NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)

StupidFlandrs48 said:
What do you make of shane reducing his side of the conversation to a series of "nuh uh"s and "no u"s? (I assume that was your read as well since you said he presented himself terribly)? Can that read as town just shutting down and getting frustrated in response to scum?
Click to expand...

i dont know shane well enough to know if it's AI. but yeah esp towards the end he really did not hold up well. i def can read it like frustrated town shutting down at scum at the end there, but that does need to have the built-in assumption that shane does genuinely believe that he wasn't partially at fault for how that argument went
 
a fairy said:
i dont know shane well enough to know if it's AI. but yeah esp towards the end he really did not hold up well. i def can read it like frustrated town shutting down at scum at the end there, but that does need to have the built-in assumption that shane does genuinely believe that he wasn't partially at fault for how that argument went
Click to expand...
He definitely has that assumption tbh. I've seen S/S thrown around once or twice as an explanation, I think it was clouds or bluedoom that mentioned the idea. Does that strike you as possible? What about T/T that Tommy's been harping on? And do you think we have better potential leads than this pairing? Bc it seems like there's not much enthusiasm to 50/50 flip celever or shane
 
StupidFlandrs48 said:
He definitely has that assumption tbh. I've seen S/S thrown around once or twice as an explanation, I think it was clouds or bluedoom that mentioned the idea. Does that strike you as possible? What about T/T that Tommy's been harping on? And do you think we have better potential leads than this pairing? Bc it seems like there's not much enthusiasm to 50/50 flip celever or shane
Click to expand...

i think, in order of likeliness

s!Cel t!Shane > s!Shane t!Cel > TvT > SvS
 
Duskfall98 said:
I would like to engage with you laurel live, since you're around it's a lot easier to work out and solve live rather than random shady pokes from far away

you have done nothing that identifies you as town imo, and some stuff that I read as scummy, if you want to try clear yourself then shading me and exaggerating how towny you should be seen as, is not the way
Click to expand...

i had to leave for work but ill be here later
 
StupidFlandrs48 said:
Well we saw that Clouds apparently didn't understand Laurel's in-thread hints so idk where the pressure came from, like I said it looms clumsy if he's actinng alone. Maybe a scummate pointed out Laurel's hints to Clouds in scumchat, would that be a thing? All of my ideas to scumread clouds have huge logic leaps in them I hate him
Click to expand...

i see clouds as town honestly. Im a known mafia troll so I think once he noticed I was serious and not trolling the dots connected. In the last game I played I spammed !idol in discord and the thread constantly so I think with that background we should give him benefit of the doubt
 
JALMONT i was only loosely here d1 but you keep making comments about hh, was he confirmed town? Did i miss something?

i used on clouds because i thought he might get shot cuz he seemed towny and generally id put like 3 ppl in the “likely to get shot night 1” who are playing - tommy, clouds, and joey

and obviously tommy cant get shot cuz hes scum and i scum read joey yesterday so the only option from my POV was clouds
 
bluedoom, HydrogenHydreigon, m2h
JALMONT, StupidFlandrs48
genisu, ImaginaryNeon
----
a fairy, Celever, Clouds
---
Alice Kazumi, joey, Shane the Shroomish
Laurel

most of my lower reads below the first dotted line are like, not explicitly scummy but just everyone above ive more reason to townread?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top