• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

RBTT Random Battles Team Tour X: Pre-Tour Discussion Thread

FreyaknightVGC said:
Gen 9 Champions Random Doubles Battle - Best of 3
...
I'm really curious of what you all may think! Thanks for the attention o7
I'm ngl I haven't played much champs randdubs and so I'm not the best person to ask. but from watching a lot of sets this RDTT, I do feel it's not quite mature enough of a format. (Similar for champs rands, I have even less of a grasp)

On a more general note: people seem to be reaching a consensus about keeping 8 teams, 16 slots, with minimal changes from last year. Don't fix what ain't broke, and lowkey the most broken thing was that losing 7-9 sucked more than usual. I would favor, though:
- keeping/making Gen 1, BSSF, maybe HC, maybe Roulette Bo5.
- if viable, replacing SV3 with something like balanced B12P6, champs rands (if it's stabilized), etc. I agree with soTsoT that RBTT should be able to showcase more unique formats than WCoR.
- if viable, somehow distinguishing the two dubs slots. I don't think champs dubs or VGC are quite up to the task though. I'd personally prefer making the first dubs slot Bo5, as the top few dubs players are indeed better than the other RBTT-caliber dubs players, and arguing this makes dubs as important as singles is kinda a bad argument when singles has 8 other gens.
 
long post incoming:

1. 8 teams. We don't need a 9-week regular season
2. 16 is fine, but if we are changing, it should be down, not up.
Generally divisive slots I would totally be ok with cutting: SV3, Dubs2, Gen 2, BSSF, Hackmons, Roulette.
I don't think you should be cutting something not on this list.
3. There are literally academic papers backing 3rd manager loafing, but there's not really much downside to a 3rd manager besides one [usually] underqualified player who otherwise wouldn't be in RBTT getting a free custom avatar.
4. Players should only make subs when it's clear the manager will not be around in time to make them. Otherwise good!

Format related discussion:
If you asked me to create my ideal RBTT in a vacuum, I would go SV1, SV2, Champs, Dubs, 8, 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, 1, Roulette. However, Rands WCOP exists and making the tours distinct is very important. This means we should have a bit of fun deciding our more niche formats. However, I'm not a big fan of putting wacky formats into RBTT (looking at you VGC Rands); there should still be some prestige and "order" for the formats included. I think it's kind of silly to include formats that people don't actively main/play just to add variety/quirk.

I like the following changes:
SV3 -> Champs, or gone
Dubs2 -> Dubs bo5, Champ Dubs bo3, or gone
Roulette -> format pick/ban, similar to circuit. It's more complicated and not self-contained, but we already played around with challenge codes and MBox in the past and this format mirror circuit more closely.
thoughts on format opinions I see in the wild
Doubles 2 is not weak! The Doubles scene has a lot of good players!!!!!!!!!!!!
There was a big argument about Doubles2 in the randdubs server a couple days ago, and the main argument I saw was that there are in fact, 16 players who are good enough to play at an "RBTT level". While I think there are reasonably more than 8 players who are RBTT level, the problem isn't finding enough players to fill 16 (I'm ok with a few stinkers like me every year), but additionally the 8 extra subs that people draft to cover two slots. In a one-slot Doubles format, you'll probably get around 9-10 Doubles players getting drafted; few teams opting for a sub, to cover for weaker resumes or availability. However, in two-slot doubles, you will get 21-24 Doubles players getting drafted; almost every team opting for a sub. Adding onto the fact that managers want to give all players some playing time, you'd be lying to yourself if you said the skill disparity between players isn't noticeably wide. It's very evident when you end up with teams like soTsoT/Freya or marco/dinis playing against weaker drafts. However, I do think the overall popularity of Random Doubles as a whole warrants two slots, whether it be in SV or Champs. (mirroring SV). I'm personally a big advocate for SV Bo5 and SV Bo3 for Doubles, it worked well in RDTT in separating those higher level players
I wasn't supposed to play Bo5 in RDTT, I was just larping​

--------------------
BSSF / Hackmons is a good format with mains!!
Honestly indifferent about these formats' existence in RBTT, but here some thoughts:

Hackmons - Playerbase definitely exists, but the skill disparity is less than other formats in RBTT. This could be because all the players are similarly skilled, but I'm more inclined to believe that the format is a bit less skill-based than advocates are making it out to be. Also shoutouts to npm for carrying Diancies last year, both in Hackmons and in vibes.
BSS Factory - Playerbase is not there. Over half of the players in the RBTT 9 pool actively play another RBTT tier at an RBTT level. I think there are more popular formats out there that can fill the "diversity quota" for RBTT/WCOP differentiation.

Funnily enough, the existence of BSSCL and HackmonsPL removed one of the old reasons for having them in RBTT: to keep them alive and represented in tours. If Challenge Cup doesn't need to be in RBTT because it has its own tour, Hackmons and BSS Factory will be just fine.

And if you look at the <insert format team tour> sheet, it had a good number of <insert format> players that ended with positive records.
Yes, Pokemon is a zero-sum game, there will be players with positive records. What actually matters is the disparity between good players and bad players. Also including players who usually play/prefer other formats is not particularly meaningful. I think Click>Think would actively murder me if I fielded him in BSS Factory or Hackmons Cup.

--------------------
Probably not a consideration for this tournament, but I do think we should atleast consider walking away from gen1-9 singles being 100% fixed slots. I think the amount of people who actually enjoy playing gen2 AND are able to play it at RBTT level can be counted with one hand. We excluded singles formats in the past because we knew they were unpopular, and while the whole thing has definitely become more serious since then, I don't think keeping a format around that hardly anyone actually wants to play helps the overall competetiveness of the tournament.
I already said this above, but 100% agree. Gens 1-9 are not mainstays, especially unpopular ones. Gen 2 wasn't included in RBTT for many previous editions, and there were very few people who complained about it. Also please don't make them a rotating format if you do axe their permanent slot, you still need to draft for each of the formats but they get less playing time/value.

--------------------
All of the pick/ban is too complicated ... I think the two things that could improve the slot to give it more variety are:
1. bo5 would increase the tiers that could be showcased in a given set.
2. No repeats allowed. Instead of just challenging the format, roll in pms beforehand and reroll on dupes, then just challenge in the tier that gets rolled. This has the added benefit of allowing calcdex to work.
Pick/Ban is a single extra step more than option 2. Hard agree on Bo5 though.

--------------------
Number of slots should stay the same but I think it should be looked into getting the subs doing more than twiddling their thumbs. Maybe have 2 or 3 sub slots playing each week with rotating formats and the team with the best subs record gets a bonus point or 2.
Rotating slots and Mystery Box are bad. Also subs are subs, their whole job is to not be doing something so they can fill in for someone who is busy. Also imo a good manager should be giving all their players some amount of playing time.

Franchising:
Franchises should change infrequently, but not never. RBTT is very guilty of having managers go: "what legendary do I want in my CA this year?" and picking a different mascot every year. Rands players currently view team continuity more through the lens of the manager core, not the team, which should be primary and not secondary to the managers/players on said teams. Franchising also helps builds more progression and storylines. You can't really have storylines like Canada going from Quals failures to Champions, or being b2b Champions when your team name and identity changes every single iteration. Maybe if people really want the opportunity to switch, we can make it so certain manager pairings have to keep their mascot for a couple years (maybe 3?), before being allowed to switch. Reminds me of the ridiculousness of WCOP Team France having swapped mascots literally every year. I just want teams themselves to have some type of continuity outside of the names comprising the manager cores, and franchising helps with that. (also the CA farming with yearly mascot changes is really stupid, both for bloat and artist workload.)
Additional Franchising Thoughts:
Also, to me one of the best aspects of rbtt is to land in a different teamenvironment every year, and retains actively work against that. I was a Hoopa for my first 2 rbtts, and while I had a good time in both of them, I was very glad to not be a hoopa for a third year in a row.
Franchising allows for more creative and fresh teams
Team Hoopa aside, the cosmetic difference of a new mascot doesn't really affect the team environment. Your managers will be the same, and the players likely not. If you ended up in a similar team environment, it's probably bc of the managers/players, not the mascot.

Mostly unrelated to RBTT but related to franchising and CAs as a whole:
why I think team-specific CAs are a really stupid concept
I might be the only person on the platform to think this, but I think team-specific CAs for getting drafted to a team tour is really stupid. 90% of people don't use them bc they have cooler ones from other tours, and they just add a bunch of bloat to the CA pool and peoples' collections. NPA got denied team-specific avis and was instead given an interesting consolation: a set of CAs for the whole tour + Team CA for the winners. It keeps the prize for getting drafted, gives every iteration its own unique vibe, and maintains further incentive for teams to win and get that Team CA. I don't really want a CA with customization restrictions (which these tours have), especially if the team performed poorly. I think there are other ways for Showdown to implement 'team pride' for these tours, such as putting up a team banner beneath their name for their tour matches, having a country flag by their name, a team badge similar to ladder achievements, etc. It's too late now to fix the CA inflation economy (especially now that each section individually gets 3 lol), but I wanted to share my thoughts on this topic anyways.

