• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

(Little) Things that annoy you in Pokémon

Charlie0108 said:
Less a thing about Pokemon and more a thing about Pokemon fandom but it does annoy me the instance that people have that certain Pokemon NEED to get an evolution or a pre-evolution. Some Pokemon are meant to standalone and some are meant to be bad in-game. I’m talking Tropius, Castform, Spinda etc.
If everything evolves into something good then it all becomes a bit pointless.
I find that it varies on the Mon. Like Castform and Spinda? They really don’t need an evolution, they’re built around gimmicks first. Heck not every single Mon needs to be part of a three stage line.

I feel like a major reason people want new evolutions for single stage Mons is because that’s exactly how Gamefreak themselves handles it.
They want to make a Mon or evolution line more interesting they just make an evolution. And when they don’t the absolute most they’ll do is give them a new attack or +10 to their stats. Maybe if you’re very lucky they’ll get a new ability. I’m shocked Shiftry got a new ability in SV.

Like for an example, Tropius is a Mon a lot of people love design wise, I don’t blame them, but it’s just not good in the slightest in gameplay. It’s simultaneously fragile, weak and slow.
It feels like a Mon that should have some decent firepower behind it, but it has basically nothing going for it even if you give it +10 to one of its attack stats. But an evolution let’s them do a lot more for it, maybe a new type, a noticeable bump in Base Stats, some new attack/signature move it couldn’t have before.
And there’s the big one, a brand new design for a Pokemon.

And these just about always work, nobody would care about Tangela gaining +10 to its defense. People care a lot more when it got Tangrowth. Same with Hydrapple and Annihilape, which really did a lot for their respective lines popularity and viability.
 
Castersvarog said:
I find that it varies on the Mon. Like Castform and Spinda? They really don’t need an evolution, they’re built around gimmicks first. Heck not every single Mon needs to be part of a three stage line.
Counterargument, Castform’s gimmick didn’t work too well because of it’s base stats are too low (70 each) for making use of it, and other Pokémon with a weather-based Ability can use weather better just by virtue of a more specialized stat spread.

Meanwhile, Spinda’s low BST isn’t well built for middle-to-lategame. It also ended up aging poorly for another reason; how difficult it is to implement in future games ever since BDSP without messing up their personality value-based patterns.

In both cases, executions matters just as much as the concept, and a lesson to not shove a gimmick if you are not gonna make them worthwhile in important aspects (exploration and battling) to begin with.

If those two don’t need an evolution, then they definitely need to be put on early game so that they can be useful for the power level they are found in. Not as route 1, but definitely as a “crutch” kind of Pokémon with slightly higher BST than average but can struggle to catch up later on, akin to the “pre-promotes” that ScraftyIsTheBest elaborated earlier.
 
Last edited:
Samtendo09 said:
Counterargument, Castform’s gimmick didn’t work too well because of it’s base stats are too low (70 each) for making use of it, and other Pokémon with a weather-based Ability can use weather better just by virtue of a more specialized stat spread.

Meanwhile, Spinda’s low BST isn’t well built for middle-to-lategame. It also ended up aging poorly for another reason; how difficult it is to implement in future games ever since BDSP without messing up their personality value-based patterns.

In both cases, executions matters just as much as the concept, and a lesson to not shove a gimmick if you are not gonna make them worthwhile in important aspects (exploration and battling) to begin with.

If those two don’t need an evolution, then they definitely need to be put on early game so that they can be useful for the power level they are found in. Not as route 1, but definitely as a “crutch” kind of Pokémon with slightly higher BST than average but can struggle to catch up later on, akin to the “pre-promotes” that ScraftyIsTheBest elaborated earlier.
That would work pretty great as well, makes them more notable as team members if you need that extra bit of oomph at the early points of the game vs appearing later on as just another random Mon that you’ll encounter but pass over because it’s just not keeping up at that time.

Though tbh, I think for Castform it could get away with having its various weather forms get a bump in their base stats while regular Castform stats as is.
 
Castersvarog said:
I feel like a major reason people want new evolutions for single stage Mons is because that’s exactly how Gamefreak themselves handles it.
They want to make a Mon or evolution line more interesting they just make an evolution. And when they don’t the absolute most they’ll do is give them a new attack or +10 to their stats. Maybe if you’re very lucky they’ll get a new ability. I’m shocked Shiftry got a new ability in SV.

