• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

(Little) Things that annoy you in Pokémon

Karxrida said:
The only upside I can think of for Take Down is the option for its TM to be infinitely purchased since it's in the Department Store. But again, Strength exists, and Normal isn't so in demand as coverage that you need to slap it on every party member anyway.
And there you have it.

It's literally a filler TM so you can have some kind of strong-ish neutral attack without burning a single-use TM or teaching an HM that can't be deleted later.

Is it a good, well-thought out choice? Not really. But it kinda makes sense.
 
Detect continues to be the weirdest move. Z-A is the first, and thus far only, time it's had some discernible difference beyond PP

Can't even go with the thing of "oh well maybe they wanted one to be a TM and the other to show up in movepools". Both show up in move pools! Both were TMs in the same generation they were introduced in! I don't even think a "oh you get it here, so you can get it more later" works either since you could have just had a TM of one-off early on then buy infinite later. Like other TMs.
 
I think I said this before, but Detect strikes me as a flavor case that distinguishes it from Protect.

Detect is a case where the user rapidly anticipates the opponent's move and dodges, while Protect is literally conjuring up a shield of energy to block the attack directly. Detect generally got assigned to fast, light, and nimble Pokemon like Yanma, Sceptile, Medicham, etc., while Protect, in terms of natural users, is assigned to cases like Blastoise, Swampert, Aggron, etc. You can see the distinction flavor-wise.

Gameplay-wise, they're functionally identical, but it was definitely more a case of flavor distinguishing the two.

With that being said, Detect has ended up being surprisingly useful in VGC over the years despite being functionally identical to Protect, because protection is a popular strategy in Doubles. Protect is so common in VGC that one of the counter-strategies to stop it is to use an Imprison user with Protect to disable the opponent's Protect. Detect, by virtue of the technicality of being a different move from Protect, can actually circumvent this strategy and act as a loophole around the Imprison+Protect counter. Because of this, any Pokemon who can learn Detect has pretty much always opted to use Detect specifically instead of Protect because this allows them to use a protection move that cannot be imprisoned by most Imprison users.

The PP difference becomes inconsequential in Doubles, especially 4v4 Doubles, because 4v4 Doubles is such a fast paced metagame anyway.

But yeah, it's a flavor difference more than anything, especially when you consider who learns which naturally in their level-up learnset.
 
ScraftyIsTheBest said:
I think I said this before, but Detect strikes me as a flavor case that distinguishes it from Protect.

Detect is a case where the user rapidly anticipates the opponent's move and dodges, while Protect is literally conjuring up a shield of energy to block the attack directly. Detect generally got assigned to fast, light, and nimble Pokemon like Yanma, Sceptile, Medicham, etc., while Protect, in terms of natural users, is assigned to cases like Blastoise, Swampert, Aggron, etc. You can see the distinction flavor-wise.

Gameplay-wise, they're functionally identical, but it was definitely more a case of flavor distinguishing the two.

With that being said, Detect has ended up being surprisingly useful in VGC over the years despite being functionally identical to Protect, because protection is a popular strategy in Doubles. Protect is so common in VGC that one of the counter-strategies to stop it is to use an Imprison user with Protect to disable the opponent's Protect. Detect, by virtue of the technicality of being a different move from Protect, can actually circumvent this strategy and act as a loophole around the Imprison+Protect counter. Because of this, any Pokemon who can learn Detect has pretty much always opted to use Detect specifically instead of Protect because this allows them to use a protection move that cannot be imprisoned by most Imprison users.

The PP difference becomes inconsequential in Doubles, especially 4v4 Doubles, because 4v4 Doubles is such a fast paced metagame anyway.

But yeah, it's a flavor difference more than anything, especially when you consider who learns which naturally in their level-up learnset.
It just stands out more here because they were introduced at the same time and one of them is a TM everyone can learn. Trick & Switcheroo have overlap but the flavor is (mostly, honestly Trick's description reads like it should have been a dark type to begin with?) there and there's a fair (albeit varying) amount who only learn one or the other.
 
They made overworld spirites for every single Pokemon in B/W to use in the Entree Forest yet they only used a handful of them within Unova itself. Krokorok, Patrat, Audino, Herdier and Minccino are the ones that stand out as being reused throughout the game. I don’t understand why they didn’t make use of the variety of sprites that already existed in the games code and make the world feel a bit more alive.
 
