• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Post your searing hot takes

This gets repeated a lot but the underlying logic doesn't work. Yes, it feels weird and surprising that FE has 8 characters. But when you break it down, there are good answers why the roster was set up that way.

First is Ultimate's "Everyone Is Here!" idea. 6 of the 8 FE fighters were in past games, so they just have to be here, unless you want to go back in time 10 years and change the whole philosophy of the game.

Beyond that, Ultimate added Chrom and Byleth. Chrom was an Echo Fighter – more on those soon. Byleth was DLC for a new and very popular franchise release, which is pretty normal stuff.

Second is developer time. Fire Emblem characters are easy to create and balance, since they are usually simple. Byleth is among the more complicated, but compared to other DLC characters of Ultimate, she's one of the most simple.

2 of the 8 FE characters are outright Echo Fighters. Echoes take way less time and effort to create because they repeat movesets and animations. In terms of the effort needed to make them, 8 FE chars might be worth 4 Mario or Pokemon characters, since we're lacking the complex features of characters like Rosalina or Bowser Jr. (8 different character models!).

If we cut them out, that would leave more room for more interesting fighters.

You couldn't just say "Substitute Lucina for Midna" because making Midna takes way more time and work, effort that has to take away from something else. FE characters take less room, so you can fit more of them. Having more characters is often fun, so if we can squeeze some more in easily, without taking much time away from other franchises, why not? It's a cherry on top. Especially since the FE chars are largely already made anyway, and a new character would be from scratch.

Third is gameplay style. With their simple, easy to pick up, hard to master gameplay, FE characters are important to have design wise. They teach players important skills, and provide challenges for competitive-minded players to win without coasting on gimmicks or hidden surprise tricks. Because of that, they're relatively straightforward to play against, which helps keep the complexity of an 80 character game at manageable levels. Their simplicity and similarity helps the complexity of other characters stand out, instead of everything turning into a janky sludge of wacky shenanigans.

These next points are less 'reasons to have them' and more addressing possible 'reasons to not have them.'

I am tired of seeing anime swordfighters again and again.

Characters predominantly wield swords. What about the axes and lances?
Since Smash 4, FE has been moving away from repeating the same stuff. Robin uses magic, Byleth uses a wide variety of weapons including axe and lance, and Corrin, while the most sword of the three, has lance and dragon attacks too. Roy is due to Everyone is Here!, but even he was changed to play less like a swordfighter, and more like an up-close brawler, with his blazing speed and crushing close-range damage. Lucina and to some extent Chrom are more traditional Swordfighters, but they are Echos and not independent characters.

Since Smash 4, most of your incoming anime swordfighters aren't from Fire Emblem at all. Shulk and Pyra / Mythra are from Xenoblade, Cloud and Sephiroth are from Final Fantasy, Hero is from Dragon Quest, and Sora is from Kingdom Hearts.

The Plant’s still more iconic than Fire Emblem’s whole roster. More people recognize the Plant than they do Marth. The Plant actually has a 40+ year legacy. Ask any of your non-gamer friends if they know who Marth is, then ask them if they know what a Piranha Plant is. Hell, they don't even have the popularity to back it up. It’s not niche anymore, sure, but can Fire Emblem compete with Mario or Pokemon?
This doesn't work because you can say this for 90% of the roster. Yeah, not every character can be a Mario or a Pokemon. What the fuck is a Magolor? I thought those were called Malboro. (Obligatory note that FE 3 Houses sold more than Magolor's game and the remake of his game combined.)

I'm kinda done with "iconic" as a character criteria anyway, these days. Basically every important guy in, let's have some fun zany guys.

In fact, many additions are just there for marketing tools.
Again, that's a bunch of other characters, not FE specifically. Sephiroth is here to market. Joker is here to market. Smash is a pretty commercial franchise.

Let’s be honest, if none of your husbandos or waifus were in Melee, your whole franchise would be dead to the West by now. Your whole franchise is carried by dating mechanics.
You're overly familiar with specific games versus the franchise at large. At the time of Melee, FE was extremely gameplay heavy and lacked dating entirely. The newest FE game, Engage, was praised for its strong gameplay, and actually panned for its character writing.

A big thing I brought up was Everyone is Here! How many FE chars should we have once that goes away? Who should we remove?

- Marth should stay, we never get rid of primary first franchise representatives. Lucina is basically free real estate as an echo, and her simplicity has the gameplay benefits I talked about too.

- Byleth should stay (or someone else from 3H to take their place). They have diverse attacks while also being relatively straightforward, and represent a very important and recent game in the series.

