• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Unpopular opinions

Magcargo said:
I am pretty grateful that Return was removed from Mega Salamence at least. While its double edge packs a punch, it still has a big drawback with the recoil which can add up with chip from other sources like Helmet or Rocks. This at least makes it easier to chip down into KO range where some priority begins to start threatening it. It winds up feeling more like a juiced up Charizard X as a result when running DD - to me anyways. You can run Facade as well which is cool to mimic those refresh sets back in Gen 6.

General solution for fixing weaker normal offense is giving all the normal types a wider array of Normal moves + buffing them appropriately. Moves like Mega Kick, Mega Punch could probably have their BP / accuracy increased respectively + given to more normal types. Moves like Facade are still amazing, and other moves like Retaliate probably could just be increased in BP in general just to give more scenarios where we click that move. I do actually like that Mega Lopunny is forced to use a normal move with consequences now as opposed to Return - given how much of a terror it would be with SD sets otherwise - but I do think Mega Kick should being something like 120 BP / 80 Acc or 120 / 85 Acc to match Power Whip or Gunk Shot. Rock Climb is cool but it could probably use a better BP / accuracy distrubution so that only tauros doesn't run it. Give mons like Unfezaunt & Stoutland Double Edge, Ambipom Tail Slap (IDK why they removed it in the first place), increase Hyper Drill distribution, etc. Most of those would go a much longer way I think in helping these normal types.

I don't really like how some of the new OP normal moves they made in gen 9 are like Blood Moon and Population Bomb. They did make good normal types in gen 9, but giving them OP tools like Ursaluna's crazy trading ability (with a truly obscene stat spread), bloodmoon having an unresisted STAB combo with its ability + Ground STAB & a broken move, or Maushold's 300 BP move that just farms any team w/o helmet wasn't the way.

In addition, creating Powerful signature moves ultimately doesn’t do anything for 99% of a types roster. Mega Lopunny still has zero good Normal type STAB, Snorlax still fell off badly without Return, and unless you’re a Guts Facade user you’re at best stuck with Double-Edge, which is equal to other variants of the move yes, is still held back because it’s a Normal type attack which hits nothing super effectively.
I wholeheartedly approve of buffing some of the worse off Normal type moves like Mega Kick, it’s basic sure but not every Fire type runs only Overheat, plenty still run Fire Blast and even Flamethrower as well.
Heck I’d even vouch for giving Normal type moves, on average, a greater BP vs their elemental counterparts. Nothing crazy mind you, I mean where other types would have something like base 80/100 STAB options Normal would instead have 90/100 STAB options.
Though Double Edge being 130 BP would make Mega Salamance even more scary so…:wo: maybe some new unique attacks for Normal types, maybe lean more into the wild animal thing vs generic attack.

Samtendo09 said:
In all fairness, Charizard is indeed a cool mon and a good design for resembling a dragon but not in an on-the-nose way. It was already popular back in RBY for those reasons.

Being media darlings is not bad by itself, but it can get to the point where one get so much new stuff at the expense of a Glup Shitto that could benefit a litle push, or worse, their own fellow Kanto starters in the case of Gen 8. That generation can be considered at being a media darling in the worst way possible, since overexposure can get people sick of it due to how artificial some of the new stuffs come across.

If they haven’t went overboard with Charizard back in Gen 6 + 7, Leon having Charizard as his ace wouldn’t be so controversial by adding overexposure on top of already blatant overexposure.
Shout out to like 99% of official merchandise that actually comes out west being some combo of Charizard, Pikachu, Gengar, Mewtwo and nobody else:
Like it doesn’t matter how good of a design something is, if it was the only design out of thousands getting all of the attention anyone would get sick of it.
I remember how utterly sick to death people were of Charizard by Gen 8, especially with Dexit happening at the same time which just made it even worse.

“Oh of course Charizard comes back, of course he gets special attention again” I’ve heard variations on that a lot back then, and I can’t really blame anyone for it either.
 
