I don't know if I'll be able to write a second post but I wanted to prioritize this one, which has some moments of reflection on key parts of the tournament and it also covers some of the aspects that have been discussed less and some ideas I thought about that could hopefully improve the tournament as a whole.
On the identity of rbtt
I read almost all the posts in this thread and some of us, directly or indirectly, talked about the identity of RBTT and what it should represent. I tried to ask myself this question and I don't think I have a clear answer outside of certain key points (how surprising, isn't it?) so let's take a step back and analyze the fundamental elements of RBTT through the years:
1) Teams > ever since the second edition, the teams have always been 8 and the mascots have always been legendary or mythical pokemon.
2) Managers > manager spots used to be reserved to auths only until RBTT 8, when they got freed to non auths as well. RBTT 9 was also the first edition to introduce 3 managers.
3) Prizes > from RBTT 2 to 5, the tournament gave a custom avatar to the winner. Given the enormous amount of signups, we are now able to give a custom to all the people who get drafted and a banner to the winners.
4) Formats > the formats obviously changed pretty much every year but I can say that the general trend, especially in the last 4-5 years, is that RBTT tried to cover almost all the main generations and other formats that were popular and "competitive". Since there was a discussion about controversial formats, I want to note that that Hackmons, BSSF and BF have always been in RBTT (outside of last year for BF), while a Mystery Box slot was there for a few editions.
5) Draft > it's always been a snake draft.
6) Structure of the tour and dates > RBTT always started in January and the formula is that of regular season, followed by semifinals and finals.
If it was for me, I would like to keep legendaries and mythicals as the mascots (for a more detailed "teams vs franchises" discussion, see below), same structure and the dates (maybe we can anticipate manager signups but that's it). I believe these are probably the elements that have best defined RBTT through the years and which would feel sad to leave behind. I can understand people saying snake draft is tied to RBTT's identity as well but I don't feel too strongly towards it (I'll probably mention something in the second post).
I consider RBTT as our most important and most competitive tournament we have. Yes, I know rands is "semi-competitive" at best and we should not take it too too seriously but we still have many amazing players which can showcase their talent despite the matchups. To me, guaranteeing that competitiveness embraces many aspects: efficient hosting and organization, selection of good managers with ties and interest in the community, a reasonable number of players and teams that should cover the great variety we have in rands without sacrificing the quality of the pools. About the formats, I think there are three criteria I would pick to determine if they are worthy of being included or not:
1) Competitiveness > possibly the most subjective of these criteria, it refers to how competitive a certain format is perceived to be.
2) Popularity > it refers to the popularity of a format mainly in terms of ladder activity
3) Representation in tournaments > it refers to the number of tournaments out there (not necessarily organized by us) that have a certain format as one of the slots. The more a format is represented in tournaments, the more likely it is that a quality playerbase is available to play it
Ideally, all the formats we have in RBTT should satisfy all 3 of these criteria and 2 should be the minimum to accept a format in the competition (for instance, Gen 8 probably satisfied 1 and 3 but the ladder is unfortunately inactive).
Moving on from formats, how should we try to differentiate RBTT from other tournaments?
RBTT vs other team tours on Smogon
Many of the changes to RBTT that happened in the last few years closely reflect the line SPL dictated (customs to all the draftees, 3 managers per team, self subs and even the ideas of having franchises and 10 teams). My question is: are we doing all of this because these changes are actively good for the tournament or are we doing them to imitate the premier Smogon tournament? I'd say that some of these changes are undoubtedly good (customs, self subs etc.) but we should definitely try to find ways to make RBTT diverse and unique from SPL and other major team tours. I believe the variety of formats, the teams (once again, see the section down below for teams vs franchises) and other minor aspects (role of the subs, tryout server) can all be enough to have a tournament we all are happy to play because it feels special and unque, even if structurally similar to your classic team tournament.
RBTT vs WCOR (and others rands team tournaments)
I agree both with soT, who made a good point when he said we should try to avoid RBTT and WCOR becoming almost the same tournaments in terms of formats, and with paysa saying that all the formats in the Circuit should appear in RBTT as well so that people can prove themselves in individual tournaments for a chance at getting drafted. I think this is still possible to achieve if we follow the "competitiveness + popularity + representation in tournaments" criteria I mentioned above. Pretty much all the main gens satisfy such criteria (Gen 2 might be more iffy but it's also getting another big change iirc) whereas some unique formats that are neither in WCOR or RBTT seem to mostly cover 2/3 of such criteria (Blitz, Champions, Shared Power, Roulette, BSSF, BF). It could be nice to run some tests (aka organize or spectate some tournaments that include these formats like BSSCL or the Liga Eventina De Randbats) to see if a playerbase is forming and if the formats are indeed as competitive as we want it to be.
Franchising
This is a more complicated topic and I'd like to discuss it in depth. From last year's discussion, I understood that franchises would allow artists to create cool avatars without having to deal with a very tight schedule, especially given the overlap with SPL. The other neat thing about franchises would be to create a brand identity for RBTT, in similar fashion to what other major tournaments on Smogon already do.
If anticipating the date of manager signups is enough to help artists do their job, that's great and something we should all aim to. Does this also mean getting rid of the franchises we tentatively established last year?
