NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)

Clouds said:
it's more like i'm trying to understand the justification for flander's read on genisu to begin with, as opposed to backing up my own read on flanders. which can't even be called a full read, cause it's not... think you're misinterpreting me trying to connect read logic and having suspicion around a slot as some sort of firm read. similar to how you thought i was making more out of your own read with genisu than you were at the time

this is a two way street -- if i have any stronger scumreads at any point, i'll be airing them for sure. something to know about my playstyle though is that i far prefer to find town first, just makes things easier for me cause i've historically had more success in solves where i've built a towncore and an outside poe to vote through vs swinging for the fences with scumreads
Click to expand...
that's fine, that's how most people play nowadays

ur not quite right, regardless of the firmness of ur read on flanders i just didn't like the reasoning, in the sense that it just seemed like you were trying to fill dead air to me so that you could Have Some Reads, just nitpicking
 
Town: M2H,Saber,Neon,Genisu, Flanders

Town Lean: Jalmont

Null: Clouds, a fairy, Laurel, joey, Shane,HH,Alice, Tommy

Scum: Celever, pulsar???

I want to say that the town read I'm most likely wrong about is Jalmont but I also think Jalmont's D1 here is v different from his D1 in the previous game where he was mafia. Could be just an attempt at a meta shift but I feel like I at least understand his train of thought in his posts unlike last time.
 
bluedoom said:
Town: M2H,Saber,Neon,Genisu, Flanders

Town Lean: Jalmont

Null: Clouds, a fairy, Laurel, joey, Shane,HH,Alice, Tommy

Scum: Celever, pulsar???

I want to say that the town read I'm most likely wrong about is Jalmont but I also think Jalmont's D1 here is v different from his D1 in the previous game where he was mafia. Could be just an attempt at a meta shift but I feel like I at least understand his train of thought in his posts unlike last time.
Click to expand...
##Vote pulsar512b

let's wagon, looks like a good play
 
bluedoom said:
I want to say that the town read I'm most likely wrong about is Jalmont but I also think Jalmont's D1 here is v different from his D1 in the previous game where he was mafia. Could be just an attempt at a meta shift but I feel like I at least understand his train of thought in his posts unlike last time.
Click to expand...

JALMONT is too good to deserve a tr for what he's given so far imo. I probably want to solve him with mech or POE later unless he becomes more obv.
 
Shane the Shroomish said:
that's fine, that's how most people play nowadays

ur not quite right, regardless of the firmness of ur read on flanders i just didn't like the reasoning, in the sense that it just seemed like you were trying to fill dead air to me so that you could Have Some Reads, just nitpicking
Click to expand...

we might be at a dead end with this then, cause the thoughts on flanders were just my honest thoughts at the time... the read seemed to be misaligned with the degree to which they cared about the vote succeeding vs just clawing at genisu's slot. not expecting any new player to take the reins or anything, but you know, there's some degree of action matching you'd expect to see when someone voices so strongly that they're sure a slot is mafia

i can see how maybe this would be alarming if they're someone you're so vested in your townread in, but i'm just not reading the same posts up to the point where they became one of your strongest townreads and feeling that same level of towniness from them. they're posting strong no matter their alignment, but can you pinpoint exactly what it is you think i should be seeing that i'm not?
 
bluedoom said:
Town: M2H,Saber,Neon,Genisu, Flanders

Town Lean: Jalmont

Null: Clouds, a fairy, Laurel, joey, Shane,HH,Alice, Tommy

Scum: Celever, pulsar???

I want to say that the town read I'm most likely wrong about is Jalmont but I also think Jalmont's D1 here is v different from his D1 in the previous game where he was mafia. Could be just an attempt at a meta shift but I feel like I at least understand his train of thought in his posts unlike last time.
Click to expand...
I find this suspicious. No reason to hard TR saber and genisu (or hell, even me) at this point, and defending genisu and jalmont when it seems there's a dynamic happening with you three is odd. SRs are somewhat understandable at least (celever could be sheepy). I also find it hard to believe that you think Shane is still null after what you (and we) have been discussing.
 
I also think Celever is scummy for not pushing clouds/me and instead voting laurel for being "the best of the presented wagons." There's misplaced conviction here and feels like scum waiting for thread direction to make whatever pushes they feel like making
 
Shane the Shroomish said:
i personally have a vendetta against "TMI" and think it's bad to invoke 99% of the time, people will see TMI in totally normal conversations and gaslight themselves over it
Click to expand...

the tmi is that you used language involving a kill (i.e., "OHKO"). Laurel caught onto this and showed that he caught on; however, he assumed you were soft claiming vig or etc. why not assume you are maf there. its subtle but it could be a verbal slip.
 
StupidFlandrs48 said:
Not every discussion or opinion has to result in a vote my guy. As this point you're just chaotic, you give only the barest justification or explanation for reads and votes and it's happened like five times now. I'd call it obvious 3P behavior but I respect you enough as a player to think you have a certain town role that makes you act like this instead of automatically being that. Will continue observing
Click to expand...
##unvote
##vote stupidflandrs48

testing 1 2 3 test
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top