Last edited:
Samtendo09 said:
If they haven’t went overboard with Charizard back in Gen 6 + 7,

already blatant overexposure.
Did they?

Across the generations, you can only normally get Charmander one time in one game, the XY second starter gift. If you say "I want another fella instead," it's just never on your team. If you don't play XY specifically, odds are you see Charizard zero times across the generations unless you go out of your way to see it with trades or USUM island scan. That's not overexposure to me.

From the average perspective playing the games, the starters are only different because their Charizard stone in XY has a letter next to it. Unless they double up on the redundant games, that other Charizard will only be something they hear about from a friend or see on the internet.

People call attention to Charizard getting two megas a lot, but I just don't think it's that important of a distinction. The biggest deal to me is getting a mega or not, and Venusaur and Blastoise got one. Their megas are pretty low-effort - I really don't think we needed more. Also, none got a Z-Move, and all three got (one) G-Max.

Also, unlike with Mewtwo and Raichu, the "surplus" Charizard mega is great. Not only is Charizard X a cool design with cool mechanical properties and balance, but the two megas reflect Charizard's different paths of "being dragon-like, but not actually a de jure manner" in a way more interesting and thoughtful than I ever would have guessed.

Is there anything else besides that one form, which only naturally appears in one version of one game, and only if you choose to get Charizard? Like everyone here, I'm a pretty big Pokemon nerd, and I checked Bulbapedia, and I couldn't find anything else substantive.

Edit:

Castersvarog said:
“Oh of course Charizard comes back, of course he gets special attention again” I’ve heard variations on that a lot back then, and I can’t really blame anyone for it either.

Charizard didn't come back as in ORAS, or SM, or USUM (unless you went out of your way to find it via trade or USUM scan). The gap from Mega Charizards to Leon's Charizard was 6 years, enough for much of the primary demographic to rotate in and out as ages change.

Charizard gets merch, sure, but I actually don't see it much, in stores or in the wild. More Pikachu and Eevee (and the -lutions), and the third name beyond that would be Gengar honestly. Truly, I see more Charmander (and Bulbasaur and Squirtle) merch than Charizard. I think the idea that Charizard gets unfair attention fits a lot of fan narratives and expectations, and ends up being "common sense," but is really overblown.

I also think that, for the ridiculous quantity of monsters Pokemon has, it does a decent job of spreading the merch wealth. I see a lot of "relatively random guy" merch out there and in stores. If you have one exact specific guy, and its Tranquil or Alcremie (yours truly) or something, you might have a harder time. And of course, Pikachu etc. crushes each individual random guy by 1-to-1 volume. (And I even saw a Tranquil figurine in stores once!) But I see fairly broad spreads often, mixing in the expected commons with some guys that don't come to mind as especially frequent.
 
Last edited:
Adeleine said:
Is there anything else besides that one form, which only naturally appears in one version of one game, and only if you choose to get Charizard? Like everyone here, I'm a pretty big Pokemon nerd, and I checked Bulbapedia, and I couldn't find anything else substantive.

Whenever you Fly in SM/USUM you have to watch an animation of Charizard doing it, and it's not even in the dex.

EDIT:
They also did distribute a plain old Charizard for SM right before USUM dropped I guess.
 
Adeleine said:
Did they?
Yes, and trying to pretend otherwise is borderline revisionist history.

First of all, getting two Megas was absolutely a big deal. Megas were the centerpiece of X and Y's marketing, and the only other Pokémon to receive similar treatment at the time was Mewtwo. That was a ridiculous privilege them and even kind of now, making it clear who the golden children were to Game Freak.

Second of all, you are ignoring other aspects of the franchise putting Charizard specifically in the limelight. Pokémon Origins had Charmander as Red's very prominent starter and caps off with Zard X vs. Mewtwo. The regular anime had both Zard Megas showing up, with Zard X being the ace of Alain; a character with his own side story meant to show off Megas and Ash's final opponent at the Kalos League. I'm willing to bet the TCG did some Charizard shilling of its own but I'm not familiar or with it, let alone during that era.

