NOC 11p gen 1 closed setup (D4 End: Dec 25 at 5 PM PST)

We're only 4 more votes away from a Celever hammer, I can't stress this enough, get voting guys

On a more serious note(s):

1) Nooby q but is an 11p game more likely to be 9town/2maf or 8town/3maf?
2) Three votes on Dusk seems a lil excessive ya know (If Former were a new player then I'd prob read their third vote as scummy)
3) bluegummybear's nonsense voting logic is rly towny (and rly nonsense)
4) T-Ballz claiming Chansey right off the bat irks me for uhh reasons
 
actually maybe it doesn't irk me that much but i hope they know claiming chansey doesn't mean they're more likely to be town even if flavour suggests they would be
 

Celever

i am town
is a Community Contributor
We're only 4 more votes away from a Celever hammer, I can't stress this enough, get voting guys
;~;

On a more serious note(s):

1) Nooby q but is an 11p game more likely to be 9town/2maf or 8town/3maf?
Let's see:

D1 9-2
MISLYNCH
D2 7-2
MISLYNCH
D3 5-2
MISLYNCH
D4 3-2 (LYLO)

D1 8-3
MISLYNCH
D2 6-3
MISLYNCH
D3 4-3 (LYLO)

I'd say 9-2 is probably likelier in that case? I mean, 9-2 is townsided and 8-3 is scumsided, but the former is probably closer to equilibrium. Could be either, though.
4) T-Ballz claiming Chansey right off the bat irks me for uhh reasons
Not having played here in a long time doesn't give me a meta-read to know if this is normal or not, but I would agree that it's either playstyle or scummy, agreed.

Nuxl can you confirm if scum were provided with safeclaims or not? They presumably were, but if they weren't then it suddenly becomes a much townier play (with the caveat that Chansey is a really likely candidate for the doc's flavour if we have one so it could be baiting a counterclaim). If they were then it probably becomes slightly scummier, hoping that we assume they weren't given safes.
 
When I heard Chansey I thought that's his real name exactly how Dusk is Tommy

googled that Poke and it looks fluffy and harmless

however I really don't think looks have anything to with alignment
 
1) Nooby q but is an 11p game more likely to be 9town/2maf or 8town/3maf?
2) Three votes on Dusk seems a lil excessive ya know (If Former were a new player then I'd prob read their third vote as scummy)
3) bluegummybear's nonsense voting logic is rly towny (and rly nonsense)
4) T-Ballz claiming Chansey right off the bat irks me for uhh reasons
1) 3 mafiosi in 11p setting but Nuxl can spice things up and allow only 2 filled with great abilities like bulletproof or lynchproof, it's all based on what Nuxl prefers
2) A vote for Dusk is always valuable
3) Not if he votes me
4) I like his transparency, I think it's good
 
Nuxl can you confirm if scum were provided with safeclaims or not? They presumably were, but if they weren't then it suddenly becomes a much townier play (with the caveat that Chansey is a really likely candidate for the doc's flavour if we have one so it could be baiting a counterclaim). If they were then it probably becomes slightly scummier, hoping that we assume they weren't given safes.

I actually think safeclaims/no safeclaims is irrelevant, my impression is that the pokemon you are has no bearing on flavour/power roles/allegiance etc, which is exactly *why* I was irked by T-Ballz claiming Chansey -- seems like, as you said, 'a really likely candidate for the doc's flavour', or at least a safely townie pokemon to be if flavour has any bearing on whether you're town or maf
 
basically i don't know if nuxl would make someone chansey because chansey is a blatantly townie pokemon and that seems too easy

i may be reading into this way too much though
 

Duskfall98

Votecount Specialist
is a Forum Moderator
Moderator
We're only 4 more votes away from a Celever hammer, I can't stress this enough, get voting guys

On a more serious note(s):

1) Nooby q but is an 11p game more likely to be 9town/2maf or 8town/3maf?
2) Three votes on Dusk seems a lil excessive ya know (If Former were a new player then I'd prob read their third vote as scummy)
3) bluegummybear's nonsense voting logic is rly towny (and rly nonsense)
4) T-Ballz claiming Chansey right off the bat irks me for uhh reasons
I'd guess 3 mafia
 

Celever

i am town
is a Community Contributor
basically i don't know if nuxl would make someone chansey because chansey is a blatantly townie pokemon and that seems too easy

i may be reading into this way too much though
I think that’s why safes would help us understand, since if they were provided then something like obvtown Chansey stops being obvtown.
 

CaffeineBoost

6th Best Circus Poster of 2023
is a Community Contributor
Gaslighting isn’t even a mafia term it’s just something that exists, so you can google it for more detail. But basically it’s making people believe something did(n’t) happen by lying about it, usually using trust to do so.
I should clarify that I was joking when I said that, doing some obvious gaslighting in the first line then asking what it was in the second.
 

CaffeineBoost

6th Best Circus Poster of 2023
is a Community Contributor
We're only 4 more votes away from a Celever hammer, I can't stress this enough, get voting guys

On a more serious note(s):

1) Nooby q but is an 11p game more likely to be 9town/2maf or 8town/3maf?
2) Three votes on Dusk seems a lil excessive ya know (If Former were a new player then I'd prob read their third vote as scummy)
3) bluegummybear's nonsense voting logic is rly towny (and rly nonsense)
4) T-Ballz claiming Chansey right off the bat irks me for uhh reasons
;~;


Let's see:

D1 9-2
MISLYNCH
D2 7-2
MISLYNCH
D3 5-2
MISLYNCH
D4 3-2 (LYLO)

D1 8-3
MISLYNCH
D2 6-3
MISLYNCH
D3 4-3 (LYLO)

I'd say 9-2 is probably likelier in that case? I mean, 9-2 is townsided and 8-3 is scumsided, but the former is probably closer to equilibrium. Could be either, though.

Not having played here in a long time doesn't give me a meta-read to know if this is normal or not, but I would agree that it's either playstyle or scummy, agreed.

Nuxl can you confirm if scum were provided with safeclaims or not? They presumably were, but if they weren't then it suddenly becomes a much townier play (with the caveat that Chansey is a really likely candidate for the doc's flavour if we have one so it could be baiting a counterclaim). If they were then it probably becomes slightly scummier, hoping that we assume they weren't given safes.
What about 8/2/1? 1 might not necessarily be a killing role.
 

Duskfall98

Votecount Specialist
is a Forum Moderator
Moderator
Not killing caffeine D1 since I killed him first last game and I would feel bad have a free pass

Not killing SB because it's a rare chance to play with him have a free pass
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 1, Guests: 0)

Top