 3HKO on the switch, and usually cannot OHKO Moltres.
I want to thoroughly understand how this team works before I change it, but here are some small things I'm considering:
- Give Tyranitar Focus Punch over Toxic. This maintains the role of punishing a switch after Taunt.
- Give Skarmory Protect over Taunt. I also strongly consider Thief, but I want to be careful about trading one gimmick for another.
- Give Blissey Thunderbolt over Seismic Toss, to better threaten bulky waters (and Skarmory). This probably has big trade-offs, like viability against CM users.
- Use a more offensive Gengar with Thunderbolt/Ice Punch/Fire Punch/Explosion. This lets it better threaten Forretress while simplifying the threat vs Blissey.
You don't have to read the spoilers, just let me know what you think about the broad observations. I was going to post this as some sort of RMT, but I don't really think this matches that format. This also doesn't really fit in the Metagame Discussion thread since I don't come at this from a point of prior knowledge, and my scope is somewhat confied to this particular team. I know this is probably an odd and somewhat long post for this thread, but I thought this more rule-abiding than posting a thread of its own. Please let me know if this is inappropriate.
Hi flome!
Thank you for your post! I wanted to try and tackle this, as this set of 6 Pokemon is very common and hopefully I can give some tips on how to use it and why the options were chosen. You are also more than welcome to make changes to the team and see how they work. Some of your suggestions are very good ones, as this sample was originally made years ago and may not have aged well for this metagame.
This team, especially by 2023 standards, is a very aggressive TSS team designed to a) hold off Spikes for as long you can as you have no way to mitigate Spikes either via spinning, having your best defensive pieces immune to them, of mag b) get sand and layers up immediately so Waters/Bliss remain low for Moltres and c) keep those layers up and punish opponents for relying on Blissey to absorb Gengar's and Moltres's Will-O-Wisp with Taunt and Roar, respectively. These teams try to win fast against opposing TSS teams with pressure from Taunt, aggressive predictions, and Moltres and maintain maximum potency with Gengar and Moltres against teams without Spikes while still having a strong defensive core in Tyranitar/Blissey/Swampert.
These teams became relatively uncommon for TSS in the following years as players realized it is quite difficult to keep opposing TSS teams from getting layers up with Taunt Skarmory, even with Taunt Tyranitar and Gengar. It requires you to aggressively predict when Spikers come in and Taunt them, which can be challenging against good players repeatedly throughout the game. Even one Spike is enough for opposing TSS to break through blissey and even Swampert. Many TSS teams, especially those with Gengar that often forgo Spinning, choose to use Flygon over Swampert or use the more resilient against residual damage Jirachi alongside Moltres. That way, you can get away with dropping Taunt on Skarmory as you arent as hellbent on preventing Spikes.
Despite what I just said, I still find this team challenging to play against at times. The advantage of Taunt on all of Gengar, Skarmory, and Tyranitar is that it makes this team relatively resilient to defensive counterplay to residual damage. Taunt Skarmory and Gengar also prevent Claydol from healing off Toxic with Refresh or Rest. While Milotic and Swampert can use Refresh and Suicune can Rest, aggressive play makes this hard to do, especially since Moltres 2HKOes Milotic and Suicune and OHKOes Swampert should they come in on 3 layers of Spikes with sand up. The most valuable member of your team is often Gengar -- if you can keep Gengar alive long enough to get an advantageous position before your opponent, you will often beat opposing TSS.
Onto your observations:
1) I think for this team to be consistent, having Taunt on Gengar and Skarmory is very good. Tyranitar can use a whole host of sets: one of the main advantages of this version of the team is because you are wholesale trying to prevent Spikes and then spinblocking with Gengar, you can afford to make Tyranitar physical. You don't need Pursuit Tar as much as you might with other structures, as it Pursuit traps Gengar and other spinners to keep the Spikes advantage. Physical Tar backed by Spikes is one of the best ways of pressuring Blissey and its switch ins -- sometimes to get that crucial advantage, all you need is one Taunt + Toxic combo and aggressive play to hold your advantage.
Having Taunt on Tyranitar though is crucial to maintaining an early Spikes advantage and putting yourself in position to capitalize on it, however. With Taunt of Tyranitar and Skarmory, you can very feasibly get one layer of Spikes up before your opponent can almost regardless of what Spiker they are using. This is extremely helpful. From reading your post, I think a new line to try is if Tyranitar is out vs Skarmory, use Taunt to prevent hazazrds and then switch to your own Skarmory to get layers on the switch in. Almost anything your opp will switch to early game is free reign for Skarmory to get layers. Your goal with this team isnt to wallbreak Swampert and Metagross with Tyranitar; it's to get layers up for Moltres and Gengar to break through Waters, Blissey, and Pursuit Tar.
I almost feel like youre underselling Wow + Taunt Gengar. Having a crucial defensive piece be able to force Blissey's and Milotic's hand is huge for Moltres. While yes, this will often take a lot of Gengar's health to do so, it can immediately put you in an advantageous situation with Moltres, as you should have the Spikes advantage. After you Taunt the opposing Skarmory and get layers, good players are going to try very hard to predict when Skarmory switches out and get their Skarmory in. This is a perfect opportunity for Gengar to get in and apply pressure with WIll-O-Wisp. From here, you can easily wear down Blissey or Celebi or whatever their pivot into Gengar is.
2) As for dealing with Refresh and Rest, it definitely requires some deft play. As all of Milotic, Suicune, and Swampert 2HKO Tyranitar and can make it hard for you to switch in with Toxic and their resiliency, they can be difficult to deal with. The way I see is to once against play highly aggressively. The first time they come in to Tyranitar if you cant hit them with Toxic is probably to switch to Skarmory and get Spikes and then go bliss once you have a layer or two. You can then try to predict a Recover or Refresh and get Gengar in if the opponent doesnt have Pursuit Tar, as this will often threaten out Suicune and Milotic while Swampert doesnt enjoy repeated Seismic Toss from Blissey. Once they switch out, again, being aggressive with Tar to Taunt their (hopefully) recovery on Toxic is critical. You will struggle to beat them if the game goes long -- try to win first with aggressive play. You often only have a few chances to do it before your overloading Pokemon get outlasted by Milotic. Maybe Wish for Blissey over Toxic might be helpful?
3) You have one of the best Blissey switches in the tier with Toxic Blissey, but your goal is to keep your Spikes advantage. Your opponent should be threatened to switch their Blissey into what you have if you get Spikes up. To your point about Forretress: playing against Forretress is a guessing game that made these teams unpopular for a time. You don't have quite enough aggressive pieces with just Moltres to hold off Forretress teams long term: you need to make aggressive reads to both spinblock Forretress and keep your Gengar alive against Pursuit Tar. If you fail to do this, exactly what you said would happen happens and you cant keep up Spikes. Typically you can Taunt Forretress as it switches into your Skarmory and then go to Gengar potentially on the Rapid Spin. Switch up your timing so you don't become so weak to Pursuit tar switching in.
As for your suggestions:
Focus Punch over Toxic is a very good idea, as this gives you a back up should your Moltres original plan fail. You will miss Toxic against Milotic specifically, but the threat of Toxic alongside Taunt is often good enough.
I would not recommend dropping Taunt on Skarmory unless you'd like to use a different special wall over the Blissey.
Thunderbolt is definitely an option over Seismic Toss, but I would not recommend that Gengar set alongside these Pokemon. You really really want at least Will-O-Wisp -- you can decide if Explosion or Taunt is better.
Redless also makes some excellent points. Hope this helps!