RBTT should do whatever cool stuff they can with the CA slots that teams are given, but cool avis should never come before other considerations for team franchising (and CA artists are really hard to find rn, like it took Canada months to find an artist, even with large financial incentive)

Other thoughts:
- Auction should just be the standard for all other mons formats; 10k per mandatory slot, min 3k.
- I want manager selfbuys to be more variable in price to account for skill level (because I'm trash), but a consistent price is just easier to follow and is less subjective. I would be careful about strong players being "manager" for the sake of going at a lower, consistent price though.
- Indifferent on retains, could be fun. Tetains should get more expensive over consecutive retains, and pause retains for a year if you go 10 teams.
- Previously Bo5 formats should stay bo5. If other formats want to join them, sure. We are NOT entertaining Bo7...
I'm probably objectively wrong on half of these opinions lol
 
FreyaknightVGC said:
Dubs mainers, mainly SolaceAnt soTsoT Optidox snorlax142857 who already wrote here, i would very much like to know your opinions on this matter specifically.
I'm really curious of what you all may think! Thanks for the attention o7
I personally would rather have SV Best of 3 and SV Best of 5 than SV and champs, but I think there are merits to both. I just think champs is in too much of a state of flux right now, as new regs drop and items get added sets and levels will change pretty frequently. Would rather have a more stable format.
 
Last edited:
Sapphire said:
long post incoming:

1. 8 teams. We don't need a 9-week regular season
2. 16 is fine, but if we are changing, it should be down, not up.
Generally divisive slots I would totally be ok with cutting: SV3, Dubs2, Gen 2, BSSF, Hackmons, Roulette.
I don't think you should be cutting something not on this list.
3. There are literally academic papers backing 3rd manager loafing, but there's not really much downside to a 3rd manager besides one [usually] underqualified player who otherwise wouldn't be in RBTT getting a free custom avatar.
4. Players should only make subs when it's clear the manager will not be around in time to make them. Otherwise good!

Format related discussion:
If you asked me to create my ideal RBTT in a vacuum, I would go SV1, SV2, Champs, Dubs, 8, 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, 1, Roulette. However, Rands WCOP exists and making the tours distinct is very important. This means we should have a bit of fun deciding our more niche formats. However, I'm not a big fan of putting wacky formats into RBTT (looking at you VGC Rands); there should still be some prestige and "order" for the formats included. I think it's kind of silly to include formats that people don't actively main/play just to add variety/quirk.

I like the following changes:
SV3 -> Champs, or gone
Dubs2 -> Dubs bo5, Champ Dubs bo3, or gone
Roulette -> format pick/ban, similar to circuit. It's more complicated and not self-contained, but we already played around with challenge codes and MBox in the past and this format mirror circuit more closely.
thoughts on format opinions I see in the wild
There was a big argument about Doubles2 in the randdubs server a couple days ago, and the main argument I saw was that there are in fact, 16 players who are good enough to play at an "RBTT level". While I think there are reasonably more than 8 players who are RBTT level, the problem isn't finding enough players to fill 16 (I'm ok with a few stinkers like me every year), but additionally the 8 extra subs that people draft to cover two slots. In a one-slot Doubles format, you'll probably get around 9-10 Doubles players getting drafted; few teams opting for a sub, to cover for weaker resumes or availability. However, in two-slot doubles, you will get 21-24 Doubles players getting drafted; almost every team opting for a sub. Adding onto the fact that managers want to give all players some playing time, you'd be lying to yourself if you said the skill disparity between players isn't noticeably wide. It's very evident when you end up with teams like soTsoT/Freya or marco/dinis playing against weaker drafts. However, I do think the overall popularity of Random Doubles as a whole warrants two slots, whether it be in SV or Champs. (mirroring SV). I'm personally a big advocate for SV Bo5 and SV Bo3 for Doubles, it worked well in RDTT in separating those higher level players
I wasn't supposed to play Bo5 in RDTT, I was just larping​

--------------------

Honestly indifferent about these formats' existence in RBTT, but here some thoughts:

Hackmons - Playerbase definitely exists, but the skill disparity is less than other formats in RBTT. This could be because all the players are similarly skilled, but I'm more inclined to believe that the format is a bit less skill-based than advocates are making it out to be. Also shoutouts to npm for carrying Diancies last year, both in Hackmons and in vibes.
BSS Factory - Playerbase is not there. Over half of the players in the RBTT 9 pool actively play another RBTT tier at an RBTT level. I think there are more popular formats out there that can fill the "diversity quota" for RBTT/WCOP differentiation.

Funnily enough, the existence of BSSCL and HackmonsPL removed one of the old reasons for having them in RBTT: to keep them alive and represented in tours. If Challenge Cup doesn't need to be in RBTT because it has its own tour, Hackmons and BSS Factory will be just fine.


Yes, Pokemon is a zero-sum game, there will be players with positive records. What actually matters is the disparity between good players and bad players. Also including players who usually play/prefer other formats is not particularly meaningful. I think Click>Think would actively murder me if I fielded him in BSS Factory or Hackmons Cup.

--------------------

I already said this above, but 100% agree. Gens 1-9 are not mainstays, especially unpopular ones. Gen 2 wasn't included in RBTT for many previous editions, and there were very few people who complained about it. Also please don't make them a rotating format if you do axe their permanent slot, you still need to draft for each of the formats but they get less playing time/value.

--------------------

Pick/Ban is a single extra step more than option 2. Hard agree on Bo5 though.

--------------------

Rotating slots and Mystery Box are bad. Also subs are subs, their whole job is to not be doing something so they can fill in for someone who is busy. Also imo a good manager should be giving all their players some amount of playing time.

Franchising:
Franchises should change infrequently, but not never. RBTT is very guilty of having managers go: "what legendary do I want in my CA this year?" and picking a different mascot every year. Rands players currently view team continuity more through the lens of the manager core, not the team, which should be primary and not secondary to the managers/players on said teams. Franchising also helps builds more progression and storylines. You can't really have storylines like Canada going from Quals failures to Champions, or being b2b Champions when your team name and identity changes every single iteration. Maybe if people really want the opportunity to switch, we can make it so certain manager pairings have to keep their mascot for a couple years (maybe 3?), before being allowed to switch. Reminds me of the ridiculousness of WCOP Team France having swapped mascots literally every year. I just want teams themselves to have some type of continuity outside of the names comprising the manager cores, and franchising helps with that. (also the CA farming with yearly mascot changes is really stupid, both for bloat and artist workload.)
Additional Franchising Thoughts:
Team Hoopa aside, the cosmetic difference of a new mascot doesn't really affect the team environment. Your managers will be the same, and the players likely not. If you ended up in a similar team environment, it's probably bc of the managers/players, not the mascot.

Mostly unrelated to RBTT but related to franchising and CAs as a whole:
why I think team-specific CAs are a really stupid concept
I might be the only person on the platform to think this, but I think team-specific CAs for getting drafted to a team tour is really stupid. 90% of people don't use them bc they have cooler ones from other tours, and they just add a bunch of bloat to the CA pool and peoples' collections. NPA got denied team-specific avis and was instead given an interesting consolation: a set of CAs for the whole tour + Team CA for the winners. It keeps the prize for getting drafted, gives every iteration its own unique vibe, and maintains further incentive for teams to win and get that Team CA. I don't really want a CA with customization restrictions (which these tours have), especially if the team performed poorly. I think there are other ways for Showdown to implement 'team pride' for these tours, such as putting up a team banner beneath their name for their tour matches, having a country flag by their name, a team badge similar to ladder achievements, etc. It's too late now to fix the CA inflation economy (especially now that each section individually gets 3 lol), but I wanted to share my thoughts on this topic anyways.

