NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)

celevers day one was a bit weird and whack and anti establishment lmao

i have scumread him for this before, but I think it's just how he plays as town, he doesnt go with the flow and can throw a spanner into the works of what people think is consensus (and be a bit tunnely/adamant about it too)

I think as mafia he maybe tries blend in a bit more and go with the flow, as he doesn't feel the need to drive his own worldview as hard, I may be wrong on this since irs a reaction to getting him wrong last time but it makes sense in my head
 
I'm struggling to understand how the thread narrative has become "1 scum in shane/celever" because the only person who has actually cased Shane today has been Celever in the previous page.

Which means that no one has outright dissected scum intent in Shane's game yet has decided that he has a coinflip chance of being mafia.

And like yeah I scumread celever. I still think that that D1 was atrocious. But my vote is on af for a good reason.
 
Duskfall98 said:
celevers day one was a bit weird and whack and anti establishment lmao

i have scumread him for this before, but I think it's just how he plays as town, he doesnt go with the flow and can throw a spanner into the works of what people think is consensus (and be a bit tunnely/adamant about it too)

I think as mafia he maybe tries blend in a bit more and go with the flow, as he doesn't feel the need to drive his own worldview as hard, I may be wrong on this since irs a reaction to getting him wrong last time but it makes sense in my head
Click to expand...
the thing is he fought m2h last game as mafia and wanted to prevent m2h from solving via massclaim

and I kinda felt like he was doing something similar D1
 
ftr I actually did townread you yesterday Shane but I think you've been less towny today too, not like actively scummy but you are similar to bluedoom for me where you had a decent D1 , but D2 hasn't had the follow up

(I do think bluedoom was better than you both days though)
 
bluedoom said:
I'm struggling to understand how the thread narrative has become "1 scum in shane/celever" because the only person who has actually cased Shane today has been Celever in the previous page.

Which means that no one has outright dissected scum intent in Shane's game yet has decided that he has a coinflip chance of being mafia.

And like yeah I scumread celever. I still think that that D1 was atrocious. But my vote is on af for a good reason.
Click to expand...

true true
 
bluedoom said:
the thing is he fought m2h last game as mafia and wanted to prevent m2h from solving via massclaim

and I kinda felt like he was doing something similar D1
Click to expand...

maybe I'm just reading the player meta as an alignment meta then but he's definitely more than capable of getting into a fight as town
 
Duskfall98 said:
ftr I actually did townread you yesterday Shane but I think you've been less towny today too, not like actively scummy but you are similar to bluedoom for me where you had a decent D1 , but D2 hasn't had the follow up

(I do think bluedoom was better than you both days though)
Click to expand...
yep, that's normal for me, so it's a positive point for you that you're pointing it out

i fall off after d1 in every game i play because my worldview gets more or less solidified and i need to start seeing flips to either dismantle or strengthen it

there are obviously things that happen d2 on that can change my mind but i am usually taking a backseat while these things develop

i've tried to change this before intentionally but it's just more or less how my brain works when i play this
 
bluedoom said:
I'm struggling to understand how the thread narrative has become "1 scum in shane/celever" because the only person who has actually cased Shane today has been Celever in the previous page.

Which means that no one has outright dissected scum intent in Shane's game yet has decided that he has a coinflip chance of being mafia.

And like yeah I scumread celever. I still think that that D1 was atrocious. But my vote is on af for a good reason.
Click to expand...
yeah i didn't think of that but it's a good point

gives me a little pause
 
bluedoom said:
by that I mean, I felt like he was trying to prevent a town core of sorts from forming and that seemed reminiscent of mafia!him trying to prevent a massclaim
Click to expand...

he did that in the last game I played with him and it made me tunnel the shit out of him and he was town lmao (think it was the last game)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top