Like for an example, Tropius is a Mon a lot of people love design wise, I don’t blame them, but it’s just not good in the slightest in gameplay. It’s simultaneously fragile, weak and slow.
It feels like a Mon that should have some decent firepower behind it, but it has basically nothing going for it even if you give it +10 to one of its attack stats. But an evolution let’s them do a lot more for it, maybe a new type, a noticeable bump in Base Stats, some new attack/signature move it couldn’t have before.
And there’s the big one, a brand new design for a Pokemon.

And these just about always work, nobody would care about Tangela gaining +10 to its defense. People care a lot more when it got Tangrowth. Same with Hydrapple and Annihilape, which really did a lot for their respective lines popularity and viability.
Now, “not every Pokémon needs to be three stage”, I agree, some lines can work nicely with just two stages, or in case for a few, single-staged among regular Pokémon.

But for Pokémon that don’t have a gimmick for it and yet still feel weak or could appreciate a new direction? It’s no big surprise why Tangrowth and Annihilape managed to be pretty popular.

Archaludon is a case where some think it is going too far (Duraludon already has 535 BST for those not in the know), but given Duraludon’s design is simple enough to be flexible for new tools, and given Duraludon itself got some issues in viability both in-game and competitive while giving it a new identity expending upon the alloy chunk of monster concept, it ended up making sense even if a new evolution is not something I thought for it in mind.
 
Oh speaking of Archaludon, a minor annoyance: the decision to give it a rain focus retroactively makes the bizarre decision to give Raihan a sand theme even more bizarre.
 
DrPumpkinz said:
Oh speaking of Archaludon, a minor annoyance: the decision to give it a rain focus retroactively makes the bizarre decision to give Raihan a sand theme even more bizarre.
I mean Raihan can never actually get Archaludon, Pokemon with the GMax factor that can GMax can't evolve. Home even prevents putting a Duraludon with the GMax factor into SV like it does Pikachu, Eevee, and Meowth with it, so they can't evolve while retaining it.
 
There were numerous bad/odd decisions with Duraludon. The typing is odd when it's supposed to oppose either Charizard or Tyranitar. Raihan's indistinct weather focus was just weird. The weight is nonsensical. It had no need of an evolution, but they added one, which makes it's rivalry with TTar silly and Raihan appear to be a terrible trainer. It has a signature hidden ability which is useless in-game, alongside 2 abilities which are useless when combined with the main mechanic for the generation it was introduced in. It's a special attacker who learns no special Dragon moves by level. It gives 2 SAtk EVs and it's evo gives 3 Def EVs because it went from 115/120 to 130/125, because that change in highest stat totally matters.

Just, whoever was in charge of Duraludon needs to stop making pokemon.
 
Hugin said:
There were numerous bad/odd decisions with Duraludon. The typing is odd when it's supposed to oppose either Charizard or Tyranitar. Raihan's indistinct weather focus was just weird. The weight is nonsensical. It had no need of an evolution, but they added one, which makes it's rivalry with TTar silly and Raihan appear to be a terrible trainer. It has a signature hidden ability which is useless in-game, alongside 2 abilities which are useless when combined with the main mechanic for the generation it was introduced in. It's a special attacker who learns no special Dragon moves by level. It gives 2 SAtk EVs and it's evo gives 3 Def EVs because it went from 115/120 to 130/125, because that change in highest stat totally matters.

Just, whoever was in charge of Duraludon needs to stop making pokemon.
I mean it failing in being a rival to Tyranitar makes sense, when has Godzilla ever lost to a building?
 
I'd argue that Archaludon was a necessary evolution. Base Duraludon's design comes off as too simple for an impressive final stage because the mon was designed around its GMax. So When Duraludon reappeared in a game without GMaxes, it needed some other method of upgrading its design. They theoretically could have given it a unique Tera form, but those were exclusive to story-relevant Legends and would have just kicked the can down the road to Champions anyway. A standard evolution has the best guarantee of continued support.
 
