NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)

As I read back the Cel/Shane/Me/M2H conversation I begin to share your concerns about AF. All I know about her at this point is that she tends to have high thread presence and generally gets what she said respected by most players, and with that in mind it seems liks scum!fairy would exploit that by subtly trying to guide arguments like this while still remaining "above" them (which is an inherent contradiction but I think she tried to toe that kind of line here). It's also true that she has no reason to do this in a high-profile argument if both belligerents are town. However, I still see no world where Cel and Shane are both town, so I think voting one of them will still give us better information. And independent of alignment, keeping Celever is most beneficial to my position in the game rn so my vote stays where it is for now.
 
bluedoom said:
Also off note: wrt celever I still think his arguments are bad but the fact that he's doubling down on them makes me go ??? Is this just town ego posting his crackpot theories or just mafia?
Click to expand...

there's a lot of town ego here for sure

I am starting to side eye clouds a bit ngl, but I've no really good reason beyond I think he's coasted a bit

your D1 also was very towny but D2 it doesn't feel like you've been trying to solve the game as hard/in the same way like you're back seating a bit more
 
Clouds said:
hi all, i've caught up mostly and have some thoughts, but i kinda want to partially clean slate today as saber death alters my view

need to reevaluate before moving ahead... 1 thing i've gathered from what i have read from today is that duskfall seems like town to me atm. following his thought process much better now & don't think his play at the start of today tracks with a mafia mindset. everything else i still need to sort through, just had several moments catching up where duskfall's posting raised multiple green flags and so i feel like calling that out
Click to expand...

oops
 
Clouds said:
the 1 thing i don't like about M2H's slot is all the focus on self-image. i.e. the "i'd argue i'm towncored now" type posts because it shows a concerning level of focus on intent to be perceived a certain way. i'm willing to look past that for now, since it's not out of question for town to just be super eager to gain the credit as well, and i'm unsure if it's a playstyle thing. that'd be the fuel for the tinfoil now, if any, but not an ideal vote
Click to expand...

m2h has a lot of towny ego, which is towny
 
hmm clouds is posting well now I guess

I have a weird paranoia over him that doesn't really have much reasoning beyond I think some other people are posting very towny like narrative and emotion, whereas clouds mostly just has the narrative, but clouds is very in control of his emotions in general so probably not useful to factor that in
 
genisu said:
i feel like one of the newbies is def getting coached here ;-; (probably not flandrs), but i could be seeing alice being told to ghost thread(also hasnt made any real posts)
Click to expand...

coached is the opposite of ghosting thread, ghosting thread is what people do often as a natural state of playing mafia (oftentimes as both alignments)
 
Clouds said:
alright here's the thing, Laurel gave me a bulletproof vest at night... it doesn't clear him by any means, but i did receive it, it's a 1x bpv that's activated passively. he did however kinda speculate that i was mafia as a result, which doesn't track super well with someone who'd be giving me that with an intent to pocket me. again, not sure it's clearing, but since he's softing so openly, might as well be forward about it. i feel like it's a waste to use this role on me if you have the ability to gift it to one of your mafia partners though, unless he was unable to for some reason
Click to expand...

how do you know it was laurel again?
 
Clouds said:
##vote genisu

highkey been thinking about genisu's return to thread here and it feels a little too informed. for someone newer like him. the martyr thing for example seems very pointed and too conclusive, also his baseless claim about coaching when it could be that he was the one coached all along, because he's had a hyperfixation on that idea. it's not just today. i don't like the claim about coaching having no basis whatsoever because then it doesn't seem like it's translating into any authentic scumread for him. typically a coaching read is linked to thinking someone's posts actually look coached, but he's got no subject matter here
Click to expand...

yeah it's weird bringing that up again it's really specific and not really applicable in the way he's using it either
 
Shane the Shroomish said:
she just seemed immediately crestfallen about a new player dying n1 twice in a row in their first two games and repeated this to me in the hood, feels less performative because we're in a hood that neither of us created (she at least denied it) and how it was brought up

you can call that weak if you want, it is of some value to me
Click to expand...

it's less valuable when you consider there's a strong chance mafia didn't intend to kill saber
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top