- Corrin should go. Their game is less important than others, their inclusion was very tied to their game's specific release a while ago, and they're neat mechanically but not breaking wild ground here.

OK, that leaves us with 4 who are less clear to judge. But this brings us to the big picture: we could remove these characters, but do we want to?

- Robin is one of 3 Awakening characters, which is a lot, even if the other 2 are Echos, but is the magic user the one you want to get rid of?

- Roy's game is less important these days, but he's just a blast to use with his free flowing mashing, lots of people have great fun with him, and he's bundled with a cherry on top in Chrom as an Echo. Is this package really a problem we need to get rid of?

- Ike may be a sword user, but he plays much more like an axe user, with satisfying, sweeping, meaty attacks, and he's great fun to just swing around with in friendlies. Sure, we could cut him, but he doesn't take a lot of work, do we gain a lot of flexibility by tossing him?

In the end, there's just not an individual rep who is a real eyesore to get rid of, besides maybe Corrin, and we don't gain a lot of dev energy by removing them. You could argue that removing some combination of Robin, Roy, Chrom, and Ike is worth it, but they have benefits, and it's just not a huge win of some massive issue, even if it's the right call.
 
Last edited:
"Good actor in bad movie innocent" - no they aren't, good actors can try their hardest and still be in bad movies, they signed on to a bad script

"I have never seen the film, but by all accounts it was terrible. However, I have seen the house that it built, and it is terrific!"
— Michael Caine, on his role in Jaws: The Revenge

Argylle
has very famous people in it, but that didn't stop it from being awful
 
Wendigoon's videos aged badly and were probably never that good

He's rarely accurate about things, lacks a lot of knowledge on most topics and gives barely any input himself. His favorite movie is No Country for Old Men and he somehow, in his video, got wrong who the main character was and misrepresented several key points. And that's one of his better videos because he at least has a conclusion there that comes from himself

His conspiracy iceberg video series is very nice because he just gives quick summaries on everything and has some breathers there where he can make some goofs. But most of his videos are kinda lame
 
Dark souls 1 is not a great game, and frankly, I think partly its given that title as "one of the best games ever" is due to rose tinted glasses.

Now I'm not going to do some youtube clickbait engagement video shit where I say ds1 is a trash game and people are stinky losers for liking it. No, ds1 is a GOOD game. But if I were to rank it on a scale out of 10, it would be a 6, maybe 7 (I hate the internet for making it so you can't do those numbers together anymore).

Before I go into my gripes, I will say, there are definetely good parts. The DLC in particular was amazing, and if it wasn't part of the game I would have rated it even lower. All the boss fights were magnificent and engaging, really coming together to feel like the esence of what a souls game is. The first part of the game was also pretty good, with a lot of engaging areas and bosses, not always amazing and sometimes too bullshit, but overall enjoyable.

Now, for the gripes. Partly I think my issue with ds1 is that it feels like its difficult because its bullshit, not difficult because its trying to give you a challenge. If that doesn't make any sense, then let me express it with a boss. Capra demon puts you in a very small arena. Fine on its own yeah? But immediately there are two dogs that attack you out of nowhere. This makes it so incredibly difficult to even start the fight, since you have to deal with two hyperactive enemies that constantly bombard you with attacks AND also deal with the regular boss. I'm not really learning much from every death, particularly combined with the long runback (you will typically go from the undead burg campfire). There are other bosses like bed of chaos and moonlight butterfly that are similar in being bullshit, but I think you get the jist.

So lemme explain it with an area, blighttown. Everybody knows blighttown sucks but it supremely sucks because there feels very little you can do to overcome said obstacles. You are on very narrow paths with enemies annoying to hit (primarily the mosquitos) at the start. Now, to hit smaller enemies, you would usually lock onto them (which I just do regardless of enemy cause its easier). Yeah get ready to not see anything because all you are seeing is the floor that is on the level above you. This is incredibly annoying to just have to deal with, especially if you die a few times (its dark souls, you will die). And then to get to the final area boss you have to go through a poisonious swamp that constantly chips you AND slows down your movement, alongside dealing with any enemies you might face. You don't really have any way to improve it and to stop the poisoning you either wait it out (thus burning 1-2 of your estus flasks which you will need for the fight) or burn a purple moss (which you have limited of unless you go out of blighttown which is annoying to do so). Part of the charm of dark souls to me is when you can overcome the obstacles by learning what to do and applying that slowly, eventually making it a lot easier. You can't really do that in blighttown, the poison area would be fine if you could find specific paths to not get poisoned but to get to the boss area, that isn't possible at all.