Last edited:
Charlie0108 said:
They made overworld spirites for every single Pokemon in B/W to use in the Entree Forest yet they only used a handful of them within Unova itself. Krokorok, Patrat, Audino, Herdier and Minccino are the ones that stand out as being reused throughout the game. I don’t understand why they didn’t make use of the variety of sprites that already existed in the games code and make the world feel a bit more lived in.
All the Entree sprites were just from HGSS, iirc, and had no Gen 5 Pokemon until BW2 (even then it wasn't all of them). Since Unova's entire "thing" was not having older Pokemon in it I think that makes sense (even if post-game probably could have).
BW2 could have spread the variety around more though, that I agree on
 
R_N said:
All the Entree sprites were just from HGSS, iirc, and had no Gen 5 Pokemon until BW2 (even then it wasn't all of them). Since Unova's entire "thing" was not having older Pokemon in it I think that makes sense (even if post-game probably could have).
BW2 could have spread the variety around more though, that I agree on
Oh, thanks for the correction! I assumed they were all in both games as I knew they were in BW2 and I never got to really interact with the Entree at the time the games came out.
 
R_N said:
It just stands out more here because they were introduced at the same time and one of them is a TM everyone can learn. Trick & Switcheroo have overlap but the flavor is (mostly, honestly Trick's description reads like it should have been a dark type to begin with?) there and there's a fair (albeit varying) amount who only learn one or the other.
Honestly, flavour is kinda a big distinguishing and justifiable reason for why some moves may be redundant with others.
Scratch and Pound are fundamentally the same move, but it adds personality to the Pokemon they are given to, Treecko could Scratch, but Pound makes it clear that its using its tail as the primary form of attack.
I think they are just trying to say everything can Protect themselves, but only a handful can do so via dexterity and foresight (speaking of which, Foresight and Odor Sleuth)

Funnily enough, many generations actually have minor interactions that make Detect and Protect marginally distinct from each other.
Gen 3 has contests, in which Detect and Protect are completely different.
Gen 4 obviously has Imprison
Gen 6 gave us Protean, even though no Protean-mon actually learns Detect.
Gen 7 gave us Z-moves, which on top of using different gems, Z-Protect is a self-Haze, whereas Z-Detect is a Double Team.
Gen 9 mainline games did not give us anything new perse, but the change to Protein/Libero activating once makes the type change potentially more impactful.

Edit:
I found another very edge case where Protect and Detect being different matters and it has to do with Sketch. Technically the move Protect and Detect are different moves, so Sketch will replace itself with Detect even if Smeargle already knows Protect. So if you try to Sketch a move from a wild Pokemon that learns Detect it can sometimes mess Smeargle up by going for Detect.
Still a very edge case because usually you go into a double battle and use Sketch on the partner, but technically technically, if the opponent has Detect and Spotlight, the Spotlight user can force you to Sketch Detect if you already have Protect.
 
Last edited:
Xeggutor said:
Honestly, flavour is kinda a big distinguishing and justifiable reason for why some moves may be redundant with others.
Scratch and Pound are fundamentally the same move, but it adds personality to the Pokemon they are given to, Treecko could Scratch, but Pound makes it clear that its using its tail as the primary form of attack.
I think they are just trying to say everything can Protect themselves, but only a handful can do so via dexterity and foresight.

Shout out to Branch Poke, which exists solely because Grookey carries a stick and was then given to Phantump because it’s made of sticks.

Still waiting on an early game physical Fire and Fairy type move
 
Last edited:
Xeggutor said:
Honestly, flavour is kinda a big distinguishing and justifiable reason for why some moves may be redundant with others.
I find Branch Poke to be the funniest of these because they really made a second Vine Whip clone (after Leafage) basically just for Grookey.

Like guys I don't think anyone would have cared if the monkey slapped people with vines lol. We already have to extrapolate how Vine Whip works for some Pokémon — see the anime doing the heavy lifting for the Bulbasaur and Chikorita lines. It's fine to just say the monkey pulled vines out of nowhere.
 
Karxrida said:
I find Branch Poke to be the funniest of these because they really made a second Vine Whip clone (after Leafage) basically just for Grookey.

Like guys I don't think anyone would have cared if the monkey slapped people with vines lol. We already have to extrapolate how Vine Whip works for some Pokémon it's fine.
Honestly Leafage is equally stupid because they realised maybe not all Grass types use Vines to attack, so they made a Leaf-based equivalent. Except leafage is just a foliage (same in JP) which are completely harmless. The CN translation is just "Leaf" which equally funny. Onix dying from just touching grass is actually canon now.