Charizard shilling died down a bit during Gen 7, I'll admit, but like Derpy said it's still the Ride Pokémon for flying. And Gen 8 came in to pick up the slack. Guess what Pokémon was the ace of Leon, Champion of Galar? Gee I wonder.
 
for the tcg, there wasn't anything too crazy. you had XY Flashfire as a set with both Zards as the headlining mons, but outside of that the only major focus it got was as part of Evolutions, which was a full on gen 1 nostalgia set where Mega Zard Y was one of the big chase cards, and Generations had a Mega Charizard X which didn't really get much spotlight.
 
Karxrida said:
Charizard shilling died down a bit during Gen 7, I'll admit, but like Derpy said it's still the Ride Pokémon for flying.
As opposed to? You have to remember that Alola had that odd gimmick of putting saddle/riding gear on Pokemon (and you know also showing the player on them) that kind of precluded most of them. Toucannon's too small, Oricorio's definitely too small, the fact Drampa learns Fly at all is weird and it's a version exclusive new mon, and no other non-legendary Alola Pokemon learn Fly.
As for non-Alola mons that were in the SM Alola dex?
  • Pelipper's too small and weirdly shaped to put a saddle on.
  • Drifblim's too small, even doing the basket thing they did in PokePark. It looked awkward with Pikachu, imagine it with a human.
  • Crobat's too small, it's literally just a soccer ball sized orb with wings.
  • Fearow's too small, and would have massive clipping issues due to being one of the few bird mons whose wings actually extend all the way back.
  • Mandibuzz's a very awkward shape to make gear for due to it already having its armor and neck ruff. Also it was a version exclusive and they probably didn't want the player being given a Pokemon they couldn't actually use that they couldn't catch for themselves
  • Braviary, see the second Mandibuzz point.
  • Delibird's too small
  • Talonflame's too small
  • Archeops and Aerodactyl are fossil Pokemon
  • Skarmory's too small, and Gamefreak really didn't seem to like animating it in the 3DS era
  • Flygon's horn's would clip into the player
  • Honchkrow's hat would clip into the player

Other Pokemon not in the Alola dex?
  • Pidgeot and Dragonite would have caused the same whining about "Kanto pandering"
  • Farfetch'd, Togekiss, Swellow, Altaria, Staraptor, Chatot, Unfezant, Swoobat, Sigilyph, Swanna, and Hawlucha are too small
  • Dodrio's too ridiculous, they have never officially aknowledged how it can fly
  • Noctowl's got the same problems as Fearow
  • Xatu's not only too small but also has clipping issues with its head feathers
  • Tropius, Hydreigon, and Volcarona have clipping issues due to how their wings move/where they attach.
  • Golurk's 3DS era model isn't capable of going into flight mode
  • Noivern would have clipping issues with it's massive neck ruff
Basically the only non-Charizard option was Salamence.
 
DrPumpkinz said:
Probably actually quite common opinion but uncommon in circles like these: Charizard getting highlighted so frequently is totally fine because Charizard fucks hard.
Generally I find Charizard is unpopular in online hardcore pokemon fan communities and nowhere else. Charizard is by far the most popular starter and always has been. The reason it gets so much special treatment is because it's so popular. Yes, the fire-breathing dragon on the box of one of the first games in the series, was the final stage of many people's first partner which would often become the centerpiece of their team, and also had a major role in the anime is actually popular. Who would have thought it?

Quite frankly I find it hard to separate Charizard hate from gen-wars, often from Gen V glazers who are on the watch for anything that can be seen as too much love towards Kanto.
 
The weird thing with Eevee as a mascot is the focus on EEVEE. I don't think anyone actually likes Eevee that much, it's mostly interesting for the evolution gimmick. But every time they push Eevee, it's as Eevee and not as "mon that can evolve in numerous ways to fit your needs and desires". And that's just not what I want from the mon.