There also also other issues. For instance, certain bosses like seath the scaleless (who I did first try hitless) were really easy and thus a letdown. Gaping dragon is a secondary example (though a lot less bad in that regard) as once you figure out the mechanics it turns from "I'm out of my league here" to "this feels like a boss I would find in the second area of the game". Grinding in this game honestly doesn't feel good, you not only have to grind souls for well, anything, but you also at times have to grind materials to upgrade your weapons to stages where they feel actually effective. Its time consuming and really shows the old age of these games.

Overall, did I enjoy my time with ds1? Yes. But I think that it ultimately is put on a pedastal that it should not be on. I'm going to attempt to play through ds2 and ds3 (have to go from my switch to my pc since they aren't available on the switch for some reason) and might give my thoughts about them too later on.
 
I don't even know if that's a hot take because I've seen varying opinions on it, but tbh I liked the ending of TADC

Spoiler
I agree that Jax was very overpresent across the show and that Gangle, Zooble and Ragatha got too little attention (albeit I think a lot of the criticism about that is overblown), but I just think that the final episode did such a beautiful job with psychoanalyzing his character and revealing so much about the relationships across the Circus. I loved that his abstraction happened off-screen, it seemed so much more natural in a way, we are not around for the worst moments of the people around us after all, we usually just see the aftermath and have to help them from there. I loved how the cast got extremely close to each other. Yeah Caine's redemption was too fast and sudden but the reveal that there is no exit, that the characters really are just characters with a sentience in a world that they can never escape is so perfectly bittersweet. Showing the people that these characters come from was gorgeous and again, bittersweet. Them doing the best they can and realizing that it will be fine aslong as they have each other, I felt very touched by that.

Honestly, I left the ending completely satisfied. It was extremely cinematic and very emotional. If the writer only has one character that they want to go really deep on, that's fine by me in all honest. Kinger was still a beautifully done character and Zooble, Ragatha, Gangle, Caine and Pomni were underrepresented for sure, but not to such a high degree that it ruins the show for me.

And a lot of the criticism I have seen feels like its coming from people that kinda had issues across the entire show, which is fine of course, but if you don't like a show... Why would you complain about the ending in the first place? I've also seen criticisms about the ending not doing a lot or that the reveals were disappointing but I really can't agree with that. I just think that people had imagined something else and were disappointed that it didn't go there

I think people will come back to the ending and be a lot more positive when they're more willing to engage with what is there and are less frustrated about what wasn't

Personally, I am very excited about what GooseworX will do next (and I hope fans will be more decent to her)
 
Local Dog said:
I don't even know if that's a hot take because I've seen varying opinions on it, but tbh I liked the ending of TADC

Spoiler
I agree that Jax was very overpresent across the show and that Gangle, Zooble and Ragatha got too little attention (albeit I think a lot of the criticism about that is overblown), but I just think that the final episode did such a beautiful job with psychoanalyzing his character and revealing so much about the relationships across the Circus. I loved that his abstraction happened off-screen, it seemed so much more natural in a way, we are not around for the worst moments of the people around us after all, we usually just see the aftermath and have to help them from there. I loved how the cast got extremely close to each other. Yeah Caine's redemption was too fast and sudden but the reveal that there is no exit, that the characters really are just characters with a sentience in a world that they can never escape is so perfectly bittersweet. Showing the people that these characters come from was gorgeous and again, bittersweet. Them doing the best they can and realizing that it will be fine aslong as they have each other, I felt very touched by that.

Honestly, I left the ending completely satisfied. It was extremely cinematic and very emotional. If the writer only has one character that they want to go really deep on, that's fine by me in all honest. Kinger was still a beautifully done character and Zooble, Ragatha, Gangle, Caine and Pomni were underrepresented for sure, but not to such a high degree that it ruins the show for me.

And a lot of the criticism I have seen feels like its coming from people that kinda had issues across the entire show, which is fine of course, but if you don't like a show... Why would you complain about the ending in the first place? I've also seen criticisms about the ending not doing a lot or that the reveals were disappointing but I really can't agree with that. I just think that people had imagined something else and were disappointed that it didn't go there

I think people will come back to the ending and be a lot more positive when they're more willing to engage with what is there and are less frustrated about what wasn't

Personally, I am very excited about what GooseworX will do next (and I hope fans will be more decent to her)
VUQlYOOldEvvIksWTAmO0w.png

A few nights ago I had a dream that Jax was dressed up as Jagi from Fist of the North Star and was named "Jaxi". That would've been so fucking badass and I would watch the show 16 times if this was real.
 