RBTT should do whatever cool stuff they can with the CA slots that teams are given, but cool avis should never come before other considerations for team franchising (and CA artists are really hard to find rn, like it took Canada months to find an artist, even with large financial incentive)

Other thoughts:
- Auction should just be the standard for all other mons formats; 10k per mandatory slot, min 3k.
- I want manager selfbuys to be more variable in price to account for skill level (because I'm trash), but a consistent price is just easier to follow and is less subjective. I would be careful about strong players being "manager" for the sake of going at a lower, consistent price though.
- Indifferent on retains, could be fun. Tetains should get more expensive over consecutive retains, and pause retains for a year if you go 10 teams.
- Previously Bo5 formats should stay bo5. If other formats want to join them, sure. We are NOT entertaining Bo7...
I'm probably objectively wrong on half of these opinions lol
BSSF? Nah, just a light 10 year prison sentence

Hackmons Cup? Yea, the whole lineage gotta go atp
 
RainListener said:
From my experience (1500+ ladder games, peaked the ladder several times), despite it being super fun, some actions should be taken on B12P6 before we seriously consider it as an option for RBTT, just like what we did with HC. Some abilities, like Shadow Tag, Huge Power and Speed Boost, can give the player a huge advantage, sometimes even an auto-win at team preview. As in the Shared Power (OM) tier, maybe we could restrict some abilities based on their win rate, meaning they cannot be shared with teammates.
So, as someone who was involved in B12P6 getting a perma ladder and who plays it w some frequency, I'd love to have it on RBTT cause the format is genuinely incredible and does value a decent gameplan on preview, I think the simple fix for the Stag, Huge and pure power and such is just doing what the main SP does, restrict the ability to the native users, in this case medi azuma goth, and id rather also mention that Regenerator, Speed boost, Adaptability and Tinted lens could also be looked at that as well, which although not outright broken like the other 3, can make games pretty obnoxious due to how well they stack with other ability multipliers as far of rand bats
 
Here are my thoughts on the points I care about...
  • Keep the numbers the same as last year: 8 teams, 16 slots. I can see the argument for 14 slots, but it's tough to cut tiers and there are new tiers people want included as well, so keeping 16 feels best. Maybe for RBTT 11 we do need to look at condensing some oldgen slots to make room for more other slots, but personally I wouldn't like to see any gen completely unrepresented, so it's difficult. Something to think about as gen 10 approaches.

  • Despite maybe not being the most "polished" and being susceptible to shock updates, I think Champions deserves a slot on account of being derived from the "most current" form of competitive mons. The slot I would most want to cut for this would be either SV3 or BSSF. Other than this change, I'd want to keep the slots essentially the same as last year.

  • I think doubles should retain 2 slots. My strong preference for this would be to have SV Bo5 and SV Bo3 slots for doubles. In RDTT, I personally felt like regular gen 9 random doubles was a good tier to play and watch while the variant doubles formats (VGC rands and Champions doubles rands) were noticeably worse. We definitely should not include VGC rands in its current form. Champions doubles would probably be okay but it somehow feels wonkier to me than Champions singles and I'd prefer just a second SV doubles slot.

  • I don't think we should have player retains. On franchising more broadly, I think managers should perhaps be encouraged but not forced to carry on the legacy of previous teams? I'm not too well-informed on this topic.

  • Roulette is a cool tier but I like some of the proposed changes. It is a tier that could benefit from being Bo5 in its current form. Alternatively, I like what hammy suggested about tiers being pre-rolled each week so teams can have a bit more strategy in deciding who to slot, but I do concede this takes away from the spirit of roulette being a purely all-rounder, ready-for-anything tier.

  • I do not care what the tiebreak rules are as long as they are laid out clearly, somewhere publicly accessible, before a tie actually eventuates.
 
I might sign up as a manager so I will talk a bit about my thoughts here :sphearical:

  • Removal of formats (and slots): I'm generally in favour of reducing the number of slots to 14 if that means that we can keep the overall quality of the tournament higher. I think SV3 would probably be the format I'd be most comfortable removing. Doubles does get a lot of support and so does Hackmons Cup.
  • Substitution of formats: If we do remove some formats, I'd rather see them replaced with something that actually brings a different experience to the tournament instead of just adding another similar format. There are quite a few interesting suggestions in the thread, so I think it's worth looking into some of those before making a decision.
  • Introduction of new formats (Champions?): I think Pokémon Champions could be an interesting opportunity to introduce something new, especially Champions Randoms or Champions Doubles. Even tho I haven't actually played Champions rands myself, I do see the support and it would make a great addition.
  • The future of formats such as Battle Stadium Singles Factory and Random Roulette: I'm personally in favour of keeping formats that make RBTT unique. BSSF offers a different kind of competitive experience, and I think Random Roulette is a fun format that adds variety to the lineup. I'd rather keep both if possible, although I'm open to adjustments if there are concerns about their competitiveness or overall quality. I think A Cake Wearing A Hat made a good suggestion about roulette that would be pretty cool :afrostar:
  • Modifying the type of series (e.g. Best of 3/5/7): I would definitely support introducing more Bo5 series, especially in formats where variance plays a bigger role, such as Hackmons Cup and Random Roulette. I also think Gen 1 and BSSF could benefit from it. Don't make it Bo7 tho pls. I like to watch people suffer but that is too much in my opinion .... :bat:
Also :
  • Removal of player retains: I do agree what the password guy O1V7O2X9O says: I don't think we should have player retains. While I can understand retains from a managers perspective and that they would want to keep a reliable player, I think it's better to give every manager the same opportunity to build their team from scratch and draft whoever they think is the best fit. It makes the draft more interesting and gives everyone more flexibility.
  • Earlier manager signups and more time for artists: I don't think Custom Avatars are the most important part about RBTT but definetely a big part and why we have so many sign ups. So I do think we should open Manager signups earlier to give artists more time to work on avatars. I also think managers should be able to talk to the artists and give some ideas or guidelines for their teams avatar since its basically the mascot which represents the team :heart:
  • RBTT winner and MVP recognition: I'd also like to see a red banner for RBTT winners, similar to what SPL has. I think winning RBTT is a pretty big achievement considering how big the tournament is, and it would be nice to have something that actually shows that on your profile. Having an RBTT MVP banner or award as well would be a cool addition to recognize the players who had an outstanding performance during the tournament.
 
Last edited:
I can only speak as someone who only has a chance of sneaking in to RBTT through HC (if any at all). I completely understand the argument against the format, and if that sentiment became an overwhelming majority of the community, then it should probably be listened to. The fact remains that there probably will be a big swing result coming down to criminal HC gens, and it will be frustrating.

That being said, I really want to argue for how critical HC being bo5 is. The argument of more games to reduce variance often feeds into the sentiment that HC being more volatile is tied to its level of skill expression. But the reason HC benefits so much more from best of 5 is because of the uniqueness of its skill expression and diversity of matchup flows that players will adapt to. This is why many recognize the absurdly high skill ceiling of HC, because the game can morph into so many different states that the breadth of your skill is as important as the depth. And at high level, the early game especially takes advantage of this as players try to settle in and gain information to even recognize what resources they have long term while trying to pay a minimal cost for said information. And of course the best players can through no fault of there own happen to take a very damaging hit even when using a very complementary scout because that's just what the opponent happened to roll. But since the skill expression is intricately tied to minimizing the variance of precisely those moments, minimizing variance overall uniquely rewards the type of play HC allows for. The best argument against making HC bo7 is ironically that there will be too much skill expression. And the chance of the type of HC game that turns into a long term siege where you need to manufacture the one situation to use an unrevealed move on your opponent's biggest threat increases. Although that's my favorite type of game, I think bo5 has much better chances of taking a reasonable amount of time to play.

And finally I must ask, why rob the world of the chance to witness more games like this one?
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9hackmonscup-2635996182
Totally objectively the best game of pokemon ever played.
 
Hello I have a lot of opinions on this

Smaller stuff basically everyone has touched on:
  • Please keep 8 teams
  • 14 vs 16 is fine (but read below)
  • Please keep 3 managers (you already opened the genie in the bottle for this, reverting and making the returning managers kick someone off would suck for a tour that is supposed to be franchising)
  • I would keep franchises. These are really cool. However I would personally benefit from them going away so I guess go with the majority
  • Keep allowing self-substitutions
  • Keep Bo3 for all other than SV Bo5 and RBY (also I think the OP missed that RBY is Bo5)
  • Speaking mostly from self-interest, please combine the RBTT server into the community server. An effort was made to crosspost games last year that did not need to be made, and it dilutes the engagement further. Do lineups on forum again for security.
  • Please add tier lock

=======================

Please keep RBTT as a Snake Draft

One of the most unique and interesting things about RBTT is its snake draft style, which has not really taken off in any subforum on the site. Its charming, unique, and really fits especially since we have to draft for 14-16 slots. Especially in this tournament, an auction would really suck; budgeting up to 200k feels like it will be a much worse experience as a manager.

One thing I have not seen anywhere would be I think we should have at least 1 extra sub slot regardless of format, especially considering how many slots are in the tournament. Quite a few tournaments do 4 subs for 12 slots and we have 16.

Not super gung-ho about this but also consider adding a second manager selfbuy (probably Round 6? Also allows for the order to reset back instead of the weird half order we have now with selfbuys in Round 5 but not a big deal either way).

If you do do auction, please allow 2 selfbuys and up to 3 retains+selfbuys total like every other tour on the site, and set the selfbuys to 20k each. Also please set the budget to account for at least 5 subs.

=======================

Please delete Random Roulette

Adding more RNG (on formats chosen) to an already RNG-prone tournament (the nature of rands) really sucks. More importantly, I think Rands Roulette actually makes strong flex players weaker; I either confine my strong multi-gen mainer to Roulette and have less flexibility across slots, or I put a player who is middle of the road in that slot. I much prefer to have strong flex players be able to actually flex into different tiers than to have to think about putting them in Roulette jail.

