np: UU - Rain Drops Keep Falling on my Head

Status
Not open for further replies.
Steelix can Roar so it's pretty much a lost cause.

I used Magneton a bunch back in really old UU (wrote the analysis) and it was ok then. I've tried it a few times in current UU and it just doesn't perform very well. Middling Speed, weakness to common attacks, and its counters' ability to work around it (see: Roar, Seismic Toss) make it a pretty bad option.
 
is everyone just forgetting magnet pull or something which is like, the only reason to even use magneton ever?

I thought it was so completely obvious that it needn't be posted, maybe I was wrong...

And explosion is perhaps the best tool Magneton carries (other than Magnet Pull, before you say it) as it gets a strong hit in on something that Raikou hates; Chansey.

I think Raikou should stick to the CM sets. I'm not saying that specs isn't good, but just pointing out that Magneton is far from outclassed.
 
Posting to say that Dugtrio outclasses Magneton in every single way possible. Dugtrio is probably the best Pokemon in the UU tier - an all purpose Pokemon. When played correctly, its probably one of the best supporters in the game right now. I'm thinking of nominating it for suspect.
 
Holy shit.

...

Posting to say that Dugtrio outclasses Magneton in every single way possible. Dugtrio is probably the best Pokemon in the UU tier - an all purpose Pokemon. When played correctly, its probably one of the best supporters in the game right now. I'm thinking of nominating it for suspect.

Is Dugtrio a good supporter? Yes. Is it broken? Not in my opinion. I think the great speed and ability are countered by the fact that a light rain will KO it. If Dugtrio switches in with a bit less than 70% health, and it can only 2HKO the opponent, then you might end up losing. You could use Choice Band to secure the KOs and not hurt yourself even more with Life Orb recoil, but that turns you into set-up bait for any flier or levitator. It's good, but not broken (from my point of view at least).
 
...



Is Dugtrio a good supporter? Yes. Is it broken? Not in my opinion. I think the great speed and ability are countered by the fact that a light rain will KO it. If Dugtrio switches in with a bit less than 70% health, and it can only 2HKO the opponent, then you might end up losing. You could use Choice Band to secure the KOs and not hurt yourself even more with Life Orb recoil, but that turns you into set-up bait for any flier or levitator. It's good, but not broken (from my point of view at least).

I keep hearing this set up bait stuff and how Choice Band is terrible. Its only terrible when you don't prepare for the levitators who will potentially set up on you. Its really easy to check these threats. I promise people that the Choice Band set is completely better: packs more punch to OHKO certain stuff and you don't suffer the LO recoil. The only merit the Sub set has is to dodge Sucker Punch Hounds, other than that its an okay item on Dugtrio. I find it broken because it can be a destructive support Pokemon at any given time, even when its HP is low (thanks to its SR resistance and fast Speed). Dugtrio is one of the few who can be useful even at 6%.
 
Posting to say that Dugtrio outclasses Magneton in every single way possible. Dugtrio is probably the best Pokemon in the UU tier - an all purpose Pokemon. When played correctly, its probably one of the best supporters in the game right now. I'm thinking of nominating it for suspect.
Dugtrio can't kill Steels until they're at around 50% HP, as it will risk being either maimed or killed by the inevitable attack. Magneton can just come in and start setting up on Registeel or something, then maintain its sub to help it kill whatever comes in next

My biggest issue with Magneton is that while its typing is definitely handy, its defenses are still pretty weak, especially for its designated function. But still, I will not count on Dugtrio to kill Steels with its already incredibly short lifespan and middling offensive capabilies.
 
Posting to say that Dugtrio outclasses Magneton in every single way possible. Dugtrio is probably the best Pokemon in the UU tier - an all purpose Pokemon. When played correctly, its probably one of the best supporters in the game right now. I'm thinking of nominating it for suspect.

A good supporter does not mean broken. Is Forretress a good supporter?? He's excellent. Is he broken?? Hell no. This is exactly why I don't think the "banning every Suspect" idea wouldn't help one bit, because people would just nominate and ban any Pokemon that is good, leaving us with a metagame dominated by Luvdisc and Magikarp and that lot of crap.
 
I keep hearing this set up bait stuff and how Choice Band is terrible. Its only terrible when you don't prepare for the levitators who will potentially set up on you. Its really easy to check these threats. I promise people that the Choice Band set is completely better: packs more punch to OHKO certain stuff and you don't suffer the LO recoil. The only merit the Sub set has is to dodge Sucker Punch Hounds, other than that its an okay item on Dugtrio. I find it broken because it can be a destructive support Pokemon at any given time, even when its HP is low (thanks to its SR resistance and fast Speed). Dugtrio is one of the few who can be useful even at 6%.

