Diamond & Pearl
Gengar. Usually Gengar’s cards depict it as kind of a jerk or mysterious or evil. This is just him enjoying a night out on his stump. Delightful.
Mysterious Treasures
Bebe’s Search. This is kind of a weak set artwise, imo, but both this & Fossil Excavator are really nice. I went with this one because this was the era where the box admins were just reusing trainer classes and are easy to forget even exist; so these cards are both a cool olive branch while offering extra characterization. Bebe’s room seems cramped, full of stuff, and just making the most of the space.
Secret Wonders
Sableye. Another weak set for art but this one’s just really good. Chilling in a cave, eating crystals, watching fireworks through the hole in a ceiling was probably a surprise to the Sableye and it’s all drawn very nicely.
Great Encounters
Kingler. I won’t lie Gen 4’s starting sets are kind of dire for me, there’s a lot of stinkers in here. But this Kingler...there’s just something about it. I can’t put my finger on it. The way it’s rendered? The lighting in general? The body language? It captivates me. This is Arita but it feels so different.
Majestic Dawn
Espeon. This is a “paired” card with Umbreon, who is running through the same snowy area but at night, but I really love the “morning sun across snow” aesthetic and Espeon fits the vibe very well.
Legends Awakened
Gligar. Hey a DP-era set that I think has a lot of nice artwork in it, it’s a miracle. I chose Gligar here for two reasons (1) I just really like the pose. It looks like it’s leaping through the air; usually it’s shown in the stock pose, gliding around, or clinging to a rock. It’s very unique and (2) for some reason this set has a lot of Pokemon amid the cherry blossoms and I wanted to acknowledge this theme.
Stormfront
Bagon. Ahhh!!!! This is so cute. I love the style of the drawing, I love the morning mountain vibes, I love the implicatoin that Bagon just crash landed off a higher cliff and is just laying there looking at the flower. Flawless card.
Platinum
Giratina (Origin, Holo). Origin Giratina’s a real cool design and the wormy body and being able to fly means they can always pose it all kind of ways, and I just adore the boon backdrop. This is a good use of the holo effect as well!
Rising Rivals
Heat Rotom. Almost missed these guys, they were a subset tucked away at the bottom. All the Rotom appliance art is really good and full of life (and if you look in the background, there’s always another appliance for it to jump into!) but I chose this one because I love how happy the rotom is for its just-made food.
Supreme Victors
Meowth. I almost chose Lucario C for its unique art style and dynamic posing but then I saw this meowth. Look how cute it is!! Get that apple, buddy.
Arceus
Bronzor. I’ve been pretty harsh on the entire Gen 4 of card art to this point; felt like every set was more bland than not, but the Arceus set is a return to form. SO many good offerings, but I chose this one, it drew me in. It’s a very unique way of rendering Bronzor’s material, reflecting the lighting like this, emphasizing the literal bronze material. And the ruins in the background are a great set piece (in a set full of them! Lots of mysterious ruins, forests and eclipse imagery)
Heart Gold & Soul Silver
Ho-oh Legend. The stellar artwork continues in this set so it’s very unfortunate that it was the set that introuced Legend cards, which just put all of them to shame. Just such an incredible represntation of Ho-oh.
Unleashed
Raikou & Suicune Legend. I tried to not just pick the legend card again but LOOK AT IT! Look how uniquely the beasts are rendered, how ferocious Raikou looks! Even the seemingly-oddlegs of Suicune works in its favor. And they’re so furry without being distracting. And the rendering of the clouds!!
Undaunted
Scizor. Thankfully the Legend cards for this set are just CG models no one cares about. Instead look at this card that’s either a CG model that looks rad as hell with its motion and backdrop or it’s a drawing designed to look like it’s CG to emphasize the metal coating, which also works.
Triumphant
Electabuzz. It was hard to beat out the Darkrai & Cresselia Legend, but, I dunno, seeing Electabuzz drawn like this andmessing with a Power Plant in a very anamilistic way just drew me in way more.. Like you get a little peak into problems this world might have with the wild life. Like an alligator climbing the fence into the restricted areas.
Call of Legends
Umbreon. Feel like you don’t see Umbreon in the day time very much, which helps it & the card stand out. I love the way the clouds are rendered and the aesthetic in general is just very good.
Calming.