NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)

a fairy said:
We’ve been voting people out on bad role mechs all game, and havent hit scum yet. I’m sure that doubling down on it as our apparent leaders are seemingly giving up is surely going to give us good results now.

i dunno what you want me to say that is convincing. I’ve been loosely scumread by just about everyone at one point or another. I’m prime ML for the mafia to get tossed without having to risk weird behavior to cinch. If you genuinely examined my gameplay, you’d find a player that has been open and transparent about every step she’s made and has answered every suspicion lobbed at her. And yet, here we are, with the playerlist tepidly going “yeah we could kill her, she’s probably not mafia but maybe she is, and mech it makes things easier” as if that had ever worked before this game.
Click to expand...
So what should we do instead and who should we vote
 
JALMONT did you read Celever and Hyhy's defence to me questioning them? If so, how would you rate it, and how do you feel they are both playing compared to their town meta? I guess I'll throw a fairy here for the meta question.

Duskfall98 same question but I'm including Jalmont in this list for meta.
 
M2H said:
victory for m2h!!!
View attachment 606201
Click to expand...
1000079762.jpg
 
bluedoom said:
tbf, I don't think this is ridiculous if you're town and you claim to be a 0x vig lol...

Shane the Shroomish what is a motion detector though
Click to expand...
watcher is broken but going 3 cycles without using an INFO action is crazy. it's not like motion detector or tracker are bad roles. i understand upgrading once maybe even twice but 3x is just crazy. the game might be over by then!

if i wasn't forced to claim and i could shoot i wouldn't have shot anyone anyways.
Laurel said:
For the record joey is the best vote but nobody is gonna do that even tho ive wanted it for days
Click to expand...
why lol
bluedoom said:
JALMONT did you read Celever and Hyhy's defence to me questioning them? If so, how would you rate it, and how do you feel they are both playing compared to their town meta? I guess I'll throw a fairy here for the meta question.

Duskfall98 same question but I'm including Jalmont in this list for meta.
Click to expand...
you can look at HH's last scum game smogon mafia mafia. p much all one liners and not nearly as much thought as this game. i think the forgetting their mind changed at random moments in the game is sort of a bad look though. celever's response was above average. i still get the sense celever is stuck tryign to find a reason to not scum read (because town cel knows it doesn't make sense) but cant because it exposes his teammates too hard or doesn't advance their win con or whatever
 
JALMONT said:
watcher is broken but going 3 cycles without using an INFO action is crazy. it's not like motion detector or tracker are bad roles. i understand upgrading once maybe even twice but 3x is just crazy. the game might be over by then!

if i wasn't forced to claim and i could shoot i wouldn't have shot anyone anyways.

why lol
you can look at HH's last scum game smogon mafia mafia. p much all one liners and not nearly as much thought as this game. i think the forgetting their mind changed at random moments in the game is sort of a bad look though. celever's response was above average. i still get the sense celever is stuck tryign to find a reason to not scum read (because town cel knows it doesn't make sense) but cant because it exposes his teammates too hard or doesn't advance their win con or whatever
Click to expand...

Joey is actively avoiding the thread and not contributing.

He is infinitely more helpful as town
 
JALMONT said:
watcher is broken but going 3 cycles without using an INFO action is crazy. it's not like motion detector or tracker are bad roles. i understand upgrading once maybe even twice but 3x is just crazy. the game might be over by then!

if i wasn't forced to claim and i could shoot i wouldn't have shot anyone anyways.

why lol
you can look at HH's last scum game smogon mafia mafia. p much all one liners and not nearly as much thought as this game. i think the forgetting their mind changed at random moments in the game is sort of a bad look though. celever's response was above average. i still get the sense celever is stuck tryign to find a reason to not scum read (because town cel knows it doesn't make sense) but cant because it exposes his teammates too hard or doesn't advance their win con or whatever
Click to expand...
I did check HH' smogon mafia mafia game and it felt similar. The thing is HH's posts are all one liners until he gets prodded in this game so idk. Do you think the anger to being called a crazy flashwagon guy is a towntell?
 
bluedoom said:
I did check HH' smogon mafia mafia game and it felt similar. The thing is HH's posts are all one liners until he gets prodded in this game so idk. Do you think the anger to being called a crazy flashwagon guy is a towntell?
Click to expand...
not really sure. i think it's reasonable to think it is but i didn't put much stock into it at the time and i don't know how much i do now. i don't really think HH is a viable candidate to vote today. if he is scum then gg I guess lol.

i know the game is really hard from your perspective but being as objective as possible i don't see how we can go outside of cele/shane/flanders/alice and then MAYBE laurel/af
 
JALMONT said:
not really sure. i think it's reasonable to think it is but i didn't put much stock into it at the time and i don't know how much i do now. i don't really think HH is a viable candidate to vote today. if he is scum then gg I guess lol.

i know the game is really hard from your perspective but being as objective as possible i don't see how we can go outside of cele/shane/flanders/alice and then MAYBE laurel/af
Click to expand...
yeah its hard because I have like 0 meta on most of the playerlist except like, you/tommy/m2h and it feels like the game scum claimed to me lol
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top