I would actually call the Choice Band set bad.

Not only do you automatically lose your Dugtrio to stuff like Scyther and Swellow Pursuit, but you also give terrors such as Moltres a free turn. Not to mention getting fucked by Sucker Punch now.

Life Orb is always better. SubLO is also good.

No where near broken.
 
Dugtrio is annoying as fuck. (It screws over a huge amount sweepers)

It's not broken due to it's frailty imo. Just about ANYTHING will OHKO. Again (it's annoying) and it angers me that such a pokemon is used due it's ridiculous ability.

Dugtrio can't kill Steels until they're at around 50% HP, as it will risk being either maimed or killed by the inevitable attack. Magneton can just come in and start setting up on Registeel or something, then maintain its sub to help it kill whatever comes in next

Not entirely true. Jolly CB Dugtrio deals 69.1% minimum (69.2% - 81.3%)
You can potentially OHKO with 3 layers of spikes. Why do people ignore this fact?
Magneton CANNOT set up on Registeel if it runs Seismic toss which in my opinion is something ALL Registeel should run.



My biggest issue with Magneton is that while its typing is definitely handy, its defenses are still pretty weak, especially for its designated function. But still, I will not count on Dugtrio to kill Steels with its already incredibly short lifespan and middling offensive capabilies.

Why do you keep reffering to *Steels*
Only 3 prominent steels in UU are: Aggron, Registeel and Steelix.
A standard Registeel actually beats you with Seis-toss, and Steelix usually career roar. (something it should ALSO always carry)

You beat Aggron, but Headmash deals (60.4% - 71.6%)
If it RP on the switch, he can 2HKO with Headsmash.
You lose to Registeel (already said) and you do nothing to steelix. (and die if you switch in on EQ)

Dugtrio is much better trapper, and should almost always be considered over Magneton.
 
@ SJcrew

You see, Dugtrio doesn't need to OHKO these guys. The true fact is, they can't escape and the Steels can't OHKO Dugtrio except for the rare Gyro Ball Steelix or using Explosion. Regardless, his task is complete since they removed the Steel-types.

@ shrang

not once did i say dugtrio is good, i said dugtrio is great! Sure, Foretress is a good support Pokemon, but these are completely different Pokemon who gets their job done differently. Forry sets up Spikes and spins, while Dugtrio traps and kills. I'm not usually the one around to swing random bans, but if we look at Dugtrio as an overall picture, it can easily trap so many dedicated walls. maybe this guy is the reason why raikou is so broken, etc. from personal experience, the one doing most of the work to help raikou sweep sufficiently easier is dugtrio.

@ heysup

yeah there are drawbacks, but pursuit scyther and swellow are p. rare. You have to admit that. I'd rather keep the extra punch than get worried about something that is rare.
 
I occasionally use Soft Sand Dugtrio. Obviously bluffs the Choice Band and then bam! Dead Moltres/Mismag/Scyther/ w/e.

*Mismag ALWAYS attempts to setup and non-boosted Night Slash cuts its Hp low enough so she cannot sub.
* No recoil means Registeel cannot KO even if they predict right.

SoftSand is the BEST Dugtrio item.
 
well dugtrio for suspect is definitely interesting. It's great against defensive teams and not that great against offense but it can revenge kill blaziken toxicroak raikou etc quite easily so its not dead weight most of the time. against the majority of defensive teams it can take out a key pokemon (registeel, steelix, chansey etc.) which makes it much much easier for moltres or cm raikou to sweep (most stall teams don't double up on special bulk and shed shell is rare).

im surprisingly close to leaning towards BL for dugtrio (surprising because right now most people are "lol suspect") just because of its ability to trap defensive pokemon in such a unique way.

edit: to clarify I mean it "fulfills" the SC (in isolated instances) against specific defensive pokemon. it's trash against most of the rest. relative to the SC, it's good vs defense but good vs offense even though it probably won't ever get more than 1 kill vs defense and might get more vs offense.
 
well dugtrio for suspect is definitely interesting. It's great against defensive teams and not that great against offense but it can revenge kill blaziken toxicroak raikou etc quite easily so its not dead weight most of the time. against the majority of defensive teams it can take out a key pokemon (registeel, steelix, chansey etc.) which makes it much much easier for moltres or cm raikou to sweep (most stall teams don't double up on special bulk and shed shell is rare).