Diluting strong players away from their respective generation makes the competition worse. For example, I *could* put drifttrick in Roulette, and he would absolutely do well. But it would be better for me to not even have that option so he can be put in SV or ADV, which would make the competition in both of those pools stronger and make for much more exciting games than potentially watching him play 3 random gens.

More importantly, any discussion of cutting HC/BSSF (actual tiers played by real people) instead of Roulette (a conglomerate tier that no one should play seriously outside of this tournament) is a bit of a joke in terms of representation for the random battles community. I implore the mods and hosts to cut this useless tier regardless of whether the format changes or not. You can replace it with Battle Factory or Champions if 16 slots is desired.

=======================
 
Last edited:
goldmason said:
Please delete Random Roulette
hello all i am writing to inform you that we should NOT delete random roulette

to address some of the arguments made here for deleting:
- did i just read that a randbats player entering a randbats tournament is opposed to rng? hm okay strong start
- putting strong flex players in roulette makes for a competitive pool where these players can play to their strength of being versatile and skilled across the board. I would also argue that it doesn't really detract from the quality of other slots since there's plenty of good 'mainers' that prefer one particular gen, and it's generally easy to transfer good fundamentals from one gen to another in randbats. this means that the gens that are more unique (1,2,3?, 8?) won't lose out from having the strongest flex players available as they're harder to flex into anyway, and the other gens aren't starved for strong players that can flex in as it stands. so really it's good to put strong flex players into Roulette paradise.
- the argument about diluting the player pool in other gens is a bit brain dead because why stop at roulette? why not just have one slot per team for sv rands to ensure that we're seeing only the best of the best compete?

rest of the post is pretty reasonable ftr

i agree with sentiments of making roulette bo5, and overall think roulette is a valuable addition to the lineup since it's so unique in the skills that it rewards and has the potential to attract such strong competition
 
Last edited by a moderator:
goldmason said:
Please keep RBTT as a Snake Draft

One of the most unique and interesting things about RBTT is its snake draft style, which has not really taken off in any subforum on the site. Its charming, unique, and really fits especially since we have to draft for 14-16 slots. Especially in this tournament, an auction would really suck; budgeting up to 200k feels like it will be a much worse experience as a manager.

One thing I have not seen anywhere would be I think we should have at least 1 extra sub slot regardless of format, especially considering how many slots are in the tournament. Quite a few tournaments do 4 subs for 12 slots and we have 16.

Not super gung-ho about this but also consider adding a second manager selfbuy (probably Round 6? Also allows for the order to reset back instead of the weird half order we have now with selfbuys in Round 5 but not a big deal either way).

If you do do auction, please allow 2 selfbuys and up to 3 retains+selfbuys total like every other tour on the site, and set the selfbuys to 20k each. Also please set the budget to account for at least 5 subs.
I wholeheartedly agree with this. Snake draft is imo part of RBTT’s identity and tmk this is the only major tournament on the site that does this. I love it, and while the chaos of an auction draft can be more entertaining I remember talking with Amaranth last year about who we wanted to draft and in what order we wanted to grab people and I was pleasantly surprised to see its way more involved than I initially thought as a drafting method. I would love to see it stay.
 
Skimmed through the thread today to collect all the major talking points in one post and share my updated thoughts. Rambled a little for the last section but will be my last big post in the thread so who cares. Looking forward to the decisions made and the tour overall :)

Least contentious
8 v 10 teams: Consensus seems to be 8 teams is the sweet spot

RBTT Server: Obviously was a hit so bring it back this year, facilitates self-subbing/scheduling and is also just nice to have a designated place to hang out and talk with other players

Substitute activity: A sub does as a sub should, have good availability in case a starter cannot play - rands or not, some subs will sit on their thumbs the entire tour in 99% of tours on Smogon but at least in this one they get a free avatar

Self substitutions: No-brainer, managers can't and should not be expected to be available 24/7, people are competent enough to know how to self-sub (usually a case of just picking the person with more format-specific experience of the 2 people that will be available anyway)

Tier locks: Self-explanatory, no-brainer

Avatars/sign-ups: Give more time for artists to work on avatars, get manager sign ups earlier, possibly stagger RBTT start date so artists aren't under a crunch to get the avatars for it and SPL within a week of each other - can't really give concrete suggestions until we have timelines but everyone stands to benefit from a better communicated schedule in advance and less crunch

Best-of-5:
- SV1, Gen 1 (and BSSF if that remains this year) should all be Bo5, no one has issues with these
- Doubles, Roulette and HC (if the last two remain this year) could be Bo5 too - in the event we have two doubles slots, obviously only the first should be Bo5

Activity wins: I don't think this even bears mentioning but follow the same protocol every tour has, which I think is players can call act 20m from ping or 30m from scheduled time, whichever is later? Whatever it is, codify it too so there's no room for misunderstanding

Somewhat contentious
No. of managers: Seems to be somewhat divisive. I don't think either choice will aggrieve the community though so shouldn't be something hosts dwell on much

No. of playing managers: If auction it should obviously be 2 (Hacker's suggestion of 20 each is probably fine and has the least headache), if snake idk I'd be fine with 2 (Round 4/5 or 5/6) but can stick with 1 to keep things simple

Max no. of players: Think it was only mentioned by myself and 1-2 other people but if we do go the way of auction, please add a max player cap. 14/16 starters + 4-5 sub slots is enough. I cannot emphasise how teams feel increasingly less like teams as you veer off into the 20s, the last thing I want is someone just drafting an army of 30 people just to donate avatars to their friends who do not give a fuck about rands or the tour

Retains: Not a fan of this anymore and don't think it should be implemented (for this year at least) - IF we do go with auction this year then we can revisit the conversation for RBTT 11. Will be heavily tied to whether we do 1) snake vs. auction and 2) franchises vs. standard teams anyway

Tiebreaks: Didn't really see anyone other than Ghost talk about this so that's why I'm putting it in this section but please make it clear before the tournament starts how it's going to be. Due to it being rands and more volatile, I would definitely want either 1) 5 best-of-threes OR 2) three best-of-fives. SV should obviously be one of those slots, as is tradition. I don't think people will mind whichever of the two it is, but just codify these things so we don't run into issues mid-tour

Implementation of Roulette (if it is to stay): I am not in favour of ideas like submitting formats nor pick-ban because it will INEVITABLY result in some formats getting underrepresented (which did not happen last year) and also goes against the 'spirit' of Roulette. I think making it Bo5 is the easiest way to ensure you see a variety of formats without compromising said spirit AND makes sense given the fact it draws in stronger players who you'd otherwise see in Bo5, so naturally I/you (as a player) would like to see them play more

RBTT IX roulette gen appearance rates
Ordered by appearance
Gen 8: 14/84
Gen 5: 11/84
Gen 1: 10/84
Gen 7: 10/84
Gen 2: 9/84
Gen 3: 9/84
Gen 9: 9/84
Gen 6: 8/84
Gen 4: 4/84
Underlying data
Week 1
Piyu v GeniusX: 7 / 6
R1C3M4N v betathunder: 3 / 8 / 7
livid washed v Trade: 9 / 5 / 7
MichaelderBeste2 v violet river: 1 / 9 / 3

Week 2
livid washed v betathunder: 7 / 9 / 2
R1C3M4N v Piyu: 6 / 1 / 7
Trade v Amaranth: 1 / 8
MichaelderBeste2 v HaunterBoy28: 2 / 5 / 4

Week 3
livid washed v Piyu: 5 / 7
R1C3M4N v MichaelderBeste2: 8 / 4 / 8
Trade v betathunder: 3 / 8 / 1
HaunterBoy28 v Amaranth: 4 / 9

Week 4
livid washed v MichaelderBeste2: 1 / 6
R1C3M4N v zioziotrip: 9 / 8 / 9
Piyu v Trade: 3 / 3
betathunder v violet river: 8 / 4 / 1

Week 5
livid washed v HaunterBoy28: 6 / 9 / 8
R1C3M4N v LoSconosciuto: 1 / 2 / 8
Piyu v betathunder: 5 / 2 / 9
MichaelderBeste2 v Trade: 1 / 8 / 7

Week 6
livid washed v R1C3M4N: 3 / 5 / 7
Piyu v LoSconosciuto: 3 / 6
Trade v HaunterBoy28: 1 / 5 / 1
MichaelderBeste2 v betathunder: 6 / 5

Week 7
livid washed v violet river: 8 / 6 / 5
R1C3M4N v Trade: 5 / 7
Piyu v MichaelderBeste2: 7 / 3
HaunterBoy28 v hammy3581: 2 / 2 / 9

Semis
livid washed v Trade (tiebreak): 2 / 2
livid washed v Trade: 2 / 8 / 5
HaunterBoy28 v betathunder: 3 / 8

Finals
betathunder v Trade: 5 / 6 / 8

Most contentious
Snake vs. Auction
Same as my original post, don't feel super strongly either way but if I had to pick, I'm like 20% more keen on snake than I am auction - snake is one of the few things that differentiates us from other tours on this site, has its own charm, inherently leads to more balanced teams etc. Just one sentiment in this thread that I'd like to reject though, which is that we should try new things simply because it's the tenth edition - I do not believe that should have any bearing on RBTT X in the slightest. If hosts wish to implement changes, it should simply be because it'd be for the betterment of the tour, not because of some boredom-induced desire for novelty.