(seriously, between Eevee and Pikachu, it's like they hate the concept of evolving your pokemon)
 
AztecCroc said:
As opposed to? You have to remember that Alola had that odd gimmick of putting saddle/riding gear on Pokemon (and you know also showing the player on them) that kind of precluded most of them. Toucannon's too small, Oricorio's definitely too small, the fact Drampa learns Fly at all is weird and it's a version exclusive new mon, and no other non-legendary Alola Pokemon learn Fly.
As for non-Alola mons that were in the SM Alola dex?
  • Pelipper's too small and weirdly shaped to put a saddle on.
  • Drifblim's too small, even doing the basket thing they did in PokePark. It looked awkward with Pikachu, imagine it with a human.
  • Crobat's too small, it's literally just a soccer ball sized orb with wings.
  • Fearow's too small, and would have massive clipping issues due to being one of the few bird mons whose wings actually extend all the way back.
  • Mandibuzz's a very awkward shape to make gear for due to it already having its armor and neck ruff. Also it was a version exclusive and they probably didn't want the player being given a Pokemon they couldn't actually use that they couldn't catch for themselves
  • Braviary, see the second Mandibuzz point.
  • Delibird's too small
  • Talonflame's too small
  • Archeops and Aerodactyl are fossil Pokemon
  • Skarmory's too small, and Gamefreak really didn't seem to like animating it in the 3DS era
  • Flygon's horn's would clip into the player
  • Honchkrow's hat would clip into the player

Other Pokemon not in the Alola dex?
  • Pidgeot and Dragonite would have caused the same whining about "Kanto pandering"
  • Farfetch'd, Togekiss, Swellow, Altaria, Staraptor, Chatot, Unfezant, Swoobat, Sigilyph, Swanna, and Hawlucha are too small
  • Dodrio's too ridiculous, they have never officially aknowledged how it can fly
  • Noctowl's got the same problems as Fearow
  • Xatu's not only too small but also has clipping issues with its head feathers
  • Tropius, Hydreigon, and Volcarona have clipping issues due to how their wings move/where they attach.
  • Golurk's 3DS era model isn't capable of going into flight mode
  • Noivern would have clipping issues with it's massive neck ruff
Basically the only non-Charizard option was Salamence.
So you're saying the field move "Fly" is a conceptual farce :tymp: (I often didn't have a flier on my teams because I just never cared for birds)

Also, just to point out a few things:

- Charizard is pretty small, too, all things considered. I guess we're never given canon heights for the protagonists, but at best, Charizard isn't more than a few inches/some small number of centimeters taller than the player. It's probably the most reasonably shaped/sized for boarding and riding, but I still think using it for the ride Pokemon in Alola for Fly, just because of animation reasons, is a little silly.

- I can see where you might think Crobat's height is mostly its wings. But no, that's a nearly six-foot blob of a bat. Bigger than Charizard!

1000004244.png


(It looks like its ears contribute a little to its height here, but still)
 
CPU said:
- Charizard is pretty small, too, all things considered. I guess we're never given canon heights for the protagonists, but at best, Charizard isn't more than a few inches/some small number of centimeters taller than the player. It's probably the most reasonably shaped/sized for boarding and riding, but I still think using it for the ride Pokemon in Alola for Fly, just because of animation reasons, is a little silly.

The Gen 4 protagonists actually do have heights because of the Pokedex height comparison feature. And they do seem to take the scaling somewhat seriously here because Furret is canonically not tall.

1791011591935.png
1791011748840.png
 
doipy hooves said:
The Gen 4 protagonists actually do have heights because of the Pokedex height comparison feature. And they do seem to take the scaling somewhat seriously here because Furret is canonically not tall.

View attachment 867285View attachment 867286
This basically proves beyond reasonable doubt that most of Furret's recorded height is its tail for the record lol.

The serpentine Pokemon were already kinda indirect proof of this but this basically settles it.
 