BIG ASHLEY said:
i haven't seen it but from what i understand this is not the correct word to use here.
tbh I wasn't entirely sure about what to use

Spoiler
The person Jax is based on still went by male pronouns by the end of the show. Jax did too. I am also not sure if the gender dysphoria of Jax is meant to lead into trans-fem or non-binary. I think male pronouns are still appropriate by the end of the show as Jax still used these. It's kinda like with Ralsei in Deltarune, who is likely on a path to realize a new gender identity but still goes with male pronouns for now (except for the "they" at the end of the chapter in the description)
 
Spoiler
Local Dog said:
tbh I wasn't entirely sure about what to use

Spoiler
The person Jax is based on still went by male pronouns by the end of the show. Jax did too. I am also not sure if the gender dysphoria of Jax is meant to lead into trans-fem or non-binary. I think male pronouns are still appropriate by the end of the show as Jax still used these. It's kinda like with Ralsei in Deltarune, who is likely on a path to realize a new gender identity but still goes with male pronouns for now (except for the "they" at the end of the chapter in the description)
Gooseworx used she ever since the show ended (I think, I deactivated my Twitter account so I only get to see her Bluesky posts) but I've been told that she's said both he and she are fine to use. I use he only if I'm trying not to spoil anything and I think that's probably the correct choice. As for Jax's real life counterpart still going by he:

rRWanHLpqWU1H6SkoOt50g.png
 
I really dislike how the Yoshi's New Island OST's hate is overblown simply because of that infamous The Yoshi Clan song

it's like thanks Internet we get it, but like the game had some legit good tunes beyond that





Also, with the disregard of the insanity that is 100%, Yoshi's Island DS is a perfectly worthy sequel to the original Yoshi's Island, the different babies were a great addition to the level design.
 
Mathy said:
the potential man meme sucks its a needlessly roundabout and not even creative way of saying "this thing seems like it could be good but isnt"

I think there can be plenty of creativity involved in making a Potential Man meme but some aspects can be pretty overplayed without putting much thought into what you're copying.

MEET POTENTIAL POST.png




DrumstickGaming said:
I really dislike how the Yoshi's New Island OST's hate is overblown simply because of that infamous The Yoshi Clan song

it's like thanks Internet we get it, but like the game had some legit good tunes beyond that





Also, with the disregard of the insanity that is 100%, Yoshi's Island DS is a perfectly worthy sequel to the original Yoshi's Island, the different babies were a great addition to the level design.
Incidentally the Yoshi's New Island OST has been terminated since the posting of this post so perhaps Nintendo isn't proud of it either. We'll see if it comes to Nintendo Music.
 
I don't know if its a hot take anymore but I really can't care much about One Piece anymore. I read it every single week for years and years. I didn't read it in months now and I kinda dread reading the newest chapters

I just don't care about random ass princesses and princes being more important than the characters we've known for decades. I don't care about waiting years for a single one of the main characters to get any piece of characterization or important thing to do. I don't care about arcs that are maybe 10% exploration/world building and 90% battles (where 40-50% is the last battle between Luffy and the main bad guy)

Elbaf genuinely lost me completely. All I wanted to see is the island of giant warriors and Usopp, the two things that were actually promised almost 25 years ago. We are in a deadlock between a random prince and the arc's main villain for months now. Usopp got a single cool sentence (that was entirely cut down to a few panels) and we've seen the actual island for maybe ~15 chapters before they started fighting. Dressrosa was kinda mid and Wano had MASSIVE issues, but they at least allowed for some characterization and Wano did a lot for the worldbuilding and had some of the best chapters in the entire series (and also some of the worst, it was a coinflip with that arc). Elbaf is just depressing honestly

If the straw hats get some characterization and we get some genuine exploration in the following arcs, I'll be back on reading it in a heartbeat. As of right now, with Luffy being gear 5 happy guy, Zoro being a fighting machine without a heart (or a brain) and the rest of the straw hats being essentially decoration, I just cant earnestly engage with the story
 
Ironmage said:
Regardless of how similar or different the gameplay ends up being for the OoT remake, I don't really want to experience Jabu-Jabu's belly with high graphical fidelity.
you could have ended it at "I don't really want to experience Jabu-Jabu's belly"
 
Hey guys
I think Touhou Histensoku (12.3) is probably the best Touhou game, maybe ever.
Yeah. 12.3. The fighting game.
I'm gonna get into it now.

So, why Touhou?
Touhou, on a brief inspection, is quite possibly the strangest franchise you could adapt into a fighting game; it's a BULLET HELL. These are two very different genres, especially with how. You know. Touhou is about throwing stacks of bullets in waves that give you a heart attack, and most people who play fighting games will testify; projectiles are fucking evil.
Great. So how does Soku adapt two foriegn genres into each other?