Number of (starting) slots
I'm actually leaning 14 after having time to dwell on it... there are a few gripes I had last year as both a manager and a player that I didn't really recall until reading through the thread and discussing with other people.

1) Absolute slog to watch and keep up with that many games. Not to say people are watching ALL 12 or 14 if we were to downsize but it just worsens the issue

2) Minimises your individual contribution - you feel less like you're playing on a team and more of a disjointed army

3) Results in less scrutiny with regards to what formats we go with (which I'll explore below) - 16 slots definitely appeases the most playerbases but I do not feel the justifications/arguments made for some formats in this thread have been that strong and don't want 16 slots IF it's just a way to get out of making a difficult decision. If 16 slots is deemed apt for a variety of reasons then that's fine

I understand that 16 is the easiest way to appease the most playerbases and I'm sure the majority of people would not fault hosts if they do decide to go with 16. But at the end of the day, it feels more like a team when each individual slot matters more and every format should be subject to scrutiny regarding their inclusion so we don't end up with a bloated tour.

Formats
I believe soTsoT was the first to make a concrete point about this but I do like the idea that RBTT should have a unique identity - standard formats are already well represented in Circuit and WCOR, we can definitely stand to push the envelope a bit more here. I am also not against walking away from 1-9 + Dubs being considered fixed slots due to some slots having poor distribution of skilled players but I don't think it's an idea with much traction for this tour and so, for this edition of RBTT, I'll be working under the assumption that the vast majority of players are okay with 1-9 + 9 Bo5 + Dubs all being mandatory slots.

So, what formats are we working with for the remaining 3-5 slots? From combing through this thread and applying some of my own judgement/bias, I believe the following are all in consideration:

- SV3, Champions Singles, Doubles 2, BSSF, Hackmons, Roulette, B12P6

BSSF: Firstly, I'd like to reiterate that I personally am not a fan of including BSSF - I do not believe there is a strong playerbase for it, it is not healthy for the tour to have a format with such a skewed distribution of skill in its playerbase (i.e. some overwhelmingly strong players and a bunch of gambles) (yes the same could be said for some standard formats, please read above) and using BSSCL as an example is a weak argument to me because the BSSF pool there was not particularly strong either so people having great records in it doesn't mean as much to me. Not in the circuit and no ladder either, quite literally the same reasons we cut Battle Factory and at least that had some niche as being a format any tours player could quickly pick up.

Hackmons: I am also not a fan of Hackmons - it is, to me, the format that requires the least skill compared to any other in the tour. That does NOT mean I am calling it skill-less, just saying it's the weakest of the bunch. It is also represented in HCPL so, like BSSF, it now has a tour outside of RBTT for fans of the format. DESPITE me saying that, in the spirit of format diversity, I am okay with keeping Hackmons in RBTT by virtue of it having 1) a bigger player pool, 2) being represented in the Circuit.

Champions/SV3: Champions' inherent format volatility is not appealing to me from a balancing perspective and I'd personally favour an SV3 slot but I think swapping out SV3 for Champions is inoffensive. May as well embrace Champs sooner than later given it's going to be The Main Thing moving forward.

The Rest: So under a 14-slot framework, that's 11 default slots + HC + Champions, leaving 14th for Doubles 2, Roulette or B12P6, and I wouldn't care which of those make it tbh. Doubles 2 probably ""warrants"" the slot the most given how many people play it. Vehemently against Champions Doubles though, if you're going to include another Doubles slot just make it SV Doubles and also make Doubles 1 Bo5. Roulette and B12P6 (with maybe some mods to make it more balanced) are more ""unique"" though so may fit the diversity quota better. Of course, you could also just make it 16 slots and include all three? Or SV3/BSSF? Who knows. I'd still prefer 14 slots but I get it, I'm not the host making difficult decisions so not gonna be too pushy on that front.

TLDR
14 format = 1-8 + two 9s + Dubs + HC + Champs + Dubs2/Roulette/B12P6

16 format = 1-8 + two 9s + two Dubs + HC + Champs + Roulette + SV3/B12P6

Gen 1, SV1, Doubles 1, HC, BSSF and Roulette should all be Best of 5, should they be included.

Franchising
Between the posts here and discussions on Discord, I still don't feel convinced about the necessity of franchises - for one, I don't think there's even a consensus as to how people want to implement franchises (should it be one fixed name/mascot, should it rotate every X years, should each team have a theme etc.) and even if we're to proceed with it, I don't think a lot of the teams last year lend themselves to being franchised. I also don't think the argument of 'burden on artists' applies fully since even with franchises most will elect for new poses, trainers and effects, it's not like most will opt to reuse assets. If we want to lessen their burden, give them/managers more time!

That being said, whilst not necessary, I still think franchises would be cool in some format. In particular, I personally like having some kind of type-themed franchises and having the mascots for those change every 2-3 years? Or maybe we keep the classic structure of 'use any legendary' but limit the pool, e.g. just one of mythicals/sub-legends/box-legends? Idk exactly, but if we have no consensus right now then I see no reason to force last years teams on this years managers.
 
A Cake Wearing A Hat said:
(disclaimer: I am not the one making the big decisions this RBTT, do not take what I'm saying as gospel)

If we really want some shenanigans we could try to really open up the roulette slot and turn it into "each team picks ANY one random format and the third game is one pop of Roulette"

It'd be the ultimate test of versatility and could be a great use of the team's subs, since the subs are often meant to be generally alright at anything needed

Plus it'd be cool as hell.
Would y'all be willing to weigh in on this idea? We're seriously considering it. We want to change something about the Roulette slot that isn't just doing !roll 9 and pretending it's roulette if the players like the result, and this is the closest we've gotten to something concrete on that front. We internally mostly have everything else decided, it's just the Roulette slot (or what it would otherwise be) that we have yet to determine. We specifically want something that can either highlight the subs or reward versatility, like the Mystery Box or Roulette slots of old, but all the ideas we've done in previous iterations have been duds.

Plus, if we do end up doing this, folks can play battle factory if they want...

edit: we can also just do bo5 roulette if y'all wanna be Boring (no actual judgement in this)
 
Last edited:
A Cake Wearing A Hat said:
Would y'all be willing to weigh in on this idea? We're seriously considering it. We want to change something about the Roulette slot that isn't just doing !roll 9 and pretending it's roulette if the players like the result, and this is the closest we've gotten to something concrete on that front. We internally mostly have everything else decided, it's just the Roulette slot (or what it would otherwise be) that we have yet to determine. We specifically want something that can either highlight the subs or reward versatility, like the Mystery Box or Roulette slots of old, but all the ideas we've done in previous iterations have been duds.

Plus, if we do end up doing this, folks can play battle factory if they want...
Why not just feature 3 games of battle factory instead? Battle factory includes 6 different tiers, which rewards versatility to the utmost degree! Moreover, teambuilding is an important factor in modern tiers, allowing subs to provide value beyond just being there in case a starter misses their game time. In my opinion, the optimal roulette format is 3 games of hard fought battles in generation 9 battle factory.
 
So i don't have the patience to read a bunch of book length posts on here to see how i should write, but i would like to put forth the meta that i am most passionate about, gan 9 blitz. there's 2 bo3 gen 9 slots and also some less popular metas from what i've been hearing through passing. I believe that it is a reasonable proposal to add blitz to the lineup. Any blitz player can play gen 9 rands, but not every gen 9 rands can play good blitz. It rewards thinking on your feet making adjustments to keep up with your opponent while also securing your own path of victory while not giving you the time to consult the calcs for long periods of time, at most you can calc with showdex 1 or 2 possibilities before your time is up. Players who can't think fast end up having to sack a mon or two while they try to come up with answers to a sweeper or other threat. The blitz ladder is one of the most competitive ladder rivaling or dwarfing most (i can only go off of elo and when i search to spectate public game numbers as i have asked but there is no tracking the total games played.) The blitz ladder is the 3rd biggest i believe on the coattails of randdubs and many of the top players on the ladder i don't see in any sort of team tournaments as they prefer to just play blitz and are not all that interested in regular gen 9 like myself. This I guess is my big pitch, it would connect a long excluded subsection and raise attendance for sign ups for this and hopefully trickle into being reoccurring players in other rands tournaments. blitz doesn't have a presence on rands smogon yet but we will have to break in somehow.
 