AztecCroc said:
As opposed to? You have to remember that Alola had that odd gimmick of putting saddle/riding gear on Pokemon (and you know also showing the player on them) that kind of precluded most of them. Toucannon's too small, Oricorio's definitely too small, the fact Drampa learns Fly at all is weird and it's a version exclusive new mon, and no other non-legendary Alola Pokemon learn Fly.
As for non-Alola mons that were in the SM Alola dex?
  • Pelipper's too small and weirdly shaped to put a saddle on.
  • Drifblim's too small, even doing the basket thing they did in PokePark. It looked awkward with Pikachu, imagine it with a human.
  • Crobat's too small, it's literally just a soccer ball sized orb with wings.
  • Fearow's too small, and would have massive clipping issues due to being one of the few bird mons whose wings actually extend all the way back.
  • Mandibuzz's a very awkward shape to make gear for due to it already having its armor and neck ruff. Also it was a version exclusive and they probably didn't want the player being given a Pokemon they couldn't actually use that they couldn't catch for themselves
  • Braviary, see the second Mandibuzz point.
  • Delibird's too small
  • Talonflame's too small
  • Archeops and Aerodactyl are fossil Pokemon
  • Skarmory's too small, and Gamefreak really didn't seem to like animating it in the 3DS era
  • Flygon's horn's would clip into the player
  • Honchkrow's hat would clip into the player

Other Pokemon not in the Alola dex?
  • Pidgeot and Dragonite would have caused the same whining about "Kanto pandering"
  • Farfetch'd, Togekiss, Swellow, Altaria, Staraptor, Chatot, Unfezant, Swoobat, Sigilyph, Swanna, and Hawlucha are too small
  • Dodrio's too ridiculous, they have never officially aknowledged how it can fly
  • Noctowl's got the same problems as Fearow
  • Xatu's not only too small but also has clipping issues with its head feathers
  • Tropius, Hydreigon, and Volcarona have clipping issues due to how their wings move/where they attach.
  • Golurk's 3DS era model isn't capable of going into flight mode
  • Noivern would have clipping issues with it's massive neck ruff
Basically the only non-Charizard option was Salamence.


If GameFreak wanted a non-Charizard option for the fly mon, they would have just designed one or rigged the animation for an existing model to avoid any clipping issues. I don't mind that they used Charizard, but they definitely used it so that Charizard would get screentime. They did not go through a giant list of options only to conclude "darn, I guess we really have no choice but to use Charizard again"

(Also tangentially, the horizons anime did address how Doduo "flies":
, which is not dissimilar to how Dodrio looks using Fly in Pokemon stadium:
)
 
Hugin said:
The weird thing with Eevee as a mascot is the focus on EEVEE. I don't think anyone actually likes Eevee that much, it's mostly interesting for the evolution gimmick. But every time they push Eevee, it's as Eevee and not as "mon that can evolve in numerous ways to fit your needs and desires". And that's just not what I want from the mon.

(seriously, between Eevee and Pikachu, it's like they hate the concept of evolving your pokemon)
I have held since it was first revealed that Gigantamax Eevee should've been an Eeveelution chimera
 
RocketSurgery said:
If GameFreak wanted a non-Charizard option for the fly mon, they would have just designed one or rigged the animation for an existing model to avoid any clipping issues. I don't mind that they used Charizard, but they definitely used it so that Charizard would get screentime. They did not go through a giant list of options only to conclude "darn, I guess we really have no choice but to use Charizard again"

I agree they could have made whatever work – they did not have to use Charizard – including just designing a new Gen. 7 mon for it. I didn't think of that at all.

This is a boring thing to say but I think the truth is somewhere in the middle here.

I imagine GF's process being like. Charizard is one of the best normal candidates if we avoid going out of our way to put in extra work or extra weirdness, and it's also popular, so win-win, no need to complicate it, don't fix what ain't broke. More effort and weirdness don't have to be bad, of course, but I imagine GF's ethos - but generally and with the ride Pokemon specifically - would prefer Charizard over Dodrio independent of base mon popularity.

In a vacuum, I'd expect Pidgeot to be the other best normal candidate, independent of mon popularity. However, maybe it's blue-collar, a bit drab-colored, Normal-type vibes are too overlapping with fellow ride Pokemon Tauros.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top