And about Vine Whip. What you mean the Chikorita line, known for its use of Vine Whip in the anime, can only learn it via breeding?
 
Last edited:
Xeggutor said:
And about Vine Whip. What you mean the Chikorita line, known for its use of Vine Whip in the anime, can only learn it via breeding?
God I forgot abotu this, which got me to look up because surely that changed at some point and no. The answer is no.

The answer is so no that Chikorita is, and has always been, the one singular Pokemon in the series to get Vine Whip through breeding.
 
Xeggutor said:
Honestly Leafage is equally stupid because they realised maybe not all Grass types use Vines to attack, so they made a Leaf-based equivalent. Except leafage is just a foliage (same in JP) which are completely harmless.
To be fair it's a 40 BP attack and I know from experience that some leaves are actually sharp depending on the plant they come from. It's not the worst reasoning.

Xeggutor said:
And about Vine Whip. What you mean the Chikorita line, known for its use of Vine Whip in the anime, can only learn it via breeding?
R_N said:
God I forgot abotu this, which got me to look up because surely that changed at some point and no. The answer is no.

The answer is so no that Chikorita is, and has always been, the one singular Pokemon in the series to get Vine Whip through breeding.
Wait what why. What purpose does this serve lol. It's not even like Phanpy getting Water Gun via breeding in Gen 2 where it was useless but still acted as a cute easter egg.
 
Karxrida said:
Like guys I don't think anyone would have cared if the monkey slapped people with vines lol
It would probably have been Leafage rather than Vine Whip, the line already gets Razor Leaf via level and Magical Leaf via TM and can't learn Power Whip even via the TR.
 
Xeggutor said:
Honestly, flavour is kinda a big distinguishing and justifiable reason for why some moves may be redundant with others.
Scratch and Pound are fundamentally the same move, but it adds personality to the Pokemon they are given to, Treecko could Scratch, but Pound makes it clear that its using its tail as the primary form of attack.
I think they are just trying to say everything can Protect themselves, but only a handful can do so via dexterity and foresight (speaking of which, Foresight and Odor Sleuth)
My main issue with this instance of the logic is that Protect and Detect are fundamentally different ideas nowadays: Detect is "you can't make this connect" while Protect is "I will block it on impact no matter what it is."

If Protect is the generic version, I feel like it should be less definitive in general, like still taking partial damage while blocking secondary effects. Like almost any dexterous creature can curl up or raise body parts to intercept incoming attacks, but that's not necessarily going to hard stop the damage: imagine putting your hands in front of your face for a punch vs a sharp object, or you being whipped in the back vs an armored creature like an Armadillo.

Detect being evasive makes sense for full null because the attack never connects so its impact on different physical targets is irrelevant.

What's funny here is up until the Switch games, both moves used the same "Evades" language that Detect is associated with, whether deliberately or from copy-paste language, before shifting to generic "protects itself/protective stance". If it stayed exactly the same the whole time I'd not even question or think about it, but it's an odd decision to rewrite both moves, still identical, to suit that flavor now.
 
pika pal said:
My main issue with this instance of the logic is that Protect and Detect are fundamentally different ideas nowadays: Detect is "you can't make this connect" while Protect is "I will block it on impact no matter what it is."

If Protect is the generic version, I feel like it should be less definitive in general, like still taking partial damage while blocking secondary effects. Like almost any dexterous creature can curl up or raise body parts to intercept incoming attacks, but that's not necessarily going to hard stop the damage: imagine putting your hands in front of your face for a punch vs a sharp object, or you being whipped in the back vs an armored creature like an Armadillo.

Detect being evasive makes sense for full null because the attack never connects so its impact on different physical targets is irrelevant.

What's funny here is up until the Switch games, both moves used the same "Evades" language that Detect is associated with, whether deliberately or from copy-paste language, before shifting to generic "protects itself/protective stance". If it stayed exactly the same the whole time I'd not even question or think about it, but it's an odd decision to rewrite both moves, still identical, to suit that flavor now.
I think that Detect is fine the way it is, and the strange part is more of how Protect is generically available or even functional, in the first place.

