Interesting catch up. I should have time later to make a more constructed post but have been out all day. Caffeine asking me to do the thing I said I was gonna do when I got back to a PC is sad but even still
Unvote
The response by Caffeine to my case was really good I think it assuaged doubts pretty well. The defence
is fakable as scum and doesn't necessarily come from a town mindset but that's also most defences I'm happy pursuing someone else.
Only read through the posts since my last post once just now on my phone so don't remember who this was but sus on whoever was like "wow your case on Caffeine is so wrong if anything this case applies to Eagle" because that was hella nonsense including in Caffeine's own opinion. IIRC it was from one of those massive null read people so being contrarian for no reason can be a scum play in this situation -- it's technically bringing up a new point but it's so wrong that no one will put any stock in it or remember the content beyond "well hey at least this guy tried".
CaffeineBoost try not to make such hard reads in D1 as saying me and Eagle are alignment-linked. If I were scum it'd be a pretty equally viable play for me to defend Eagle as to pile more pressure on him in this situation. Equally, Eagle could be scum and my defence of him could just be wrong; town are wrong most of the time that's why we have to critique each other's takes.
I also feel like shub's push has built up more momentum than it should've done, since everyone has him only at leans if not null. Will look into this later.