As I said, Archaludon is a different take on the same underlying concept that goes on between Duraludon and G-Max Duraludon. Duraludon itself is a fairly plain hunk of metal monster, but both its Gigantamax form and Archaludon are different forms of architecture. G-Max Duraludon is a skyscraper, and since G-Maxes are visually colossal in appearance, that fits. Archaludon is instead a bridge, and that actually works pretty well in animation since you can see it when Archaludon bends down on all fours. In both cases, Duraludon is a plain, relatively formless hunk of metal that gets "sculpted" into a more distinct, identifiable form of architecture.

Also, Duraludon's weight actually makes perfect sense when you consider what metal it's made of. It's made of duralumin (hence the name), which is a really lightweight metal alloy that has a very low density compared to heavy metals. That actually makes Duraludon really light despite being quite tall.
 
ScraftyIsTheBest said:
Also, Duraludon's weight actually makes perfect sense when you consider what metal it's made of. It's made of duralumin (hence the name), which is a really lightweight metal alloy that has a very low density compared to heavy metals. That actually makes Duraludon really light despite being quite tall.
It's 5'11" and 88 lbs. That's half the weight of a healthy adult of that height. And it gets Light Metal, meaning a chance it's 44 lbs. I can lift a third of all Duraludons with one hand and hold them above my head. That's not impressive, it's hollow.
AztecCroc said:
I mean it failing in being a rival to Tyranitar makes sense, when has Godzilla ever lost to a building?
That's the weird part, is Duraludon supposed to win against TTar or lose? Because Steel is SE and resists Rock, while Dark and Dragon have no interactions. But TTar has Sand Stream and Duraludon is a special attacker. And TTar often runs Ground coverage. While the most prominent Duraludon we see is used on a Sand team TTar would like facing. But Duraludon CAN get fighting coverage that presumably 1-shots TTar.

How are we supposed to expect the TTar/Duraludon rivalry to go? What's the intended story here?
 
Hugin said:
It's 5'11" and 88 lbs. That's half the weight of a healthy adult of that height. And it gets Light Metal, meaning a chance it's 44 lbs. I can lift a third of all Duraludons with one hand and hold them above my head. That's not impressive, it's hollow.

That's the weird part, is Duraludon supposed to win against TTar or lose? Because Steel is SE and resists Rock, while Dark and Dragon have no interactions. But TTar has Sand Stream and Duraludon is a special attacker. And TTar often runs Ground coverage. While the most prominent Duraludon we see is used on a Sand team TTar would like facing. But Duraludon CAN get fighting coverage that presumably 1-shots TTar.

How are we supposed to expect the TTar/Duraludon rivalry to go? What's the intended story here?
I think the intended story is just mechagodzilla vs godzilla

sometimes godzilla wins
sometimes mecha wins

In terms of Pokemon rivalries aren't always even, anyway.
 
R_N said:
I think the intended story is just mechagodzilla vs godzilla

sometimes godzilla wins
sometimes mecha wins

In terms of Pokemon rivalries aren't always even, anyway.
I think if anything this is more bizarre because Duraludon has very few traits to even the score. Like if they had more mutual weaknesses, it'd click as a back and forth rivalry idea, but as is, it feels more like the type of Mechagodzilla that's used to fight Godzilla but gets wrecked until another Kaiju appears
 
something really small, but it kinda sucks how handmade poffins in singleplayer gen 4 are totally outclassed by the ones from the veilstone department store (and that actually matters cause you can only feed each mon a limited number of poffins)

oh yeah on a similar topic, it's very maddening how you can only buy mulch 1 at a time in dpp lol
 
Found out recently that, at least prior to SV, Umbreon, Espeon, and Sylveon were unable to learn Roar, while the Kanto and Sinnoh Eeveelutions could. And I've been trying to understand what the thought process was there seeing that there's no real reason for them not to learn it, Roar was even a TM in their debut games so it's not like it wasn't available to them originally and carried over for far too long.
 
igiveuponaname said:
Found out recently that, at least prior to SV, Umbreon, Espeon, and Sylveon were unable to learn Roar, while the Kanto and Sinnoh Eeveelutions could. And I've been trying to understand what the thought process was there seeing that there's no real reason for them not to learn it, Roar was even a TM in their debut games so it's not like it wasn't available to them originally and carried over for far too long.
fwiw we have the Movepool Oddities and Explanation thread for posts like this.

But yeah it sounds annoying lol.
 