AquaGuy2.0 said:
So i don't have the patience to read
AquaGuy2.0 said:
I believe that it is a reasonable proposal to add blitz to the lineup
Absolute cinema

In all seriousness, I don't think blitz is a good idea due to connectivity reasons, access to showdex, etc. There are definitely better alternatives which i discuss below.

also, RE:
AquaGuy2.0 said:
blitz doesn't have a presence on rands smogon yet but we will have to break in somehow.
I hosted a blitz tour two years ago and am planning to bring it back once i have the time to host a swiss version and am not getting shafted by IRL. I'll make sure to ping you when it happens!



I briefly skimmed the thread, it seems most of the topics have been finalized but i figured id drop my two cents on some of the more contentious items.

textdump
Franchising: I can't remember who made this point (probably 35Q71N) but I think if the plan is franchising, then there should be more effort in developing themes for each team as opposed to just trying to design something around one legendary. Expand the pool of viable pokemon as mascots, trying to transition from legendaries as mascots to legendaries with specific themes in terms of name, design, etc just felt too hamstringed.

Snake Draft: Do a snake draft this year. Personally, I think that if the plan is to move towards auctions and retains, it needs to be decided well in advance of the tour. If people really really want it, we can do it next year and start fresh with auctions and the concept of retains for franchises; but right now, I feel that we are too late in the game to be deciding this right now.

New Formats: first to go should be sv3, then dubs 2. HC/BSSF are integral and have dedicated playerbases. IMO SV3 should be replaced with another SV based tier (CAP, baby, or B12P6 ig?). I have played a bunch of B12P6 and agree with the others who have said some abilities need to be regulated. However, said abilities aren't super common and don't feel as oppressive/different from other bad MU that are inherent in rands, but balancing them is probably the best.

Battle factory still feels like MU simulator but with the bonus of having preview, but if there are enough dedicated people for it sure, why not. I'll push the narrative to even crazier ideas (chimera 1v1 bo7? Making a mystery box slot that is just spotlight formats?). I would advocate for replacing SV3/Dubs2 with champ and champ dubs, but it seems that people think the formats are too green to include.

To those who are saying gen2/3 and others should be cut due to lack of competent/interested players, I would rather cut said formats from wcor than rbtt. IMO rbtt is supposed to be the flagship tour for showing the best of the best in rands; therefore it makes more sense to me to cut less-played formats from the tour that would require more people to sign up for it than the tour with a capped number of teams?

Roulette hate makes no sense to me - it is by definition IMO the truest expression of rands skill as it requires knowledge of how team generation works, as well as each gen's mechanics. I would support an all-gen bo9 slot but i can understand fatigue and scheduling would make that hellish in a practical setting.

Realistically though we should go back to our roots and bring back mono rands and super staff bros to RBTT. not a racist i want my runback
 
betathunder said:
Absolute cinema

In all seriousness, I don't think blitz is a good idea due to connectivity reasons, access to showdex, etc. There are definitely better alternatives which i discuss below

I briefly skimmed the thread, it seems most of the topics have been finalized but i figured id drop my two cents on some of the more contentious items.

textdump
Franchising: I can't remember who made this point (probably 35Q71N) but I think if the plan is franchising, then there should be more effort in developing themes for each team as opposed to just trying to design something around one legendary. Expand the pool of viable pokemon as mascots, trying to transition from legendaries as mascots to legendaries with specific themes in terms of name, design, etc just felt too hamstringed.

Snake Draft: Do a snake draft this year. Personally, I think that if the plan is to move towards auctions and retains, it needs to be decided well in advance of the tour. If people really really want it, we can do it next year and start fresh with auctions and the concept of retains for franchises; but right now, I feel that we are too late in the game to be deciding this right now.

New Formats: first to go should be sv3, then dubs 2. HC/BSSF are integral and have dedicated playerbases. IMO SV3 should be replaced with another SV based tier (CAP, baby, or B12P6 ig?). I have played a bunch of B12P6 and agree with the others who have said some abilities need to be regulated. However, said abilities aren't super common and don't feel as oppressive/different from other bad MU that are inherent in rands, but balancing them is probably the best.

Battle factory still feels like MU simulator but with the bonus of having preview, but if there are enough dedicated people for it sure, why not. I'll push the narrative to even crazier ideas (chimera 1v1 bo7? Making a mystery box slot that is just spotlight formats?). I would advocate for replacing SV3/Dubs2 with champ and champ dubs, but it seems that people think the formats are too green to include.

To those who are saying gen2/3 and others should be cut due to lack of competent/interested players, I would rather cut said formats from wcor than rbtt. IMO rbtt is supposed to be the flagship tour for showing the best of the best in rands; therefore it makes more sense to me to cut less-played formats from the tour that would require more people to sign up for it than the tour with a capped number of teams?

Roulette hate makes no sense to me - it is by definition IMO the truest expression of rands skill as it requires knowledge of how team generation works, as well as each gen's mechanics. I would support an all-gen bo9 slot but i can understand fatigue and scheduling would make that hellish in a practical setting.


Realistically though we should go back to our roots and bring back mono rands and super staff bros to RBTT. not a racist i want my runback
It does seem like things are more or so settled so i figured i'd put a response for those who do like reading this thread and may be dissuaded of adding it to any future tournaments. For the blitz concerns as i don't want to have this thought hinder the possibility of blitz being a part of team tournament or having it's own standalone tournament in the future. People who should be signing up to play blitz in rbtt, rbel, or any type of team tournament format should be the best blitz players and people who have a history of connection issues would be highly unlikely to be high rated blitz players as they would lose too much elo from disconnections. As for the showdex concern in every team tour i've been in the managers have always let me and my teammate know of showdex and for non team tournaments putting a link or a little note in the sign up post for the tournament should suffice giving everyone who takes it serious an equal opportunity to gain knowledge of it. Blitz is very popular for the high skill ceiling and the fast paced matches that start from turn one and doesn't slow till the end of the game, it is a format that is great to watch live and to experience first hand. With how active the ladder is if you go looking asking for the best blitz players they will come we know how to handle the format and we will put on fantastic showings if given the chance!
 
AquaGuy2.0 said:
It does seem like things are more or so settled so i figured i'd put a response for those who do like reading this thread and may be dissuaded of adding it to any future tournaments. For the blitz concerns as i don't want to have this thought hinder the possibility of blitz being a part of team tournament or having it's own standalone tournament in the future. People who should be signing up to play blitz in rbtt, rbel, or any type of team tournament format should be the best blitz players and people who have a history of connection issues would be highly unlikely to be high rated blitz players as they would lose too much elo from disconnections. As for the showdex concern in every team tour i've been in the managers have always let me and my teammate know of showdex and for non team tournaments putting a link or a little note in the sign up post for the tournament should suffice giving everyone who takes it serious an equal opportunity to gain knowledge of it. Blitz is very popular for the high skill ceiling and the fast paced matches that start from turn one and doesn't slow till the end of the game, it is a format that is great to watch live and to experience first hand. With how active the ladder is if you go looking asking for the best blitz players they will come we know how to handle the format and we will put on fantastic showings if given the chance!

My concern with showdex is moreso that there have been reports previously of it significantly lagging browsers, which may prevent certain people from installing it and using it effectively in a blitz match. Obviously when there is such a short timer, having a built in calc that auto-updates is preferred to manual calcing and those who can effectively utilize showdex due to their hardware are inherently advantaged over those who can't.

Perhaps your point of "the best blitz players don't have connection issues" is true, but i'd rather people's draft stock for any tier be determined by their innate skill, not how reliable their connection is or the strength of their PC. Further, timer losses are already upsetting/not ideal as is, and i am sure that blitz would further exacerbate this. There is also the spectator aspect of a bo5 blitz being hard to follow/catch live, etc. etc. I do think blitz rands is fun and enjoyable to play, but IMO I would rather pilot it in another (team) tour first before immediately adding it to RBTT.
 
Quick answer to Paysa and Cake(dunno how useful it can still be with hosts having decided the most of it but it's worth to try)

PAYSA
I agree on basically everything Paysa said. I expecially think his 14 slots lineup (with dubs 2) is AMAZING.
Teams too big can be hard to deal with(or to feel an important part of as he said) for both managers and players, taking into account that more starting slots you have the more subs you also have.

I think that's the way to go, with the main question being "do we want Champions?"
If we don't want to, instead of champs you go sv3 or roulette and you have the two doubles with one bo5.
If we want, the 2nd dubs becomes champs.

About champs dubs i disagree with Paysa. IF you trust champs to take the place of sv3, you should trust champs dubs to be able to do so as well for dubs2. If we decide it's the future, i'm sure the dubs community will adapt to that. (They just nerfed rock slide in champs as i'm writing this, legendary!!!)

I unfortunately think BSSF can stay only on a 16 formats scenario, which i don't hate but i don't support anymore either.
To me it would definitely have the priority over Battle Factory or other unmentioned stuff though.

