Wanted to take some time to post thoughts on the discussions in this thread and the
other tournament feedback thread. (Why we have two threads for the same purpose I have no idea.)
1.
Swapping DPL & Derby - I’m fine with this since I’m pretty indifferent as long as both tours occur, I just don’t understand the point. This year the tours were the same length, so it’s not like swapping them changes much, unless we prefer the tiers played occurring at the swapped times?
2.
Replacing DOU Swiss with a second seasonal - I’m cool with this. The idea behind Swiss was hopefully to guarantee more play for newer users, but I don’t know how fruitful that’s been.
3.
Replacing Oldgens Swiss with Double Elim Tours - This can definitely be done, but I do think there’s some drawbacks. #1 being double elim takes longer, (even after we fsr added an extra round of Swiss mid-circuit), so to run 6 cups + Vintage & Classic will have some serious overlaps, but I guess if it’s just at the end of the previous double elim tours where there’s only ~8-16 people remaining in the previous tour it wouldn’t be too bad.
4.
Adding auto-qualifiers to CG Circuit - I’m cool with this as long as it’s just winner only (and not second place gets it if winner is already qualified), and not from team tours. Historically auto-qualifiers wouldn’t have mattered much since winners would basically have enough points to qualify, but since in 2024 we increased circuit point rewards at the top of the biggest tours, this has left winners of things like DLT & Last Chance in a spot where they’re not even close to qualifying after winning, so I’d be fine giving the winners of those tours auto-qualification spots. That would mean like typically 3-5 people out of 16 auto-qualify, which I think is fine. We should still seed invites based on circuit points though, to give some small encouragement to qualified players to continue participating in the circuit.
5.
Adding DOU Draft to Circuit - I don’t know how this would work, and I don’t really think this should happen, as it’s a
very different way of playing DOU than the rest of the circuit. DOU Draft is free to make their own circuit if they’d like.
6.
Expanding invitationals for DOU/Oldgens: There was some discussion about this on the previous thread, and I just want to say, I think 16 is plenty. Once you start getting into 24/32, there’s a few problems. First, the ties start to get quite massive, like ~6-10 ways, which is a mess. Second, the qualification starts getting very easy, to the point you don’t even need decent results. 32nd place in the 2024 cg circuit was 12 points, which doesn’t require much performance-wise. This should be a tour of the year’s best performers.
Lastly, there hasn’t been much discussion on tournament point rewards, which I think means people were generally pleased with it? In 2024 we increased the point output for OSDT to even more heavily weight it, and I think that showed as 2nd place qualified for invites without participating in another circuit tournament. (3-4 place just required two more circuit points to meet the 16th place tiebreaker, though they both got way more than that). Is there any further feedback on the circuit points?