I admit I didn't even think about it but like Rogi is saying, some managers put effort (and even money) to create the logos and the teams under the premise that those would remain. Removing franchises outright would be a disservice in their regard but I admit that, if franchising is the end goal and we want RBTT to shine, we could have done much better, both in terms of pokemon chosen and in terms of "team identity".
Time to ramble
As I said above, franchises should establish a "team" or "brand identity" in my humble opinion. This can be achieved in multiple ways: do the team have a lore? Do they have a specific chant/motto? Do the avatars represent something unique? Do they have something unique they do in their server or in battle? I feel like there was (almost) nothing like that in RBTT 9. If you look at teams like "Flame Body Faction", "Mecha Magearnas", "Diamond Storms", their names and avatars are simply uninspiring in terms of concept. "Relic Song Royals", "Time Travelers", "Dark Moon Lunalas" and "Pyrite Phantoms" had some ideas in terms of name, logo, customs but I feel like they could have been developed more to create a proper franchise (I'll explain it more in detail when I discuss the Phantoms down below).
"All-Star Hoopers" are probably the only real attempt at creating an original identity, pairing the devilish psychic-dark pokemon with different characters that are involved with sports or activities all involving hoops (basketball, hula hoop, gymnastic rings, synchronized swimming etc.). I am not saying people need to like the concept, at all. I am just saying that it's clear that there was a theme that can also be used in the future as well.
Reworking a franchise: the Pyrite Phantoms
The logo has Marshadow as the centerpiece and references to Pokemon Colosseum since Pyrite Town gives half of the name to the team. The custom avatars have the mythical pokemon with two type of trainers, the thief and the karate-girl, who symbolize its dual typing. It doesn't seem like there is a real dialogue between the logo and the avatars and that's a shame. I don't see a big difference between the Pyrite Phantoms and, for instance, team Chi-Yu in RBTT 7, which is another team whose customs have characters that fit well with the fish.
Here is an idea I had that I hope can express my idea of team identity. The story behind the Marshadow team could be of that of a group of few elite fighters who have manage to unlock occult powers after years and years of training. The logo can reflect this idea, just like the avatars (you can use a dark aura outline for the fighters, you can make them levitate, you can turn them into a ghost-like creature etc.). You wanna take things to a different level? Paysa and co. could even create a channel in their server dedicated to gym stuff. It would be a way to break the ice and create a nice team atmosphere too! Heck, they could even establish a honor code that if you lose a match, you have to do a certain physical exercise as a punishment! Once again, these are just ideas and it's not like things need to be this articulated, but this level of care for the franchises is what I'd like to see. From my experience as a Hoopa, even the silly Hoop Hoop motto and changing our nicknames in the server to something related to the pokemon were enough to create a positive environment.
To summarize:
Team > often a one time only thing, even if the avatars are thematically coherent between mons and characters
Franchise > a theme that is expected to last in time and that should reflect the identity of the team
My opinion is that if we want to continue franchising, the teams need a big overhaul, along the lines of what I proposed above. I think it would be ok to keep the same franchises for at least 3 years and then people could try to change and introduce new teams and/or change mascots.
If we want to scrap them, I think it's ok to return to the "classic" system of RBTT with only legends/mythicals teams. Maybe we could force to guarantee that at least 3-4 teams from the previous edition(s) are kept in the present one too, in order to facilitate the job of the artists.
Miscellaneous
-
Role of the subs > if we want to give a more prominent role to the subs, I came up with the idea of having some friendly matches between teams every week, probably in a 3v3 format. Every win is worth 100 reaction points but only the team winning RBTT will be able to cash in on this prize. This way, we can keep subs active and give them another purpose outside of covering for the starters. If the matches between subs don't get to be scheduled for any reasons, it's not a big deal and if a sub is called to replace a starter, they can play both games. We can also use this system to test if formats like Blitz, BP Shared Power etc. could be worthy of a slot in future iteractions of the tournament.
Note: I was looking at last year's discussions and it's not too far away from what Sharp
posted.
-
Additional prizes > see above for option #1. Alternatively, we could give only one avatar to each team and a second to the winning team but I think y'all would shoot me for this. I also thought about creating a MVP title in similar fashion to what happens now with WCOP, SCL and SPL. In my head, the winner would receive a mention in the Hall of Fame and a badge on their profile in the room. Heck, we could give them room prize winner as well.
-
Prediction contest > I started doing this for Gen 9 swiss and then brought it back for WCOR Top 8 and Circuit Playoffs. I haven't given a prize yet but if we keep advertising it and we get more and more people to submit predictions, maybe we can finally unlock a prize (reaction scores?) for the winner.
-
Streaming and RBTT weekends > I really like the idea Smogon had to stream notable SPL matches on Twitch on Sunday and I'd love to see something similar for RBTT. At the same time, I fully recognize there are some problems: 1) The inevitable overlap between SPL and RBTT means they will prioritize streaming SPL matches 2) Unlike tiers, many matches of our tournament are played before the weekend and it's not always guaranteed to find a certain range on Saturday or Sunday in which multiple games happen. Maybe we can do all of this in a more informal way in the RBTT server in a vc for spectators?
-
Tryout server > it seems like it worked well last year so maybe we can propose it again with some new changed to improve the formula. The problem is finding someone else who can run everything in the coming weeks.