I still also slightly prefer auction Paysa, expecially with no retains.

CAKE
The roulette idea sounds fun, but i'm not sure how it would really bring subs to do something. With how much flexibility you would need, arguably more than the regular one now(battle factory, dubs, and every colorful existing rands format), you are definitely just slotting your best and well rounded clicker there without thinking twice. Expecially considering a guaranteed roulette game!

Also subs sometimes are people who cannot play in the week/they are taking a rest for reasons...if we are thinking something for them it should be as flexible as possible but also not "okay just choose your best available player and go ahead unless he is injured" which was clearly former roulette direction. I don't think a roulette slot is the right way to do this, unfortunately.

I think subs can already be engaged with practice, fun teams environments(having fun with the custom will help here even if it's not enough obviously) and be ready to play for their specific formats when needed.
This is also the reason why i support Paysa's point of having a team to focus on and not an army of people that ends up doing nothing and feel forgotten.

Aside from subs, i don't personally like it as Roulette new direction...i don't think there is more than 1 person that can play literally every existing rands format on a good level (or someone who enjoy all of them if we consider this) and i think the format being overly competitive by itself doesn't align well with the fun/chaotic element you would expect from this choice.
 
betathunder said:
My concern with showdex is moreso that there have been reports previously of it significantly lagging browsers, which may prevent certain people from installing it and using it effectively in a blitz match. Obviously when there is such a short timer, having a built in calc that auto-updates is preferred to manual calcing and those who can effectively utilize showdex due to their hardware are inherently advantaged over those who can't.

Perhaps your point of "the best blitz players don't have connection issues" is true, but i'd rather people's draft stock for any tier be determined by their innate skill, not how reliable their connection is or the strength of their PC. Further, timer losses are already upsetting/not ideal as is, and i am sure that blitz would further exacerbate this. There is also the spectator aspect of a bo5 blitz being hard to follow/catch live, etc. etc. I do think blitz rands is fun and enjoyable to play, but IMO I would rather pilot it in another (team) tour first before immediately adding it to RBTT.
So this'll i guess be my closing statement as i don't want to make the thread a back and forth on blitz and i see that i didn't tackle it at quite the right angle the first time. Showdex does lag for me when i first start playing blitz every single time, but after thousands of games with showdex i have realized that if you just queue the format one time and have showdex load up properly into one blitz game it will load up right away in any blitz game after, so you just make a heads up to the managers to let their blitz player know this fact and the players can easily queue up a ladder blitz game or a friendly a minute or so before their match have it properly load up and then on turn 1 it should be fine unless there's some cases that i am not made aware of but no one in the blitz circle has brought it up to me that they have any other type of issue, and of course this should only really be a matter of the blitz player slot which managers who are looking for talent i'd argue can and should ask their blitz players if they experience any issues with it.

For your reasoning on well some of the best blitz players might have connection issues i really don't see this being the case. The best blitz players are the ones who play blitz and the ones who play blitz will be at the top of the ladder. my concern is with this line of thinking it's more so a let's grab top regluar gen 9 players and slot them in blitz even though they aren't known in the blitz circle. I believe that blitz players should be drafted to play high level blitz and not gen 9 players unless they have a standout record in the scene and even then you can just draft those guys to regular gen 9 slot.

Finally I don't think my push here will be enough with this being my first time bringing this idea forth and not having the chance to play in rbtt myself i don't have as much credibility, and so i decided when i made my first post that every single rands tour discussion thread i will make myself and my blitz opinion known from rbtt to rbel to wcor till i have a breakthrough this is me trying to crack the door open to try and stick my foot in the door in the future may it be soon or not so soon. (if there are any other questions, concerns, or comments about blitz i will be happy to answer them in the rands discord as to not flood here as i have no issues going on forever on blitz!)
 
AquaGuy2.0 said:
It does seem like things are more or so settled so i figured i'd put a response for those who do like reading this thread and may be dissuaded of adding it to any future tournaments. For the blitz concerns as i don't want to have this thought hinder the possibility of blitz being a part of team tournament or having it's own standalone tournament in the future. People who should be signing up to play blitz in rbtt, rbel, or any type of team tournament format should be the best blitz players and people who have a history of connection issues would be highly unlikely to be high rated blitz players as they would lose too much elo from disconnections. As for the showdex concern in every team tour i've been in the managers have always let me and my teammate know of showdex and for non team tournaments putting a link or a little note in the sign up post for the tournament should suffice giving everyone who takes it serious an equal opportunity to gain knowledge of it. Blitz is very popular for the high skill ceiling and the fast paced matches that start from turn one and doesn't slow till the end of the game, it is a format that is great to watch live and to experience first hand. With how active the ladder is if you go looking asking for the best blitz players they will come we know how to handle the format and we will put on fantastic showings if given the chance!
I think a blitz tourney would be great
 
I agree with Freya that I don't think the "each team chooses any tier" roulette idea would really be able to engage subs more, because even if you have a sub who is an expert at [whacky format], you would likely still rather slot your standard all-rounder because they have to play other tiers in the set as well. I would probably prefer to just keep roulette as is but make it best of 5.
 
Ye0GKY7ewtVRTZncdcN8nA.png

  • 8 teams
  • 14 slots, 16 is way too much ngl. formats at the end
  • Increase subs, even if it's by +1 per team.
  • 2 managers. literally no reason for a third other than gifting a free ca, unless 2x selfbuys are allowed, which i wouldnt rlly mind
  • keep self-substitution(if manager isnt around), best decision ever...
  • snake>auction especially for rbtt, I don't ever see a snake draft in any tour other than rbtt and would like to keep seeing it here, it makes this tour unique. Auction really isn't necessary unless:
  • Tbh not sure if auction is required for this but... Introduce franchises. I'm someone who would really be into franchises, maintaining some legacy, history, rivalry etc etc. I also don't like seeing completely different teams every year just so one can get different mascots for CA, really kills the hype for me. Also really like the concept of retains so thats another positive thing
  • If auction, selfbuys at 20k+ 30k fr...
  • Fully down for 1 single Randbats Discord server which would handle all the tours
formats
Gen 9 (Best of 5)
Gen 9
Gen 9
- Really didn't mind a third sv slot, plenty of very very good players. Would also not mind if it's gone but didnt know what else to add
Gen 8
Gen 7
Gen 6
Gen 5
Gen 4
Gen 3
Gen 2
Gen 1 (Best of 5)
Doubles
Roulette (Best of 3)
- Exactly what betathunder said. Also bo5 would be way too long imo, very limited amount of players would be keen to watch the whole series. Also kinda tiring for the player
Battle Factory- Free this af

Remove/Don't add:
Dubs 2
, I personally dont think the quality of gameplay is convincing enough to be stealing a slot from another tier.
Hc, hackmons hater since day 1. pure ragebait
Champions/Champions Dubs, no opinions on this tbh but haven't seen much activity here and would rather keep sv3 or the other mentioned formats
 
Last edited:
I don't know if I'll be able to write a second post but I wanted to prioritize this one, which has some moments of reflection on key parts of the tournament and it also covers some of the aspects that have been discussed less and some ideas I thought about that could hopefully improve the tournament as a whole.

On the identity of rbtt
I read almost all the posts in this thread and some of us, directly or indirectly, talked about the identity of RBTT and what it should represent. I tried to ask myself this question and I don't think I have a clear answer outside of certain key points (how surprising, isn't it?) so let's take a step back and analyze the fundamental elements of RBTT through the years:

1) Teams > ever since the second edition, the teams have always been 8 and the mascots have always been legendary or mythical pokemon.

2) Managers > manager spots used to be reserved to auths only until RBTT 8, when they got freed to non auths as well. RBTT 9 was also the first edition to introduce 3 managers.

3) Prizes > from RBTT 2 to 5, the tournament gave a custom avatar to the winner. Given the enormous amount of signups, we are now able to give a custom to all the people who get drafted and a banner to the winners.

4) Formats > the formats obviously changed pretty much every year but I can say that the general trend, especially in the last 4-5 years, is that RBTT tried to cover almost all the main generations and other formats that were popular and "competitive". Since there was a discussion about controversial formats, I want to note that that Hackmons, BSSF and BF have always been in RBTT (outside of last year for BF), while a Mystery Box slot was there for a few editions.

5) Draft > it's always been a snake draft.

6) Structure of the tour and dates > RBTT always started in January and the formula is that of regular season, followed by semifinals and finals.

If it was for me, I would like to keep legendaries and mythicals as the mascots (for a more detailed "teams vs franchises" discussion, see below), same structure and the dates (maybe we can anticipate manager signups but that's it). I believe these are probably the elements that have best defined RBTT through the years and which would feel sad to leave behind. I can understand people saying snake draft is tied to RBTT's identity as well but I don't feel too strongly towards it (I'll probably mention something in the second post).