Soku's button choice is extremely strange; in many fighting games, you get a choice between a Light Attack (A), Medium Attack (B), or a Heavy Attack (C). Now of course buttons vary differently among different games (like JJBA's Heritage for the Future, which takes the prexisting ABC we've mentioned while adding it's own unique S Button, P4 Arena Ultimax subbing the standard ABC for ABCD (Light, Heavy, Persona Light, and Persona Heavy respectively), and others), most of them stick to these, at very least with Heavy and Light attacks.
Soku doesn't have a concept of a "Light" attack, or a "Heavy" one either. A is just "Attack". It can come out as quick as Cirno's 2a or as slow as Komachi's f.5a (5 and 57 frames respectively.) So. Does it only have attacks?
Of course not.
B is "Light Bullet". C is "Heavy Bullet".
If you play fighting games like. consistently and it's the genre you play the most i'm 93% sure your jaw has completely dislocated and dropped to the floor. A dedicated bullet button happens in most fighting games, um, NEVER. Soku has fucking 2. It has more bullet options than you do options to whack your opponent in the face, which makes sense for the game it's based on but not really for the HUGE elephant in the room; how do you stop the game from being camp simulator?
Soku does this in a few very interesting ways. First, removing the timer. You cannot win simply by stalling your opponent out; you must drain all 10000 hp that your opponent has. While you think removing the timer is a bad thing, it really isn't, not in the context of Soku anyway. Games don't take long at all.
In a game where every character can like get to their opponent thanks to the universal flying options, running in this game is punished more subtly.
Such as with next example, Spirit orbs!
Spirit orbs are this games main resource system. Using bullets, blocking wrong (we'll get into it), and flying through the air (done by holding the D button, which is your dash. Dashing is free but only on the ground) all expend your spirit gauge. Once you run out, you need to regen these resources by doing any actions that are not the above. As you see, you can dump your spirit gauges into bullets but there is a limit. You can't just bullet spam, otherwise you run out of moves and just eat a nasty punish when you try blocking wrong, as blocking wrong with no spirit orbs results in a guard crush, which takes the max amount of orbs down for each time you've been crushed (they also regen but you do NOT wanna be down on these) as well as open you to a combo. Blocking wrong, other than eating your orbs, doesn't punish you like most other fighting games, which makes Soku's defense quite a bit stronger than other fighting games when combined with mechanics like Border Escape and Tech Rolls, but I don't particularly have an issue with it since any game which can allow characters to reset to neutral and not have to deal with ridicously oppressive okizeme every time someone drops down makes for a more interactive and fun game (looking at you JJBA Heritage for the Future)
Great, Datrix. But how do you even get in? Bullets seem near unbeatable, and you'd really only have the option to block. How do you get in?
Simple answer.
You graze.
Grazing in a Touhou bullet hell is the game's reward system for you not being a pussy. When your hitbox comes close to a bullet, you recieve score bonuses for not staying somwhere safe (which was adapted in Deltarune with a TP reward. Toby Fox couldn't be original to save his life.)
In Soku, Dashing or Flying puts you in a graze state. In this window, BULLETS CANNOT HARM YOU. They simply pass on through you and earn you meter for your specials while your opponent earns NOTHING except some spirit orb chip and a commit.
This results in a rock-paper-scissors of the game.
Melees beat Dashes.
Dashes beat Bullets.
Bullets beat Melee.
Finally, and though it
that's cool too. but how are supers done?
Supers in this game are based on the spell card system. You build meter by doing damage, taking damage, and grazing. System mechanics (like what most have games have has burst and others), as well as Special Move enchancers (as well as alternative variants) take up card space as well, and while they (usually. coin being the only exception) only cost themselves to use, it's wise to balance supers and mechanics given you are allowed to deckbuild 20 of these cards with a limit of 4 to any.
What's also fun is that you have to really think about how you spend meter. Once you burn a card, it's GONE until you get a knockout to your opponent, or more likely vice versa. Supers take 2 or more, so when you use them you must also factor if you need an alternate skill or otherwise it's spent on a flashy super (which you chose from the decklist).
We're also forgetting the roster variety; no one plays the same and with the exception of a few really bad apples (GOD cirno is miserable to play because she has a total of one good move compared to everyone else on the roster having decent moves, suwako is bad but mainly because she's so fucking weird) most everyone else is good
 
BestDatrix said:
Hey guys
I think Touhou Histensoku (12.3) is probably the best Touhou game, maybe ever.
Yeah. 12.3. The fighting game.
I'm gonna get into it now.