I don't buy it. The way I view it, that is just a testament to how powerful Moltres and Raikou can be. The fact that there are so few options available to safely switch in on Moltres especially lends itself to the fact that Moltres is more the issue, not Dugtrio. Without Dugtrio you can really hurt the prospects of other 'lower class' special sweepers, such as Exeggutor etc.
 
I wouldn't mind that much if Dugtrio was shipped of to BL. Fantatic tool though.

Moltres/Froslass/Raikou are still my number 1 priority for BL.
 
Wow are you guys kidding? Nobody even looked at Dugtrio before, and now one person thinks its maybe BL and now at least two others are hopping on the bandwagon. No wonder so many people are hyped up about Froslass/Raikou/Moltres (even though we all three could have been taken out last round)
 
The metagame is already far too stall focused, its ludicrous to suggest dugtrio is broken. I think stall users want it banned because they dont like having their walls trapped... seriously put a shed shell on it and stop crying. In fact, I believe the main reason behind this sudden fad is a byproduct of Raikou being such a potent threat. Ban Raikou, not Dugtrio.
 
Hmm... Dugtrio is too frail and has many "checks" (well... it doesn't really). And it doesn't hit as hard as we would like.
Best "checks" for it are bulky grasses (especially Torterra, who can be a nightmare if it gets a RP... something it can easily get against Duggie.)
 
well dugtrio does have access to AA.. doing 35.6% - 42.3% to torterra... which can really f up its sweep when u have that + life orb + entry hazards + using woodhammer ever

but i am not even saying dugtrio is suspect worthy. that is just... lame.
 
You can potentially OHKO with 3 layers of spikes. Why do people ignore this fact?
Because it's stupid to assume three layers of Spikes are down every time you want something OHKOed. Some teams don't even use Spikes. Spikes is a popular strategy in UU these days, but people are really abusing this fact to make horrible arguments.

Besides, the LO set is much more popular these days, so in reality, the numbers look like this: 59.3% - 69.8%

Either way, Dugtrio is going to incur some massive damage.

Magneton CANNOT set up on Registeel if it runs Seismic toss which in my opinion is something ALL Registeel should run.
Of course they should, even though it's less practical than running EQ and Iron Head and makes it easier setup bait for Mismagius or Raikou. Regardless of what Registeel runs, Magneton is going to kill it and there's nothing you can do about it.

Why do you keep reffering to *Steels*
Um, because that is their typing? Steel? Yes there are only a few, but it's a worthy cause if the only thing between me and a Raikou sweep is Registeel or Steelix.

You beat Aggron, but Headmash deals (60.4% - 71.6%)
I really wouldn't count on Magneton beating Aggron unless it can get in on the revenge while it hasn't used a Sub or Rock Polish.

Steelix usually career roar.
lol, no they don't. It's not even an option on the standard set. The only place I see a Roar Steelix is on a Stall team, which is generally just to rack up damage from entry hazards.

Dugtrio is much better trapper, and should almost always be considered over Magneton.
No shit? There's just far less risk for Magneton to switch right into Steelix or Registeel and make sure they die so that my sweepers won't have to face them. Once they're dead, just use that awesome base 120 Sp. Att to kill bulky Waters or just explode on something.

Alternatively I could also use both and get a free Raikou sweep for my troubles. Really, that's the only reason I'd even consider using Magneton, personally. Dugtrio is obviously going to be the better revenge killer, since its ability keeps any that doesn't float in place and allows it to get a guaranteed kill, but Magnezone's niche is much smaller and it's better to use that if you can't afford to pack another frail Pokemon and you're only worried about the odd Steel type. Not a very common occurence, but at least it does something.

You see, Dugtrio doesn't need to OHKO these guys. The true fact is, they can't escape and the Steels can't OHKO Dugtrio except for the rare Gyro Ball Steelix or using Explosion. Regardless, his task is complete since they removed the Steel-types.
Dugtrio can still kill more Pokemon if you don't go out there and suicide him like an idiot. If you send him out to kill Registeel prematurely, he will get hit by Iron Head and LO recoil, then revenged by something else, since there's no point in you'll let him die (not like you have a choice if there are any Spikes down), then Raikou or whatever shows up. Whoops, bad idea. Oh, and all Steelix run Gyro Ball, so there's no way I'm coming in on that thing until at least half its health is gone.