I consider RBTT as our most important and most competitive tournament we have. Yes, I know rands is "semi-competitive" at best and we should not take it too too seriously but we still have many amazing players which can showcase their talent despite the matchups. To me, guaranteeing that competitiveness embraces many aspects: efficient hosting and organization, selection of good managers with ties and interest in the community, a reasonable number of players and teams that should cover the great variety we have in rands without sacrificing the quality of the pools. About the formats, I think there are three criteria I would pick to determine if they are worthy of being included or not:

1) Competitiveness > possibly the most subjective of these criteria, it refers to how competitive a certain format is perceived to be.
2) Popularity > it refers to the popularity of a format mainly in terms of ladder activity
3) Representation in tournaments > it refers to the number of tournaments out there (not necessarily organized by us) that have a certain format as one of the slots. The more a format is represented in tournaments, the more likely it is that a quality playerbase is available to play it

Ideally, all the formats we have in RBTT should satisfy all 3 of these criteria and 2 should be the minimum to accept a format in the competition (for instance, Gen 8 probably satisfied 1 and 3 but the ladder is unfortunately inactive).

Moving on from formats, how should we try to differentiate RBTT from other tournaments?

RBTT vs other team tours on Smogon
Many of the changes to RBTT that happened in the last few years closely reflect the line SPL dictated (customs to all the draftees, 3 managers per team, self subs and even the ideas of having franchises and 10 teams). My question is: are we doing all of this because these changes are actively good for the tournament or are we doing them to imitate the premier Smogon tournament? I'd say that some of these changes are undoubtedly good (customs, self subs etc.) but we should definitely try to find ways to make RBTT diverse and unique from SPL and other major team tours. I believe the variety of formats, the teams (once again, see the section down below for teams vs franchises) and other minor aspects (role of the subs, tryout server) can all be enough to have a tournament we all are happy to play because it feels special and unque, even if structurally similar to your classic team tournament.

RBTT vs WCOR (and others rands team tournaments)
I agree both with soT, who made a good point when he said we should try to avoid RBTT and WCOR becoming almost the same tournaments in terms of formats, and with paysa saying that all the formats in the Circuit should appear in RBTT as well so that people can prove themselves in individual tournaments for a chance at getting drafted. I think this is still possible to achieve if we follow the "competitiveness + popularity + representation in tournaments" criteria I mentioned above. Pretty much all the main gens satisfy such criteria (Gen 2 might be more iffy but it's also getting another big change iirc) whereas some unique formats that are neither in WCOR or RBTT seem to mostly cover 2/3 of such criteria (Blitz, Champions, Shared Power, Roulette, BSSF, BF). It could be nice to run some tests (aka organize or spectate some tournaments that include these formats like BSSCL or the Liga Eventina De Randbats) to see if a playerbase is forming and if the formats are indeed as competitive as we want it to be.


Franchising
This is a more complicated topic and I'd like to discuss it in depth. From last year's discussion, I understood that franchises would allow artists to create cool avatars without having to deal with a very tight schedule, especially given the overlap with SPL. The other neat thing about franchises would be to create a brand identity for RBTT, in similar fashion to what other major tournaments on Smogon already do.

If anticipating the date of manager signups is enough to help artists do their job, that's great and something we should all aim to. Does this also mean getting rid of the franchises we tentatively established last year?
I admit I didn't even think about it but like Rogi is saying, some managers put effort (and even money) to create the logos and the teams under the premise that those would remain. Removing franchises outright would be a disservice in their regard but I admit that, if franchising is the end goal and we want RBTT to shine, we could have done much better, both in terms of pokemon chosen and in terms of "team identity".

Time to ramble
As I said above, franchises should establish a "team" or "brand identity" in my humble opinion. This can be achieved in multiple ways: do the team have a lore? Do they have a specific chant/motto? Do the avatars represent something unique? Do they have something unique they do in their server or in battle? I feel like there was (almost) nothing like that in RBTT 9. If you look at teams like "Flame Body Faction", "Mecha Magearnas", "Diamond Storms", their names and avatars are simply uninspiring in terms of concept. "Relic Song Royals", "Time Travelers", "Dark Moon Lunalas" and "Pyrite Phantoms" had some ideas in terms of name, logo, customs but I feel like they could have been developed more to create a proper franchise (I'll explain it more in detail when I discuss the Phantoms down below).
"All-Star Hoopers" are probably the only real attempt at creating an original identity, pairing the devilish psychic-dark pokemon with different characters that are involved with sports or activities all involving hoops (basketball, hula hoop, gymnastic rings, synchronized swimming etc.). I am not saying people need to like the concept, at all. I am just saying that it's clear that there was a theme that can also be used in the future as well.

Reworking a franchise: the Pyrite Phantoms
The logo has Marshadow as the centerpiece and references to Pokemon Colosseum since Pyrite Town gives half of the name to the team. The custom avatars have the mythical pokemon with two type of trainers, the thief and the karate-girl, who symbolize its dual typing. It doesn't seem like there is a real dialogue between the logo and the avatars and that's a shame. I don't see a big difference between the Pyrite Phantoms and, for instance, team Chi-Yu in RBTT 7, which is another team whose customs have characters that fit well with the fish.
Here is an idea I had that I hope can express my idea of team identity. The story behind the Marshadow team could be of that of a group of few elite fighters who have manage to unlock occult powers after years and years of training. The logo can reflect this idea, just like the avatars (you can use a dark aura outline for the fighters, you can make them levitate, you can turn them into a ghost-like creature etc.). You wanna take things to a different level? Paysa and co. could even create a channel in their server dedicated to gym stuff. It would be a way to break the ice and create a nice team atmosphere too! Heck, they could even establish a honor code that if you lose a match, you have to do a certain physical exercise as a punishment! Once again, these are just ideas and it's not like things need to be this articulated, but this level of care for the franchises is what I'd like to see. From my experience as a Hoopa, even the silly Hoop Hoop motto and changing our nicknames in the server to something related to the pokemon were enough to create a positive environment.

To summarize:
Team > often a one time only thing, even if the avatars are thematically coherent between mons and characters
Franchise > a theme that is expected to last in time and that should reflect the identity of the team

My opinion is that if we want to continue franchising, the teams need a big overhaul, along the lines of what I proposed above. I think it would be ok to keep the same franchises for at least 3 years and then people could try to change and introduce new teams and/or change mascots.
If we want to scrap them, I think it's ok to return to the "classic" system of RBTT with only legends/mythicals teams. Maybe we could force to guarantee that at least 3-4 teams from the previous edition(s) are kept in the present one too, in order to facilitate the job of the artists.


Miscellaneous

- Role of the subs > if we want to give a more prominent role to the subs, I came up with the idea of having some friendly matches between teams every week, probably in a 3v3 format. Every win is worth 100 reaction points but only the team winning RBTT will be able to cash in on this prize. This way, we can keep subs active and give them another purpose outside of covering for the starters. If the matches between subs don't get to be scheduled for any reasons, it's not a big deal and if a sub is called to replace a starter, they can play both games. We can also use this system to test if formats like Blitz, BP Shared Power etc. could be worthy of a slot in future iteractions of the tournament.
Note: I was looking at last year's discussions and it's not too far away from what Sharp posted.

- Additional prizes > see above for option #1. Alternatively, we could give only one avatar to each team and a second to the winning team but I think y'all would shoot me for this. I also thought about creating a MVP title in similar fashion to what happens now with WCOP, SCL and SPL. In my head, the winner would receive a mention in the Hall of Fame and a badge on their profile in the room. Heck, we could give them room prize winner as well.

- Prediction contest > I started doing this for Gen 9 swiss and then brought it back for WCOR Top 8 and Circuit Playoffs. I haven't given a prize yet but if we keep advertising it and we get more and more people to submit predictions, maybe we can finally unlock a prize (reaction scores?) for the winner.

- Streaming and RBTT weekends > I really like the idea Smogon had to stream notable SPL matches on Twitch on Sunday and I'd love to see something similar for RBTT. At the same time, I fully recognize there are some problems: 1) The inevitable overlap between SPL and RBTT means they will prioritize streaming SPL matches 2) Unlike tiers, many matches of our tournament are played before the weekend and it's not always guaranteed to find a certain range on Saturday or Sunday in which multiple games happen. Maybe we can do all of this in a more informal way in the RBTT server in a vc for spectators?

- Tryout server > it seems like it worked well last year so maybe we can propose it again with some new changed to improve the formula. The problem is finding someone else who can run everything in the coming weeks.
 
35Q71N said:
Maybe we can do all of this in a more informal way in the RBTT server in a vc for spectators?
Been saying for a while about some kind of RBTT coverage, and I think we can also do a coverage style vid where we go over some good matches from the week, share updates about the week's scores, points table and leaderboards, playoff implications etc.
As for where? Smogon's yt is kinda ded surely we can get goldmason to manage perms for us right?

Think it's worth a shot to see how it works out and I'd be absolutely down to help with something like that if needed
 
Back
Top