At first I missed the list as well, so I can imagine others forgetting as well. Maybe post the list once more during the next round, maybe that'll help.
It's true that it's very subjective, so it's hardly worth going into discussion with others, since tastes differ. Still, it's fun to see what all the other's think of someone.
My ratings also end up above average, most of the time. Me and a couple others once made a comparable list in class, my average was more than half a point above average, on a 1-10 scale. I don't know if it's bad to be too appreciative :P