NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)

I think Laurel is an interesting character this game and I hope he stays active even after his flavour thing was seemingly successfully shot down in the pages I didn’t read

JALMONT flavour claiming happens in theme games sometimes, but I agree with saber that you may feel more compelled to do that with provided safe claims. It’s certainly something that could happen organically (especially if he’s Kecleon who’s kinda of a highly iconic PMD character) but it could also be a scum perspective slip that he felt emboldened to do so as a result of getting a safe.

It is a little curious because the last game in this vein (Assist Trophy, the last proper theme game on this site) Laurel was mafia in, I provided safe claims, and he didn’t interact with flavour at all. I provided the same warning that the game can’t be solved by mass claim too because I back myself to design games that well lol.

"interesting character" is such an odd thing to say tbh
 
celever doesnt feel bad imo. maybe celever just doesn't understand the ways of the mech. he's not like flanders in that regard (ha double entendre)

celever is like completely different to me as town and he says things i consideri scummy and odd (or so ive learned), so my read is bad on him

im pointing out its odd, but i do also think hes capable of saying such and odd thing as town

however, i also think describing someone as interesting is like such a fence sit fake content post, in most circumstances
 
celever is like completely different to me as town and he says things i consideri scummy and odd (or so ive learned), so my read is bad on him

im pointing out its odd, but i do also think hes capable of saying such and odd thing as town

however, i also think describing someone as interesting is like such a fence sit fake content post, in most circumstances

was mostly mentioning jalmont in that post, im not really feeling a celever push rn anymore
 
Duskfall98 tbh 30% of the reason i spammed was i wanted to see how people would react

we had “fake” role PMs we could have gotten in assist trophy but i never asked for one lol

i just figured kecleon was a hard clear (tired of being lynched d2) and didnt read the OP to see mafia got fake claims anyways (funny they never claimed).

understandalbe, i regardless think its far more likely to come from scum you than town you, as i feel like ive seen you do something like this most times youre mafia to try get a fake clear
 
this is straight up too level-1 of a read for me tbh, bluedoom has played enough mafia to capitalise on stuff like that

anyone my food's here bye

its such a throwaway comment its not something people really feel the need to fake much i think, because they dont think anyone else would actually care to read them on it

might be right though, its more a micro read than anything

i did like his follow up posts to shanes posts though also
 
would love to hear your thoughts on laurel/shane but im gonna dip now

laurel is my top scumread, shane has been townier than people give him credit for imo, but i simultaneously like a lot of the people pushing him so i think hes probably town pushed by town
 
in my catch up people seemed to be interested in my thoughts on m2h, i think they are town, in regards to their read on me, im not really too pushed about it they do tend to scumread me mostgames, so suspicion from them is something id anticipate regardless of alignment (if anything, i think slightly more likely to townread me as mafia)

that being said, its been many years since we have played together which gives a lot of time to change
 
Alright time for an update
1708209942444.png

No changes from first list: Me (Town), Neon (TR), Jalmont (SL), Laurel (SR), Joey (null)

-Saber just feels more comfortable this time. He's not acting like he has much to hide, and as a newer player I don't think he's capable of pulling off a facade to this effect without obvious coaching tells
-Clouds interactions and reads feel genuine and consistent even if I have no past experience to draw from. His actions around me make sense even if he's just as uninformed about me as I am him
-Tommy is like Clouds but I'm a little less convinced based on the same reasons. Strong T/S equity with M2H
-HyHy is HyHy, not much to say. Small post count but it's all substance
-Jumped the gun on Celever, I can't read him at all and I don't think I'll be able to for the rest of D1.
-Alice is mixed, behavior is consistent with last time but I feel like she's making a point of TRing me so that I'll reciprocate. Might be my imagination so not enough for an SL
-M2H's interactions with Tommy are weird. Currently strikes me as someone fishing for towncred at every angle and not actively solving as much as I remember them doing before.
-Bluedoom is only an SL based on Jalmont and Genisu but his playstyle also makes me more naturally suspicious of him than most people so idk
-JALMONT is like a completely different person and their votes are nonsensical for the most part. The one that makes the most sense (Joey) was immediately sheeped by Laurel, which I imagine is for towncred since several people (including myself) are scumreading him. Very weird.
-I didn't think much of fairy's content but others have been pointing out how weird the progression with genisu has been + I get weird juju from them in general so fuck it we ball
-Pulsar jumping on the genisu train I tried to push feels sheepy and her reasoning strikes me as strangely weak. Surprised she hasn't been more active in general. Big 3P energy
-Shane is just weird. However I think some of his decisions have been strange, especially the genisu progression and his generally defensive attitude towards everyone. I mostly rely on other people's impressions of him here since I find him unreadable outside of a few objective oddities
-I'm not recouting The Genisu Chronicles again, just go back and see our spat from last night + Shane's comments.
 
in my catch up people seemed to be interested in my thoughts on m2h, i think they are town, in regards to their read on me, im not really too pushed about it they do tend to scumread me mostgames, so suspicion from them is something id anticipate regardless of alignment (if anything, i think slightly more likely to townread me as mafia)

that being said, its been many years since we have played together which gives a lot of time to change

last game is my only game in like ~3 years if that means anything

im still goated tho
 
last game is my only game in like ~3 years if that means anything

im still goated tho

btw i am not trying to rain on your parade, but i am kind of curious where your mechanical god stuff came from

historically you sure were a good town player, and the most pure posting town player alive, but you werent really a town leader, so for me this is a big change in your playstyle
 
Back
Top