So, why Touhou?
Touhou, on a brief inspection, is quite possibly the strangest franchise you could adapt into a fighting game; it's a BULLET HELL. These are two very different genres, especially with how. You know. Touhou is about throwing stacks of bullets in waves that give you a heart attack, and most people who play fighting games will testify; projectiles are fucking evil.
Great. So how does Soku adapt two foriegn genres into each other?

Soku's button choice is extremely strange; in many fighting games, you get a choice between a Light Attack (A), Medium Attack (B), or a Heavy Attack (C). Now of course buttons vary differently among different games (like JJBA's Heritage for the Future, which takes the prexisting ABC we've mentioned while adding it's own unique S Button, P4 Arena Ultimax subbing the standard ABC for ABCD (Light, Heavy, Persona Light, and Persona Heavy respectively), and others), most of them stick to these, at very least with Heavy and Light attacks.
Soku doesn't have a concept of a "Light" attack, or a "Heavy" one either. A is just "Attack". It can come out as quick as Cirno's 2a or as slow as Komachi's f.5a (5 and 57 frames respectively.) So. Does it only have attacks?
Of course not.
B is "Light Bullet". C is "Heavy Bullet".
If you play fighting games like. consistently and it's the genre you play the most i'm 93% sure your jaw has completely dislocated and dropped to the floor. A dedicated bullet button happens in most fighting games, um, NEVER. Soku has fucking 2. It has more bullet options than you do options to whack your opponent in the face, which makes sense for the game it's based on but not really for the HUGE elephant in the room; how do you stop the game from being camp simulator?
Soku does this in a few very interesting ways. First, removing the timer. You cannot win simply by stalling your opponent out; you must drain all 10000 hp that your opponent has. While you think removing the timer is a bad thing, it really isn't, not in the context of Soku anyway. Games don't take long at all.
In a game where every character can like get to their opponent thanks to the universal flying options, running in this game is punished more subtly.
Such as with next example, Spirit orbs!
Spirit orbs are this games main resource system. Using bullets, blocking wrong (we'll get into it), and flying through the air (done by holding the D button, which is your dash. Dashing is free but only on the ground) all expend your spirit gauge. Once you run out, you need to regen these resources by doing any actions that are not the above. As you see, you can dump your spirit gauges into bullets but there is a limit. You can't just bullet spam, otherwise you run out of moves and just eat a nasty punish when you try blocking wrong, as blocking wrong with no spirit orbs results in a guard crush, which takes the max amount of orbs down for each time you've been crushed (they also regen but you do NOT wanna be down on these) as well as open you to a combo. Blocking wrong, other than eating your orbs, doesn't punish you like most other fighting games, which makes Soku's defense quite a bit stronger than other fighting games when combined with mechanics like Border Escape and Tech Rolls, but I don't particularly have an issue with it since any game which can allow characters to reset to neutral and not have to deal with ridicously oppressive okizeme every time someone drops down makes for a more interactive and fun game (looking at you JJBA Heritage for the Future)
Great, Datrix. But how do you even get in? Bullets seem near unbeatable, and you'd really only have the option to block. How do you get in?
Simple answer.
You graze.
Grazing in a Touhou bullet hell is the game's reward system for you not being a pussy. When your hitbox comes close to a bullet, you recieve score bonuses for not staying somwhere safe (which was adapted in Deltarune with a TP reward. Toby Fox couldn't be original to save his life.)
In Soku, Dashing or Flying puts you in a graze state. In this window, BULLETS CANNOT HARM YOU. They simply pass on through you and earn you meter for your specials while your opponent earns NOTHING except some spirit orb chip and a commit.
This results in a rock-paper-scissors of the game.
Melees beat Dashes.
Dashes beat Bullets.
Bullets beat Melee.
Finally, and though it
that's cool too. but how are supers done?
Supers in this game are based on the spell card system. You build meter by doing damage, taking damage, and grazing. System mechanics (like what most have games have has burst and others), as well as Special Move enchancers (as well as alternative variants) take up card space as well, and while they (usually. coin being the only exception) only cost themselves to use, it's wise to balance supers and mechanics given you are allowed to deckbuild 20 of these cards with a limit of 4 to any.
What's also fun is that you have to really think about how you spend meter. Once you burn a card, it's GONE until you get a knockout to your opponent, or more likely vice versa. Supers take 2 or more, so when you use them you must also factor if you need an alternate skill or otherwise it's spent on a flashy super (which you chose from the decklist).
We're also forgetting the roster variety; no one plays the same and with the exception of a few really bad apples (GOD cirno is miserable to play because she has a total of one good move compared to everyone else on the roster having decent moves, suwako is bad but mainly because she's so fucking weird) most everyone else is good
Have you tried AoCF?
 