Typhlosion having the same exact stats as Charizard is bothering me to no end.
Hisuian Typhlosion losing 5 speed and missing out on the base 100 speed benchmark is even worse.

Meganium and Venusaur also bother me a lot.

Venusaur is supposed to be the more offensive-geared of the two, and Meganium is supposed to lean more on defense and support.

Guess whose Megas have an ability to nullify two of their weaknesses and a bigger defensive stat boost, and which one bumps its SpA to 145 and lets it spam Solar Beam with no remorse.
 
Last edited:
Volt-Ikazuchi said:
Meganium and Venusaur also bother me a lot.

Venusaur is supposed to be the more offensive-geared of the two, and Meganium is supposed to lean more on defense and support.

Guess whose Megas have an ability to nullify two of their weaknesses and a bigger defensive stat boost, and which one bumps its SpA to 145 and lets it spam Solar Beam with no remorse.

I suspect that's likely why it was done that way. Meganium wouldn't be the first Mega to go in a pretty different direction to its base form; Starmie goes physical, Pidgeot goes from leaning physical to leaning special, Diancie goes from defensive to offensive. Either someone thought it'd be conceptually boring to make it "base Meganium but better" or there were concerns it'd be overpowered.
 
Volt-Ikazuchi said:
Typhlosion having the same exact stats as Charizard is bothering me to no end.
Hisuian Typhlosion losing 5 speed and missing out on the base 100 speed benchmark is even worse.

Meganium and Venusaur also bother me a lot.

Venusaur is supposed to be the more offensive-geared of the two, and Meganium is supposed to lean more on defense and support.

Guess whose Megas have an ability to nullify two of their weaknesses and a bigger defensive stat boost, and which one bumps its SpA to 145 and lets it spam Solar Beam with no remorse.
I have to question that initial orientation. Venusaur has always had a bigger stall presence for me thanks to Leech Seed and the Poison typing, while Meganium's support focusing more on screens means it wants to close out fights before they expire.
 
It's worth noting Venusaur and Meganium really got that offensive vs defensive orientation when Hidden Abilities became a thing in Gen 5

Both of them got abilities tied to the strong sunlight weather, but Venusaur got Chlorophyll which doubles Speed under Sun while Meganium got Leaf Guard which prevents it from being inflicted with status conditions under Sun.

Venusaur has higher Special Attack while Meganium has higher Defense for the record. Their natural move pools do lend to the difference though in their own way. Venusaur has Growth which boosts offensive stats, moreso under Sun, and Meganium has Aromatherapy and Synthesis which lend to longevity and team support. That said, Venusaur's status moves tend to lean more into damage, particularly passive damage, while Meganium's status moves lean more into team support with reducing damage and healing status.

I actually do think it's cool that their Megas lean in opposite directions, because both of their Megas do that switch really well. Mega Venusaur is good at being a defensive tank who refuses to die, and Mega Meganium is also hella fun with spamming Solar Beam for free and having extra tools to use Mega Sol with.
 
R_N said:
It just stands out more here because they were introduced at the same time and one of them is a TM everyone can learn.
It's been a while but the answer to why there are two when everything learns Protect struck me the other day. Detect was infinitely available from the department store, Protect was single use unless you had a second Gameboy and a gen 1 game to trade Nidorans from.
 
Something I noticed about the anime is that it seems to follow a game mechanic it really doesn't have to with decent consistency:
limited known moves.

Pokémon only having 4 moveslots in the games is something with little to possibly no in-universe lore explanation because it's a blatant balance contrivance. Why can my living and breathing magic monster only know four highly specific combat tricks. It has a brain and presumably some degree of intelligence higher than a dog, or possibly even sapience. Or sentience? (Don't um ackually me here with the distinction, it ultimately doesn't matter.) Unless you get super esoteric about it (read: spout bullshit) there's no way to really justify limited moveslots in a way that's both diegetic and believable.

The anime doesn't really try to justify it either but still follows this from what I can tell? For no reason? Like, guys, you're trying to write something that is (presumably) prioritizing having the Pokémon be actual characters instead of interchangeable stat blocks that rigidly adhering to the original gameplay mechanics. I think people would be fine with you bending the rules on this one. Lord knows the anime sometimes BSes stuff anyway.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top