I think one way to have it make sense is if we interpret Protect as a shield from SSB, and that consecutive uses leaves you easier to being shield poked, and Detect is more of a case like Sheik Up B, where you dodge out of the way, but spamming it a lot leaves you more predictable.

However, now that you brought up move description, it’s honestly so strange. I would assume Protect says to protect and Detect says to evade, but apparently it just reads the same for both, like you mentioned.
 
Xeggutor said:
Honestly, flavour is kinda a big distinguishing and justifiable reason for why some moves may be redundant with others.
Scratch and Pound are fundamentally the same move, but it adds personality to the Pokemon they are given to, Treecko could Scratch, but Pound makes it clear that its using its tail as the primary form of attack.
I think they are just trying to say everything can Protect themselves, but only a handful can do so via dexterity and foresight (speaking of which, Foresight and Odor Sleuth)
Nothing but facts
 
I don't like it when it's impossible to complete the regional Pokedex before obtaining the National Pokedex in the older gens. I tend to do a run-through of the entire series every few years as part of the build up to the next generation coming out and part of my prefered play-style is to catch everything possible on every route with the aim of having a full living Pokedex at the end of it. Naturally I order my boxes 1-30, 31-60 etc. but in certain games it's impossible to complete the regional Pokedex without extensive trading prior to getting the national Pokedex, which in turn throws everything off for me as the Pokedex numbers displayed in the PC switch from regional to national.

Of course, there are always going to be a certain number of trade-only Pokemon anyway due to the version exclusives, but I'm playing through White 2 at the moment and here is a list, off the top of my head, of all the Pokemon in the expanded Unova dex completely unobtainable prior to rolling credits (not including version exclusives):

  • List
    • Munna
    • Musharna
    • Cleffa
    • Tirtouga
    • Carracosta
    • Archen
    • Archeops
    • Budew
    • Blitzle
    • Larvesta
    • Heatmor
    • Durant
    • Cryogonal
    • Tornadus
    • Thundrus
    • Landorus
    • Shuppet
    • Wingull
    • Tympole
    • Palpitoad
    • Seismitoad
    • Stunfisk
    • Vanillite
    • Vanillish
    • Vanilluxe
    • Swinub
    • Beldum
    • Gollett
    • Deino
    • Slakoth
    • Vigoroth
    • Slaking
    • Corphish
    • Crawduant
    • Igglybuff
    • Jigglypuff
    • Wigglytuff
    • Lickitung
    • Lickilicky
    • Yanma
    • Yanmega
    • Tropius
    • Carnivine
    • Croagunk
    • Toxicroak
    • Larvitar
    • Pupitar
    • Tyranitar
    • Reshiram
    • Zekrom
    [*]

50/300 Pokemon in the Dex completely unobtainable prior to the E4! For some reason they made 20 or so Pokemon completely post-game exclusive meaning you don't even see they on trainers teams until the post-game and thus serve zero purpose being in the regional Pokedex as you receive the National Pokedex immediately after beating the league.
 
vgc Needing protect is definitely a flaw, but its one that would require uprooting the entire system to be fixed imo, so while i agree protects distribution is weird im also not sure if cutting it down would be good for vgc.

im not sure it matters nearly as much either way for casual play unless youre doing a challenge run of some sorts... not really the most useful move vs npcs
 
So I'm in the crowd that's been elated with Mega Golisopod, given the ability, typing, and stat boosts have given it massive buffs that are synergistic with its existing strong suits and fix quite a few of its issues (both typical and intentional). The design is sick too and I love how it has a clear strengths and weaknesses with its playstyle (low speed and high bulk, draining move with iffy Neutral coverage that makes it only semi-reliable to heal).

That said, the shiny feels like someone slept in. The base form gets a cool Gray and Glossy shell, reflecting the Steel type change and greater emphasis on protecting itself with Armor that suited its Emergency Exit intent (strong dude who's still a coward and trying to avoid being hurt instead of win its fights).
h8tej8eFuuQ6T00RcpxvJw.png


The Shiny, at least on the in-game model, looks almost identical in color scheme between the base and Mega form, which loses that effect on the armor. The base form this change wasn't too egregious as a typical sort of shade shift on an exoskeleton/shell, but it's a much more noticeable contrast from the Mega Shade. White is also not a color I think of being associated with a sturdy/defensive material the way dark-grey Iron/Steel is, so it's hard to reinterpret same-color, different material as a justification either.

BCt1KHoBkEGvSDCts02tRw.png
 
Back
Top