Mathy said:
Have you tried AoCF?
i have yet to
AoCF has a number of flaws i have heard about that have driven me not to try it
for one, it's cast is a lot less iconic. there's like 5 people from soku here and it's like. marisa. ok. most touhou-knowing people know marisa. reimu. cool. most people know her too. and then like. yukari and reisen (who are like a little nicher). oh yeah tenshi too. No Cirno, No Sakuya, and No Patchy (who i THINK are the iconic ones, definately to much higher degree with Sakuya and Cirno) and everyone else is someone i've never fucking heard about. i guess you can make the same arguement against soku but every character there is in bad apple which was really cool to figure out where you can point out most of them by silloutte (although i still can't tell which one's komachi)
gameplay is also weird. i think there's a tag-in system, defense is a lot fucking stronger because there's no wrongblocking and you can't like do anything because though everyone gets grabs they're really baitable? (
i use this video as a base. you may notice me saying similar arguements. in fact in retrospect. all of them. yikes scoob. maybe i agree! it's a good video and maybe a bit biased)
main thing that's really deterring me is just
one. very bad issue.
It has zero rollback. if i happen to like the game, Cool! Now i can't play anyone in the entire world because i live in Australia and even on Soku i get complains that the match is laggy. I think i'll be able to play a slideshow at best if i try my hand at AoCF.
I could try the story mode, but then again I don't give a fuck about like 75% of the roster and i cannot gauge how many people do. Not to mention AoCF is 35 (AUD but still) dollars and Soku is. say it with me guys. Free. Free with a capital F, R, and both Es. (not hard to find these btw. not on steam but like if you're careful. you can find it fine) if you don't like Soku, drop it. if you don't like AoCF. Fuck. you wasted 35 dollars and now you're gonna. play soku again. which was free. And has a very funny story that i enjoy. (you do have to downgrade to Scarlet Weather Rhapshody for some reason to play a fair amount more story mode. which i am going to knock. but SWR is free too and i'm pretty sure you can find it easy as well??? do not quote me.)
still. looks cool. if it gets rollback and more people play it i'm completely down to try. but for now i don't think it compares to 12.3
 
BestDatrix said:
for one, it's cast is a lot less iconic. there's like 5 people from soku here and it's like. marisa. ok. most touhou-knowing people know marisa. reimu. cool. most people know her too. and then like. yukari and reisen (who are like a little nicher). oh yeah tenshi too. No Cirno, No Sakuya, and No Patchy (who i THINK are the iconic ones, definately to much higher degree with Sakuya and Cirno) and everyone else is someone i've never fucking heard about.
cant really argue against that, it's all down to personal preference. AoCF does have Koishi who is the most popular touhou according to the last couple popularity polls, as well as my personal favorite Mamizou, but yeah as far as cultural osmosis goes, a lot fewer people are going to recognize, say, the stage 5 boss from TD. but idk, framing it as "having more of the iconic ones [read: the ones from EoSD]" feels like judging pokemon games based on how many gen 1 mons they have. which you can absolutely do if you want, but dont try to frame it as anything beyond personal preference. i guess if the logic youre going for is "more tourists will try the game -> the game has a larger playerbase -> the game becomes more competitive" then sure, whatever
BestDatrix said:
every character there is in bad apple
cirno actually isn't! which is funny because you called her the "bad apple" of the cast lolol (this isnt meant as a "gotcha! fake fan detected" and i know cirno is famous for other reasons. just thought it was funny
BestDatrix said:
defense is a lot fucking stronger because there's no wrongblocking
this is true, also pushblock is insanely op like u straight up cannot do pressure at all. i do not think AoCF is a good fighting game, but it certainly has some fun stuff. the tag system is so-so, you can cancel the characters' specials into each other and there's a health recovery system, but otherwise there's not a whole lot of incentive to even engage with it. plus it's an extra character to learn
BestDatrix said:
It has zero rollback. if i happen to like the game, Cool! Now i can't play anyone in the entire world because i live in Australia and even on Soku i get complains that the match is laggy. I think i'll be able to play a slideshow at best if i try my hand at AoCF.
this is also completely true, but we're not far off from AoCF rollback, i think the modding team said in july that it would likely be playable by the end of the year? so there's that to look forward to
BestDatrix said:
I could try the story mode, but then again I don't give a fuck about like 75% of the roster and i cannot gauge how many people do. Not to mention AoCF is 35 (AUD but still) dollars and Soku is. say it with me guys. Free. Free with a capital F, R, and both Es. (not hard to find these btw. not on steam but like if you're careful. you can find it fine) if you don't like Soku, drop it. if you don't like AoCF. Fuck. you wasted 35 dollars and now you're gonna. play soku again. which was free. And has a very funny story that i enjoy. (you do have to downgrade to Scarlet Weather Rhapshody for some reason to play a fair amount more story mode. which i am going to knock. but SWR is free too and i'm pretty sure you can find it easy as well??? do not quote me.)
ok but like... a game no longer being sold by the publisher isnt the same thing as "free", like if tasofro fsr decided to release the original soku on steam would it cease to be considered "free"? i did not pay for AoCF, if you are curious.