I would really prefer to keep Dugtrio alive as long as possible to make sure it kills anything on your team that might pose a threat to one of my sweepers. Sending it in on Steelix or Registeel right away is just plain silly.
 
the thing with Dugtrio is that it isn't very offensively threatening in the classical sense. it can't sweep teams easily and is easily walled by the majority of the tier and it seems like people confuse that with being automatically not broken. it can't sweep teams, and rarely gets more than one kill. but it does what it's supposed to do very well, almost too well. it's true that if your opponent doesn't have a pokemon that you can trap on your team, Dugtrio is basically deadweight. but if they do have that pokemon they probably are counting on it as one of if not their only hard counter to something which means Dugtrio can make it a lot easier for your sweeper.

Wow are you guys kidding? Nobody even looked at Dugtrio before, and now one person thinks its maybe BL and now at least two others are hopping on the bandwagon. No wonder so many people are hyped up about Froslass/Raikou/Moltres (even though we all three could have been taken out last round)
im sure im just hoppin' on the bandwagon cause I can't think for myself

edit: in fact I'm almost certain I brought up Dugtrio as a potential suspect for roughly these same reasons in #stark a month or two ago

Smurf. said:
The metagame is already far too stall focused, its ludicrous to suggest dugtrio is broken. I think stall users want it banned because they dont like having their walls trapped... seriously put a shed shell on it and stop crying. In fact, I believe the main reason behind this sudden fad is a byproduct of Raikou being such a potent threat. Ban Raikou, not Dugtrio.

I have played probably 3 games of stall and 200 games of offense this round and I know franky has also been laddering almost exclusively with an offense team built around Dugtrio as well. nice ad hom attack, didn't work.

Dugtrio makes it substantially easier for Raikou to sweep regardless of how good Raikou is in the first place. it still has plenty of checks and even some counters (Registeel, Chansey, Umbreon, since RestTalk Calm Mind is almost never seen) but Dugtrio eliminates 95%+ of the counters that are vulnerable to it (all those without Shed Shell), which is a LOT of the specially defensive Pokemon in UU.

granted, Shed Shell is a major problem for Dugtrio based teams because they depend so much on it to take out specific walls. this big drawback should however be weighed in proportion to the number of Pokemon that actually use Shed Shell and it seems like there simply aren't enough of them running around to balance it out.

M BLADE said:
Hmm... Dugtrio is too frail and has many "checks" (well... it doesn't really). And it doesn't hit as hard as we would like.

its easy to focus on its flaws but the problem I see is that it can trap specific parts of a team and take them out even if it has to sacrifice its HP to do so. it hits "hard enough" for what it needs to do even if it very clearly cannot hold up to the bulk of the defensive Pokemon in UU (Milotic, Donphan, etc.)
 
panamaxis said:
granted, Shed Shell is a major problem for Dugtrio based teams because they depend so much on it to take out specific walls. this big drawback should however be weighed in proportion to the number of Pokemon that actually use Shed Shell and it seems like there simply aren't enough of them running around to balance it out.

On the other hand, if players were worried about Dugtrio killing their walls, they'd run Shed Shell. It's an easy change, doesn't gimp movesets and the only thing you lose is Leftovers recovery. Since they don't, I'm inclined to conclude that they don't perceive Dugtrio as a threat, and so it's not BL.
 
Wow are you guys kidding? Nobody even looked at Dugtrio before, and now one person thinks its maybe BL and now at least two others are hopping on the bandwagon. No wonder so many people are hyped up about Froslass/Raikou/Moltres (even though we all three could have been taken out last round)

Well for one thing, its not even about band-waggoning, the evidence is clearly there. Dugtrio traps something, something sweepers sufficiently easier, simple as that. That is the standard meaning of the support characteristics. Though I expected this kind of reaction when I decided to bring it up as a suspect because I noticed that Dugtrio is rarely used in the ladder. Often times I get people saying "wtf? whats with the sudden use of dugtrio?". this gives me an idea that people rarely see dugtrio in the ladder.

I brought it up before, I think the reason why I think Raikou is broken is because Dugtrio traps his hard counter quite easily. I mean Chansey doesn't even stand a chance to Dugtrio. From there on, Raikou's hard counter is removed, meaning people are left somewhat vulnerable to Raikou. I guess in a nutshell, I'd nominate Dugtrio before Raikou first.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top