Knock Off was an option I considered during Concept Assessment, as it is one of the utility tools that is comparable to Toxic in Ubers in its broad applicability. However, I think it pushes us in the wrong direction re: playstyle. The goal of a Knock Off user is to remove HDB from its checks, and wear them down over long games via repeated switching via hazards. This doesn't really match how Eternatus uses Toxic, which allows it to force its checks out via Toxic timer in a 1v1. I'd prefer utility options that encourage Eternatus to stay in and trade. Additionally, now that we have secured Ground-type coverage, Knock Off becomes a bit less necessary to get past Pokemon like Slowking-G and Mollux, so I don't think there is a strong argument from viability.
Apple Acid is an interesting tool. On one hand, it improves the spammability of our STAB and eases prediction, which is a major problem we have not addressed yet. Additionally, Apple Acid's ramping damage definitely feels right for emulating Toxic's effect on defensive Eternatus sets, though it puts offensive sets in an awkward spot. The main downside is that, for offensive sets, the immediate output is nerfed due to 80bp; maybe it is fine though, as offensive Eternatus often relies on 2HKOs (Meteor Beam is owned though). I think this is probably worth including and we can see how we feel about it during Stats and Movesets stage.
Anyways, relating to Potatochan's post, there is a 120bp Signature move that we could free here...
Finally, . I'll disagree with Gekokeso a bit in that I don't think we should be restricted to just Poison / Grass-type. In Concept Assessment, we decided that CAP38 would have a limited toolbox of utility, but we didn't really place any hard guidelines on what utility options would be available. The reality is that Toxic is significantly less consistent in CAP than it is in Ubers, so I think it's worth looking at other options.
Leech Seed
Generic Grass utility option that is supported by our Poison typing threatening opposing Grass-types. I think its cool, fits the vibe, and is nice for 1v1ing or occasionally team support (?). Maybe the power level is a bit low? I'm not sure.
Will-o-Wisp
Wisp is an option that works very well with our build (fast, access to Recover, Ground coverage for Fires). Out of the three listed here, it's the only permanent progress option. Tagging Corviknight or Slowking-G with a Burn is definitely nice.
Salt Cure
I think this fits the vibe well in terms of forcing opponents out with passive damage, and has a strong matchup into various Steels, notably Corviknight and Equilibra, which are problematic matchups if we don't have Fire coverage.
Anyways, discussion is ongoing in Discord regarding this now. I'll take some points made by
Pipotchi and
Gekokeso that I agree with:
From pip
my issue with knock off is, and this is from someone who admittedly has not played ubers so only knows etern from OMs:
it doesnt play how toxic plays. mainly because it doesnt actually deal with mons directly. toxic is a defensive tool that does hurt mons across the length of the game but its also important for winning the 1v1 against stuff that decides to stay in and continue to punch you, recover or boost on you. i cant even compare knock to anything apart from maybe the act of setting up hazards which is the other half to knock off in the gameplan of slowly wearing down checks and counters. and considering one of our hardest counters is a steel flying type that is the most hazard immune mon without an immunity ability to them.. idk. its still a fantastic move but it feels not tailored to this mon or our goal
From Gekokeso
The way I see it etern uses toxic to pressure walls who would usuablly use calm to scare it off
like Lunala and Arceus
Knock really doesn't do that
I agree with these a lot, and think Apple Acid might be the answer. I don't think there are great options here, and SpDef dropping might be a good path to pseudo-replicate Toxic on Etern.
Also, there are discussions regarding Corrosive Gas, though this feels to me like just Knock Off downgrade.