as far as the story goes, aocf is probably worse than soku, way fewer spell cards and it certainly isnt as humorous as swr/soku, save for Koishi's iconic "I like not thinking!" so i dont blame you for passing on it

anyways idk why im going to bat for a game i havent played in years and suck at vs a game i havent played at all and not like i can force u to play it. really just a "dont knock it" suggestion
 
Mathy said:
cirno actually isn't!
i rewatched bad apple to confirm this. very thankful i did.
you're right. i had like. mandela'd myself into thinking she'd be there. crazy. anyways. i'm going to ramble about why she does suck (because otherwise this would be a boring reaction post and also because i made the mistake of maining her for three days before i switched to youmu so yes this is a vent post)
she's terrible in Soku because the game designers clearly put her in there as a joke; she is designed like a pixie character but the only real way you can play her in Soku is weird rushdown because you can't just get a life-lead and camp; the game has no round timer (i did forget to mention the weather. which DOES do important stuff. like, for instance, typhoon. which gets rid of both hitstun and the ability to block for a good 15 seconds. yes this is as insane as you think it is). Her jabs are fast but incredibly stubby; she has really bad combo potential because her best combo starter, 5.a (or jab) has an activation radius which needs you to be practically sniffing your opponent balls which takes a substanial amount of effort to do in Soku because everyone's throwing out bullets and the like.
Yes this is Cirno's 5.a max distance
4SlOXULqMmiXvIqMFXz5zA.png
any further and you get f.5a which yes isn't bad to hit (you do get a combo) but it's a much more limited one (3a reset to neutral, most times)
this is like her least awful problem. we're also forgetting she does like zero damage with any of her pokes or honestly literally any of her moves: most of her moves place her in the hundreds range while her competition places themselves far closer to the thousands. she has one good move, 5C.
-hNtrt8SQYx262sRU1yRNA.png

spectucular move; 15 frames, fits into all your combo routes, usable as a surprise get off me tool out of corner, cleans your dishes, mows your lawn, wipes your face clean, brushes your teeth, and tucks you into bed. does very decent damage (since each projectile hits three times for 300, which usually wipes a tenth of your opponents health if they get hit by it). and yet even as much as i'm glazing this move, it's a projectile which means you can graze through it (and the cirno player can't just use a melee because you can't cancel into them, just keep dashing because they'll likely cancel into a second one (yes they can do that. yes she needs it)) and then just have your way since she has zero reversals or really any in kit way to get the fuck out of bad situations because, again, nearly all of her buttons suck, you want to replace all of her special moves with cards. wanna guess how good she is at gaining meter (spoiler. VERY BAD). shame too because she has like. one of top 3 ultimates (don't like calling it an ultimate but it's the best way i can describe it as it burns all 5 cards in your hand) in the game. great crusher is a ridicious move and it's an actual wincon Cirno can play for (comes out stupidfast (you have like the superflash to react) and it's air unblockable and also has a giant hitbox. so like you can kind of make your opponent fear jumping when you're on the ground). most tierlists put her as bottom 1 (though some put her higher. the promotion is usually only to bottom 6 though and even then she's competing against the same faces)
we're also forgetting how BAD she feels to pilot. she has the second fastest walk speed but god it doesn't feel like it, she has a weird hover after her jump which doesn't matter because you should really just be dashing in the air, it feels like you just can't do literally anything with her and your one good option is one you have to fucking think about using (because if you're not smart about it you can eat a punish and die). Yuyuko can shit out a screens worth of projectiles and is essentially untouchable if she sets up (she will) but cirno has to play the worst game ever to get a fraction of literally anything. and yes, i am comparing the top and bottom characters to each other but it's so night and day in words i cannot describe. i would reccomend playing soku to try cirno for like a single game to realise in real time how much the devs fucking HATED her.
rant over.
 
The Amazing Digital Circus Spoilers
Am I too woke for thinking that the "___ if it was written by Gooseworx" meme was fucked up and kinda transphobic? Like, you're taking a scene about a trans girls suicide and then making fun of it by making a version of it with the death of any plain old villain from any piece of media. Like, I can't be the only one who has problems with that, right?
 
Back
Top