-
Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Tracker Jailer Follower - Game Thread - Day 2!
- Thread starter AngryPidgeon
- Start date
- Status
ok so again basically zero explanation for why those posts were terrible. cool!
their terrible because i cant see a conceivable reason for them to be made, and you're making assumptions out of nothing
isn’t this the part where you stop being insufferable? wonder when that’ll happen
that is my reason for scumreading Celever, you can claim it’s “making assumptions” then but that’s why I was against him once he made that string of posts
no im saying your posts are terrible, not his
I’m defending my posts, consider learning to read properly
This pop-in by genisu wasn’t good IMO
Glad we got an unvote on DBD at least but I think he’s not really help advance the gamestate (not even saying “hey it’s not me it’s x person” and dropping a vote)
Based off the posts it looks like he suspects Miyami by process of “I think DBD and Miyami are most suspect, wait actually DBD is innocent,” but I’m not 100% sure because nowhere in this latest batch of posts does he point the finger at anyone/give an explanation of who he thinks is scum, I’d even take an OMGUS. I don’t get why he’s not providing an alternative when he’s still suspect #1 by number of votes and also in the court of public opinion too from what I’m reading
Glad we got an unvote on DBD at least but I think he’s not really help advance the gamestate (not even saying “hey it’s not me it’s x person” and dropping a vote)
Based off the posts it looks like he suspects Miyami by process of “I think DBD and Miyami are most suspect, wait actually DBD is innocent,” but I’m not 100% sure because nowhere in this latest batch of posts does he point the finger at anyone/give an explanation of who he thinks is scum, I’d even take an OMGUS. I don’t get why he’s not providing an alternative when he’s still suspect #1 by number of votes and also in the court of public opinion too from what I’m reading
i feel bad for u its like me last game except its less confusing
agreed
i think this idea of 'most likely scum -> must vote' is not necessarily correct and misses peum's point. peum's point is that other people, such as celever, give more information from their flip
see ^
Overall thoughts:
Town:
Me
Jalmont - I do not think mafia goes to this level of trying to force activity out of dead slots pretty much ever
pulsar - I really like her posts now that she's actually here. Feels like good solving
DBD - There's no chance mafia buses des in that exact gamestate and his responses to cel and genisu just feel like frustrated town imo
Phoopes - just kind of vibes based so far. Don't know how to word it
Joey - Please do not trick me for a third time thanks. I think the AirC push was kinda bad and that is colouring my thoughts on Joey so far but I think we probably leave this slot until after Genisu flips anyways.
Peum - I don't disagree with their line of reasoning even if how they got there felt kinda weird. I don't think Mafia goes to the amount of effort to create three scenarios and then vote like that given how easy it is to take the scenarios post in obvious bad faith and draw heat on themselves, but I've also never played with Peum before so I'm very willing to be wrong here.
???:
Neon - 99% white noise. The DBD vote isn't great but I can't really figure him out when most his posts are just nothing
ShyPebble - basically not here until 2026
PoE for today:
Celever - As I said before, "Celever is wrong with his whole chest and refuses to back down" isn't exactly uncommon and hard to separate from Celever actually posting in bad faith. I think the constant 1v1ing and not acknowledging other options at all is inherently anti-town a bit but it is hard to tell if he's town or scum here not. I do think Peum is kinda right and a cel flip gives more information than a genisu flip at the moment, although I think genisu is more likely to flip scum. This is not a player we take to MeLo in any world as town but I'm not sure he needs to go today.
Genisu - feels like flailing mafia right now. He's spent the past two game days refusing to explain his line of reasoning or answer questions at all and now that we're here it kind of feels like he's getting frustrated and trying to throw things at the wall and see what sticks to maybe live another day.
##vote: genisu
I would say Genisu today, Celever tomorrow if nothing changes. I don't think cel v peum is ever SvS, which means it's either TvT again or cel is actually mafia
Town:
Me
Jalmont - I do not think mafia goes to this level of trying to force activity out of dead slots pretty much ever
pulsar - I really like her posts now that she's actually here. Feels like good solving
DBD - There's no chance mafia buses des in that exact gamestate and his responses to cel and genisu just feel like frustrated town imo
Phoopes - just kind of vibes based so far. Don't know how to word it
Joey - Please do not trick me for a third time thanks. I think the AirC push was kinda bad and that is colouring my thoughts on Joey so far but I think we probably leave this slot until after Genisu flips anyways.
Peum - I don't disagree with their line of reasoning even if how they got there felt kinda weird. I don't think Mafia goes to the amount of effort to create three scenarios and then vote like that given how easy it is to take the scenarios post in obvious bad faith and draw heat on themselves, but I've also never played with Peum before so I'm very willing to be wrong here.
???:
Neon - 99% white noise. The DBD vote isn't great but I can't really figure him out when most his posts are just nothing
ShyPebble - basically not here until 2026
PoE for today:
Celever - As I said before, "Celever is wrong with his whole chest and refuses to back down" isn't exactly uncommon and hard to separate from Celever actually posting in bad faith. I think the constant 1v1ing and not acknowledging other options at all is inherently anti-town a bit but it is hard to tell if he's town or scum here not. I do think Peum is kinda right and a cel flip gives more information than a genisu flip at the moment, although I think genisu is more likely to flip scum. This is not a player we take to MeLo in any world as town but I'm not sure he needs to go today.
Genisu - feels like flailing mafia right now. He's spent the past two game days refusing to explain his line of reasoning or answer questions at all and now that we're here it kind of feels like he's getting frustrated and trying to throw things at the wall and see what sticks to maybe live another day.
##vote: genisu
I would say Genisu today, Celever tomorrow if nothing changes. I don't think cel v peum is ever SvS, which means it's either TvT again or cel is actually mafia
- Status